Skip to main content

What's the Best V-8 Muscle Car for 2016?

img48979090 1457737705645 jpg Cars.com photo by Evan Sears

Americans always have loved muscle cars, and they love muscle cars with big V-8 engines. With gas below $2 a gallon in many places, there might not be a better time to buy some modern muscle. We tested muscle cars with V-8 monsters. They provided plenty of thrills, plenty of noise and lots to talk about.

The V-8 Muscle Car Challenge
Results | Performance | Mileage Test

The contenders:

  • 2016 Chevrolet Camaro 2SS
  • 2016 Dodge Challenger R/T Scat Pack
  • 2016 Ford Mustang GT

We flexed these muscle cars in a week’s worth of testing:

  • We put them on a racetrack outside of Phoenix to see how well they performed in zero-to-60-mph tests, quarter-mile times and speeds, and 60-mph-to-zero braking distance tests.
  • We drove them on a 130-mile real-world mileage course in and around Phoenix.
  • We had our judges drive them back-to-back-to-back on the same pavement to evaluate ride, handling, comfort, acceleration and more.
  • We brought in an in-market shopper to test the cars for ride, handling, acceleration and more.

From all of the points we awarded in those tests, we found our winner. Our judges were:

  • Aaron Bragman, Cars.com Detroit bureau chief
  • Joe Bruzek, Cars.com senior road test editor
  • Joe Wiesenfelder, Cars.com executive editor
  • Brian Robinson, PBS’ “MotorWeek” producer
  • Jason Kadah, our in-market shopper. In the interest of transparency, Kadah owned a Mustang years ago, but he promised prior to his involvement that he would judge the cars without bias.

The scoring broke down this way:

  • 48 percent from the judges’ scoring
  • 30 percent from the track tests
  • 12 percent from our shopper
  • 10 percent from the mileage drive

Here’s how they finished:

What You Get

img1527453114 1456960770499 jpg img 64975918 1456960771022 jpg img1527453114 1456960770499 jpg img 64975918 1456960771022 jpg

What the Judges Said

32016 Ford Mustang GT, 797 points

The Verdict: “With more evolved performance than the Challenger, yet still a little rough and raucous around the edges when driven hard, the Mustang is the perfect evolution of the muscle car,” Wiesenfelder said. “It’s fun and ready for track day yet comfortable and livable for daily use.”

