Save your search and get notified when new inventory arrives.
Contact seller
Customize your budget
*Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.
**Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.
About your privacy: Cars.com is asking for your ZIP and credit rating because it helps us to make an educated guess at your sales tax and loan interest. These two factors can greatly change your monthly payment.
Used
hatchbacks
for sale
near
Sheridan, IN
under $40,000
- Down Payment
- $0
- Net trade-in value
- $0
- Months
- 72
- APR
- 7.0%
- Sales tax
- 0.0%
*Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.
**Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.






Used
2012 Volkswagen GTI
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Great Team!
Fadi was great to work with. He was very knowledgeable and honest. I enjoyed working with him. His mechanic was also very friendly and helpful. Great experience!
The best bang for your buck
The best bang for your buckThis car is not overly flashy it makes you feel young when you want but yet distinguished when you need to






Used
2013 Honda Fit Base
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
A car dealership that gets it right.
Too often you go to a car dealership with feeling like the vultures are descending upon you. When I arrived at the dealership no one came out to hassle me while I was looking. When we were done looking a salesman did approach us. His name was Neal Graham. Neal was warm, friendly and attentive. My father-in -law was with me as he himself had purchased a brand new Toyota just two years ago at this very dealership. He was right to recommend them to me. He would later say " How did you feel about your experience today"? I said " That's a dealership that gets it." Ed Martin Toyota is just simply the best dealership in Indiana. While I am ringing their bell the finance did a remarkable job explaining everything to us. Thanks Sam! There are very few places anymore that can bring you "The A game" in customer service. It is my hope that you visit this dealership so you to can have the experience that my wife, my father-in-law and I had. Thanks again Neal!
It is now 2024, my Fit is a bought new 2013.
It is now 2024, my Fit is a bought new 2013. Still drives like new. It's a little light, keeps you attentive to the road, the back seats are a little firm, but this car holds everything. All the ways you can configure the interior is amazing. If anyone thinks this car is weak, remember the peak horsepower is 6800 RPM. Run it out and feel the Vtec boost. Heat, A/C, ell that works well. Stereo has good sound, and you can connect iPhone through USB and track and volume is controlled by radio head. Body design still looks modern.



Used
2025 MINI Hardtop Cooper S
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
I stopped in to look at a vehicle not expecting to get
I stopped in to look at a vehicle not expecting to get the numbers to work. I worked with Virginia and she, not only, made the numbers work, but got the numbers to work better than I expected. She wasn't pushy or forced anything that I didn't want and was phenomenal in answering all the questions I had. And the bonus was that the process was quick. Thank you, Virginia for making the process so easy!






Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
I bought a car from here the car was perfect no issues
I bought a car from here the car was perfect no issues they have really good prices
I LOVE THIS CAR
Diesel Volkswagen. Need I say more? Comfort, reliability, BEST FUEL MILEAGE, and they don’t hesitate to continue making manual vehicle. 10/10 recommend. I can’t see myself driving anything else.






Used
2015 Honda Fit LX
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Two Great Experiences — A History of Authenticity
I’ve had two great experiences buying cars from Fritz in Fishers. The staff is warm, welcoming, friendly, and very real. It’s easy to have a long conversation with them, just chatting about the business and about the market climate and etc. They’ve been in the auto sales business for more than 40 years and there’s many good reasons why. Most of the bad reviews seem to be written by people who failed to ask questions or do their homework on the ***used*** cars they purchased. All used cars have surprises, whether big or small. Fritz has a solid warranty on their vehicles and a dedicated service department, and will be honest with you if they think you would get better help from a dealership. All in all, I’m happy to call myself a repeat customer of Fritz in Fishers.
Great commuter, buy the manual 6 transmission
Great overall little commuter hatchback. We got ours a few years old with low mileage due to the options we wanted. The other reviews are kind of silly on here, complaining about a car due to lack of options selected by the buyer. Yes it wont have heated seats if you dont get the heated seat models lol. Our model is the EX, it has a sunroof, blind mirror indicator, heated seats, and a manual 6 speed transmission. Basically all features any high end model could use, I dont like leather seats due to the degradation long term. Just make sure you avoid the CVT transmission. Our area would not offer manual 6 speed on the high end trim so we had to travel out of state to get ours. Few mods added to the car to make it even better: - bi-led projector retrofit on headlights - led bulbs all around, plates, interior. - auto dim rear view mirror (easy wire in) - front facing dash cam - sirius satellite radio - winter aluminum rims (instead of steelies), summer has factory 17" aluminum black/silver combo - towing hitch (bike carrier) -- vehicle rated at 2000 lbs Overall its been very reliable, super practical with the folding seats. It gets excellent fuel efficiency and fits everywhere. Power wise, its very snappy given with a manual transmission you can control it a lot better than the sloppy CVT. The manual does 0-60mph in 8 seconds or less, which is very fast for a little car. Its not a tesla or a GTR with 130hp but its plenty for its 36-40 mpg. One issue ours had was the starter went out really early, but it was an easy change out, its a known issue. The seats are not very comfortable for long trips but thats because they are so small and its a commuter car. The cam gear also can get noisy on these at start up, so they will rattle but has no impact to performance. We have just over 100k miles on ours and its a very strong little car, will be getting another one of the final production year as this one gets higher in mileage. Again get the manual 6, you will not regret it, honda manual cars are semi automatic, the clutch is like a feather vs. a subaru for example. Totally worth it.






Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
My Subaru forester had the 6 month service appointment
My Subaru forester had the 6 month service appointment with Tony today. He is very professional and thorough and seems to enjoy his work. Tom Wood’s dealership is a very clean and welcoming environment. Work was done in timely manner. Great experience today. Ann
It saved my life! REALLY!!!!
Bought it new in 2017 because I wanted a small car that didn’t crumple in an accident. Well it didn’t. Had a major accident and it was totaled. Hit by a much larger truck combined front and driver side collision, went airborne over 2/3 lanes, knocked down utility poles and stopped. I crawled out the drivers door with only bumps and bruises. I am 76ers old. Nothing in the car touched me, except the airbags. The medics didn’t believe me. (I am an RN). I am so grateful that it did it’s job by saving my life. So, I Bought another FIT. The driver’s seat is uncomfortable on a long trip and it takes a few seconds to get in gear. That’s all I have for negatives.






Used
2019 Audi A5 45 Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Never have any issues when coming into Audi!
Never have any issues when coming into Audi! I can make my appointments online and can come in when I have the time. I love that the minute you drive up someone is waiting in the bay for you so I never have to go look for someone. Ben Robbins is great! I mostly work with him when I go in which is nice seeing a familiar face and knowing he will get me taken care of! Thank you!
Beautiful inside & out!
Beautiful styled Car inside and out! Great 4 cylinder gas milage with the performance of a true sports car! This makes it an Amazing value car to me!






Used
2017 Toyota Prius c Two
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
An excellent team from the moment you walk in to the
An excellent team from the moment you walk in to the final handshake with the sales manager. We had a complicated trade-in situation, but their sales manager worked some real magic and made the deal happen in a way we never even imagined possible. I would absolutely trust these guys to sell cars—they truly know what they’re doing. Plus, I came in through a referral and even got a $100 discount! Recommend An excellent team from the moment you walk in to the final handshake with the sales manager. We had a complicated trade-in situation, but their sales manager worked some real magic and made the deal happen in a way we never even imagined possible. I would absolutely trust these guys to sell cars—they truly know what they’re doing. Plus, I came in through a referral and even got a $100 discount! Recommend
Low Cost of ownership
Is it the most fun car to drive? No. Is it a really cool car? No, unless you're an engineer. Is it reliable, cheap to operate and maintain? Yes! That's what this car is designed to do. It doesn't get up like a sports car or carry as much as a truck. Over 3 years of ownership I've experienced Zero problems with this car. I routinely transport my 4 kids around in it. I have moved 2x4's (8ft limit) in this. I have driven 500 miles at once in it. I have driven it in snow (once). It's a great car for anyone concerned about total cost of ownership.






Used
2018 Toyota Prius c Two
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Got a great price for my trade-in!
Got a great price for my trade-in! And even after the sale, they had my back. Highly recommend—seal of approval!
So cheap to run and all the modern conveniences.
A straight forward economy car to save money but it is very comfortable and fun to drive because it's so light. The gas savings at almost 50mpg are amazing.






Used
2016 BMW 328 Gran Turismo i xDrive SULEV
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
My kind of dealer
They have the best selection of used Muranos around that I was interested in. They have the best service and quality available. I recommend them heartily.
Very fun to drive.
I really enjoy the car almost as much as the service! The reason is the service has been flawless so far! We had an issue with one of the sensors where it would give us a drivetrain error and cut the power to 40mph! We found out that there’s a bug that triggers once you hit 1/8 of fuel left it happened ever time and there’s no fix.






Used
2018 Toyota Prius c Two
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Mustafa was easy to work with and we were able to make a
Mustafa was easy to work with and we were able to make a deal that worked for the both of us. A lot faster transaction than going to a dealership.
Cool little transportation unit is this....
So, our 2nd c. This little bugger has wheels (a 2), is sandstorm colored, has rails on the roof (like you'd ever carry much on it) and is just a great little car to drive. Our other car is a newish Forester and we fight over who takes the little c every day. Avg mpg over 50, even with Maine winters.






