2013 Smart ForTwo at the 2012 New York Auto Show

By David Thomas  on April 5, 2012


  • Competes with: Scion iQ, Chevy Spark, Mini Cooper
  • Looks like: New wrappings around the same small box
  • Drivetrain: 70 hp, three-cylinder engine with automated-manual transmission
  • Hits dealerships: May 2012

Smart debuted the ForTwo in the U.S. to great fanfare. That was before anyone drove the tiny city runabout, though. We infamously called it the worst car of the 2000s.

More 2012 New York Auto Show Coverage

Smart has announced a redesigned model for 2013 that will go on sale this summer. It gets some exterior updates — you tell us the difference — and the interior materials are improved, but the car remains virtually the same underneath. That means we likely won't be recommending this one, either.


It's not necessarily the 70-horsepower three-cylinder engine — which remains for 2013 — that is our biggest gripe. It's the automated-manual transmission, which we've found to lurch instead of actually shift. The car's proportions also lead it to feel tipsy, and indeed the ForTwo has a worse rollover rating than a Ford Explorer.

The ForTwo is tiny for sure, but its gas mileage of 34 /38 mpg city/highway is relatively unchanged from when the car debuted. And with a Hyundai Accent getting 40 mpg highway — along with a cadre of other thrifty options — the ForTwo doesn't seem so smart. Sorry, they just make it too easy.


Smart ForTwo Smart 2012 2012 New York Auto Show Auto Show

Managing Editor David Thomas has a thing for wagons and owns a 2010 Subaru Outback and a 2005 Volkswagen Passat wagon.  Email David