Sort

Used Subaru Legacy for Sale in Elmira, NY

See all 11 photos
Used

2012 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium

137,815 mi.
$6,998
FAIR PRICE
DELIVERY AVAILABLE
  • Ext. Color: Blue
  • Int. Color: Beige
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
Walushka Autohouse
() -
(607) 654-0608
5 (2 reviews)
12 mi. from 14902
Check Availability
Call
2012 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Review
Good Reliable Car
by Traveling Man from Falls, PA
May 5, 2019
5
Bought it new in Oct 2011, fantastic in snow, I live in a hilly area of PA and still get 28 mpg local and 33 mpg on trips, only issue I had with it was had to replace front wheel bearing, which i did myself. Takata air bag issue was fixed promptly by dealer, very satisfied with car and dealer, Minooka Subaru Moosic PA.
PRICE DROP
See all 29 photos
Used

2018 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Sport

21,867 mi.
$21,599 $800 price drop!
GOOD DEAL $360 Under
DELIVERY AVAILABLE
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: Black
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
Maguire Hyundai Subaru
() -
(607) 216-9330
4.6 (172 reviews)
26 mi. from 14902
Authorized Subaru Dealer
Check Availability
Call
Maguire Hyundai Subaru Review
Excellent car purchased from an excellent dealer
by Geoff from ithaca, ny
November 5, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.6 (172 reviews)
I came in knowing that I wanted to buy a used Crosstrek. I originally came in to purchase a 2013 model with lots of miles, but got second thoughts after I test drove it. Shawn was very helpful, and showed me a newer model that rode a lot better. I was not pressured to make a day-of decision, and they didn't try to pressure me by phone afterwards. I ended up calling 4 days later to purchase the newer car. Shawn was very friendly and made the process very straightforward. While Maguire will not negotiate down the sticker price of used cars, I got a good deal on the warranty. I was expecting that I'd have to go to Syracuse or Rochester to find a good deal, but I ended up getting a good deal here in Ithaca.
2018 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Sport Review
Very reliabe
by Zach from New York
March 2, 2019
5
Just purchased my new car. Already i feel a huge difference in comfort and how well it controls. I look forward to the years to come with it
See all 16 photos
Used

2014 Subaru Legacy 3.6R Limited

26,000 mi.
$18,995
GOOD DEAL $350 Under
  • Ext. Color: Red
  • Int. Color: Beige
  • Transmission: Automatic
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX Report
Greg's Auto Sales
() -
(607) 354-4938
4.9 (60 reviews)
29 mi. from 14902
Check Availability
Call
Greg's Auto Sales Review
Great car buying experience
by Dom D from Endicott/Owego, NY
November 6, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.9 (60 reviews)
I emailed Greg about an 06 Honda Pilot on a Saturday or Sunday, heard back from him Monday via phone call, and we set up for me to look at after the dealerships hours to check it out. Test drove it, and came back the next day and drove it off the lot, again after hours. Greg was really accommodating with flexible hours, a great price on the super clean vehicle, and did me a few favors to ensure a quick process that Thursday night. When the time comes for a new car, and if Greg has a vehicle I'm interested in, I wouldn't hesitate a bit to buy here again.
2014 Subaru Legacy 3.6R Limited Review
Went back for another; great car
by Rayallen from Plainfield, CT
October 29, 2018
5
Excellent car offering high mpg for 4wd(symmetrical). Can’t beat a Subaru on this! Previously owned a Legacy GT and after many miles, went back for another, (minus the turbo).
See all 30 photos
Used

2020 Subaru Legacy Sport

2,420 mi.
$27,999
GOOD DEAL $586 Under
DELIVERY AVAILABLE
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: White
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
Maguire Hyundai Subaru
() -
(607) 216-9330
4.6 (172 reviews)
26 mi. from 14902
Authorized Subaru Dealer
Check Availability
Call
Maguire Hyundai Subaru Review
Just bought a Subaru
by Casey from Freeville, NY
November 5, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.6 (172 reviews)
I was helped by Jon-Michael Ottenschot today, and the experience was easy (although lengthy--paperwork processing took a while, not his fault). Knowledgeable, friendly, and helpful!
See all 28 photos
Used

