Save your search and get notified when new inventory arrives.
Contact seller
Customize your budget
    
  *Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.
  
  
  **Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.
  
About your privacy: Cars.com is asking for your ZIP and credit rating because it helps us to make an educated guess at your sales tax and loan interest. These two factors can greatly change your monthly payment.
  Used
  cars
  for sale
  
  
    near
Bay Shore, NY 
    under $19,963
  
      - Down Payment
- $0
- Net trade-in value
- $0
- Months
- 72
- APR
- 7.0%
- Sales tax
- 0.0%
    
  *Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.
  
  
  **Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.
  
 
            
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2018 Nissan Rogue SV
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
My review is about Paul Whaley; i have only good things
My review is about Paul Whaley; i have only good things to say about him. Paul is a young man, very respectful, professional, attentive. He is very patience young man and always in contact with me without put pressure on me .Thanks Paul for all your efforts to close this deal, and I hope we do it.
This was a replacement vehicle for a Toyota Camry that
This was a replacement vehicle for a Toyota Camry that was totaled. Bought it, it was 3 years old with 36,032 miles on it. Been rear ended $14,000 in Damages to the rear, there’s only 2 things I would complain about. One getting a replacement Drivers seat has been a problem, I’ve even looked in Auto salvage yards to get a replacement seat, it’s been a headache, and if you do find one you got to give the first 2 numbers of the VIN # so the wiring Harness will work.. if you have the American built version , the Japanese or Korean Version Wiring Harnesses will not work, they will bolt in, but the Harnesses won’t work. Been looking for 3 years for a seat , still can’t find one. I’ve looked in both North & South Carolina for a replacement seat.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2020 Hyundai SANTA FE SEL 2.4
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
We are in our 70's and wanted a car that had blind spot
We are in our 70's and wanted a car that had blind spot protection with great window visability, a good sized GPS map, keyless entry, and good fuel economy. Also, it has good space in trunk with fold down rear seats. At 51,000 miles we have had no issues.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2017 Subaru Outback Limited
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Tommy the lot attendant greeted me in a friendly manner,
Tommy the lot attendant greeted me in a friendly manner, and helped me with a minor problem. We had a chuckle as well. Michelle greeted me warmly, addressed my concerns about a tire issue, escorted me to the lounge area, and said she would text me with updates. Lori and I had a nice chat before I settled into the lounge. Michelle came to get me to talk to the tech Adrien who reassured me about my tire concern. Everyone was professional, helpful, respectful of my concerns. I cannot imagine better service anywhere.
Functional, cute, & saved me from a bad crash!
I went from owning a 2003 Monte Carlo SS to a 2017 Subaru Outback. It was worth every penny. My Subaru is not only reliable, functional, and cute; it also saved me from being injured in a bad crash. This past fall a six point buck hit my car head on and I never saw it coming. It was a fatal crash for the deer, but not for me. As heartbroken as I was to see my car crumpled on the front, I was so glad it wasn't me. It was a repairable fix and made me really appreciate my car.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2019 Mazda CX-5 Sport
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
A great car - again
This is my second CX-5. This first was a 2016 I bought in 2019 and loved tremendously and then it was totaled when I was rear-ended by someone texting and driving during Covid. I drove a sort of hand-me-down Jeep for a while during the weird Covid period when everything was uncertain but knew I wanted another CX-5 as soon as I felt financially comfortable. The car is extremely comfortable, handles well and has a beautiful streamlined and simply classic look. My partner who is a die-hard Mercedes snob even loves it!
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2019 Volkswagen Tiguan 2.0T SE
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Looking for a good car
Nice profesional people worry for the coustumers I’m happy whit my car . The sale guy find me a good deal for my and my family
Good all - around vehicle.
Good all - around vehicle...decent power, roomy and comfortable interior, quiet and smooth ride, good handling and nice steering feel, great gas mileage, good visibility... Freeway passing requires a bit of patience and planning...
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Hi i had the best experience Abdul was wonderful
Hi i had the best experience Abdul was wonderful and a pleasure to work with. Mary was nice and sweet Hernan from finance was excellent and a pleasure everyone i came in contact with was so nice and made the car buying experience fun !!!!! def will recommend to family and friends
despite numerous quality & reliability issues ( 2016 thru
