Skip to main content

What's the Best Midsize SUV for 2016?

img 53979198 1473802153894 jpg
2016 Midsize SUV Challenge | Cars.com photo by Evan Sears

CARS.COM — SUVs are the vehicle of choice in 2016 and the midsize category is one of the most popular with shoppers. They’re large enough to carry five adults comfortably, with plenty of cargo space but not the fuel penalty that full-size SUVs impose.

The 2016 Midsize SUV Challenge

Results | What You Get

Our criteria for this year’s test were simple: Each SUV model had to come in for less than $45,000, including its destination fee. Contenders included the 2016 Ford Edge, 2017 Hyundai Santa Fe Sport, 2016 Jeep Grand Cherokee, 2017 Kia Sorento and 2016 Nissan Murano. We know that shoppers in this category like to get a lot of bells and whistles with their SUV, and these came nicely equipped.

Our judges for this Challenge were:

  • Kelsey Mays, a Cars.com senior editor
  • Jennifer Newman, Cars.com managing editor
  • Mark Williams, a Cars.com assistant managing editor
  • Brian Robinson, a producer from the PBS show “MotorWeek”
  • Johnny and Marianne Walker, parents of two boys and in the market for a two-row midsize SUV

You can see how we conducted testing below the results. Here’s how they finished:

52016 Jeep Grand Cherokee, 694 points

The Verdict: “As you might expect, the Jeep is the only one here that still feels like a truck-style SUV, which is great if that’s what you’re looking for,” Robinson said. “But if a modern carlike ride quality is what you’re after, you’d be better off with one of the crossovers here.”

img 1673183011 1473802500310 jpg
img 630217094 1474297437489 jpg
img53221407 1473802500601 jpg
img1779625825 1473802500827 jpg
img 788937053 1473802501062 jpg
img937467365 1473802501249 jpg
img 1631095513 1473802501539 jpg
img95308905 1473802501744 jpg
img1821713323 1473802502023 jpg
img 746849555 1473802502217 jpg
img 1420658023 1473802502480 jpg
img305746395 1473802502792 jpg
img2032150813 1473802503023 jpg
img 536412065 1473802503223 jpg
img1189992353 1473802503431 jpg
img 1378570525 1473802503590 jpg
img347833893 1473802503805 jpg
img2074238311 1473802504000 jpg
img 494324567 1473802504200 jpg
img1232079851 1473802504399 jpg
img558271383 1473802504614 jpg
img 2010291495 1473802504801 jpg
img 283887077 1473802505041 jpg
img1442517341 1473802505259 jpg
img 1126045537 1473802505427 jpg
img600358881 1473802505689 jpg
img 1968203997 1473802505947 jpg
img 241799579 1473802506172 jpg
img1484604839 1473802506374 jpg
img 1083958039 1473802506591 jpg
img 1757766507 1473802506823 jpg
img 31362089 1473802507013 jpg
img1695042329 1473802507207 jpg
img 873520549 1473802507423 jpg
img852883869 1473802507623 jpg
img 1715679009 1473802507855 jpg
img10725409 1473802508107 jpg
img1737129827 1473802508328 jpg
img 831433051 1473802508541 jpg
img894971367 1473802508789 jpg
img221162899 1473802509074 jpg
img1947567317 1473802509269 jpg
img 620995561 1473802509494 jpg
img1105408857 1473802509723 jpg
img 1463154021 1473802509977 jpg
img263250397 1473802510222 jpg
img1989654815 1473802510423 jpg
img 1673183011 1473802500310 jpg
img 630217094 1474297437489 jpg
img53221407 1473802500601 jpg
img1779625825 1473802500827 jpg
img 788937053 1473802501062 jpg
img937467365 1473802501249 jpg
img 1631095513 1473802501539 jpg
img95308905 1473802501744 jpg
img1821713323 1473802502023 jpg
img 746849555 1473802502217 jpg
img 1420658023 1473802502480 jpg
img305746395 1473802502792 jpg
img2032150813 1473802503023 jpg
img 536412065 1473802503223 jpg
img1189992353 1473802503431 jpg
img 1378570525 1473802503590 jpg
img347833893 1473802503805 jpg
img2074238311 1473802504000 jpg
img 494324567 1473802504200 jpg
img1232079851 1473802504399 jpg
img558271383 1473802504614 jpg
img 2010291495 1473802504801 jpg
img 283887077 1473802505041 jpg
img1442517341 1473802505259 jpg
img 1126045537 1473802505427 jpg
img600358881 1473802505689 jpg
img 1968203997 1473802505947 jpg
img 241799579 1473802506172 jpg
img1484604839 1473802506374 jpg
img 1083958039 1473802506591 jpg
img 1757766507 1473802506823 jpg
img 31362089 1473802507013 jpg
img1695042329 1473802507207 jpg
img 873520549 1473802507423 jpg
img852883869 1473802507623 jpg
img 1715679009 1473802507855 jpg
img10725409 1473802508107 jpg
img1737129827 1473802508328 jpg
img 831433051 1473802508541 jpg
img894971367 1473802508789 jpg
img221162899 1473802509074 jpg
img1947567317 1473802509269 jpg
img 620995561 1473802509494 jpg
img1105408857 1473802509723 jpg
img 1463154021 1473802509977 jpg
img263250397 1473802510222 jpg
img1989654815 1473802510423 jpg

