Auto Mart Of Ohio

(72 reviews)
2063 E Livingston Ave, Columbus, OH 43209
Visit Auto Mart Of Ohio
Sales hours: 10:00am to 5:00pm
View all hours
Sales
Monday 9:00am–6:00pm
Tuesday 9:00am–6:00pm
Wednesday 9:00am–6:00pm
Thursday 9:00am–6:00pm
Friday 9:00am–6:00pm
Saturday 10:00am–5:00pm
Sunday Closed
(866) 282-6044 (866) 282-6044
72 matches
[{"search_type":"general-inventory-search","vehicle_array":[{"trim":"Base","make":"Subaru","cat":"sedan_midsize","year":"2017","customer_id":"5377366","stock_type":"Used","listing_id":"31cb512f-15f8-4409-b524-be2d7677e416","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"99930","sponsored":false,"model":"Legacy","nvi_program":false,"vin":"4S3BNAA66H3068140","exterior_color":"Crystal Black Silica","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Slate Black","drivetrain":"All-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Auto Mart Of Ohio","msrp":"0","dealer_zip":"43209","seller_type":"dealership","price":"9995","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"Sedan","relevancy_score":null,"cpo_indicator":false,"badges":["great_deal"],"canonical_mmt":"Subaru:Legacy:Base","canonical_mmty":"Subaru:Legacy:Base:2017","cpo_package":null,"photo_count":58,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"LX","make":"Honda","cat":"sedan_compact","year":"2020","customer_id":"5377366","stock_type":"Used","listing_id":"bc64cad5-0c4b-48cf-9ccc-d6ffd47c79a3","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"31739","sponsored":false,"model":"Civic","nvi_program":false,"vin":"2HGFC2F66LH580770","exterior_color":"Modern Steel Metallic","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Black","drivetrain":"Front-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Auto Mart Of Ohio","msrp":"0","dealer_zip":"43209","seller_type":"dealership","price":"18495","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"Sedan","relevancy_score":null,"cpo_indicator":false,"badges":["great_deal"],"canonical_mmt":"Honda:Civic:LX","canonical_mmty":"Honda:Civic:LX:2020","cpo_package":null,"photo_count":67,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"EX","make":"Honda","cat":"sedan_compact","year":"2010","customer_id":"5377366","stock_type":"Used","listing_id":"b18d3f92-b015-4375-8889-fb6f888891d8","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"93699","sponsored":false,"model":"Civic","nvi_program":false,"vin":"2HGFG1B86AH535430","exterior_color":"Rallye Red","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Black","drivetrain":"Front-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Auto Mart Of Ohio","msrp":"0","dealer_zip":"43209","seller_type":"dealership","price":"7495","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"Coupe","relevancy_score":null,"cpo_indicator":false,"badges":["great_deal"],"canonical_mmt":"Honda:Civic:EX","canonical_mmty":"Honda:Civic:EX:2010","cpo_package":null,"photo_count":52,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"LX","make":"Honda","cat":"sedan_compact","year":"2013","customer_id":"5377366","stock_type":"Used","listing_id":"046db75a-aed4-4ff6-8adb-d1e57bb4036e","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"54124","sponsored":false,"model":"Civic","nvi_program":false,"vin":"2HGFG3B54DH514694","exterior_color":"Taffeta White","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Beige","drivetrain":"Front-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Auto Mart Of Ohio","msrp":"0","dealer_zip":"43209","seller_type":"dealership","price":"9495","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"Coupe","relevancy_score":null,"cpo_indicator":false,"badges":["great_deal","hot_car"],"canonical_mmt":"Honda:Civic:LX","canonical_mmty":"Honda:Civic:LX:2013","cpo_package":null,"photo_count":53,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"LX-P","make":"Honda","cat":"sedan_compact","year":"2018","customer_id":"5377366","stock_type":"Used","listing_id":"6a439876-7e31-48e5-b8fe-a7f39b9ef069","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"76741","sponsored":false,"model":"Civic","nvi_program":false,"vin":"2HGFC4B09JH302505","exterior_color":"Crystal Black Pearl","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Black/Gray","drivetrain":"Front-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Auto Mart Of