Cars.com Home Cars.com Home Buy a Car Sell a Car Research New and Used Cars Automotive News and Advice

Cars.com Best Bets for New Pickup Trucks

Pickup trucks come in more body styles, lengths, driveline combinations and ranges of capability than any other vehicle type. Thankfully, there are actually few separate models. This makes the pickup truck Best Bets few and the methodology brief.

Cars.com Best Bets for 2005 Pickup Trucks
Here, cars.com staff reviewer Joe Wiesenfelder applauds four pickup trucks, which are ordered from lowest to highest starting manufacturer's suggested retail price. The destination charge is not included.
Ford F-150$20,180 - $36,445
Best overall full-size pickup: The pickup builders tend to leapfrog each other every time they issue a full redesign. If that's so, the F-150 redesigned last year is a giant leap for Ford and will be a giant leap for any frog that intends to compete. The F-150 comes in regular, extended and crew cabs where some competitors leave out a body style. The F-150 lineup impresses with its ride and handling, features, amenities, quietness and interior quality. If you want your truck to do work, all of the F-150's capabilities are competitive if not best in class.

Nissan Titan   $22,800 - $35,250
Best full-size Detroit challenger: Toyota has been trying for more than a decade to compete with Detroit's full-size pickup trucks and only now is its Tundra in the same ballpark (and truly only one of its body styles goes the distance). Nissan, on the other hand, hit the ground running with the Titan. Right off the bat, it was large enough for the U.S. market. Aside from its competitive capabilities, what impresses is a standard engine comparable to Ford's optional one and some clever features such as access doors that open nearly 180 degrees, a factory spray-in bedliner and tie-down cleats that can be repositioned. (Where's your innovation, Detroit?) Excellent crash-test ratings and safety equipment such as an optional stability system help make the Titan a more than viable option.

Chevrolet Avalanche$34,010 - $38,420
Best transformer pickup: The term hybrid now applies to gasoline/electric-powered vehicles, and "crossover" has been used to describe everything from SUV/pickup combinations to car-based vehicles with trucklike features. So I use the term transformer to describe a vehicle that attempts to fit into two classes. Vehicles like the 2005 Ford Explorer Sport Trac are handy, but they're really just short-bed crew-cab pickups. Transformers require a structural doohickey like the Avalanche's midgate, which folds to extend the cargo bed into the cabin. The Hummer H2 SUT has an updated midgate with a roll-down window — nice, but the point of a transformer is versatility and usability. Unless your goal is to climb boulders, the Avalanche offers more.

Dodge Ram SRT10$45,225 - $50,250
Fastest pickup: The SRT10 version of the Ram pickup is also the quickest pickup, meaning its 0-to-60-mph times are lowest. Powered by the 8.3-liter V-10 from the Viper, generating 500 horsepower and 525 pounds-feet of torque, the regular-cab version sprints to 60 mph in less than 5 seconds. The crew-cab version adds at least half a second, but it can tow a trailer (up to 7,500 pounds) whereas the regular cab model cannot. The Ram SRT10 bests Ford's SVT F-150 Lightning pickup in several ways: 1) Ford doesn't make the Lightning anymore (good reason!) and 2) The regular-cab SRT10 comes with a six-speed-manual transmission (Lightning was automatic only). If the regular cab's StairMaster of a clutch pedal causes cramping, get the Quad Cab, which comes with a four-speed automatic. It can ferry your entire family — fast.

The following new models were not considered when making the above selections:

  • 2006 Dodge Ram Mega Cab
  • 2006 Honda Ridgeline
  • Redesigned Nissan Frontier
  • Redesigned Toyota Tacoma


Best Bet Selection Methodology
Cars.com Best Bets are intended to reflect reality. While a good number of the nearly 1 million Ford F-150 full-size pickups sold each year are true work trucks, the pickup category and its sales have been growing because people increasingly buy them for personal use. Encouraged by the proliferation of the crew-cab body style — the type with four full doors and a roomy backseat — the pickup has become an SUV-alternative family mover.

Personal pickup truck use is far more homogeneous than is work use. Work-truck buyers know more about their particular needs than we do. What's good for one may be irrelevant for another. No wimpy trucks need apply, but we don't pick nits over specifications. You can find all you need to know about a truck's standard and optional capabilities by sifting through the data we provide. We would probably take fuel economy and emissions into account, but they're all pretty much the same: really, really bad.

What does that leave? Safety, real-world performance, refinement, comfort, features, innovation and value. The safety picture is looking up for full-size trucks. All the pickups considered except for General Motors' score Good in the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety's Crashworthiness Evaluations. The other criteria, again, are based on consumer use.

 


Ask.cars.com: Our Experts Answer Your Questions
Mother Proof: Car Reviews by Real Moms
KickingTires: Get the Latest in New-Car News
PickupTrucks.com: Get news and reviews at PickupTrucks.com
Home | Contact Us | Site Index | About Cars.com | Employment Opportunities | Become a Cars.com Dealer
Cars.com Mobile | Búsqueda en Español de Carros Usados

Powered by: Google
By using this site, you agree to our terms of service
©2009 Cars.com | Privacy Statement


Visit our partners: Apartments.com | Find a Realtor | Homes for Sale | Apartments for Rent | CareerBuilder.com