What They Liked

Power aplenty: “When passing on a two-lane highway, the Grand Cherokee’s V-6 engine didn’t hesitate when I stomped on the accelerator. That quick response inspires a lot of confidence,” Newman said, “and it’s a lot of fun, too.” “The engine and transmission is probably the best pairing of the group,” Williams said. “The eight-speed transmission is as ready to squeeze out mpg with its auto stop-start and its Eco mode on air conditioning as it is to rock and roll with fast-shifting Sport mode engaged.”

Brute force: “So for the same or similar price to the other players here, I can get a four-position multiterrain system, an extra low-range gear, carry heavier people and cargo than any of the others, tow a bigger boat and get the best driver-information screen, too? Done deal,” Williams said. “The Grand Cherokee comes with legit off-road potential and 6,200 pounds of towing capacity,” Robinson noted. “Nothing else here even comes close to that.”

Tech friendly: “If you’ve got older kids, the backseat is loaded with amenities, such as two USB ports, heated rear seats, seatback pockets and hooks for smaller bags — all of which will help keep whining to a minimum,” Newman said. “Maybe.” For Mays, “the multimedia system might be a few features short of the pack, but its huge screen and big, dummy-proof knobs win for outright simplicity.”

Riding in style: “If sheer ride comfort is your thing, the Grand Cherokee is king. The suspension banishes potholes to a galaxy far, far away,” Mays said. “The interior is a good mix of comfort and luxury without being over the top or pretentious,” Robinson said. Newman noted it has the parental holy grail: “For families with younger kids in car seats, the Grand Cherokee easily handles three car seats across the backseat.” “I like the higher feel I have when driving,” Marianne said. “It feels more like an SUV, but the side mirrors seem so small.”

And…: “Visibility is terrific,” Mays said. “The Grand Cherokee boasts a high driving position and the second-row head restraints flip out of the way for an unobstructed view out back.”

What They Didn’t

Rough ride: “If you’re looking for a smooth ride, this is not the SUV for you,” Newman said, in a comment that was echoed by Robinson. “Every road imperfection is transmitted into the cabin. For some, this is a plus — and a reason to buy a Jeep — but others will find it tiresome.” “On curvy roads, this is the truck of the group,” Mays said, “with soupy steering, spongy brakes and plenty of body roll.”

Hard to load: “The Grand Cherokee’s cargo floor is a few inches higher than the others. Load up often at Costco or Home Depot and your back will prefer something else,” Mays said. Robinson agreed.

Tight inside: “I definitely felt the most claustrophobic inside, with the cockpit surrounding you like an overstuffed couch,” Williams said. “It does not have the open-space feel of the other midlevel players.”

And…: “There’s a pretty dramatic difference between how nice the front seats are and how much less money looks like was spent on the backseats,” Johnny said. “The Grand Cherokee’s interior looks like an afterthought, with a poor imitation of metallic trim and not much else to set it apart,” Newman said. “Every window behind the driver and passenger is fairly compact, limiting more visibility than I’d like,” Williams said. “The rearview mirror has a small rear window to see through, as well.” “It’s one of only two V-6 engines here, but it doesn’t feel as powerful as the Murano,” Robinson said.

Research the 2016 Jeep Grand Cherokee | Search Inventory | Car Seat Check

42017 Hyundai Santa Fe Sport, 706 points

The Verdict: “What happened to the Santa Fe Sport?” Newman asked. “The darling of the midsize SUV class has slipped with its cheap-looking and feeling interior, noisy ride and lackluster engine.”