img 1149436121 1456338967743 jpg img 1189710044 1457126937139 jpg img 1148512600 1456338967981 jpg img 1147589079 1456338968218 jpg img 1146665558 1456338968528 jpg img 1145742037 1456338968798 jpg img 1144818516 1456338969074 jpg img 1143894995 1456338969308 jpg img 1142971474 1456338969605 jpg img 1142047953 1456338969849 jpg img 1121730491 1456338970127 jpg img 1120806970 1456338970423 jpg img 1119883449 1456338970728 jpg img 1118959928 1456338971024 jpg img 1118036407 1456338971461 jpg img 1117112886 1456338971809 jpg img 1116189365 1456338972108 jpg img 1115265844 1456338972338 jpg img 1114342323 1456338972624 jpg img 1113418802 1456338972864 jpg img 1093101340 1456338973144 jpg img 1092177819 1456338973442 jpg img 1091254298 1456338973707 jpg img 1090330777 1456338973957 jpg img 1089407256 1456338974256 jpg img 1088483735 1456338974533 jpg img 1087560214 1456338974809 jpg img 1086636693 1456338975142 jpg img 1085713172 1456338975463 jpg img 1084789651 1456338975708 jpg img 1064472189 1456338975979 jpg img 1063548668 1456338976300 jpg img 1062625147 1456338976592 jpg img 1061701626 1456338976892 jpg img 1060778105 1456338977175 jpg img 1059854584 1456338977462 jpg img 1058931063 1456338977750 jpg img 1058007542 1456338978012 jpg img 1057084021 1456338978277 jpg img 1056160500 1456338978577 jpg img 1035843038 1456338978811 jpg img 1034919517 1456338979096 jpg img 1033072475 1456338979698 jpg img 1033995996 1456338979411 jpg img 1032148954 1456338979976 jpg img 1031225433 1456338980327 jpg img 1030301912 1456338980729 jpg img 1029378391 1456338981096 jpg img 1027531349 1456338981926 jpg img 1028454870 1456338981543 jpg img 1007213887 1456338982327 jpg img 1006290366 1456338982648 jpg img 1005366845 1456338982963 jpg img 1004443324 1456338983277 jpg img 1003519803 1456338983558 jpg img 1002596282 1456338983879 jpg img 1001672761 1456338984164 jpg img 1000749240 1456338984461 jpg img 999825719 1456338984762 jpg img 998902198 1456338985051 jpg img 978584736 1456338985420 jpg img 977661215 1456338985765 jpg img 976737694 1456338986094 jpg img 975814173 1456338986424 jpg img 1149436121 1456338967743 jpg img 1189710044 1457126937139 jpg img 1148512600 1456338967981 jpg img 1147589079 1456338968218 jpg img 1146665558 1456338968528 jpg img 1145742037 1456338968798 jpg img 1144818516 1456338969074 jpg img 1143894995 1456338969308 jpg img 1142971474 1456338969605 jpg img 1142047953 1456338969849 jpg img 1121730491 1456338970127 jpg img 1120806970 1456338970423 jpg img 1119883449 1456338970728 jpg img 1118959928 1456338971024 jpg img 1118036407 1456338971461 jpg img 1117112886 1456338971809 jpg img 1116189365 1456338972108 jpg img 1115265844 1456338972338 jpg img 1114342323 1456338972624 jpg img 1113418802 1456338972864 jpg img 1093101340 1456338973144 jpg img 1092177819 1456338973442 jpg img 1091254298 1456338973707 jpg img 1090330777 1456338973957 jpg img 1089407256 1456338974256 jpg img 1088483735 1456338974533 jpg img 1087560214 1456338974809 jpg img 1086636693 1456338975142 jpg img 1085713172 1456338975463 jpg img 1084789651 1456338975708 jpg img 1064472189 1456338975979 jpg img 1063548668 1456338976300 jpg img 1062625147 1456338976592 jpg img 1061701626 1456338976892 jpg img 1060778105 1456338977175 jpg img 1059854584 1456338977462 jpg img 1058931063 1456338977750 jpg img 1058007542 1456338978012 jpg img 1057084021 1456338978277 jpg img 1056160500 1456338978577 jpg img 1035843038 1456338978811 jpg img 1034919517 1456338979096 jpg img 1033072475 1456338979698 jpg img 1033995996 1456338979411 jpg img 1032148954 1456338979976 jpg img 1031225433 1456338980327 jpg img 1030301912 1456338980729 jpg img 1029378391 1456338981096 jpg img 1027531349 1456338981926 jpg img 1028454870 1456338981543 jpg img 1007213887 1456338982327 jpg img 1006290366 1456338982648 jpg img 1005366845 1456338982963 jpg img 1004443324 1456338983277 jpg img 1003519803 1456338983558 jpg img 1002596282 1456338983879 jpg img 1001672761 1456338984164 jpg img 1000749240 1456338984461 jpg img 999825719 1456338984762 jpg img 998902198 1456338985051 jpg img 978584736 1456338985420 jpg img 977661215 1456338985765 jpg img 976737694 1456338986094 jpg img 975814173 1456338986424 jpg

What They Liked

Ride and handling: “The GT feels right at home on the road course with superb balance and a playful, tail-happy attitude, even if it doesn’t have the outright grip and speed of the Camaro SS,” Bruzek said. “The handling isn’t quite as unflappable as the Camaro, but I think it’s more fun,” Wiesenfelder said. “It still has a lightweight, nimble feel to it,” Robinson said. The Mustang was Kadah’s favorite, even though it tied with the Challenger in points for him. “It’s a coin toss,” he said, but he thought “the Mustang definitely feels lighter and more responsive than the Challenger, but not as responsive as the Camaro.”