2018 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium

44,830 mi.
$17,999
GOOD DEAL $897 Under
DELIVERY AVAILABLE
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: Silver
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
Maguire Hyundai Subaru
() -
(607) 216-9330
4.6 (172 reviews)
26 mi. from 14902
Authorized Subaru Dealer
Check Availability
Call
Maguire Hyundai Subaru Review
Excellent experience buying a car at Maguire
by Suzanne from Ithaca, NY
November 5, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.6 (172 reviews)
We came looking for a specific set of features in a new car. We were greeted by John-Michael who spent a lot of time familiarizing us with the various features of the Subaru cars. He was patient and thorough in his process, and answered all our questions in good detail, finding out answers if he did not have them readily available. He had a warm and open approach and clearly knew a lot about the cars in the lot and the various features of each. We appreciated his sense of humor and quick wit. We had a test drive in a car that fit all our requirements and we were pleased to complete a purchase in a matter of only a few hours. The environment at the dealership was clean and friendly. It was all in all a very pleasant experience, even for people who are not crazy about automobile shopping. We appreciate Maguire and we appreciate John-Michael for helping us find just what we needed and wanted.
2018 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Review
Engine and mileage troubles
by Cora from Tulsa OK
February 24, 2019
3
It's a pretty little car. I got the white. It does have excellent outboard visibility which was important to me . The seats are comfortable and I wanted it for the safety ranking, the AWD and the visibility all of which are as promised. It is the smallest car I've had in 40 years but has room for what I need at my age. However it did not get better than 19 mpg city and highway and they had to put a new engine in it. Now it is averaging 24 and can get 32 on the hwy in favorable conditions. I like the heated sets on the lowest setting and am happy to have the back up camera although it is nearly useless after dark-very blurry. I think it accelerates fast enough. I am not happy to not have retained auxiliary power which I thought was standard on something at this price : $26,0000. It is a huge nuisance to have to turn the car back on to close the sunroof or roll a window up or down, The sound system is horribly overcomplicated. Too many unneeded warning indicators which are pretty tiny and take research to figure out.I like the driver info center. I'm getting older and would prefer a car with fewer rather than more features. I had to search hard to find one with a compass , which I still find useful and essential but it is placed-way up in a corner of the rearview mirror. Should be on the dash somewhere to be really useful. The salesforce and the mechanics are very responsive and the car is generally well made. They fixed the engine without complaint. So they get points for that. I just think it is complicated in ways that are not helpful.
See all 12 photos
Used

2011 Subaru Legacy 2.5 i Premium

189,600 mi.
$5,995
FAIR PRICE
HOT CAR
  • Ext. Color: Gray
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: Manual
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
Miller Bros. Auto Sales
() -
(866) 984-2803
4.5 (17 reviews)
9 mi. from 14902
Check Availability
Call
Miller Bros. Auto Sales Review
Beautiful Pre- Owned Cars and Trucks
by Nancy A. Nelson from Annapolis, MD
December 3, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.5 (17 reviews)
The customer service is above and beyond. Truly great experience. The daughters are an exceptional sales staff/ owners and extremely courteous and friendly. They treat you like family. Truly a great shopping experience. I will go back again for my next purchase! All their cars and trucks were in such great condition, very well taken care of and they offered the option to find a vehicle that I wanted or was looking for if they did not have it in stock.
2011 Subaru Legacy 2.5 i Premium Review
This is a very stylish car that is also safe
by Andrew from Ocean
March 8, 2019
5
I've only owned this car for a little over a month, but so far it has been a pleasure to drive. Four wheel drive for a sedan is always a big plus.
See all 27 photos
Used