img 66387464 1473864589409 jpg
img537921236 1474297436827 jpg
img264301818 1473864590847 jpg
img594991100 1473864592079 jpg
img925680382 1473864593096 jpg
img1256369664 1473864594016 jpg
img1587058946 1473864595124 jpg
img1917748228 1473864596214 jpg
img 2046529786 1473864597256 jpg
img 1715840504 1473864598456 jpg
img1264356404 1473864599501 jpg
img1595045686 1473864600400 jpg
img1925734968 1473864601468 jpg
img 2038543046 1473864602483 jpg
img 1707853764 1473864603663 jpg
img 1377164482 1473864604598 jpg
img 1046475200 1473864605923 jpg
img 715785918 1473864607441 jpg
img 385096636 1473864608575 jpg
img 54407354 1473864609663 jpg
img 1369177742 1473864611084 jpg
img 1038488460 1473864612504 jpg
img 707799178 1473864613958 jpg
img 377109896 1473864615306 jpg
img 46420614 1473864616928 jpg
img284268668 1473864618405 jpg
img614957950 1473864619531 jpg
img945647232 1473864621208 jpg
img1276336514 1473864622514 jpg
img1607025796 1473864623575 jpg
img292255408 1473864625080 jpg
img622944690 1473864626653 jpg
img953633972 1473864628083 jpg
img1284323254 1473864629416 jpg
img1615012536 1473864630815 jpg
img1945701818 1473864632458 jpg
img 2018576196 1473864633609 jpg
img 1687886914 1473864634789 jpg
img 1357197632 1473864636120 jpg
img 1026508350 1473864637635 jpg
img1953688558 1473864638690 jpg
img 2010589456 1473864640123 jpg
img 1679900174 1473864641376 jpg
img 1349210892 1473864642574 jpg
img 1018521610 1473864643830 jpg
img 687832328 1473864645228 jpg
img 357143046 1473864646459 jpg
img 26453764 1473864647780 jpg
img304235518 1473864649510 jpg
img634924800 1473864651085 jpg
img 679845588 1473864652834 jpg
img 349156306 1473864654357 jpg
img 18467024 1473864655897 jpg
img 66387464 1473864589409 jpg
img537921236 1474297436827 jpg
img264301818 1473864590847 jpg
img594991100 1473864592079 jpg
img925680382 1473864593096 jpg
img1256369664 1473864594016 jpg
img1587058946 1473864595124 jpg
img1917748228 1473864596214 jpg
img 2046529786 1473864597256 jpg
img 1715840504 1473864598456 jpg
img1264356404 1473864599501 jpg
img1595045686 1473864600400 jpg
img1925734968 1473864601468 jpg
img 2038543046 1473864602483 jpg
img 1707853764 1473864603663 jpg
img 1377164482 1473864604598 jpg
img 1046475200 1473864605923 jpg
img 715785918 1473864607441 jpg
img 385096636 1473864608575 jpg
img 54407354 1473864609663 jpg
img 1369177742 1473864611084 jpg
img 1038488460 1473864612504 jpg
img 707799178 1473864613958 jpg
img 377109896 1473864615306 jpg
img 46420614 1473864616928 jpg
img284268668 1473864618405 jpg
img614957950 1473864619531 jpg
img945647232 1473864621208 jpg
img1276336514 1473864622514 jpg
img1607025796 1473864623575 jpg
img292255408 1473864625080 jpg
img622944690 1473864626653 jpg
img953633972 1473864628083 jpg
img1284323254 1473864629416 jpg
img1615012536 1473864630815 jpg
img1945701818 1473864632458 jpg
img 2018576196 1473864633609 jpg
img 1687886914 1473864634789 jpg
img 1357197632 1473864636120 jpg
img 1026508350 1473864637635 jpg
img1953688558 1473864638690 jpg
img 2010589456 1473864640123 jpg
img 1679900174 1473864641376 jpg
img 1349210892 1473864642574 jpg
img 1018521610 1473864643830 jpg
img 687832328 1473864645228 jpg
img 357143046 1473864646459 jpg
img 26453764 1473864647780 jpg
img304235518 1473864649510 jpg
img634924800 1473864651085 jpg
img 679845588 1473864652834 jpg
img 349156306 1473864654357 jpg
img 18467024 1473864655897 jpg

What They Liked

Driving with confidence: “The steering feel was a big standout,” Williams said. “It had a real precision and quickness to it that was nice when pushing through corners. It feels like the nimblest of our competitors, very likely because it’s the lightest package.” “The Santa Fe Sport is well-planted on the road,” Newman said, “especially through twists and turns.”

Cargo friendly: “There’s no shortage of enclosed storage cubbies in this group, but for sheer convenience, nothing beats the big, open tray ahead of the Santa Fe Sport’s gearshift,” Mays said. “It’s roomier inside than it appears outside,” Robinson added.

Value proposition: “As is traditional with Hyundai, you get plenty of features for the money,” Robinson said. “Stout safety ratings and an excellent warranty make a logical case for the Santa Fe Sport,” Mays said.

And…: “From the reclining and sliding rear seats to the pull-up window shades, the Santa Fe Sport had the backseat to beat,” Mays said. “The Santa Fe Sport has a multiview camera that allows the driver to see where the car is in relation to other cars when pulling into a parking spot, or to the street curb when parallel parking,” Newman said.

What They Didn’t

Interior motives: “The interior needs some work,” Mays said. “Hyundai’s grainy dashboard plastics, dull silver trim and wafer-thin seats need to go.” “The interior materials don’t appear as nice as most in this group,” Robinson added. “I’m not a fan of the control busyness,” Williams said. “The chrome buttons on a shiny black surface in a giant V-shape doesn’t look well-designed or executed.” “The center console has a strange look to it,” Marianne said. “All the controls seem easy to read and push up high, but it gets busy and strange looking down below.”

Poor performer: “The turbocharged engine, which is the same engine found in the Sorento, didn’t seem powerful enough for highway driving,” Newman said. “The turbo four-cylinder is peakier than most,” Mays said. “You have to keep the revs high for much power and the engine makes a coarse din to get there.”