The engine: “The 5.0-liter V-8 makes big noise and big thrust,” Bragman said. “This thing feels crazy fast, especially on the track.” “It may not be the most capable on the track,” Robinson said, “but it is quite possibly the most fun.”

The shifter: “The best of all the manuals,” Robinson said, and Bragman added, “It feels very precise, with short, direct throws.”

Room and visibility: ‘The Mustang is the perfect size, with enough front passenger comfort and cargo room to be usable as a daily driver,” Bruzek said. “It provides the best visibility of the three contestants, in all directions, which lends confidence on the track as well as in daily traffic,” Wiesenfelder said.

And…: “The clutch pedal is crazy light,” Kadah said, “like I’m just pushing air.” “Ford’s Sync 3 is a huge improvement,” Bruzek said. “It has the most linear braking, on application and release,” Wiesenfelder said, “with superior pedal feel.” Kadah found the Recaro seats “crazy comfortable,” but he may have been alone there. …

What They Didn’t

Recaro seats: OK, several judges hated the Recaro seats. “They absolutely ruin this car,” Bragman said. “They’re not nearly adjustable enough and are mounted in a position that puts me into a horribly uncomfortable driving position.” “Those damn Recaro seats don’t have power adjustability, a heated or ventilated function, cost $1,595, are uncomfortable and don’t grip any better than the sports seats in the Challenger or Camaro, which have power, heated and ventilated front seats,” Bruzek complained. “As equipped, our car replaced the most adjustable standard seats in the test with overly restrictive, barely adjustable Recaros that must fit someone perfectly, just not any of our editors,” Wiesenfelder added.

Underpowered: “The Mustang could use some more muscle and horsepower under the hood, and some exhaust note to go with it,” Robinson said. “It sounds the most tame here by a wide margin.” “Its acceleration is a bit soft off the line, though the GT came into its own on the track where the revs are higher and 1st gear is but a memory,” Wiesenfelder added.

Fit-and-finish fail: “The exterior fit and finish are a problem,” Robinson said. “The body gaps are not consistent, and panels are misaligned.” “Inconsistent sheet-metal gaps and uneven trunk lids make a terrible impression,” Wiesenfelder said. “Poor build quality is apparent from nose to tail,” Bruzek said.

And…: “On the drag strip, the GT’s excessive wheel hop makes it the hardest car to drive,” drag-strip driver Bruzek said, “plus it’s just not as fun to wind out the gears thanks to a whisper-quiet exhaust.” “While the interior is nowhere near as cramped as the Camaro, it’s also nowhere near as comfortable as the Challenger,” Robinson said. “The clutch travel is really long, and the throttle is extremely springy, making for a lot of pogo-ing in everyday driving,” Bragman said, while noting that “the Brembo brakes that work so well on the track are overly grabby on the street, making a smooth stop a delicate and difficult balancing act.”

Research the 2016 Ford Mustang GT | Search Inventory

22016 Dodge Challenger R/T Scat Pack, 809 points

The Verdict: “This car is everything you want a muscle car to be: It’s big, it’s loud, it looks aggressive, it’s a handful to drive, and it’s a little bit scary at times,” Robinson said. “But it puts a big smile on your face every time you get behind the wheel and fire it up.”

