2009 Acura TL Review by Jim Mateja

2009 Acura TL

Change

2009 Acura TL

Kelley Blue Book Retail $24,200  

Best Bet

Expert Reviews

By Jim Mateja

chicagotribune.com January 11, 2009

The flagship Acura RL sedan now has an all-wheel-drive companion for 2009: the midsize TL sedan that adds AWD for security when roads are wet and snowy and sure-footedness when they're dry.

The system is designed to serve notice to performance enthusiasts that they don't need rear-wheel-drive. Enthusiasts, of course, shun front-wheel-drive because of its tendency to sudden sharp movement to one side when you take off at speed. But, Acura says, AWD earns the enthusiasts' blessing.

With an AWD TL and RL, that leaves the TSX as odd car out. No reason for that drivetrain in the FWD compact, says Acura spokesman Mike Spencer. Acura also offers the compact RDX and midsize MDX crossovers with AWD.

The TL AWD system directs torque front to rear or side to side for optimum control regardless of speed or surface. Stability control helps prevent shimmy into and out of curves while traction control prevents skidding away from the light in rain or snow.

This TL also adds SH (Super Handling) to its name. Don't be fooled. Despite larger 18-inch radials (17 inchers on the base) and larger-diameter stabilizer bars, the suspension was jittery at times on uneven roads. Maybe we just expected a softer ride in keeping with Acura's luxury image but got a firmer ride to announce its performance turn.

For 2008 Acura offered base and Type-S TL. For 2009 it's base and SH-AWD. We tested the SH-AWD Tech, which adds voice-activated navigation system, real-time traffic and weather reports and backup camera.

The SH-AWD clings to the road, especially in the twisties. When called on in the snow, it did as asked without rear end traveling south while front end headed north-on an east-west road.

With the meager mileage of AWD SUVs, it's nice to have a higher mileage sedan alternative. But this AWD sedan isn't meant to climb hills, leap boulders or ford streams. It's meant to provide sure-footed handling on open roads and keep you from slipping or sliding when a few inches of snow cover the path to work. A few inches is key: TL masters 2 to 3 inches but the double digits are best left to the Hummer, Tahoe or Expedition.

TL has been redesigned for 2009, with a bolder chrome beak that looks fashionably aggressive. It also sports a rounded roofline for a coupe-like profile, but the slope is so pronounced it's easy to dent the melon when getting in or out.

The TL has added 6 inches and back-seat leg and trunk room. Cabin space is adequate though not exceptional. There are places to store coins and iPods, cell phones and steaming hot lattes (or cold colas), though not as many as in the larger RL.

The leather seats are perforated, which helps keep occupants from slipping during aggressive driving. And they're heated but not cooled, as in the RL. If the RL can share AWD with TL, why not the cooled seats?

The TL looks good and behaves well.

One gripe, however, is that it sits low, a family trait of Acura and Honda. That's fine for handling, but when you pull to the stoplight and have to look up at the car in the next lane, you wonder why the sedan goes so low, especially an AWD one that's going to be called on in the snow.

The base FWD TL has a 3.5-liter, 280-horsepower V-6; the SH-AWD we drove a new 3.7-liter, 305-h.p. V-6 with a 5-speed automatic with manual mode. No traditional manual. The V-6 is spirited but no lightning bolt. The exhaust is tuned to make the TL sound quicker than it is. The mileage rating is only 17 m.p.g. city/25 m.p.g. highway.

There's no high-mileage hybrid and no cylinder deactivation that shuts off those not needed to conserve fuel. If the Honda Accord can have the latter, why not TL?

There's no V-8 at Acura, either. If one does ever come, it would go to the RL.

The TL SH-AWD TECH is one of those fully loaded cars that starts at $42,235 and offers just about everything as standard: dual climate control, power moonroof/windows/locks/mirrors/seats (10-way driver/eight-way passenger), AM/FM/DVD player, MP3 capability and auxiliary jack, push-button start, side-curtain air bags and the voiced-activated navigation.

Skip the Tech package and save $4,000, enough to buy a map or two.

Read Jim Mateja Sunday in Rides. Contact him at rides@tribune.com.

Additional Reviews

Cars.com Expert Reviews

David ThomasCars.com NationalAugust 18, 2008
Cars.com StaffCars.com NationalAugust 18, 2008

Affiliate Reviews

G. Chambers Williams IIIStar-Telegram.comJune 25, 2009
Tom StrongmanKansasCity.comJune 4, 2009
Jim Matejachicagotribune.comJanuary 11, 2009
Warren Brownwashingtonpost.comDecember 14, 2008
Dan NeilLos Angeles TimesOctober 31, 2008
G. Chambers Williams IIIStar-Telegram.comSeptember 28, 2008
Scott BurgessThe Detroit NewspapersSeptember 4, 2008

People Who Viewed This Car Also Viewed

Choose up to three models to compare to the 2009 Acura TL.

Compare Side-by-Side
2012 Infiniti M37

2012 Infiniti M37

Starting MSRP
$49,850 - $49,850

2013 Acura ILX

2013 Acura ILX

Starting MSRP
$25,900 - $29,200

2009 Acura TSX

2009 Acura TSX

Kelley Blue Book Retail
$19,750 - $19,750

Change Location

Closest Dealers Listing this Car in ZIP 07095

*Invoice prices are made available by Cars.com and are not dealer advertising. All prices are subject to regional variations. Prices last updated 9/23/10. Click here for more information.