Design fails: “The overall look seems like it should cost less than the others. I’m not sure I could justify spending the same amount of money for this as with the Nissan, Jeep or Subaru,” Marianne said.  “I can’t get over how much like a jelly bean the Santa Fe looks from across a parking lot,” Williams said. “This is almost the exact shape the whole segment is trying not to be.”

Hard to see out: “The Santa Fe Sport’s visibility is one of the worst here,” Robinson said. “The Santa Fe Sport’s swoopy styling sacrifices visibility,” Mays added. “The rising beltline shrinks the second-row windows and the rear-quarter windows are useless.”

Not sitting well: “The Santa Fe Sport has a sliding rear bench, which I’m normally a fan of, but when the bench is moved forward, there’s a sizable gap between it and the cargo floor,” Newman said. “In some cars, there’s a flap that bridges that gap, but the Santa Fe Sport doesn’t have it, which seems like an oversight.”

Research the 2017 Hyundai Santa Fe Sport | Search Inventory | Car Seat Check

32017 Kia Sorento, 740 points

The Verdict: “The Sorento is the one best suited to be the middle-of-the-road family vehicle, easily useful for all members of the family to drive comfortably: grandma, newly licensed driver and spouse,” Williams said. “As long as your needs are well-defined and you don’t expect to need much more, this is a solid, affordable choice.”

img813746951 1473864693864 jpg
img976088245 1474297437221 jpg
img559933927 1473864694988 jpg
img306120903 1473864696096 jpg
img52307879 1473864697137 jpg
img 201505145 1473864698817 jpg
img 455318169 1473864700354 jpg
img 709131193 1473864701919 jpg
img 962944217 1473864703100 jpg
img 1216757241 1473864704133 jpg
img1789290823 1473864705100 jpg
img1535477799 1473864706554 jpg
img1281664775 1473864708024 jpg
img1027851751 1473864709543 jpg
img774038727 1473864710843 jpg
img520225703 1473864712355 jpg
img266412679 1473864713719 jpg
img12599655 1473864714963 jpg
img 241213369 1473864716703 jpg
img 495026393 1473864718072 jpg
img 1783945625 1473864719422 jpg
img 2037758649 1473864720935 jpg
img2003395623 1473864722581 jpg
img1749582599 1473864723925 jpg
img1495769575 1473864725255 jpg
img1241956551 1473864726692 jpg
img988143527 1473864728201 jpg
img734330503 1473864729591 jpg
img480517479 1473864731021 jpg
img226704455 1473864732387 jpg
img 1062214777 1473864733933 jpg
img 1316027801 1473864735346 jpg
img 1569840825 1473864736622 jpg
img 1823653849 1473864737577 jpg
img 2077466873 1473864738724 jpg
img1963687399 1473864740113 jpg
img1709874375 1473864741554 jpg
img1456061351 1473864742987 jpg
img1202248327 1473864744596 jpg
img948435303 1473864746119 jpg
img 340483929 1473864747660 jpg
img 594296953 1473864749202 jpg
img 848109977 1473864750904 jpg
img 1101923001 1473864752508 jpg
img813746951 1473864693864 jpg
img976088245 1474297437221 jpg
img559933927 1473864694988 jpg
img306120903 1473864696096 jpg
img52307879 1473864697137 jpg
img 201505145 1473864698817 jpg
img 455318169 1473864700354 jpg
img 709131193 1473864701919 jpg
img 962944217 1473864703100 jpg
img 1216757241 1473864704133 jpg
img1789290823 1473864705100 jpg
img1535477799 1473864706554 jpg
img1281664775 1473864708024 jpg
img1027851751 1473864709543 jpg
img774038727 1473864710843 jpg
img520225703 1473864712355 jpg
img266412679 1473864713719 jpg
img12599655 1473864714963 jpg
img 241213369 1473864716703 jpg
img 495026393 1473864718072 jpg
img 1783945625 1473864719422 jpg
img 2037758649 1473864720935 jpg
img2003395623 1473864722581 jpg
img1749582599 1473864723925 jpg
img1495769575 1473864725255 jpg
img1241956551 1473864726692 jpg
img988143527 1473864728201 jpg
img734330503 1473864729591 jpg
img480517479 1473864731021 jpg
img226704455 1473864732387 jpg
img 1062214777 1473864733933 jpg
img 1316027801 1473864735346 jpg
img 1569840825 1473864736622 jpg
img 1823653849 1473864737577 jpg
img 2077466873 1473864738724 jpg
img1963687399 1473864740113 jpg
img1709874375 1473864741554 jpg
img1456061351 1473864742987 jpg
img1202248327 1473864744596 jpg
img948435303 1473864746119 jpg
img 340483929 1473864747660 jpg
img 594296953 1473864749202 jpg
img 848109977 1473864750904 jpg
img 1101923001 1473864752508 jpg

What They Liked

Top-notch backseat: “There’s lots of rear-seat room and cargo space,” Robinson said, and Williams agreed: “The extra wheelbase and larger interior volume really opens up the rear legroom.” It’s not just about the room, though. “Backseat passengers will enjoy the built-in sunshades, rear vents and rear reading lights, which sit near the doors and ensure the driver won’t be bothered by them at night,” Newman said. “There are plenty of ways to charge devices back there, too.”