Used
2016 Porsche Panamera 4
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Bentley Indianapolis and Josh Rhodius were GREAT to work
Bentley Indianapolis and Josh Rhodius were GREAT to work with. I am near Seattle and they provided all the pictures, videos, and PPI coordination I asked for. Easy negotiation. 10/10 and highly recommended.
I am a 30 year automotive professional and a Porsche
I am a 30 year automotive professional and a Porsche owner since 1985. The Panamera GTS v8 is a BEAST. I love this car. I mean I love this car. If I ever sell it, I would want it to go to a family member or a close friend without hesitation. Having driven and owned multiple marque brands including Aston Martin, Bentley, Ferrari, BMW I can say that Porsche never disappoints. My GTS is a daily driver and one of the most comfortable and reliable cars I have ever driven. The interior is laid out extremely well and the exterior design is still jaw dropping. The performance from the 440 HP engine and multiple performance setting make this a true driver's car. P.S. Since 1984, All I have to do is hold the Porsche key in my hand to put a smile on my face, and I'm still smiling.






Used
2015 Audi A7 3.0T Premium Plus
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Penske Chevrolet
Excellent buying experience!!! Ordered the truck and got it in less than 6 weeks. Jayce, Mike and Scott treated me fantastic!
Most Reliable car I've ever owned.
This car met all of my needs and more. Very smooth drive, Very reliable, and definitely a head turner. Sad to see it go but I am in need of an SUV.






Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Great selection.
Great selection. Stuff very helpfull. No pressure. Bought great car at very fair price. Thank you Z.
Excellent value, and Completely Reliable.
This car is on the slow side, but can be peppy if the buyer is willing to consider a manual transmission. Having a second Cam, and weighing less than the previous generation is a boon to it’s performance. While the Car is certainly comfortable, it’s lacking heated seats is a tad unfortunate. The handling is great with maybe a lighter steering feel, but on wider tires that goes away. The Fit feels equally at home carving mountain passes as it does on city streets. As for the styling, there are fake vents on the rear of the car that are somewhat distracting to me, but those have been slimmed down with models more recent than the 2015 I bought. The magic seats are an awesome space saving solution and the rear seats have much more space than the car is given credit for. All in all, it is an excellent car with good feel, and great value.






Used
2025 MINI Hardtop Cooper S
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Very good people very nice made it so easy for me to get
Very good people very nice made it so easy for me to get what I wanted 😁👍
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
The salespeople were friendly and helpful.
The salespeople were friendly and helpful. Unfortunately we were not able to come to terms on a price.
I absolutely love mine in comfort I think that it could
I absolutely love mine in comfort I think that it could have been a little bit better but that's on long trips. Short trips the comfort is fine. My car was totaled and my airbags blew on my steering wheel and at my legs and I'm so glad that they did because I really would have gotten hurt without those airbags The seat belt also did its job very well and the brakes warning light came on first then the brakes came on the exact same time I was putting the brakes on a guy ran a stop sign and there really wasn't much I could do but hit him which it did total my car and I am now looking for another one of the exact same kind I want my car back I love my Honda Civic sport touring.






Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
We bought the Subaru, that speaks for it's self.
We bought the Subaru, that speaks for it's self. We really like the all wheel drive.
Best car I have ever owned. Super great!
This car is great and I can’t wait to take it on the open road this summer. Zoom zoom zoom zoom zoom zoom zoom zoom zoom!!!






Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
I'm an out of state buyer who is willing to gamble.
I'm an out of state buyer who is willing to gamble. I was looking for the best specimen of a particular older car which I didn't need-but wanted. I went into this with the attitude I was willing to spend a couple of thousand extra to get eveything right. The car was a one owner 2009 Florida car with 74K miles. The body and paint was in incredible condition. I spent an additional $1500 for a new suspension and to replace degraded window rubber seals neither of which was absolutely necessary-but I like to have things right. The car now looks and runs like 2 year old car-people are shocked when I tell them it is 15 years old! This is the second -and probably last car I will purchase online. I got burned on a previous online purchase-but this was an impulse buy which I could afford to risk and only time will tell if I made out Ok. But for now, I'm pleased. All this being said, Emron was true to his word and even came through with the missing owners manual a couple of weeks later. As of now, I consider my experience was good one.
11 years and going strong
Bought my Fit Sport new in 2013 (Ge8). Milano Red with 5 speed auto and paddle shifters. Almost never use paddles but use Sport mode for on ramps and merges sometimes. New it got 28 mpg in City and 45 mph long trips. Now 27-31 mpg in city and 40 mpg long trips Built at Hiroshima plant. It has not been babied but has been well-maintained for 142000 miles. Visibility is great and I tinted the glass when car is new. Interior is well designed, attractive and functional...the only thing I would change would be a bit more color, "lounge mode" on back seats, and a front passenger seat that would fold forward completely flat....I have hauled everything in this car...Gone through 4 sets of front brakes, 2 batteries, put in new spark plugs (1 original plug had lost its electrode!) at 110000 miles and a valve adjustment. Filters, oil, bulbs, transmission fluid refresh, etc...Also then installed Koni SRT orange struts and shocks. At 110k miles rear drum brakes were still at 90% so if anybody is thinking of doing jdm rear disc swap its not necessary. About 7 years ago tpms sensors started to fail but I never bothered to replace them....Total maintenance and repair costs have been .027 cents per mile! It's still tight, no rattles. Its been parked outside most of its life. Clear coat is starting show some wear in small areas. Hit a small deer once. Had headlights polished about 3 years ago. I am a big guy and have taken many long trips in it and no problems with front seat comfort. I have 6 wheels so I run snow tires on the front in winter. I use 205/55/16 tires as it seems to handle and ride a bit better with these slightly bigger tires. I wish Honda still sold them here. I am biased but I feel the 2nd gen Ge8s are the best looking and funnest to drive