img 2131414492 1456338894176 jpg img 992035946 1457126935321 jpg img 2130490971 1456338894542 jpg img 2129567450 1456338894800 jpg img 2128643929 1456338895115 jpg img 2127720408 1456338895717 jpg img 2126796887 1456338895981 jpg img 2125873366 1456338896220 jpg img 2124949845 1456338896443 jpg img 2124026324 1456338896666 jpg img 2103708862 1456338896920 jpg img 2102785341 1456338897170 jpg img 2101861820 1456338897383 jpg img 2100938299 1456338897698 jpg img 2100014778 1456338897989 jpg img 2099091257 1456338898282 jpg img 2098167736 1456338898569 jpg img 2097244215 1456338898917 jpg img 2096320694 1456338899182 jpg img 2095397173 1456338899466 jpg img 2075079711 1456338899799 jpg img 2074156190 1456338900067 jpg img 2073232669 1456338900300 jpg img 2072309148 1456338900616 jpg img 2071385627 1456338900951 jpg img 2070462106 1456338901281 jpg img 2069538585 1456338901615 jpg img 2068615064 1456338902066 jpg img 2067691543 1456338902422 jpg img 2066768022 1456338902818 jpg img 2046450560 1456338903203 jpg img 2045527039 1456338903599 jpg img 2044603518 1456338903932 jpg img 2043679997 1456338904282 jpg img 2042756476 1456338904583 jpg img 2041832955 1456338904905 jpg img 2040909434 1456338905267 jpg img 2039985913 1456338905715 jpg img 2039062392 1456338906132 jpg img 2038138871 1456338906483 jpg img 2017821409 1456338906822 jpg img 2016897888 1456338907183 jpg img 2015050846 1456338907867 jpg img 2015974367 1456338907518 jpg img 2014127325 1456338908316 jpg img 2013203804 1456338908681 jpg img 2012280283 1456338909008 jpg img 2011356762 1456338909351 jpg img 2009509720 1456338909934 jpg img 2010433241 1456338909616 jpg img 1989192258 1456338910199 jpg img 1988268737 1456338910477 jpg img 1987345216 1456338910881 jpg img 1986421695 1456338911254 jpg img 1985498174 1456338911551 jpg img 1984574653 1456338911832 jpg img 1983651132 1456338912216 jpg img 1982727611 1456338912599 jpg img 1981804090 1456338912997 jpg img 1980880569 1456338913316 jpg img 1960563107 1456338913665 jpg img 1959639586 1456338914000 jpg img 1958716065 1456338914285 jpg img 1957792544 1456338914571 jpg img 1956869023 1456338914915 jpg img 1955945502 1456338915250 jpg img 1955021981 1456338915600 jpg img 1954098460 1456338915920 jpg img 1953174939 1456338916257 jpg img 1952251418 1456338916517 jpg img 1931933956 1456338916803 jpg img 1931010435 1456338917052 jpg img 1930086914 1456338917322 jpg img 2131414492 1456338894176 jpg img 992035946 1457126935321 jpg img 2130490971 1456338894542 jpg img 2129567450 1456338894800 jpg img 2128643929 1456338895115 jpg img 2127720408 1456338895717 jpg img 2126796887 1456338895981 jpg img 2125873366 1456338896220 jpg img 2124949845 1456338896443 jpg img 2124026324 1456338896666 jpg img 2103708862 1456338896920 jpg img 2102785341 1456338897170 jpg img 2101861820 1456338897383 jpg img 2100938299 1456338897698 jpg img 2100014778 1456338897989 jpg img 2099091257 1456338898282 jpg img 2098167736 1456338898569 jpg img 2097244215 1456338898917 jpg img 2096320694 1456338899182 jpg img 2095397173 1456338899466 jpg img 2075079711 1456338899799 jpg img 2074156190 1456338900067 jpg img 2073232669 1456338900300 jpg img 2072309148 1456338900616 jpg img 2071385627 1456338900951 jpg img 2070462106 1456338901281 jpg img 2069538585 1456338901615 jpg img 2068615064 1456338902066 jpg img 2067691543 1456338902422 jpg img 2066768022 1456338902818 jpg img 2046450560 1456338903203 jpg img 2045527039 1456338903599 jpg img 2044603518 1456338903932 jpg img 2043679997 1456338904282 jpg img 2042756476 1456338904583 jpg img 2041832955 1456338904905 jpg img 2040909434 1456338905267 jpg img 2039985913 1456338905715 jpg img 2039062392 1456338906132 jpg img 2038138871 1456338906483 jpg img 2017821409 1456338906822 jpg img 2016897888 1456338907183 jpg img 2015050846 1456338907867 jpg img 2015974367 1456338907518 jpg img 2014127325 1456338908316 jpg img 2013203804 1456338908681 jpg img 2012280283 1456338909008 jpg img 2011356762 1456338909351 jpg img 2009509720 1456338909934 jpg img 2010433241 1456338909616 jpg img 1989192258 1456338910199 jpg img 1988268737 1456338910477 jpg img 1987345216 1456338910881 jpg img 1986421695 1456338911254 jpg img 1985498174 1456338911551 jpg img 1984574653 1456338911832 jpg img 1983651132 1456338912216 jpg img 1982727611 1456338912599 jpg img 1981804090 1456338912997 jpg img 1980880569 1456338913316 jpg img 1960563107 1456338913665 jpg img 1959639586 1456338914000 jpg img 1958716065 1456338914285 jpg img 1957792544 1456338914571 jpg img 1956869023 1456338914915 jpg img 1955945502 1456338915250 jpg img 1955021981 1456338915600 jpg img 1954098460 1456338915920 jpg img 1953174939 1456338916257 jpg img 1952251418 1456338916517 jpg img 1931933956 1456338916803 jpg img 1931010435 1456338917052 jpg img 1930086914 1456338917322 jpg