Driving fun: “I like having the different mode settings. I’d probably want to keep it in Sport mode all the time,” Johnny said. “I really like the small performance touches Kia has included, such as the three separate modes for the transmission [Sport, Eco and Normal],” Williams said, “as well as the Auto Hold aspect that allows you to paddle-shift to hold the gear you want.”

Tech heaven: “Our test car lacked navigation, but its connectivity was otherwise an embarrassment of riches: Android Auto, Apple CarPlay, three USB ports and a 110-volt household outlet,” Mays pointed out.

Value, value, value: “The Sorento looks like a much pricier SUV thanks to its stunning grille and eye-catching alloy wheels,” Newman said. “It’s fairly luxurious for a midlevel trim,” Robinson said. Mays noted that, “with the lowest as-tested price and one of the best warranties in the group, the Sorento has undeniable value.”

And…: “The control layout looks clean and everything is simple to operate,” Robinson said. “It has the longest skyroof, so it really makes the inside of the vehicle feel open and airy,” Williams said. “The Sorento’s deep cargo area is the best-suited for large loads,” Mays added, “with a backseat pass-through that’s missing in the Ford, Jeep and Nissan.”

What They Didn’t

Noisy: “Driving the Sorento down most roads yields a symphony of sounds,” Newman said. “Only perfectly paved streets, which are few and far between, keep things quiet.” Robinson noted the “noisy rear suspension over harsh bumps,” and Williams “found quite a bit of ‘booming’ in the cabin when going over rougher roads and expansion joints.”

Slow and thirsty: “The Sorento’s turbo four-cylinder doesn’t feel as powerful as its numbers indicate,” Robinson said, “and its fuel economy is not that much better than a V-6.” “The accelerator lag seems consistently bad. Prod the gas and sometimes nothing happens until the transmission downshifts — and that can take a while, too,” Mays said. Newman agreed.

Design faux pas: “The designers seemed to just give up on the exterior styling,” Williams said. “This one is the minivan of our group.” And it didn’t end there for him. “I’m both a fan and detractor of the Kia grille,” he said. “I like the look of the floating pods that remind me of a ‘Star Trek’ episode, but it makes the transmission and air-conditioning coolers very visible when looking at the vehicle head-on.” For Newman, “while the Sorento gets the wood trim right, it has a rubbery-looking dash that looks like it belongs in a much lower priced SUV.”

Rough ride: Robinson bemoaned the “rougher ride than I remember,” and Mays added that “none of these SUVs rides poorly, but the Sorento probably comes closest to it. Potholes and tar patches elicit a noticeable degree of shimmy.”

And…: “The leather seats feel more like vinyl and they’re also a bit stiff,” Mays said.

Research the 2016 Kia Sorento | Search Inventory | Car Seat Check

22016 Ford Edge, 779 points

The Verdict: “Ford just edges out its Challenge competitors by doing most things — comfort, technology and family-friendliness — a little better than the rest,” Newman said, “but it could use some improvement with its turbo four-cylinder.”