despite numerous quality & reliability issues ( 2016 thru 2021 ) > many will never be resolved by Honda as Honda accepts no responsibility nor concern about problems > including mechanical & in-vehicle entertainment systems, Honda still retains value.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2015 Honda Civic EX-L
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
John Farley is the best sales person.
John Farley is the best sales person. He did a great job with my financing. Thanks.
It's a small but not tiny.
It's a small but not tiny. It sort of roomier in the front but tighter in the rear seats. My model is the 2 doors coupe ex, with stick shift, it came well equipped with all the bells and whistles. Is good on gas and fun to drive. It's not incredible peppy but is fast and strong, and there's a lot of ways you can customize it with. Hondas have always been known for reliability, and this car won't disappoint you, it has 140k miles on it and stills runs like it was new. I got a really good deal from the dealer I bought it from, and they're pretty good overall. I would definitely buy from this place again!
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2019 Honda Civic LX
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
I bought 2 cars and have been bringing all my Honda cars,
I bought 2 cars and have been bringing all my Honda cars, including those I bought for my family members from other dealerships, for service and service is very professional.
Just bought the Honda Civic 2020 Sport Coupe and I’m
Just bought the Honda Civic 2020 Sport Coupe and I’m really happy with it. The car looks sharp, drives smoothly, and has enough power to make daily driving fun without sacrificing fuel economy. Interior is comfortable and modern, with all the tech I need. Overall, a great blend of sporty looks, efficiency, and reliability. I would Highly recommend this car.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
K.A. of Bayside
Great work . I have nothing to say only good words for this organization. Always number one.
I own a 2013 Altima with technology package sport mode
I own a 2013 Altima with technology package sport mode use shifting flippers to shift at red line v6 270hp flat out flies for a Sudan.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2020 Honda Civic Sport
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Abraham in service handled my recall service for my 2013
Abraham in service handled my recall service for my 2013 Accord and it was seamless. They gave me an appointment for the same week I called and the car runs better than ever now!
Get you one!
Best year civic thus far....gas mpg, handling, features, and comfort. I've had prolly 10 civics in my lifetime and this is the best one yet.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2018 Honda Civic EX
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Project Manager
Came in to purchase a new car after 12 years and the team at Jeep Chrysler Dodge City was very attentive, not pushy and very informed. Christina Granchelli provided a stress free car buying experience. She was especially helpful the day i picked up my Cherokee and was well informed on all the features. Would definitely recommend this dealership.
Absolutely love my car.
Absolutely love my car. 2018 SI sedan 6speed manual. A/C was fixed at dealer a while back. No problem since. No other problems of any kind. I never get under 35MPG COMBINED city and freeway. We drove to Phoenix and never got gas on the way. I’m at almost 90k miles, favorite car I have owned. I added a subwoofer to the stock stereo and it’s pretty good with Dolby Neural. I am amazed at the engineering to have over 200hp and just under 40mpg. Seat material is cheap. That’s one complaint. And it rides like a civic SI especially in sport mode. The handling is top notch I’ve scared a few people taking corners. If you like the SI cars over the years, this is one of the best
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2017 Honda Civic Sport
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Very happy with our new car purchase at Smithtown
Very happy with our new car purchase at Smithtown Toyota. Our salesperson was Trisha and she managed us through the smoothest transaction we've ever experienced. We had a question or two after the purchase, and Trisha got back to us right away. Thank you Trisha and to the entire team at Smithtown Toyota!
Best in Class, bar none.
Within it's class there is no better value. The overall layout and functionality of the car is superb. The 1.5L Turbo exhibits less turbo lag than any other turbo car I have ever driven. At first I was skeptical about the CVT, however, a hatchback with a 5-speed manual was unavailable (searched a 5 state area) when I purchased in March 2017. I was quite impressed with the performance of the CVT both in acceleration, functionality, and most of all the mileage matched with the engine. (70 mph cruise w/ A/C 38 mpg) Six years and 45K miles later (COVID kept the miles low) the car has had zero repairs other than routine maintenance. Handling is superb. Rear end styling isn't my favorite; but the hatchback is extremely useful in hauling materials (10 ft 2" x 4" lumber with fit with hatch closed). My 5th Honda bought new. (1982 Accord, 1997 Civic, 2002 S2000, 2007 CRV, & 2017 Civic Sport Hatchback).
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2020 Nissan Rogue SV
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Best customer service and very smooth process.
Best customer service and very smooth process. Highly recommend going to Albert Salib. He made the purchase smoothly. I recommend my family and friends to see Albert!!