2020 Subaru Legacy Premium

9,594 mi.
$24,599
FAIR PRICE
DELIVERY AVAILABLE
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: Gray
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
Maguire Hyundai Subaru
() -
(607) 216-9330
4.6 (172 reviews)
26 mi. from 14902
Authorized Subaru Dealer
Check Availability
Call
Maguire Hyundai Subaru Review
5 Star Service
by Dianna Curren from Spencer, Ny
November 5, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.6 (172 reviews)
I had an exceptional experience buying my new car at Maguire's. Everyone was polite and friendly. Brian Nowlan was friendly right from the start. He greeted us with a smile and a handshake and offered his help. Brian was an exceptional sales person, he wasn't pushy but he was professional and accommodating. He made the car buying experience fun and relaxing. I would recommend him to anyone seeking to buy a new or used car. Tom Baren's was able to get us better financing than we had expected. he was also a down to earth friendly guy. Brian and Tom went out of their way to help us through an experience we had dreaded. Exceptional, Professional, Friendly!
JUST ADDED
Used

2013 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium

61,269 mi.
Not Priced
  • Ext. Color: White
  • Int. Color: Beige
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX Report
Williams Subaru of Sayre
() -
(607) 565-0703
4 (5 reviews)
16 mi. from 14902
Authorized Subaru Dealer
Check Availability
Call
Williams Subaru of Sayre Review
Love our 2017 KIA Sorento
by Reggie Jividen from Painted Post, NY
November 6, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4 (5 reviews)
Had a few hitches in our purchase process for living in NY state and purchasing lease in Pa. but they quickly resolved the situation. Dealership was excellent for friendly, helpful service.
2013 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Review
Reliable but Brash
by Jakob from Rochester Hills
April 25, 2019
4
The Subaru Legacy is an excellent vehicle. Subaru has nailed the practicality formula with this vehicle. It is large inside, gets excellent fuel economy, has strong mechanical components (engine, trans, AWD system), and is a perfect family vehicle, though the engine is lacking in power. However, and this is a big, however, the Subarus are NOT built for your comfort. The seats are comfortable enough, as is the ride comfort, but the lack of refinement is alarming. The vehicle is loud, brash, and has little concern for luxury. The interior trim is cheap plastic and rough to the touch. There is very little sound deadening, a decibel meter read 79 decibels at only 50 mph, unacceptable in modern vehicles. Reliability is something great to be concerned about, and Subaru offers an excellent package for reliability and practicality, however, the lack of concern for refinement and quality engineering, especially in todays market, is bad enough to make me sell the car. In a modern market, reliability is something that can be found in most vehicles, but modern interiors have improved far past where Subaru is currently. Want reliability, get a Toyota. Need AWD, get a Toyota RAV4. Your comfortable bottom will thank you for it.
See all 28 photos
Used

2018 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium

4,274 mi.
$21,999
GOOD DEAL
DELIVERY AVAILABLE
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: Silver
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
Maguire Hyundai Subaru
() -
(607) 216-9330
4.6 (172 reviews)
26 mi. from 14902
Authorized Subaru Dealer
Check Availability
Call
Maguire Hyundai Subaru Review
Brian Nowlan is the man!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
by Matthew Mcgrain from Breeseport, Ny
November 5, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.6 (172 reviews)
Brian was extremely knowledgeable of Maguire's inventory and helpful in all facets of the car-buying experience. I came to Maguire ready to buy a used Nissan Xterra and left with a Subaru Forester based on his testimonies and Maguire's all around offers- including great price, extended used car warranty and the all around experience that Maguire offers. I would recommend Maguire Hyundai Subaru and Brian Nowlan as the sales consultant to anyone!
2018 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Review
nices car I have owned very solid
by JGM 2110 from Hobart IN 46342
February 20, 2019
5
The car is very comfortable and stylist and gets a lot of head turns mine happens to be the 50 year addition the more I drive it the more I lean and like it .
See all 22 photos
Used

