Save your search and get notified when new inventory arrives.
Contact seller
Customize your budget
    
  *Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.
  
  
  **Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.
  
About your privacy: Cars.com is asking for your ZIP and credit rating because it helps us to make an educated guess at your sales tax and loan interest. These two factors can greatly change your monthly payment.
  Used
  convertibles
  for sale
  
  
    near
Bay Shore, NY 
    under $25,000
  
      - Down Payment
- $0
- Net trade-in value
- $0
- Months
- 72
- APR
- 7.0%
- Sales tax
- 0.0%
    
  *Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.
  
  
  **Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.
  
 
            
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Great experience had a little trouble with my convertible
Great experience had a little trouble with my convertible Zl1’ .Anthony the manager had me come in the following day at 9am .the car was fixed by 920 . Great experience from beginning to the end keep up the the work
Mine is a 2006 4.
Mine is a 2006 4.0 V6 convertible. I am absolutely in love with this car. It was very, very well maintained by the previous owner, and aside from minor paint chipping, looks to be almost brand new. It never fails to turn heads.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2008 Pontiac Solstice Base
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Outstanding dealership, Outstanding service
I bought a 2009 Mercedes S550 from Matt. Car was in superb Condition. I came from out of state, Bought the car, had it inspected at home, and drive it every day. You can trust this dealership. The product and sales were impeccable.
I absolutely love my Solstice GXP.
I absolutely love my Solstice GXP. It's got all the pep you could ever want,it handles & corners like it's on rails! I laugh everytime I see & easily pass Miata's,what a joke they are. I see people complaining about no storage space with these cars! Yes a little more space would be nice but that's what my truck is for. I go every 2 weeks & get groceries & supplies & I spend between $250-$400 and i can get it all in the car. And there are big items in there like 2 cases of pop,a big pail of Cat litter (the 35 lb. pail) and lots of other items. 12 rolls of paper towels, I do use the passenger & floor too but I can get it all in there. I also see people complain about cup holders,and somewhere to put change. The guy in Delaware. There are pockets on the front of both seats,rear of them too. Also the cup holder on the passenger side of console by their left knee,as well as the 2 behind your right elbow. If it bothers you that much buy the aftermarket cup holder for these cars! I'm 6 ft tall & don't have any sight problems he complained about,my Solstice has a power seat button that raises & lowers the drivers seat (only) not forward & back. The button is between your knees more on the left side. I had my car for almost 3 yrs before I discovered this. LOL I took the seat out to install some wiring for the interior lighting I put in,that's when I saw it. The only thing I can complain about is the location of the power window buttons. When I rest my right arm I accidentally hit the buttons and the windows go down. But that's not a big deal. Besides this winter when I put the car away I'm going to relocate them to the center console behind the shifter,because I can! The stereo system is quite impressive for a factory unit. I've had several thousand dollar Alpine,Nakamichi,ADS,Eclipse,Denon systems in my cars thru the years & this is comparable. Could use another subwoofer,to really get the bass i want. But it rocks! My brother always says I can't believe that's a factory system!!!. I love my Solstice. Everywhere I go i get asked what kind of car it is,how fast it is,and they love the color,Mean Yellow! I get alot of looks,especially when I get out of it because this spring i installed the Lamborghini door kit. So people really freak out when they see that. I think for giggles I'm going to buy either Lamborghini or Ferrari emblems to put on it. LOL I did tgat on a Dodge Neon i had years ago, i put Chevy emblems on it. When i traded it in the salespeople laughed hard when they saw it. I bought it in August of 2018 with 13,000 miles,I've got 36,000 on it now & haven't had a single problem. None!!!!
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2023 Ford Mustang EcoBoost Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
GT/CS
I bought a GT Premium/California Special and love it. It has more bells and whistles than any Mustang I have ever owned. The Mustang is well insulated and is a solid vehicle.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2007 Saturn Sky 2dr Conv
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
You can be confident in doing business here!
Inquired by email with a few questions and they were answered quickly and accurately on a Saturday! I almost gave up with inquiring by email as most dealers you will just get an automated response if any at all! Looks like a solid place to do business with a great line up of vehicles. Hope to get out there soon to grab my next ride!
Buy a Redline.
Bought the Sky Redline in ruby red with black racing stripes. we like to drive the back roads in Michigan especially in the Fall. Always get "THUMB'S UP" approval. Just a fun toy to drive. If you buy a SKY get a Redline turbo: it moves!
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2011 Mercedes-Benz E-Class E350 Cabriolet
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Best experience buying a vehicle!
My husband purchased a truck a few weeks ago from JTL in selden and it was the best experience we’ve had at any dealership in years. Everyone there was patient and really accommodating, we had some hiccups while getting approved for a loan but they helped us in any way they could, all while making sure we were still comfortable with the payments we’d have to make. The truck is exactly what my husband wanted and everything about this process was amazing, thank you JTL!
HAD TO HAVE ANOTHER
I mistakenly sold my 2012 E350 in 2023 thinking I should upgrade to an SUV. I regretted selling the wagon, though the 2020 MB GLB was a very nice vehicle. So I found a 2011 E350 wagon and couldn't been happier. Maintenance is key, yes. But the leather (not MBTex) wears very well, and the exterior is flawless.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2010 Nissan 370Z Touring
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Great experience with My sales woman Jaz
