Are Vehicle Service Contracts a Scam? Sorting Fact From Fiction

Editorial Note: Content was created in partnership with Money Research Collective. Cars.com receives a commission from the partner links contained within the content.

Vehicle service contracts aren’t inherently scams, but the industry has had some fraudulent providers. As a result, many people forgo VSCs. In fact, 55% of registered vehicles that are less than 16 years old aren’t covered under a VSC.

A legitimate VSC provider can protect you against unexpected and costly vehicle repairs, so it’s important to learn the differences between a legitimate provider and a predatory contract.

Key Facts

  • VSCs are different from manufacturer warranties and are issued through third-party companies.
  • Coverage varies by plan and provider, ranging from basic powertrain warranties and more comprehensive bumper-to-bumper contracts.
  • Top providers, such as CarShield, have longstanding histories of serving customers and paying out claims.

Are All Vehicle Service Contracts Scams?

No, not all vehicle service contracts are scams. Although the Federal Trade Commission has taken action against some companies for issues like misleading claims or high-pressure sales tactics, there are many reputable and legitimate VSC providers.

A contract that you purchase through a reputable company can save you thousands in repair costs, especially as your vehicle ages and your manufacturer warranty ends.

5 Common Myths About Vehicle Service Contracts

These are some of the five most common myths and misconceptions about VSCs:

All vehicle service contract companies are unreliable

There are several established companies with long track records and strong customer reviews. For example, CarShield has served customers for over 20 years, and it has paid over $1 billion in claims.

Vehicle service contracts are the same thing as extended warranties

Although people often use the terms extended warranty and VSC interchangeably, they’re different. An extended warranty comes from the manufacturer or dealership and extends the original factory warranty. By contrast, a VSC is a separate agreement sold through a third-party provider. The distinction matters because it affects what regulatory authorities oversee the warranty or contract and what legal protections cover you.

Vehicle service contracts pay 100% of repairs

Even with covered repairs, VSCs don’t cover 100% of the cost. While coverage varies by provider and contract, the customer is typically responsible for the deductible for covered repairs, and there may be caps on the maximum coverage limits.

Vehicle service contracts are too expensive

A common concern about purchasing a VSC is the cost. On average, VSCs are $75 to $170 per month, or $950 to $2,000 per year.

Considering the cost of replacing a transmission can be anywhere from $2,900 to $7,100, according to Kelley Blue Book, the price of a VSC can be well worth the investment.

Vehicle service contracts cover maintenance

Routine maintenance, such as oil changes or brake pad replacements, are not covered by VSCs. These contracts cover unexpected mechanical breakdowns, not normal maintenance or wear and tear.

How to Find a Legitimate Vehicle Service Contract Provider

To find a reliable VSC provider, follow these steps:

  • Read a sample contract: A reputable provider will be transparent about their plans and contracts, with a sample contract readily available to review. If a company is unwilling to share one with you, that’s a major red flag.
  • Confirm repair shop rules: Some contracts require you to use a specific repair shop network, while others allow you to use any certified mechanic. If you have a particular mechanic you trust, confirm that your mechanic is approved through the VSC provider.
  • Review coverages and exclusions: Review the contract and make sure you understand what’s covered and what’s not. Common exclusions include preexisting conditions and damage caused by lack of maintenance.
  • Read customer reviews: Look at reviews from multiple sources, such as the Better Business Bureau and Trustpilot. A company with a pattern of similar complaints may be one to avoid.

When it comes to VSCs, a little research and due diligence can eliminate fraudulent or unreliable companies so you can find a company you can rely on for coverage. For those with older vehicles or a car make that is prone to expensive repairs, a legitimate contract can offer protection and peace of mind.

FAQs

Is CarShield a legitimate vehicle service contract company?

Yes, CarShield is a legitimate vehicle service contract company. It has been in operation for over 20 years, and customers report positive experiences. On Trustpilot, CarShield has a 4.1 out of five rating based on 56,000 reviews as of August 2026.

How do I know if a vehicle service contract provider is trustworthy?

Look for vehicle service contract providers who have been in operation for several years, have strong ratings on customer review platforms like Trustpilot, and share sample contracts upfront. Legitimate companies give you clear information and don’t pressure you into making quick decisions.

What repairs aren’t covered by vehicle service contracts?

Most vehicle service contracts exclude routine maintenance, such as oil changes or tire rotations, cosmetic damage or preexisting conditions. Coverage for electronics, GPS systems and luxury features like heated seats also varies by contract, so review the contract for a full list of exclusions before signing.

Disclosure: We earn a commission from partner links from this article.