Ohio","msrp":"0","dealer_zip":"43209","seller_type":"dealership","price":"13740","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"Coupe","relevancy_score":null,"cpo_indicator":false,"badges":["great_deal"],"canonical_mmt":"Honda:Civic:LX-P","canonical_mmty":"Honda:Civic:LX-P:2018","cpo_package":null,"photo_count":56,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"Base","make":"Honda","cat":"wagonhatchback_hatchback","year":"2008","customer_id":"5377366","stock_type":"Used","listing_id":"80264b00-328c-4231-acad-a65ea46828bf","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"142271","sponsored":false,"model":"Fit","nvi_program":false,"vin":"JHMGD37468S025044","exterior_color":"Gray","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Black","drivetrain":"Front-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Auto Mart Of Ohio","msrp":"0","dealer_zip":"43209","seller_type":"dealership","price":"5995","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"Hatchback","relevancy_score":null,"cpo_indicator":false,"badges":["fair_deal"],"canonical_mmt":"Honda:Fit:Base","canonical_mmty":"Honda:Fit:Base:2008","cpo_package":null,"photo_count":53,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"SE","make":"Ford","cat":"crossover_compact","year":"2019","customer_id":"5377366","stock_type":"Used","listing_id":"16d0ca17-dbb2-40af-83da-3eb6d794023b","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"73539","sponsored":false,"model":"Escape","nvi_program":false,"vin":"1FMCU0GD3KUA06943","exterior_color":"Magnetic Metallic","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Black","drivetrain":"Front-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Auto Mart Of Ohio","msrp":"0","dealer_zip":"43209","seller_type":"dealership","price":"12195","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"SUV","relevancy_score":null,"cpo_indicator":false,"badges":["great_deal"],"canonical_mmt":"Ford:Escape:SE","canonical_mmty":"Ford:Escape:SE:2019","cpo_package":null,"photo_count":56,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"LX","make":"Kia","cat":"sedan_compact","year":"2015","customer_id":"5377366","stock_type":"Used","listing_id":"83763fd4-c439-4e06-a833-e1851217d947","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"106646","sponsored":false,"model":"Forte","nvi_program":false,"vin":"KNAFX4A62F5400537","exterior_color":"Crimson Red","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Black","drivetrain":"Front-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Auto Mart Of Ohio","msrp":"0","dealer_zip":"43209","seller_type":"dealership","price":"5495","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"Sedan","relevancy_score":null,"cpo_indicator":false,"badges":["great_deal"],"canonical_mmt":"Kia:Forte:LX","canonical_mmty":"Kia:Forte:LX:2015","cpo_package":null,"photo_count":55,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"SE","make":"Ford","cat":"wagonhatchback_hatchback","year":"2019","customer_id":"5377366","stock_type":"Used","listing_id":"82c8e8e0-3a94-44fd-8d84-52128d2c8491","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"49690","sponsored":false,"model":"Fiesta","nvi_program":false,"vin":"3FADP4BJXKM119562","exterior_color":"Shadow Black","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Black","drivetrain":"Front-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Auto Mart Of Ohio","msrp":"0","dealer_zip":"43209","seller_type":"dealership","price":"8995","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"Sedan","relevancy_score":null,"cpo_indicator":false,"badges":["good_deal"],"canonical_mmt":"Ford:Fiesta:SE","canonical_mmty":"Ford:Fiesta:SE:2019","cpo_package":null,"photo_count":59,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"SL","make":"Nissan","cat":"crossover_compact","year":"2017","customer_id":"5377366","stock_type":"Used","listing_id":"db3fd9fe-7090-4ea1-b11f-89c277d2af9e","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"36292","sponsored":false,"model":"Rogue Sport","nvi_program":false,"vin":"JN1BJ1CR2HW114731","exterior_color":"Monarch Orange","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Black","drivetrain":"All-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Auto Mart Of Ohio","msrp":"0","dealer_zip":"43209","seller_type":"dealership","price":"11995","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"SUV","relevancy_score":null,"cpo_indicator":false,"badges":["great_deal","hot_car"],"canonical_mmt":"Nissan:Rogue Sport:SL","canonical_mmty":"Nissan:Rogue