img2015323273 1473869451212 jpg
img1634675087 1474297437762 jpg
img206464675 1473803047782 jpg
img238408003 1473803048001 jpg
img270351331 1473803048196 jpg
img302294659 1473803048434 jpg
img334237987 1473803048628 jpg
img366181315 1473803048804 jpg
img398124643 1473803049062 jpg
img430067971 1473803049287 jpg
img462011299 1473803049502 jpg
img1164764515 1473803049852 jpg
img1196707843 1473803050118 jpg
img1228651171 1473803050291 jpg
img1260594499 1473803050477 jpg
img1292537827 1473803050678 jpg
img1324481155 1473803050917 jpg
img1356424483 1473803051110 jpg
img1388367811 1473803051351 jpg
img1420311139 1473803051684 jpg
img1452254467 1473803051908 jpg
img 2139959613 1473803052167 jpg
img 2108016285 1473803052341 jpg
img 2076072957 1473803052584 jpg
img 2044129629 1473803052865 jpg
img 2012186301 1473803053109 jpg
img 1980242973 1473803053319 jpg
img 1948299645 1473803053521 jpg
img 1916356317 1473803053768 jpg
img 1884412989 1473803053971 jpg
img 1852469661 1473803054141 jpg
img 1149716445 1473803054337 jpg
img 1117773117 1473803054537 jpg
img 1085829789 1473803054800 jpg
img 1053886461 1473803055032 jpg
img 1021943133 1473803055366 jpg
img 989999805 1473803055617 jpg
img 958056477 1473803055902 jpg
img 926113149 1473803056183 jpg
img 894169821 1473803056452 jpg
img 862226493 1473803056723 jpg
img 159473277 1473803056986 jpg
img 127529949 1473803057238 jpg
img 95586621 1473803057443 jpg
img 63643293 1473803057684 jpg
img 31699965 1473803057924 jpg
img243363 1473803058168 jpg
img32186691 1473803058419 jpg
img64130019 1473803058668 jpg
img96073347 1473803058934 jpg
img128016675 1473803059222 jpg
img2015323273 1473869451212 jpg
img1634675087 1474297437762 jpg
img206464675 1473803047782 jpg
img238408003 1473803048001 jpg
img270351331 1473803048196 jpg
img302294659 1473803048434 jpg
img334237987 1473803048628 jpg
img366181315 1473803048804 jpg
img398124643 1473803049062 jpg
img430067971 1473803049287 jpg
img462011299 1473803049502 jpg
img1164764515 1473803049852 jpg
img1196707843 1473803050118 jpg
img1228651171 1473803050291 jpg
img1260594499 1473803050477 jpg
img1292537827 1473803050678 jpg
img1324481155 1473803050917 jpg
img1356424483 1473803051110 jpg
img1388367811 1473803051351 jpg
img1420311139 1473803051684 jpg
img1452254467 1473803051908 jpg
img 2139959613 1473803052167 jpg
img 2108016285 1473803052341 jpg
img 2076072957 1473803052584 jpg
img 2044129629 1473803052865 jpg
img 2012186301 1473803053109 jpg
img 1980242973 1473803053319 jpg
img 1948299645 1473803053521 jpg
img 1916356317 1473803053768 jpg
img 1884412989 1473803053971 jpg
img 1852469661 1473803054141 jpg
img 1149716445 1473803054337 jpg
img 1117773117 1473803054537 jpg
img 1085829789 1473803054800 jpg
img 1053886461 1473803055032 jpg
img 1021943133 1473803055366 jpg
img 989999805 1473803055617 jpg
img 958056477 1473803055902 jpg
img 926113149 1473803056183 jpg
img 894169821 1473803056452 jpg
img 862226493 1473803056723 jpg
img 159473277 1473803056986 jpg
img 127529949 1473803057238 jpg
img 95586621 1473803057443 jpg
img 63643293 1473803057684 jpg
img 31699965 1473803057924 jpg
img243363 1473803058168 jpg
img32186691 1473803058419 jpg
img64130019 1473803058668 jpg
img96073347 1473803058934 jpg
img128016675 1473803059222 jpg

What They Liked

Rockin’ ride: “The ride quality is terrific. The suspension blends control, comfort and quietness as well as some luxury SUVs,” Mays said, and Robinson agreed: “The Edge’s ride quality is easily one of the best here.”

Interior quality: “I’m impressed with the overall interior quality,” Williams said. “All gaps are pretty tight, all touch points on armrests and the console are soft for elbows and hands, and the design is simple.” Mays offered his own, backhanded praise: “Aside from its dullsville center controls, the Edge has top-notch cabin materials and uber-comfy seats,” he said. Newman chimed in on the seats, “The Edge’s seats get the Goldilocks award for comfort: They’re not too firm or too soft.”

Multimedia nirvana: If you’re a longtime reader of Cars.com, you know that we have not liked Ford’s MyFord Touch (for many good reasons). But now, with the introduction of the revamped Sync 3 system, the tide has turned. “Ford is emerging from a bad era of multimedia systems, but Sync 3 was worth the wait. It’s fast, simple and high-resolution,” Mays said. “Sync 3 is the best multimedia system in the Challenge,” Newman said. “It’s straightforward to use with no learning curve for first-time users.” Ford “has finally gotten it right,” Robinson said.

Fanny friendly: “The Edge has the most rear hip room of the Challenge contenders and it made easy work of fitting three car seats across its roomy backseat,” Newman said.

And…: “There were several little things that I liked,” Williams said. “Steering feel is impressively different when moving slow in parking lots than when compared to highway speeds; the tow hitch is nicely integrated into the rear bumper; and all the engine maintenance details (dipstick, filter, oil filler, battery, etc.) are easily accessible.”

Power push: “The engine is surprisingly powerful and snappy,” Williams said. “It ramps up quickly and can throw you into the back of the seats.”

What They Didn’t

Power failure: While Williams (and our family testers) liked the Edge’s acceleration, the other judges weren’t impressed. “You shouldn’t have to drive in Sport mode all the time to mitigate the Edge’s prodigious accelerator and transmission lag, but you end up having to,” Mays said. “The transmission seems to be on its own timetable and not in any particular hurry,” Robinson said. “Though I noticed it most when doing the usual multiple three-point turns when shooting driving shots, it takes forever to switch between Drive and Reverse.” “When you step on the accelerator, it takes a beat or two for the engine to engage, which is disconcerting when trying to jump into fast-moving traffic,” Newman added.