Honestly enjoyed this car buying experience! Just bought a brand new Altima from Jaz! No pressure at all, would definitely recommend her and this dealership to all my friends and family.
Awesome Car. One of the best desicion ive made.
Great Car. 26 mpg. I get a lot of complements. Its easy to drive and park. Im thinking of buying a second 370z for my son. Im Loving it.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2009 Jaguar XK Base
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Amazing Car Dealer & Perfect Car
Best car dealer I've ever done business with. I bought a car from him, while waiting for delivery Mike answered all my questions and tried to solve my concerns. Also, the vehicle was as clean as described.
Classy and sporty
A great reliable car with low cost of maintenance. The Jaguar reputation of years ago is long gone. Many people have asked if it is an Aston Martin.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
1990 Cadillac Allante 2dr Coupe Convertible
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Mike's knowledgeable and to the point.
Mike's knowledgeable and to the point. Qualities I appreciate. Car as represented and a good deal.
Very stylish Cadillac.
I have been a Cadillac owner all my driving life. I must say the Allante is very sporty compared to the boat like ride of the classic Cadillacs. I enjoy driving it especially with the top down.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2016 Audi A5 2.0T Premium Plus
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
What a terrific experience
What a terrific experience in buying a car Matt and his staff were so helpful. Made buying a car enjoyable again. If looking for a car you must visit this fine establishment Car was exactly the same as advertised. Perfect
Beautiful and it goes!
Great comfort and every conceivable feature. Responsive steering and breaking and plenty of power. Doesn’t hurt that it a beautiful car in perfect condition. Bought it at the right time from the right place.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2006 BMW Z4 3.0i Roadster
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Papa’s Z
A fun car to drive. I’ve received several compliments because how new or newer it looks being a 2006 Z4 e85. Kudos to the designers.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
      Used
2012 Audi A5 2.0T Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
A great car for 8 years and counting
Specifically, my car is the Audi A5 Cabriolet with all-wheel-drive. It's a gorgeous car, drives great, comfortable, and reliable. I would have preferred a manual transmission (this is my first ever automatic daily-driver), but a manual was unavailable in the cabriolet (and most cars anymore these days). The bottom line: It is a nice, comfortable, and reliable cruiser.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2009 Mercedes-Benz SLK-Class SLK350 Roadster
Vehicle information
Reviews
Fun to drive, small for comfort driving, noisy
The car drives fast and has superb handling. There is quite a bit of cabin noise driving through bumps. LA traffic really kills the fun of this car.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2002 Ford Thunderbird Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Great sales experience, Dan and his team were extremely
Great sales experience, Dan and his team were extremely helpful in our purchase. They went out of their way to make sure we were in a vehicle we wanted and were comfortable with. All of the vehicles on the lot were clean and in great shape. Highly recommend
Maybe it was just ahead of it’s time?
In 2002 they sold over MSRP adjusted for inflation @$54K in todays money- pricier than the 2002 Corvette and sold like 30,000 that year. I think that new car buyer had to probably be searching for the 1955 Thunderbird experience to shell out that kind of cash, and most people born on the 60’s and 70’s just didn’t understand that appeal. Oddly, the demographic that did BABIED their cars, kept up maintenance, have all the original tools and covers (just try and find that T-handle wrench for the hard top for example) when you get lucky enough to get a shot at buying one of these babies cars you’ll find they’re sharp and quick, amazingly so despite what people someone lent one to to write about said 20 years ago. Shod with 17inch tires 🛞 and solid suspension, people can complain about the horsepower being light, but stomp it and it will jump, zoom and weave solidly with the best of them. My drive home from buying this car was a blast. Will other sports models eke out slightly better speed, power and performance over these 20 year old T-birds? Sure, why not. Does it matter if you’re not at Road Atlanta? No. For me, this a sleeper sports car that’s about to bust onto the scene and see its reputation finally living up to the 2002 Car of the Year Award Motor Trend gave it. I think you need to find one of these babied sweethearts like I did. It’s a blast to find a good one and discover what an under rated blast it is to drive. Can’t really call it super nimble, but I respect mines solid ride and reasonably quick response & rocket like performance. The incredibly clean lines scream style visually and I suggest that a 2 tone leather optional interior is worth an extra $1K (over the basic. $11-12 K value) a hard top/rack/tonneau cover intact is worth another grand. ($13-14K total seems fair generally for a babied one). Check the rubber suspension parts underneath (inside the front wheel well behind the tire) is the easiest one to check quickly for rot w/o getting under the rear).
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2015 BMW 435 i xDrive
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
A Second Choice
Over a year ago I purchased a Nissan Altima from capital motors and still enjoy driving it every day. Because of the nature of my job It is necessary to have a back up vehicle. I had a Town&Country since 2004 which recently died and I needed to replace it. My first thought was to look at the inventory at Capital Motors and they had Ford Escape which looked good and affordable price. ERIN and Nick were very friendly and helped me with my second purchase. This car is also a joy to drive. Thank you again to Erin and to Nick. - Joseph Raffaele
FUN! A hard top convertible cannot be beat.
Quick, classy and fun. Makes you feel good every time you start it. There are cars that do many things better, but as a package it cannot be beat.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2002 Ford Thunderbird Deluxe
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
The dealership provided a quick response and follow up to