Recommended
Nice interiors, good spaces, great color, perfect for family and daily use, engine in perfect conditions, the seller Juan Gonzalez from Seminole Toyota help me a lot in the right choice
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
I purchased my 2022 Kia Sorrento Hybrid last week.
I purchased my 2022 Kia Sorrento Hybrid last week. Karol Sanchez was my sales person and I can't begin to tell you how incredibly nice she was. She was very informative about the car we purchased and answered all of our questions without being pushy. She never made us feel rushed even when we were asking questions about different cars on the lot. Karol was instrumental in us deciding to purchase that day. Lawrence in finance was very helpful as well. Will definitely be returning their for our next family care.
Great vehicle
I have owned my 2017 Forester since late 2016. Except for normal maintenance I've had no problems with thr vehicle. All of the warning systems work very well,they have saved me from accidents numerous times. The automatic seat repositioning when some one else has used my is really handy eliminates all the adjusting needed to get the position back to my needs. Traction and controll during winter and bad weather are excellent. My forrester get used like a truck at times. Great overall car.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2021 Nissan Rogue SV
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Great experience they were prompt and they explained
Great experience they were prompt and they explained everything any questions that I had answered immediately
This 2021 Nissan Rogue SL is a great car.
This 2021 Nissan Rogue SL is a great car. It is very comfortable and loaded with features. I am very pleased with fuel efficiency. There has been no problems to report since I bought this car.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
The process was simple straight forward and fair.
The process was simple straight forward and fair. I wouldn’t hesitate to use legend Nissan again.
Great mileage and very nice interior.
Great mileage and very nice interior. Lotsa stuff but sadly only drivers window is auto. Wheels are terrible. They look great but very hard to clean. Good trunk space and nice seats. Having problems with backup camera it looks very foggy. Had it back to dealer twice, no luck. No CD player.. big downgrade.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
I?ve been going to Baron Nissan for years. I always get
I?ve been going to Baron Nissan for years. I always get the best deals. I?ve shopped them around before, but I always end up coming back.
I came from a 2018 Honda Accord EX to a 2022 Nissan
I came from a 2018 Honda Accord EX to a 2022 Nissan Altima SR VC-Turbo. The reason I switched to Nissan was the high lease price of the Accord in 2022. These cars are very similar in gas mileage, ride quality, trunk space and tech features. The Honda had a slightly smoother ride(but the Nissan does have 19" rims which means you feel the road imperfections more). My only complaint with the Altima is the back up camera. To put it frankly the resolution sucks!! The Accord had a crystal clear back up camera. Finally, my Accord had 190 hp and the Altima has 234 but honestly the acceleration is very similar.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2019 Hyundai SANTA FE 2.4 Limited
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
This dealer provided a purchase alternative to buying my
This dealer provided a purchase alternative to buying my vehicle at end of least that was very beneficial to us . New vehicle at close to The same monthly cost of financing the purchase of my vehicle with 51k miles on it.
We’ve put 85,000 miles on our Santa Fe, including a trip
We’ve put 85,000 miles on our Santa Fe, including a trip from Maryland to Idaho and Utah, and have consistently been happy happy with it. It’s needed no work/repairs, other than routine maintenance.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2019 Hyundai SANTA FE SEL Plus 2.4
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Nice place to do business.
Nice place to do business. Professional and courteous salesman. This car was exactly what I was looking for.
Reviews by Edson
I wanted a nice car at a value price at a great price so I got the 2019 Santa Fe and it had 30,000 miles on it and this thing runs and drives as smooth as glass
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2019 Subaru Forester 4DR SUV 2.5I
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
I can't tell you how happy I am with the service you
I can't tell you how happy I am with the service you provided, the great price you offered, and I just love my "used" Prius. Even though you are over four hours away from where I live and three states away, I would definitely come back again to Penn Toyota to purchase another vehicle! Your service is impeccable, your attention to detail and the overall great experience I had with your dealership was fantastic. Luis, my, salesman, was wonderful, kind and considerate. Thank You for being wonderful and honest dealership!!!
I had to make a 5 1/2 hour drive recently and loved how
I had to make a 5 1/2 hour drive recently and loved how smoothly my car drove, especially using cruise control with “eyesight” so it slowed when I was too close to the car in front of me. I couldn’t even feel it; I watched the speedometer. Love the safety features and extras like seat warmers and large sunroof.
    