What They Liked

Puts the “muscle” in muscle cars: “The Challenger R/T Scat Pack is fun in the most immature way imaginable with obnoxiously loud exhaust, a huge Shaker hood scoop and bright purple paint that lets everyone at the party know you’ve arrived,” Bruzek said. “It is unabashedly, unapologetically retro in everything it does,” Bragman said, “from the styling, to the interior, to the Shaker hood on the massive Hemi V-8.” It’s “by far the most muscular looking of these muscle cars,” Robinson said, “but it is as comfortable as a big family sedan.” Wiesenfelder said, “the Challenger proves that style needn’t sacrifice utility or comfort.” “Definitely fun,” Kadah said, “but definitely different than the others. The Challenger is still a muscle car while the Camaro and Mustang are sports cars.”

Hemi engine: “It has the most immediate response of any of the engines here, with gobs of low-end torque available right now, but it still calmly motors around town without any quirks,” Bragman said. “Really feels like a muscle car,” Robinson said, “especially when you fire that big Hemi up.” “This giant purple hulk doesn’t belong on a racetrack,” Wiesenfelder said, “yet somehow it does.”

Exhaust note: “The V-8 rumble is terrific at all speeds,” Wiesenfelder said.

And…: “You might think skinny tires are a downside, which they are in terms of outright performance, but being able to ignite the rear tires in a cloud of smoke, on command, never gets old,” Bruzek said. And, he noted, “The Challenger is the only car in this comparison with enough interior room to fit four adults comfortably.”

What They Didn’t

That look: “I’ve never been one to own something that announces when I’ve arrived,” Kadah said, “and that’s exactly what the Challenger does.”

That clutch: “It’s the StairMaster of the group,” Wiesenfelder said, “too firm for daily driving.” “The clutch-pedal and gear-shifter effort are as old school as the styling, with serious punch and pull required when shifting gears,” Robinson said.

That size: “While it feels great in a straight line, and the sport suspension improves its track performance, it’s still just too massive to be fun on twisty mountain roads or tight racetracks,” Bragman said. “It’s so darn big,” Robinson said.

That exhaust note: “Great sound, but I wouldn’t want to drive this if I’m nursing a headache on the way home from work,” Kadah said.

That ride and handling: “There’s just an overall soft feel that keeps you from pushing things too hard through corners,” Robinson said. “Whether on the street or in a high-speed corner, the Scat Pack’s suspension is bouncy and never feels settled like the Camaro SS and Mustang GT,” Bruzek said. “Even though the road-holding exceeds expectations,” Wiesenfelder said, “this car’s handling isn’t in the same class as its competitors.”