Sport:SL:2017","cpo_package":null,"photo_count":58,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"EX","make":"Honda","cat":"sedan_midsize","year":"2016","customer_id":"5377366","stock_type":"Used","listing_id":"7c6df482-d9b7-4359-bd3d-37b9fe4a316e","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"57326","sponsored":false,"model":"Accord","nvi_program":false,"vin":"1HGCR2F72GA048642","exterior_color":"Crystal Black Pearl","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Black","drivetrain":"Front-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Auto Mart Of Ohio","msrp":"0","dealer_zip":"43209","seller_type":"dealership","price":"16495","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"Sedan","relevancy_score":null,"cpo_indicator":false,"badges":["good_deal"],"canonical_mmt":"Honda:Accord:EX","canonical_mmty":"Honda:Accord:EX:2016","cpo_package":null,"photo_count":61,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"S","make":"Nissan","cat":"crossover_compact","year":"2020","customer_id":"5377366","stock_type":"Used","listing_id":"b942a25e-a55b-408c-b04a-d9c8b9d1b56b","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"51812","sponsored":false,"model":"Rogue Sport","nvi_program":false,"vin":"JN1BJ1CW9LW647237","exterior_color":"Gun Metallic","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Charcoal","drivetrain":"All-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Auto Mart Of Ohio","msrp":"0","dealer_zip":"43209","seller_type":"dealership","price":"14995","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"SUV","relevancy_score":null,"cpo_indicator":false,"badges":["good_deal"],"canonical_mmt":"Nissan:Rogue Sport:S","canonical_mmty":"Nissan:Rogue Sport:S:2020","cpo_package":null,"photo_count":57,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"SR5","make":"Toyota","cat":"truck_fullsize","year":"2015","customer_id":"5377366","stock_type":"Used","listing_id":"63cb8869-440f-4485-abb8-49a7656a0843","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"273764","sponsored":false,"model":"Tundra","nvi_program":false,"vin":"5TFUY5F13FX426174","exterior_color":"Blue Ribbon Metallic","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Graphite","drivetrain":"Four-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Auto Mart Of Ohio","msrp":"0","dealer_zip":"43209","seller_type":"dealership","price":"14995","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"Truck","relevancy_score":null,"cpo_indicator":false,"badges":["great_deal"],"canonical_mmt":"Toyota:Tundra:SR5","canonical_mmty":"Toyota:Tundra:SR5:2015","cpo_package":null,"photo_count":58,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"2.5 S","make":"Nissan","cat":"sedan_midsize","year":"2018","customer_id":"5377366","stock_type":"Used","listing_id":"6c90d0e5-8ee2-4dbb-8033-1d28c60c8196","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"35410","sponsored":false,"model":"Altima","nvi_program":false,"vin":"1N4AL3AP3JC249844","exterior_color":"Gun Metallic","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Charcoal","drivetrain":"Front-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Auto Mart Of Ohio","msrp":"0","dealer_zip":"43209","seller_type":"dealership","price":"14295","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"Sedan","relevancy_score":null,"cpo_indicator":false,"badges":["good_deal"],"canonical_mmt":"Nissan:Altima:2.5 S","canonical_mmty":"Nissan:Altima:2.5 S:2018","cpo_package":null,"photo_count":61,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"S FWD","make":"Nissan","cat":"sedan_midsize","year":"2021","customer_id":"5377366","stock_type":"Used","listing_id":"37432e45-182c-4470-ad99-65a635f789f8","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"29994","sponsored":false,"model":"Altima","nvi_program":false,"vin":"1N4BL4BV4MN420925","exterior_color":"Super Black","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Black","drivetrain":"Front-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Auto Mart Of Ohio","msrp":"0","dealer_zip":"43209","seller_type":"dealership","price":"16595","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"Sedan","relevancy_score":null,"cpo_indicator":false,"badges":["good_deal"],"canonical_mmt":"Nissan:Altima:S FWD","canonical_mmty":"Nissan:Altima:S FWD:2021","cpo_package":null,"photo_count":60,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"Sport