  *Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.
  
  
  **Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.
  
Cars under $19,963 in Bay Shore, NY by make
- 
  
    Nissan under $19,963 in Bay Shore, NY
  
  145 Great Deals out of 377 listings starting at $2,700 
- 
  
    Jeep under $19,963 in Bay Shore, NY
  
  132 Great Deals out of 291 listings starting at $2,759 
- 
  
    Honda under $19,963 in Bay Shore, NY
  
  81 Great Deals out of 256 listings starting at $2,444 
- 
  
    Chevrolet under $19,963 in Bay Shore, NY
  
  129 Great Deals out of 254 listings starting at $1,750 
- 
  
    Mercedes-Benz under $19,963 in Bay Shore, NY
  
  95 Great Deals out of 199 listings starting at $4,500 
- 
  
    Hyundai under $19,963 in Bay Shore, NY
  
  68 Great Deals out of 186 listings starting at $2,999 
- 
  
    Ford under $19,963 in Bay Shore, NY
  
  68 Great Deals out of 177 listings starting at $3,299 
- 
  
    Toyota under $19,963 in Bay Shore, NY
  
  57 Great Deals out of 174 listings starting at $2,500 
- 
  
    BMW under $19,963 in Bay Shore, NY
  
  55 Great Deals out of 156 listings starting at $4,995 
- 
  
    Volkswagen under $19,963 in Bay Shore, NY
  
  47 Great Deals out of 136 listings starting at $3,602 
- 
  
    Kia under $19,963 in Bay Shore, NY
  
  38 Great Deals out of 109 listings starting at $2,900 
- 
  
    MINI under $19,963 in Bay Shore, NY
  
  35 Great Deals out of 108 listings starting at $3,985 
- 
  
    Subaru under $19,963 in Bay Shore, NY
  
  36 Great Deals out of 104 listings starting at $3,995 
- 
  
    Audi under $19,963 in Bay Shore, NY
  
  31 Great Deals out of 86 listings starting at $4,400 
- 
  
    Dodge under $19,963 in Bay Shore, NY
  
  27 Great Deals out of 66 listings starting at $5,432 
- 
  
    Mazda under $19,963 in Bay Shore, NY
  
  14 Great Deals out of 42 listings starting at $5,500 
- 
  
    Acura under $19,963 in Bay Shore, NY
  
  10 Great Deals out of 41 listings starting at $6,800 
- 
  
    RAM under $19,963 in Bay Shore, NY
  
  13 Great Deals out of 39 listings starting at $4,995 
- 
  
    GMC under $19,963 in Bay Shore, NY
  
  11 Great Deals out of 37 listings starting at $5,977 
- 
  
    Chrysler under $19,963 in Bay Shore, NY
  
  13 Great Deals out of 35 listings starting at $4,995 
- 
  
    Lexus under $19,963 in Bay Shore, NY
  
  12 Great Deals out of 28 listings starting at $6,098 
- 
  
    Buick under $19,963 in Bay Shore, NY
  
  10 Great Deals out of 26 listings starting at $5,950 
- 
  
    INFINITI under $19,963 in Bay Shore, NY
  
  10 Great Deals out of 24 listings starting at $4,300 
- 
  
    Mitsubishi under $19,963 in Bay Shore, NY
  
