2009 Pontiac G8 Review by Jim Mateja

2009 Pontiac G8

Change

2009 Pontiac G8

Kelley Blue Book Retail $20,300–$32,400  


Expert Reviews

By Jim Mateja

chicagotribune.com July 30, 2009

Pontiac came so close to getting its act together.

But close, as they say, counts only in horseshoes, and the division designated by General Motors to create excitement is going to stop creating anything by the end of 2010.

In exchange for government loans, General Motors had to jettison a chairman, Rick Wagoner, and several divisions. So long, Pontiac, the architect of the Grand Prix, Firebird and GTO.

Of course, it also brought forth econocars, minivans and the category- and gut-busting Aztek, which didn't do the division any good. Still, it's a shame that the fat lady is singing just as it has a couple vehicles that make the hair stand up on your neck when you kick the pedal.

For the 2009 model year, the Pontiac we know and love is back with high-performance GXP versions of its sporty G8 sedan and knockout Solstice coupe. Better too late than never?

We tested both, which already are out of production.

The G8 is the better of the two GXPs, though it's aimed at a decidedly different audience than Solstice.

The regular G8 was offered with a 3.6-liter, 256-horsepower V-6 or a 6-liter, 361-h.p. V-8; GXP packs a 6.2-liter, 402-h.p. V-8 with a 6-speed automatic. It does zero to 60 in about 4.7 seconds. And the "G" stands for g forces, so be ready to be snapped back into the bucket seat on launch.

The 13 m.p.g. city/20 m.p.g. highway rating saddles GXP G8 with a $1,700 gas-guzzler tax, though when the speedometer leaves the legal zone, you're not thinking much about the price of gas. Top speed: 108 m.p.h.

Thanks to the potent V-8 and stability control with traction assist, quick-response power steering, track-tuned suspension and 19-inch performance radials (summer tires and, yup, they don't run in snow), the G8 GXP is exceptionally quick and sure-footed; that's how you build excitement.

Hood scoops, front-fender vents and projector-beam headlamps in crystal-clear lenses complete the package.

The two-seat Solstice GXP doesn't have the same muscle as the G8 GXP, of course, but it is absolutely a work of art.

The design crew, led by Ed Welburn, created a machine whose styling hints at Porsche and Jaguar, with regal carved and curved lines that are a joy just to admire.

The Solstice roadster comes with a soft top; the coupe has a removable hard top -- unlock two levers upfront and one in back and take it off. Light enough for one person to manage.

If the car was going to be around for more than one model year, we'd insist that the guy who designed the front locks on the top should have done the one in back. It's difficult to open, even harder to close.

The Solstice roadster offers a 2.4-liter, 173-h.p. 4 that's adequate for cruising, but the GXP coupe slips in a 2-liter, 260-h.p. turbo 4 with an attitude. Mileage is a respectable 19 m.p.g. city/28 m.p.g. highway with a notchy 5-speed manual. Automatic runs $995 and gets 1 more m.p.g. on the highway.

The turbo 4 gives the GXP the power the roadster should have had to match its dramatic styling. Very good handling, too, thanks to stability and traction control and steering tuned to react more quickly to wheel input than in the roadster.

But, as with the roadster, the ride is a tad rough, and the cabin more than a bit snug. If your favorite meal is dessert, the midsize G8 is a better fit than the Solstice, in which long-distance travel is a squeeze at any speed.

Not that it really matters, but why are there cupholders behind the headrests? Can we thank the guy who designed the rear roof latch for putting them there?

Base price for the GXP Solstice coupe: $30,375, about $890 more than a roadster. The GXP G8 starts at $37,610, or about $7,000 more than G8 with 6-liter V-8.

You may not find a lot of either GXPs in showrooms -- Pontiac built just 1,892 of the G8s and 2,000 Solstices -- but they'll be appearing in museums, car shows and collectible vehicle auctions soon.

A thumbs-up would make a fitting final salute.

Read Jim Mateja Sunday in Rides. Contact him at transportation@tribune.com.

Tribune Media Services

Additional Reviews

Cars.com Expert Reviews

Mike HanleyCars.com NationalMay 12, 2009
David ThomasCars.com NationalDecember 5, 2008
Cars.com StaffCars.com NationalJune 30, 2008

Affiliate Reviews

Jim Matejachicagotribune.comJuly 30, 2009
G. Chambers Williams IIIStar-Telegram.comJuly 17, 2009
Scott BurgessThe Detroit NewspapersJune 4, 2009
Warren Brownwashingtonpost.comApril 12, 2009

People Who Viewed This Car Also Viewed

Choose up to three models to compare to the 2009 Pontiac G8.

Compare Side-by-Side
2008 Cadillac CTS

2008 Cadillac CTS

Kelley Blue Book Retail
$18,950 - $18,950

2011 Audi A5

2011 Audi A5

Kelley Blue Book Retail
$34,400 - $39,900

Change Location

Closest Dealers Listing this Car in ZIP 20146

*Invoice prices are made available by Cars.com and are not dealer advertising. All prices are subject to regional variations. Prices last updated 9/23/10. Click here for more information.