Touring","make":"Buick","cat":"luxurysuv_crossover","year":"2020","customer_id":"5377366","stock_type":"Used","listing_id":"ad1dc0dd-154c-478e-ab30-ac717671209a","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"55247","sponsored":false,"model":"Encore","nvi_program":false,"vin":"KL4CJ1SB8LB025102","exterior_color":"Quicksilver Metallic","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Ebony","drivetrain":"Front-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Auto Mart Of Ohio","msrp":"0","dealer_zip":"43209","seller_type":"dealership","price":"13895","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"SUV","relevancy_score":null,"cpo_indicator":false,"badges":["great_deal"],"canonical_mmt":"Buick:Encore:Sport Touring","canonical_mmty":"Buick:Encore:Sport Touring:2020","cpo_package":null,"photo_count":59,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"EX-L","make":"Honda","cat":"crossover_midsize","year":"2015","customer_id":"5377366","stock_type":"Used","listing_id":"9c914e74-1e03-4fee-acc8-188dc10e2754","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"121915","sponsored":false,"model":"Pilot","nvi_program":false,"vin":"5FNYF4H52FB027168","exterior_color":"Gray","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Gray","drivetrain":"Four-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Auto Mart Of Ohio","msrp":"0","dealer_zip":"43209","seller_type":"dealership","price":"10995","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"SUV","relevancy_score":null,"cpo_indicator":false,"badges":["great_deal"],"canonical_mmt":"Honda:Pilot:EX-L","canonical_mmty":"Honda:Pilot:EX-L:2015","cpo_package":null,"photo_count":57,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"LX","make":"Honda","cat":"wagonhatchback_hatchback","year":"2019","customer_id":"5377366","stock_type":"Used","listing_id":"85105ab9-74e7-4ff5-ab31-6d20d357d84b","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"44464","sponsored":false,"model":"Fit","nvi_program":false,"vin":"3HGGK5H48KM738272","exterior_color":"Platinum White Pearl","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Black","drivetrain":"Front-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Auto Mart Of Ohio","msrp":"0","dealer_zip":"43209","seller_type":"dealership","price":"13495","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"Hatchback","relevancy_score":null,"cpo_indicator":false,"badges":["good_deal","hot_car"],"canonical_mmt":"Honda:Fit:LX","canonical_mmty":"Honda:Fit:LX:2019","cpo_package":null,"photo_count":53,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"SV","make":"Nissan","cat":"crossover_compact","year":"2018","customer_id":"5377366","stock_type":"Used","listing_id":"1d6a47e9-0b83-402d-9438-5bcbb34fca6f","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"57529","sponsored":false,"model":"Rogue Sport","nvi_program":false,"vin":"JN1BJ1CRXJW267797","exterior_color":"Brilliant Silver","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Beige","drivetrain":"All-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Auto Mart Of Ohio","msrp":"0","dealer_zip":"43209","seller_type":"dealership","price":"11995","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"SUV","relevancy_score":null,"cpo_indicator":false,"badges":["great_deal","hot_car"],"canonical_mmt":"Nissan:Rogue Sport:SV","canonical_mmty":"Nissan:Rogue Sport:SV:2018","cpo_package":null,"photo_count":61,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"LX","make":"Honda","cat":"crossover_compact","year":"2013","customer_id":"5377366","stock_type":"Used","listing_id":"907ee33d-494e-40a9-8694-5477dd7440a4","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"88362","sponsored":false,"model":"CR-V","nvi_program":false,"vin":"2HKRM4H33DH636177","exterior_color":"Crystal Black Pearl","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Black","drivetrain":"All-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Auto Mart Of Ohio","msrp":"0","dealer_zip":"43209","seller_type":"dealership","price":"11795","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"SUV","relevancy_score":null,"cpo_indicator":false,"badges":["great_deal"],"canonical_mmt":"Honda:CR-V:LX","canonical_mmty":"Honda:CR-V:LX:2013","cpo_package":null,"photo_count":56,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"Preferred","make":"Buick","cat":"luxurysuv_crossover","year":"2019","customer_id":"5377366","stock_type":"Used","listing_id":"af2be9b4-5b29-448d-8c99-1c59e6f1d2f7","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"55919","sponsored":false,"model":"Encore","nvi_program":false,"vin":"KL4CJASB0KB708300","exterior_color":"Quicksilver