Research the 2016 Dodge Challenger R/T Scat Pack | Search Inventory

12016 Chevrolet Camaro 2SS, 816 points

The Verdict: “The Camaro SS is the surprise in this test, demonstrating remarkable civility, comfort and user friendliness on the street, and eye-popping capability when raced on a racetrack,” Bragman said, “with only its poor brake feel and lack of head and trunk space counting against it.”

img 1029082035 1456338816435 jpg img660311126 1457126933421 jpg img 1028158514 1456338816860 jpg img 1027234993 1456338817169 jpg img 1026311472 1456338817385 jpg img 1025387951 1456338817673 jpg img 1024464430 1456338817953 jpg img 1023540909 1456338818190 jpg img 1022617388 1456338818455 jpg img 1021693867 1456338818737 jpg img 1001376405 1456338818986 jpg img 1000452884 1456338819300 jpg img 999529363 1456338819586 jpg img 998605842 1456338819891 jpg img 997682321 1456338820158 jpg img 996758800 1456338820378 jpg img 995835279 1456338820625 jpg img 994911758 1456338820886 jpg img 993988237 1456338821153 jpg img 993064716 1456338821437 jpg img 972747254 1456338821723 jpg img 971823733 1456338822041 jpg img 970900212 1456338822336 jpg img 969976691 1456338822671 jpg img 969053170 1456338823355 jpg img 968129649 1456338823720 jpg img 967206128 1456338824053 jpg img 966282607 1456338824387 jpg img 965359086 1456338824695 jpg img 964435565 1456338825053 jpg img 944118103 1456338825385 jpg img 943194582 1456338825704 jpg img 942271061 1456338826003 jpg img 941347540 1456338826324 jpg img 940424019 1456338826588 jpg img 939500498 1456338826844 jpg img 938576977 1456338827178 jpg img 937653456 1456338827506 jpg img 936729935 1456338827825 jpg img 935806414 1456338828102 jpg img 915488952 1456338828423 jpg img 914565431 1456338828755 jpg img 912718389 1456338829406 jpg img 913641910 1456338829088 jpg img 911794868 1456338829689 jpg img 910871347 1456338829956 jpg img 909947826 1456338830253 jpg img 909024305 1456338830537 jpg img 907177263 1456338831157 jpg img 908100784 1456338830875 jpg img 886859801 1456338831495 jpg img 885936280 1456338831797 jpg img 885012759 1456338832204 jpg img 884089238 1456338832588 jpg img 883165717 1456338832922 jpg img 882242196 1456338833263 jpg img 881318675 1456338833621 jpg img 880395154 1456338833977 jpg img 879471633 1456338834257 jpg img 878548112 1456338834530 jpg img 858230650 1456338834890 jpg img 857307129 1456338835192 jpg img 856383608 1456338835473 jpg img 855460087 1456338835832 jpg img 854536566 1456338836130 jpg img 853613045 1456338836372 jpg img 852689524 1456338836678 jpg img 851766003 1456338836989 jpg img 850842482 1456338837259 jpg img 849918961 1456338837590 jpg img 829601499 1456338837903 jpg img 1029082035 1456338816435 jpg img660311126 1457126933421 jpg img 1028158514 1456338816860 jpg img 1027234993 1456338817169 jpg img 1026311472 1456338817385 jpg img 1025387951 1456338817673 jpg img 1024464430 1456338817953 jpg img 1023540909 1456338818190 jpg img 1022617388 1456338818455 jpg img 1021693867 1456338818737 jpg img 1001376405 1456338818986 jpg img 1000452884 1456338819300 jpg img 999529363 1456338819586 jpg img 998605842 1456338819891 jpg img 997682321 1456338820158 jpg img 996758800 1456338820378 jpg img 995835279 1456338820625 jpg img 994911758 1456338820886 jpg img 993988237 1456338821153 jpg img 993064716 1456338821437 jpg img 972747254 1456338821723 jpg img 971823733 1456338822041 jpg img 970900212 1456338822336 jpg img 969976691 1456338822671 jpg img 969053170 1456338823355 jpg img 968129649 1456338823720 jpg img 967206128 1456338824053 jpg img 966282607 1456338824387 jpg img 965359086 1456338824695 jpg img 964435565 1456338825053 jpg img 944118103 1456338825385 jpg img 943194582 1456338825704 jpg img 942271061 1456338826003 jpg img 941347540 1456338826324 jpg img 940424019 1456338826588 jpg img 939500498 1456338826844 jpg img 938576977 1456338827178 jpg img 937653456 1456338827506 jpg img 936729935 1456338827825 jpg img 935806414 1456338828102 jpg img 915488952 1456338828423 jpg img 914565431 1456338828755 jpg img 912718389 1456338829406 jpg img 913641910 1456338829088 jpg img 911794868 1456338829689 jpg img 910871347 1456338829956 jpg img 909947826 1456338830253 jpg img 909024305 1456338830537 jpg img 907177263 1456338831157 jpg img 908100784 1456338830875 jpg img 886859801 1456338831495 jpg img 885936280 1456338831797 jpg img 885012759 1456338832204 jpg img 884089238 1456338832588 jpg img 883165717 1456338832922 jpg img 882242196 1456338833263 jpg img 881318675 1456338833621 jpg img 880395154 1456338833977 jpg img 879471633 1456338834257 jpg img 878548112 1456338834530 jpg img 858230650 1456338834890 jpg img 857307129 1456338835192 jpg img 856383608 1456338835473 jpg img 855460087 1456338835832 jpg img 854536566 1456338836130 jpg img 853613045 1456338836372 jpg img 852689524 1456338836678 jpg img 851766003 1456338836989 jpg img 850842482 1456338837259 jpg img 849918961 1456338837590 jpg img 829601499 1456338837903 jpg