Used
2022 Honda Civic Sport Touring
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Ray Skillman Mitsubishi West
We have purchased four vehicles from Ray Skillman West Mitsubishi. We also have our vehicle serviced at Ray Skillman MITSUBISHI West. My husband and I will continue our business with MITSUBISHI West and have and will recommend Ray Skillman MITSUBISHI West To our family and friends they are awesome!!
I absolutely love this car, I am so glad i went with this
I absolutely love this car, I am so glad i went with this car instead of the other option i was looking at. The only things i don’t like, are the limited storage space, and the engine start stop feature. There should be an option to turn it off and keep it off instead of having to turn it off every time i start the car. Other than that, this car is amazing. It has great leg room in the back, which is what i was looking for the most besides the remote start. I upgraded from a 2003 elantra.






Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Great service.
Great service. Great prices. We came in for an affordable car and found one! Thank you!
Great mileage, bought used
Bought used @ 8 yrs old. Very satisfied for retiree use and care. Great mileage. Some paint issues with rust on rear tire wells. It's Michigan winters & no garage.
*Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.
**Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.
Find great prices by city
-
Hatchbacks under $40,000 in Sheridan, IN
75 Great Deals out of 405 listings starting at $2,750
-
Hatchbacks under $40,000 in Westfield, IN
84 Great Deals out of 461 listings starting at $2,750
-
Hatchbacks under $40,000 in Kirklin, IN
52 Great Deals out of 312 listings starting at $2,750
-
Hatchbacks under $40,000 in Cicero, IN
73 Great Deals out of 382 listings starting at $2,995
-
Hatchbacks under $40,000 in Arcadia, IN
62 Great Deals out of 352 listings starting at $2,995
-
Hatchbacks under $40,000 in Zionsville, IN
78 Great Deals out of 448 listings starting at $2,750
-
Hatchbacks under $40,000 in Atlanta, IN
58 Great Deals out of 333 listings starting at $2,995
-
Hatchbacks under $40,000 in Carmel, IN
85 Great Deals out of 482 listings starting at $2,750
-
Hatchbacks under $40,000 in Noblesville, IN
83 Great Deals out of 439 listings starting at $2,750
-
Hatchbacks under $40,000 in Whitestown, IN
78 Great Deals out of 448 listings starting at $2,750
-
Hatchbacks under $40,000 in Tipton, IN
45 Great Deals out of 251 listings starting at $2,995
-
Hatchbacks under $40,000 in Lebanon, IN
73 Great Deals out of 403 listings starting at $2,750
Find great prices on used Hatchbacks in Sheridan, IN
- Hatchbacks for sale under $5,000
- Hatchbacks for sale under $6,000
- Hatchbacks for sale under $7,000
- Hatchbacks for sale under $8,000
- Hatchbacks for sale under $9,000
- Hatchbacks for sale under $10,000
- Hatchbacks for sale under $15,000
- Hatchbacks for sale under $20,000
- Hatchbacks for sale under $25,000
- Hatchbacks for sale under $30,000
- Hatchbacks for sale under $40,000
- Hatchbacks for sale under $50,000
- Hatchbacks for sale under $100,000
- ${price_badge()}
- ${ami_badge()}
- ${battery_badge()}${ev_report_link()}
- ${hot_car_badge()}
- ${award_badge()}
- ${cpo_badge()}
${price_badge_description}
${ami_badge_description}
The EV Battery Rating is based on this vehicle's current expected range relative to the vehicles expected range when new. ${battery_badge_text}
Certified cars are manufacturer warrantied and typically go through a rigorous multi-point inspection.
This car is likely to sell soon based on the price, features, and condition.
${award_blurb}
${award_two_blurb}