The dealership provided a quick response and follow up to insure that all my questions were answered. They were friendly, knowledgeable and I felt that the asking price was fair and reasonable for the car. They also provided a very reasonable transportation quote in a timely manner. I would highly recommend this dealership.
Dale Jarrett’s 2002 Tbird
A beautiful automobile gift from my beautiful wife on 6/2/23. I’ve been searching for a tbird and a friend told me to call and see if this guy was willing to sell one of 3 Tbirds he had. Little did I know in a few hours I’d be the new owner of Dale Jarrett’s personal Tbird with only 6,842 miles on it. His signature is on the dash and also his personal leather racing jacket signed. Needless to say it handles like new and has new car smell. We drove it from Charlotte NC to Charleston SC and couldn’t believe how it performed handled and rode. It’s definitely an eye catcher. The hardtop was easy to remove with 2 people. It would have been nice if it would have been designed to retract into the trunk. But mine came with hoist to attach to garage ceiling which made it very easy. I’m 100% satisfied and happy with my new Tbird.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2000 Jaguar XK8 4.2 L
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Steve is honest and caring.
Steve is honest and caring. I’ve bought and sold four cars from him and couldn’t be happier. The dealership looks like a museum, it’s gorgeous with cars ranging from $5000 to $300,000. I love it there.
Great Coupe!
I just bought this Coupe with 60,000 miles on the clock. The vehicle had been in a minor accident, but is still in decent condition. He runs like a stallion! I plan on changing out the transmission filter/fluid to keep the transmission shifting smoothly. (I am currently replacing the valve chains/tensioners on April 2nd, 2024). I'll keep working on the interior and plan on replacing the old headlamps with LED units. I also plan on removing (and selling) the rear seats, replacing them with slide bars for extra luggage room. This really is a two-seat, Grand Touring automobile, not a Sports Coupe. Since I have no family (and never will) the XK8 will allow me to travel at 1000+ mile stretches in comfort. The style is impeccable and the engine's smooth performance is pulse-quickening. Since I live in Northwestern Oregon, the convertible wasn't a practical option, so I sought out a Coupe. (I'm happy that I did). Put your money into restoring one of these Grand Touring machines. You'll gain more attention than the Corvette, Mercedes, Audi, Nissan and Porsche owners and you'll enjoy the ride. Come on. You know that you really want one, or you wouldn't be reading this.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2018 BMW 440 i xDrive
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Love my 440i
This is my 16th BMW since 1976 and I have never been disappointed. It's the perfect car for me, as I enjoy the performance, the style, the handling and the economy. I'm very pleased with 28+ MPG overall economy in any car that is capable of this type of performance. I cannot imagine that my next car won't be another BMW.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2002 Mercedes-Benz CLK-Class 320 Cabriolet
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
REVISED RATING OF DEALERSHIP
I wrote a negative review of this dealership earlier but I am rescinding that one and revising my overall rating from 2 to 4 because I received a full refund of my deposit of $500 within 5 days of being unable to consummate a deal due to the high cost of shipping the 2006 Honda CRV I was interested buying. They were also quick to provide me photos of sections of the vehicle I wanted to check.
The CLK 320 stands out as the most remarkable car I've
The CLK 320 stands out as the most remarkable car I've driven In terms of reliability, appearance and performance it truly excels. I've driven my cabriolet for 260k miles and still going strong. Love it so much that I just bought another for my daughter to start college at 81K miles, I anticipate tis vehicle to last 450K-500k miles on original engine and transmission (all with proper maintenance).
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2011 Lexus IS 250C Base
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Technically
The technician was very helpful( Max) easy to talk to and was very Polite make our transaction easy and quickly and mannerly will go again to him for assistance
A beautiful cruise.
It’s a really nice car and it does tend to get looks. My first Lexus and so far I’m really impressed with the performance. A nice car for a nice cruise.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2019 FIAT 124 Spider Abarth
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
As reliable as my Honda S2000, just not as fast
Three years of ownership and My Luso version is comfortable, fun to drive, A real keeper. Add a custon exhaust, with great sound. Not as loud as the Abarth but jst right.
About convertibles
What is the cheapest convertible available?
The Volkswagen Eos is the cheapest available convertible by average Cars.com listing price, with an average listing price of $9,353.
Which convertible has the best MPG?
The FIAT 500C has the best MPG among traditional internal combustion convertibles and offers up to 31 MPG city and 40 MPG highway for a combined rating of 34 MPG. The Mercedes-Benz AMG SL 43 has the best MPG amongst convertibles with hybrid powertrains, reaching 21 MPG city and 27 MPG highway for a combined rating of 23 MPG.
These figures are based on EPA mileage ratings and are for comparison purposes only. The actual mileage will vary depending on the selected vehicle model year, trim, driving conditions, driving habits, vehicle maintenance, and other factors.
Which convertible has the longest range?
The Tesla Roadster has the longest range among convertibles and can travel up to 245 miles on a single charge depending on electric motor and battery options.
EPA-estimated range is the distance, or predicted distance, a new plug-in vehicle will travel on electric power before its battery charge is exhausted. Actual range will vary depending on model year, driving conditions, driving habits, elevation changes, weather, accessory usage (lights, climate control), vehicle condition and other factors.
Which automaker has the most convertible deals?
Ford has the most available convertible deals on Cars.com with 777 great deals out of 2524 listings starting at $1,200.
Where can I find the most convertible deals?
The most convertible deals can be found near Dix Hills, NY with 39 great deals out of 119 listings starting at $2,995.
    