  7 Great Deals out of 23 listings starting at $5,318 
- 
  
    Cadillac under $19,963 in Bay Shore, NY
  
  4 Great Deals out of 22 listings starting at $3,700 
Find great prices by city
- 
  
    Cars under $19,963 in Brightwaters, NY
  
  1195 Great Deals out of 3157 listings starting at $1,750 
- 
  
    Cars under $19,963 in West Bay Shore, NY
  
  1193 Great Deals out of 3154 listings starting at $1,750 
- 
  
    Cars under $19,963 in North Bay Shore, NY
  
  1211 Great Deals out of 3209 listings starting at $1,750 
- 
  
    Cars under $19,963 in Baywood, NY
  
  1322 Great Deals out of 3424 listings starting at $1,750 
- 
  
    Cars under $19,963 in West Islip, NY
  
  1219 Great Deals out of 3232 listings starting at $1,750 
- 
  
    Cars under $19,963 in Islip, NY
  
  1060 Great Deals out of 2782 listings starting at $2,444 
- 
  
    Cars under $19,963 in East Islip, NY
  
  1054 Great Deals out of 2762 listings starting at $2,444 
- 
  
    Cars under $19,963 in Islip Terrace, NY
  
  1056 Great Deals out of 2779 listings starting at $2,444 
- 
  
    Cars under $19,963 in Brentwood, NY
  
  1197 Great Deals out of 3269 listings starting at $1,750 
- 
  
    Cars under $19,963 in North Babylon, NY
  
  1394 Great Deals out of 3602 listings starting at $1,750 
- 
  
    Cars under $19,963 in Deer Park, NY
  
  1390 Great Deals out of 3604 listings starting at $1,750 
- 
  
    Cars under $19,963 in Central Islip, NY
  
  1108 Great Deals out of 3046 listings starting at $2,444 
Find great prices on used cars in Bay Shore, NY
- Used cars for sale under $4,000
- Used cars for sale under $5,000
- Used cars for sale under $6,000
- Used cars for sale under $7,000
- Used cars for sale under $8,000
- Used cars for sale under $9,000
- Used cars for sale under $10,000
- Used cars for sale under $15,000
- Used cars for sale under $20,000
- Used cars for sale under $25,000
- Used cars for sale under $30,000
- Used cars for sale under $40,000
- Used cars for sale under $50,000
- Used cars for sale under $100,000
Used cars by body style and price
- ${price_badge()}
- ${ami_badge()}
- ${battery_badge()}${ev_report_link()}
- ${hot_car_badge()}
- ${award_badge()}
- ${cpo_badge()}
${price_badge_description}
${ami_badge_description}
The EV Battery Rating is based on this vehicle's current expected range relative to the vehicles expected range when new. ${battery_badge_text}
This vehicle is certified pre-owned, backed by a manufacturer warranty, and typically undergoes a rigorous multi-point inspection to ensure quality and reliability.
This vehicle is currently in high demand given its competitive price, desirable features, and overall condition, and may have a higher chance of selling quickly.