What They Liked

Performance: “The 6.2-liter Chevrolet engine is the sweet spot between the more modest Ford 5.0-liter and the Dodge’s brute-force 6.4-liter V-8, with great power off the line and all the way up,” Wiesenfelder said. It should be noted that the SS swept all three performance tests and still won the top prize for fuel economy to boot. “The V-8 always responds with a burst of acceleration no matter what engine speed, vehicle speed or gear is chosen,” Bruzek said. “It’s solid, grips well and has instant response from the accelerator,” Kadah said. Out of the three, “the SS is the easiest to drive fast with little effort required to achieve the fastest acceleration times,” Bruzek noted. He was the track driver for all of the performance tests.

Handling: “Its handling and steering precision have a feel more similar to a Chevy Corvette than any of the other muscle cars,” Bruzek said. “The excellent steering, balance and road-holding raises the Camaro above the level of muscle car and into the realm of sports cars,” Wiesenfelder said.

Exhaust note: “With its active exhaust, this Chevrolet sounds great when you want it to, without being overly rumbly when you don’t,” Wiesenfelder said. “I almost want to turn down the radio and just listen to the exhaust,” Kadah said.

Worth the upgrade: “Of all the V-8s, the SS is the one that stands apart from its V-6 counterpart the most,” Robinson said. “The aggressive front end clues everyone in that you’re rolling with the big boy under the hood.”

And…: “The 8-speed automatic transmission’s active rev-matching feature is wonderful on the track,” Robinson said. “Excellent driver comfort, just the right combination of sporting seat position and adjustability for multiple body types,” Bragman said. “There would never be a boring day driving this car,” Kadah said.

What They Didn’t

Brakes: “The numbers may look good,” Wiesenfelder said, “but the brake pedal is mushy and seriously nonlinear.” “They feel much too soft for a car like this,” Bragman said, “with no confidence-inspiring initial bite at all.”