Metallic","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Ebony","drivetrain":"Front-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Auto Mart Of Ohio","msrp":"0","dealer_zip":"43209","seller_type":"dealership","price":"12295","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"SUV","relevancy_score":null,"cpo_indicator":false,"badges":["great_deal"],"canonical_mmt":"Buick:Encore:Preferred","canonical_mmty":"Buick:Encore:Preferred:2019","cpo_package":null,"photo_count":56,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"LS","make":"Chevrolet","cat":"sedan_compact","year":"2017","customer_id":"5377366","stock_type":"Used","listing_id":"b89fb71f-7c14-4b89-b477-544d50530a45","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"33163","sponsored":false,"model":"Cruze","nvi_program":false,"vin":"1G1BC5SM9H7219919","exterior_color":"Summit White","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Jet Black","drivetrain":"Front-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Auto Mart Of Ohio","msrp":"0","dealer_zip":"43209","seller_type":"dealership","price":"10195","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"Sedan","relevancy_score":null,"cpo_indicator":false,"badges":["good_deal"],"canonical_mmt":"Chevrolet:Cruze:LS","canonical_mmty":"Chevrolet:Cruze:LS:2017","cpo_package":null,"photo_count":55,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"SE","make":"Ford","cat":"wagonhatchback_hatchback","year":"2017","customer_id":"5377366","stock_type":"Used","listing_id":"ec407e8b-e5ca-42bd-bacd-0721ea42e2b0","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"47253","sponsored":false,"model":"Fiesta","nvi_program":false,"vin":"3FADP4EJ8HM156646","exterior_color":"Ruby Red Metallic Tinted Clearcoat","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Black","drivetrain":"Front-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Auto Mart Of Ohio","msrp":"0","dealer_zip":"43209","seller_type":"dealership","price":"7995","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"Hatchback","relevancy_score":null,"cpo_indicator":false,"badges":["good_deal"],"canonical_mmt":"Ford:Fiesta:SE","canonical_mmty":"Ford:Fiesta:SE:2017","cpo_package":null,"photo_count":41,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"Preferred","make":"Buick","cat":"luxurysuv_crossover","year":"2020","customer_id":"5377366","stock_type":"Used","listing_id":"03df8f2e-9893-49eb-b5fd-3abb50b434b7","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"43342","sponsored":false,"model":"Encore","nvi_program":false,"vin":"KL4CJASB4LB052281","exterior_color":"Summit White","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Shale/Ebony Accents","drivetrain":"Front-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Auto Mart Of Ohio","msrp":"0","dealer_zip":"43209","seller_type":"dealership","price":"12795","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"SUV","relevancy_score":null,"cpo_indicator":false,"badges":["great_deal"],"canonical_mmt":"Buick:Encore:Preferred","canonical_mmty":"Buick:Encore:Preferred:2020","cpo_package":null,"photo_count":57,"stock_sub":""}]}]
Used
2017 Subaru Legacy Base
99,930 mi.
$9,995
Used
2020 Honda Civic LX
31,739 mi.
$18,495
Used
2010 Honda Civic EX
93,699 mi.
$7,495
Used
2013 Honda Civic LX
54,124 mi.
$9,495
Used
2018 Honda Civic LX-P
76,741 mi.
$13,740
Used
2008 Honda Fit Base
142,271 mi.
$5,995
Used
2019 Ford Escape SE
73,539 mi.
$12,195
Used
2015 Kia Forte LX
106,646 mi.
$5,495
Used
2019 Ford Fiesta SE
49,690 mi.
$8,995
Used
2017 Nissan Rogue Sport SL
36,292 mi.
$11,995
Used
2016 Honda Accord EX
57,326 mi.
$16,495
Used
2020 Nissan Rogue Sport S
51,812 mi.
$14,995
Used
2015 Toyota Tundra SR5
273,764 mi.
$14,995
Used
2018 Nissan Altima 2.5 S
35,410 mi.
$14,295
Used
2021 Nissan Altima S FWD
29,994 mi.
$16,595
Used
2020 Buick Encore Sport Touring
55,247 mi.
$13,895
Used
2015 Honda Pilot EX-L
121,915 mi.
$10,995
Used
2019 Honda Fit LX
44,464 mi.
$13,495
Used
2018 Nissan Rogue Sport SV
57,529 mi.
$11,995
Used
2013 Honda CR-V LX
88,362 mi.
$11,795
Used
2019 Buick Encore Preferred
55,919 mi.
$12,295
Used
2017 Chevrolet Cruze LS
33,163 mi.
$10,195
Used
2017 Ford Fiesta SE
47,253 mi.
$7,995
Used
2020 Buick Encore Preferred
43,342 mi.
$12,795

Used cars for sale by city

Used cars for sale in Columbus, OH by make