2017 Subaru Legacy 3.6R Limited

41,291 mi.
$20,495
GOOD DEAL
  • Ext. Color: Gray
  • Int. Color: White
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
Pritchard Automotive
() -
(607) 216-6467
4.9 (182 reviews)
27 mi. from 14902
Check Availability
Call
Pritchard Automotive Review
Very satisfied customer
by Nancy M. from Marathon NY
November 6, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.9 (182 reviews)
My vehicle needed an inspection and it had a sound in front end that I needed to have checked. They got me right in, did the inspection and checked out the problem. They were great and very efficient. They contacted manufacturer dealer to see if vehicle was still under warranty. It was so I have to take it else where to be fixed. If it wasn't under warranty, I would have totally trusted the mechanic at Pritchards that did my inspection to do any repairs on my vehicle.
2017 Subaru Legacy 3.6R Limited Review
I love the car.
by Virginia from Poughkeepsie, n y
May 10, 2019
5
I really enjoy almost everything about the car. It drives well, good features, good mileage for AWD. I wish the body was not so low to the ground ( easy to scrape on curbs etc ) but I want a sedan and it seems all sedans now are low like this one nowadays.
PRICE DROP
See all 27 photos
Used

2010 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium

120,891 mi.
$7,999 $1,000 price drop!
FAIR PRICE
DELIVERY AVAILABLE
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: Gray
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free AutoCheck Report
Maguire Automotive (Imports - Audi, VW, Volvo, Kia and Toyota)
() -
(607) 233-4680
4.7 (2669 reviews)
25 mi. from 14902
Check Availability
Call
Maguire Automotive (Imports - Audi, VW, Volvo, Kia and Toyota) Review
Great service!
by Annie from Ithaca, NY
November 6, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.7 (2669 reviews)
Smart mechanics, timely turn around. I have a manual 98 jeep that is getting along in its life, and has suffered some wear and tear in the past few years. These guys always know exactly the issue I am facing when other mechanics are unsure. They have always been able to turn around the repair very quickly, with quality service, and their price point usually comes below their original quotes. I will miss this place when I leave Ithaca.
2010 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Review
Love the vehicle but have had to put 8 low beam bt
by Eds from Bear Lake Michigan
April 2, 2019
4
Love the vehicle other than having to put 8 low beam bulbs in it over the last nine years. This task is very difficult to do and expensive to have a mechanic do. This is such an issue it almost would make me not want the vehicle
Used

2013 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Limited

104,914 mi.
$9,999
GOOD DEAL
  • Ext. Color: Silver
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX Report
Williams Subaru of Sayre
() -
(607) 565-0703
4 (5 reviews)
16 mi. from 14902
Authorized Subaru Dealer
Check Availability
Call
2013 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Limited Review
Powerful. Commanding on hills, snow
by Juice from Seattle wa
April 5, 2019
5
Very good if you live in the snow or in the mountains or hills. Subaru has truly mastered the symmetrical 4wheel system. Can’t go wrong with it. And this car still gets the same gas mileage as it’s compe like Camry and accord of same years who don’t have the extra stuff like the 4wd.
See all 30 photos
Used

2020 Subaru Legacy

3,458 mi.
$30,999
DELIVERY AVAILABLE
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: Gray
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
Maguire Hyundai Subaru
() -
(607) 216-9330
4.6 (172 reviews)
26 mi. from 14902
Authorized Subaru Dealer
Check Availability
Call
Maguire Hyundai Subaru Review
Maguire Subaru review
by Bob Sullivan from Seneca Falls
November 6, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.6 (172 reviews)
Brian was pleasant to deal with and made our car buying experience a positive one. As we declined extended warranty offer (multiple times), Brian tactfully persisted. Overall, a positive experience for us. Looking forward to working with Brian again as he looks for another car for our daughter.
See all 28 photos
Used

