Unlimited Motors Fishers

(70 reviews)
Visit Unlimited Motors Fishers
Sales hours: 10:00am to 7:00pm
View all hours
Monday 9:00am–7:00pm
Tuesday 10:00am–7:00pm
Wednesday 10:00am–7:00pm
Thursday 10:00am–7:00pm
Friday 9:00am–7:00pm
Saturday 9:00am–7:00pm
Sunday Closed
(317) 348-4410 (317) 348-4410


See all 92 vehicles from this dealership.

About our dealership

This seller has been on Cars.com since November 2012.
We are a family owned and operated dealership specializing in quality pre-owned cars, trucks, and suv's. We appreciate every one of our customers and treat you like family! We have several financing options available as well as extended service plans for all of our vehicles.Please stop in today and experience the "Unlimited" difference!
We treat you like our family!

Service center

Phone number (317) 578-2222

Service hours



(70 reviews)

A dealership’s rating is calculated by averaging its lifetime reviews. Includes reviews from DealerRater


Horrible waste of time

Informed me car was pick up ready and upon arrival the car was damaged and not inspected. Drove 6 hours to be lied to. Hope no one buys from this guy and gets lied to


Bought a car

TJ did a good job! Recommend if you look to purchase a car, he does his job well to make sure his meeting your goals.


Used Car

Just bought a Mustang convertible from Tim Smith. Was fast and easy process, price was fair and wonderful customer service. Love my new to me car.


First Online Buying Experience

This was my first online buying experience, which trying to overlook a car from pictures and online information will make anyone nervous. I worked with Tariq and had a great experience. He was honest and upfront with all the information. He called me back within a reasonable amount of time when he wasn't with a customer. I did a lot of research on the truck I wanted and knew all the combinations of miles and prices for the trucks I was interested in in that range. They have upfront pricing and don't really haggle with the price since they offered this particular truck lower in price than the same years and mileage as similar trucks. It was a lower price than average, so i felt like i got a good deal compared to other trucks with similar miles and age. The only reason I didn't give a 5 star was I felt the inside center console and under the seats could have been cleaned a little better. Other that that it was great.


Reached out but no response

I reached out to them via email in regards to a car I was interested in. Unfortunately I have had no response back. I guess they don't like business. Oh well. Thank you!

Dealer response

Mr Jethroe. I personally looked through our incoming leads and have not received one from you. Not sure if it went through .Unfortunately sometimes that happens. Please contact me directly to discuss and I will personally help you. Thanks John May, General Manager 317-578-2222



Tim Smith was a wonderful help. Professional, respectful, and explained everything so well. I was a good few hours away when I found the vehicle I was looking for. He was very upfront about everything, kept in touch throughout the process, and had exactly what I wanted finished and done in just a few short days. Also what a great personality!! Thank so much Tim!

Dealer response

Thank you Samantha!



After purchasing our vehical from them, within an hour of owning it, the check engine light came on. Took it to our mechanic, he found the issue, went back to them and they did not care one bit that their mechanics screwed up and made the engine blow. No reputable dealer would let a customer go out thier door with such a huge issue like what we dealt with. Bad, uncaring and only in it for the money! Will never ever trust another dealer that is not local to me. Definetly get your vehical checked out by a mechanic BEFORE purchasing!!

Dealer response

Sorry to hear you had trouble with your vehicle. Please contact me directly immediately to resolve this issue. You can reach me at 317-578-2222. Thank you. John May,General Manager


Had a good time buying a car. Highly recommend

I had a great time getting a new car at Unlimited Motors. I was a little bit nervous about the whole buying process since it was my first time to get one from a dealership. However, all that nervousness went away thanks to one of the agent, Tim Smith. He was extremely useful: He helped me picked the car that was right for me. I'm glad that he allowed me to look and test drive other car because that was how I was able to finally get the car that I liked. Furthermore, he also took his time to explain thoroughly all the clauses found in my contract. Thank you T. Smith!

Dealer response

Thank you Tim Smith! And no is was not OUR Tim Smith but how funny is that! We appreciate your business.


Good, easy going, not high pressure sales

The guys there are easy to talk with, straight shooters when I was dealing with them and shared real world experiences. While I didn't buy a car from them, they did give me useful information like on the extended warranty and whom not to go with regarding extended warranties. The cars I looked at were not a good fit for me but could be for someone else.

Dealer response

We appreciate the kind words T squared! Glad we could help!


False Information

Talked to TJ several times on the telephone today in regard to 2018 Chevy pu. He said to come in to look at it and I told him I'd be in tonight. Called TJ before leaving home to make sure the truck was LT model. Left home immediately and drove to dealership, upon arriving heard truck had been sold earlier today. WON'T RETURN--POOR COMMUNICATIONS! I'm giving my poor rating for this reasoning.

Dealer response

Thank you for the information Caseman. We will continue to improve our process to make sure this does not happen in the future.

Read all 70 reviews