  *Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.
  
  
  **Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.
  
Find great prices by city
- 
  
    Convertibles under $25,000 in Brightwaters, NY
  
  36 Great Deals out of 105 listings starting at $2,995 
- 
  
    Convertibles under $25,000 in West Bay Shore, NY
  
  35 Great Deals out of 102 listings starting at $2,995 
- 
  
    Convertibles under $25,000 in North Bay Shore, NY
  
  36 Great Deals out of 105 listings starting at $2,995 
- 
  
    Convertibles under $25,000 in Baywood, NY
  
  36 Great Deals out of 107 listings starting at $2,995 
- 
  
    Convertibles under $25,000 in West Islip, NY
  
  35 Great Deals out of 105 listings starting at $2,995 
- 
  
    Convertibles under $25,000 in Islip, NY
  
  32 Great Deals out of 97 listings starting at $6,985 
- 
  
    Convertibles under $25,000 in East Islip, NY
  
  31 Great Deals out of 95 listings starting at $6,985 
- 
  
    Convertibles under $25,000 in Islip Terrace, NY
  
  31 Great Deals out of 96 listings starting at $6,985 
- 
  
    Convertibles under $25,000 in Brentwood, NY
  
  38 Great Deals out of 108 listings starting at $2,995 
- 
  
    Convertibles under $25,000 in North Babylon, NY
  
  36 Great Deals out of 108 listings starting at $2,995 
- 
  
    Convertibles under $25,000 in Deer Park, NY
  
  36 Great Deals out of 108 listings starting at $2,995 
- 
  
    Convertibles under $25,000 in Central Islip, NY
  
  33 Great Deals out of 101 listings starting at $6,985 
Find great prices on used Convertibles in Bay Shore, NY
- ${price_badge()}
- ${ami_badge()}
- ${battery_badge()}${ev_report_link()}
- ${hot_car_badge()}
- ${award_badge()}
- ${cpo_badge()}
${price_badge_description}
${ami_badge_description}
The EV Battery Rating is based on this vehicle's current expected range relative to the vehicles expected range when new. ${battery_badge_text}
This vehicle is certified pre-owned, backed by a manufacturer warranty, and typically undergoes a rigorous multi-point inspection to ensure quality and reliability.
This vehicle is currently in high demand given its competitive price, desirable features, and overall condition, and may have a higher chance of selling quickly.