2018 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium

45,972 mi.
Not Priced
DELIVERY AVAILABLE
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: Red
  • Int. Color: Green
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
Maguire Hyundai Subaru
() -
(607) 216-9330
4.6 (172 reviews)
26 mi. from 14902
Authorized Subaru Dealer
Check Availability
Call
Maguire Hyundai Subaru Review
Super car Subaru impresa, Very impressed!
by tim richards from tully, ny
November 5, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.6 (172 reviews)
I fount this dealership MAGUIRE Subaru very efficient and extremely helpful ! I fount that Jon -Michael Ottenscot my sales man went out of his way to get me the best price and deal possible . He was very helpful in making sure my needs were met so it was possible to make a smooth deal that fits my finical needs. I found this dealership extremely pleasant without all the pushing that i have experienced at other dealerships! On that note Kudos to Maguire dealership and Jon - Michael he should be a valued employee to your business Excellent job !
2018 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Review
Good car but many distraction dangers
by LeeLaVin from Laguna Niguel, CA
February 19, 2019
4
Unless you like to stay up at night reading your Subaru Legacy manual, you may never get the hang of this car. We lease it. Really hard to figure out the settings for window operations, radio, air conditioner (but NO heater), headlight setting, door functions (which doors you gotta open first in order to open other doors), how to get the darn trunk open. So many things. Overr-designed. Too much dashboard disboard distraction. Plus, you can never leave the radio on and open the door (buzzers go off). One must leave the engine on if you want to listen to the radio, open or close a window. I've always had Sirius in previous cars and had no difficulties. Legacy radio display is horrifically complex. Hard to set favorites. Worst of all, you cannot readily know when you are out of gas. My old Volvo used to give me a digital readout on how many miles were left before I'd run out of gas. Really helped me gauge when to stop and refuel. In the Legacy, you can read the meter and think you're okay and then suddenly you see the Orange alert. I tend tonot kno get nervous not knowing approximately how many miles I can drive before I run out completely. In short, the Subaru drives very well, looks pretty good, but is not designed to be user friendly. If you don't like reading manuals in order to listen to a car radio, you'll be irritated often. And the temptation to try to figure these things out WHILE YOU ARE DRIVING is a danger that absolutely must be avoided. I'd love to have a talk with the dashboard designer!
Used

2014 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium

111,678 mi.
$8,995
GREAT DEAL $394 Under
DELIVERY AVAILABLE
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: Blue
  • Int. Color: Blue
  • Transmission: Automatic
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
Top 5 Rated
() -
(607) 233-4763
4 (11 reviews)
26 mi. from 14902
Check Availability
Call
Top 5 Rated Review
Explained everything clearly
by Kathleen from Auburn
November 6, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4 (11 reviews)
Top 5 did all the work after we picked out car -- the loan, registration, joining the credit union, the works. Made our first auto loan process fairly painless. Nice car with reasonable warranty. Would go there again.
2014 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Review
Wish I could buy it.
by CGBurke from American Fork, Utah
September 14, 2018
5
It's stiff to drive but handles well and the interior is comfortable and feels good. I love it. I wish I could afford the vehicle.
* Title, other fees, and incentives are not included in this calculation, which is an estimate only. Monthly payment estimates are for illustrative purposes only and do not represent a financing offer from the seller. Other taxes may apply.
The information on vehicles provided in this service is supplied by the seller or other third parties; Cars.com is not responsible for the accuracy of such information. Cars.com provides this service and materials without representations or warranties of any kind, either expressed or implied. See our terms of service for more details.
15 results
Save Search
  • Location
    • Search within
  • Shop from Home
  • New/Used
  • Year
    Min
     
    to
    Max
  • Model
  • Trim
  • Price
    Min
     
    to
    Max
  • Mileage
  • Deal Rating
  • Features
  • Body Style
  • Exterior Color
  • Interior Color
  • Drivetrain
  • Transmission
  • Cylinders
  • Photos
  • Fuel
  • Door Count
  • Dealer Ratings
  • Listing Date
  • Seller Type
  • Keywords
New Search

Save Your Search

Search saved!

You can manage your searches in your profile.

That's too many

You can only compare up to 4 cars at a time.

You've reached your limit

Sorry, you've saved the maximum amount of favorites for your account. Please unsave some if you wish to save others.