Funky steering: “Sports-car steering meets SUV handling,” Mays said. “Our test car’s fancy — and excellent — variable-ratio steering will have you tossing the Edge into corners only to discover lots of body roll and tentative grip.”

Hard to get into: “The Edge felt most like a bathtub when entering the vehicle. I had to lift my legs pretty high up and over the door sill,” Williams said.

Seat failures: “The Edge is the only SUV in our Challenge to have power-folding rear seats, but manually folding the heavy seatbacks into the upright position requires serious muscle,” Newman said. “The rear seats don’t fold flat; hauling larger items in the cargo area could be a little precarious.”

And…: “Visibility is not great, even out the front, with very thick A-pillars,” Robinson said. “Our Edge had the second-highest as-tested price, yet it was the only SUV in our group without all-wheel drive,” Mays said.

Research the 2016 Ford Edge | Search Inventory | Car Seat Check

12016 Nissan Murano, 811 points

The Verdict: “The Murano is the closest thing to a luxury SUV in this group, with a level of cabin materials and styling flair that’s largely missing among the others,” Mays said. “But, perhaps because of that, it’s also the least practical.”

img282253173 1473863844873 jpg
img 1015270180 1474297437995 jpg
img294492821 1473863846254 jpg
img306732469 1473863847244 jpg
img318972117 1473863848410 jpg
img331211765 1473863849261 jpg
img343451413 1473863850143 jpg
img355691061 1473863850984 jpg
img367930709 1473863851981 jpg
img380170357 1473863853202 jpg
img649442613 1473863854365 jpg
img661682261 1473863855409 jpg
img673921909 1473863856262 jpg
img686161557 1473863857365 jpg
img698401205 1473863858471 jpg
img710640853 1473863859462 jpg
img722880501 1473863860497 jpg
img735120149 1473863861510 jpg
img747359797 1473863862464 jpg
img759599445 1473863863473 jpg
img1028871701 1473863864519 jpg
img1041111349 1473863865564 jpg
img1053350997 1473863866803 jpg
img1065590645 1473863867759 jpg
img1077830293 1473863868880 jpg
img1090069941 1473863870135 jpg
img1102309589 1473863871223 jpg
img1114549237 1473863872233 jpg
img1126788885 1473863873247 jpg
img1139028533 1473863874199 jpg
img1408300789 1473863875771 jpg
img1420540437 1473863877064 jpg
img1432780085 1473863878483 jpg
img1445019733 1473863879837 jpg
img1457259381 1473863881255 jpg
img1469499029 1473863882484 jpg
img1481738677 1473863883665 jpg
img1493978325 1473863884883 jpg
img1506217973 1473863885719 jpg
img1518457621 1473863887044 jpg
img1787729877 1473863888300 jpg
img1799969525 1473863889387 jpg
img1812209173 1473863890328 jpg
img1824448821 1473863891520 jpg
img1836688469 1473863892603 jpg
img1848928117 1473863893923 jpg
img1861167765 1473863895141 jpg
img1873407413 1473863896355 jpg
img282253173 1473863844873 jpg
img 1015270180 1474297437995 jpg
img294492821 1473863846254 jpg
img306732469 1473863847244 jpg
img318972117 1473863848410 jpg
img331211765 1473863849261 jpg
img343451413 1473863850143 jpg
img355691061 1473863850984 jpg
img367930709 1473863851981 jpg
img380170357 1473863853202 jpg
img649442613 1473863854365 jpg
img661682261 1473863855409 jpg
img673921909 1473863856262 jpg
img686161557 1473863857365 jpg
img698401205 1473863858471 jpg
img710640853 1473863859462 jpg
img722880501 1473863860497 jpg
img735120149 1473863861510 jpg
img747359797 1473863862464 jpg
img759599445 1473863863473 jpg
img1028871701 1473863864519 jpg
img1041111349 1473863865564 jpg
img1053350997 1473863866803 jpg
img1065590645 1473863867759 jpg
img1077830293 1473863868880 jpg
img1090069941 1473863870135 jpg
img1102309589 1473863871223 jpg
img1114549237 1473863872233 jpg
img1126788885 1473863873247 jpg
img1139028533 1473863874199 jpg
img1408300789 1473863875771 jpg
img1420540437 1473863877064 jpg
img1432780085 1473863878483 jpg
img1445019733 1473863879837 jpg
img1457259381 1473863881255 jpg
img1469499029 1473863882484 jpg
img1481738677 1473863883665 jpg
img1493978325 1473863884883 jpg
img1506217973 1473863885719 jpg
img1518457621 1473863887044 jpg
img1787729877 1473863888300 jpg
img1799969525 1473863889387 jpg
img1812209173 1473863890328 jpg
img1824448821 1473863891520 jpg
img1836688469 1473863892603 jpg
img1848928117 1473863893923 jpg
img1861167765 1473863895141 jpg
img1873407413 1473863896355 jpg

What They Liked

It’s quick!: “Hit the gas and the Murano moves quickly,” Newman said. “Highway on-ramps and high-speed passing are a breeze thanks to its 3.5-liter V-6.” “You can have your peaky turbo fours,” Mays said. “Like our Grand Cherokee tester, the Murano had a big-boy V-6 — without the Jeep’s big-boy curb weight. It’s clearly the quickest one here.” “Despite being hampered with a continuously variable automatic transmission,” Robinson added, “it’s probably the best overall powertrain here.”