Lack of space: Kadah found the backseat, uh, snug. “Wow, this hurts. And I’m a short guy,” he said. Then, thinking positively, he added, “it makes me feel tall! I’m psyched.” He was kidding. “The backseat and cargo room make compromises you shouldn’t have to in a four-seater that isn’t a dedicated weekend-duty sports car,” Bruzek added. And Robinson found “the driver’s area is incredibly cramped.”

Visibility: “The super-high beltline combines with the low roof to make visibility the worst of all the cars here,” Bragman said. Several judges agreed. “The Camaro is consistently criticized for its rearward visibility, but it’s the compromised forward sightlines that are a liability both on the street and on the racetrack, especially when there are elevation changes,” Wiesenfelder said.

Poor interior quality: “It definitely looks cool,” Kadah said, “but it has a more plasticky feel than the Challenger.” “The SS interior comes up short on material quality against the Mustang and Challenger, even with a few nicer touches on the inside compared with the Camaro 1LT,” Bruzek said.

And…: “The V-8 feels strong, but it doesn’t have the immediacy of the Challenger’s Hemi,” Bragman said. “It’ll pull, but you have to specifically ask it to pull.” “It has the smallest trunk opening with a high lift-over that makes loading and unloading a chore,” Robinson said. “The hyperactive skip-shift feature that forces the stick from 1st to 4th gear is an abomination that outweighs whatever enjoyment you get from the active rev-matching incorporated in this transmission,” Wiesenfelder said.

Research the 2016 Chevrolet Camaro 2SS | Search Inventory

How the Competitors Fared in Each Category

Judges’ Average Score for Interior Quality

  1. 2016 Dodge Challenger R/T Scat Pack

    7.6

  2. 2016 Ford Mustang GT

    7.0

  3. 2016 Chevrolet Camaro 2SS

    6.8

Judges’ Average Score for Cargo

  1. 2016 Dodge Challenger R/T Scat Pack

    8.4

  2. 2016 Ford Mustang GT

    6.8

  3. 2016 Chevrolet Camaro 2SS

    4.6

Judges’ Average Score for Occupant Comfort

  1. 2016 Dodge Challenger R/T Scat Pack

    7.8

  2. 2016 Chevrolet Camaro 2SS

    5.0

  3. 2016 Ford Mustang GT

    4.6

Judges’ Average Score for Controls & Multimedia

  1. 2016 Ford Mustang GT

    7.6

  2. 2016 Dodge Challenger R/T Scat Pack

    7.4

  3. 2016 Chevrolet Camaro 2SS

    7.2

Judges’ Average Score for Handling

  1. 2016 Chevrolet Camaro 2SS

    9.2

  2. 2016 Ford Mustang GT

    7.8

  3. 2016 Dodge Challenger R/T Scat Pack

    6.6

Judges’ Average Score for Acceleration

  1. 2016 Chevrolet Camaro 2SS

    8.6

  2. 2016 Dodge Challenger R/T Scat Pack

    8.2

  3. 2016 Ford Mustang GT

    6.6

Judges’ Average Score for Braking

  1. 2016 Ford Mustang GT

    7.8

  2. 2016 Chevrolet Camaro 2SS

    6.6

  3. 2016 Dodge Challenger R/T Scat Pack

    6.4

Judges’ Average Score: Fun to Drive?

  1. 2016 Chevrolet Camaro 2SS

    8.2

  2. 2016 Ford Mustang GT

    8.2

  3. 2016 Dodge Challenger R/T Scat Pack

    7.4

Judges’ Average Score for Street Manners

  1. 2016 Ford Mustang GT

    8.0

  2. 2016 Dodge Challenger R/T Scat Pack

    7.2

  3. 2016 Chevrolet Camaro 2SS

    5.4

Judges’ Average Score: Worth the Money?

  1. 2016 Chevrolet Camaro 2SS

    7.8

  2. 2016 Dodge Challenger R/T Scat Pack

    6.0

  3. 2016 Ford Mustang GT

    5.8

Featured stories