Heavenly seats: Much like Ford has had issues with its multimedia systems, Nissan seats have long drawn ire from Cars.com reviewers. Not here. “I’m definitely impressed with the larger, plusher seating feel — for both front and back seats,” Williams said. “The seats are incredibly comfortable,” Robinson added. “I like the luxury feel and looks of the front seats,” Johnny said. “I like the material and how they wrap around me, and I’m a pretty big guy.”

Quality, smart interior: “The interior is more of an upscale cocktail lounge than a typical automotive interior,” Robinson said, and Mays agreed. “Premium cabin materials abound, with convincing double-stitched dash panels and attractive piano-black trim,” he said. “This SUV model is a pack rat’s dream, with tons of cubbies in the cabin for storing all sorts and sizes of items,” Newman said. “I like the thoughtful detail in the rear area where the manual release drops the second-row seats and a push button allows you to raise them,” Williams said.

And…: “The Murano’s around-view camera system makes quick work of parallel parking, and it’s easy to access the multicamera view with the push of a button on the multimedia system,” Newman said. “It has a low load floor with seats that both fold down and power back up from the cargo area,” Mays added.

What They Didn’t

Hard to see: “The Murano’s C-pillars should be called C-, D- and E-pillars as they’re that wide,” Newman said. “This creates a giant blind spot that no amount of shifting in the driver’s seat can overcome.” “The small rear window, bulky backseat head restraints and ceiling-mounted center seat belt conspire to obstruct your rear view,” Mays added.

Driving concerns: “The steering requires a lot of effort at low speeds but doesn’t reward you at higher speeds,” Mays said. “On curvy roads, the crossover’s feedback is still numb.” “I understand the theory behind the CVT and the fuel economy advantages,” Williams said, “but the continual 1,500- to 2,000-rpm drone gets on my nerves.”

Poor design choices: “The exterior design tries too hard to be different,” Robinson said.  “I’m not a fan of the white-beige-cream-vanilla color and weird white-wood trim panels,” Williams said. “I get that it’s supposed to make the interior look bigger, but it seems more like a failed Ikea trim package experiment.” “From the side, the Murano’s profile doesn’t seem to flow together cohesively,” Newman said. “It has a huge, almost bulbous front end that’s married to a squat-looking cabin.” And finally, Robinson added, “I’m not sure what they call striated, shiny plastic trim, but I’m not a fan.”

Cargo mistakes: “The Murano doesn’t have any under-floor storage in the cargo area — not even a token sliver,” Newman said. “The center console and glove box are both quite big, but the Murano lacks much storage around the gearshift, an important convenience for its sheer accessibility,” Mays said.

And…: “It might be a small, weird thing [Editor’s note: And it is!], but the hood doesn’t lift very high, forcing a person to dip their head underneath to check the oil and air filters,” Williams said.

Research the 2016 Nissan Murano | Search Inventory | Car Seat Check

How the Competitors Fared in Each Category

img1186444390 1475197863607 jpg
img381289966 1475197849124 jpg
img496538910 1475197842721 jpg
img1945278078 1475197835398 jpg
img 990805696 1475197882359 jpg
img 645622575 1475197856190 jpg
img736102550 1475197829706 jpg
img 1095079650 1475197876934 jpg
img1581236448 1475197870739 jpg
img1174445066 1475197888811 jpg
img1186444390 1475197863607 jpg
img381289966 1475197849124 jpg
img496538910 1475197842721 jpg
img1945278078 1475197835398 jpg
img 990805696 1475197882359 jpg
img 645622575 1475197856190 jpg
img736102550 1475197829706 jpg
img 1095079650 1475197876934 jpg
img1581236448 1475197870739 jpg
img1174445066 1475197888811 jpg

 

How We Tested

We took these five midsize SUVs to the wilds of Wisconsin to put them through a week’s worth of testing. We had an expert round robin, where our judges took all five vehicles over the same roads to assess ride, handling, braking, noise and more. We drove a 145-mile real-world mileage route in and around Milwaukee to judge real-world fuel economy. We also brought an in-market couple to help us evaluate this year’s SUVs.

From all of the points we awarded in those tests, we found our winner. The scoring broke down this way:

  • 64 percent from the judges’ scoring
  • 16 percent from our shoppers
  • 10 percent from the crash-test score
  • 10 percent from the mileage drive
img 775399965 1475198162968 jpeg
Cars.com graphics by Paul Dolan

 

Add Cars.com as a preferred source on Google
Former editor-in-chief Patrick Olsen was born and raised in California. He loves pickup trucks and drivers who pay attention.

Featured stories