Used Ferrari cars for sale near West Sayville, NY

Blake was our sales person and could not say enough about our interaction. We never felt pressured but we felt he heard what we wanted and showed us options that checked all of the boxes. We weren’t pressured to leave money down when we were still contemplating. Blake did keep in touch with us to see what our feelings were about the options. Again- didn’t feel pressured but it was nice to have a follow up. Once we made a decision, we were in and out the same day. We got a great deal on our trade in and could not be happier. This is our second purchase in 2 years and would recommend. I will be back when I’m ready to trade in a few years down the line. Thanks again for making this process seamless/painless!

Great performance Overall the best performing car I have ever owned the acceleration is exhilarating. Wished I had bought one earlier. I love the wow!

Purchase a very nice Porsche from Motorcar Classics. The entire process was straight forward and very professional. Would highly recommend them to anyone looking for an exotic or classic car.

Even if Thomas Magnum was too tall for the Ferrari 308 GTS thats why he drove with the Targa roof off always. The 308-328 series is timeless work of art and that makes 328 GTS the best of 80's Era!!! Handles and drives Fantastic A+++++++

I have been left speechless by the services provided by MotorCar Classics. I had called their office and was so lucky to be connected to Craig. The original conversation started with info on a car they had recently sold. We talked for a good 20-30 minutes and I can tell Craig was full of enthusiasm and a passion for cars. One conversation led to another and he taught me how consignment works. I had sold 4 jeeps prior on my own and didn't even know consignment to sell a car was a thing. He walked me through the details on how it works. I ended up giving them my Jeep CJ-7 after a week and they had it sold faster than I had imagined. For my age, my biggest battle is getting a conversation going with such professionals who deal with cars worth hundreds of thousands. Their ENTIRE staff including the owner were so friendly & welcoming. I would do business with them a hundred times over. I HIGHLY recommend them.

Just a quick note of thanks. Every time I shift through the 6 speeds or exit a corner I have a greater sense of appreciation for this Porsche. You spent a considerable amount of time and were very patient with me during the buying process. I realize it was a small sale for Motorcar Classics but I felt as if I were buying a Carrera GT from you. There were no surprises, the delivery you arranged was smooth and I just love this car!

The Ferrari 360 Modena is an incredible vehicle that truly transports you back to the early 2000s. It's not the most comfortable ride—you feel every bump in the road, and it’s almost as if you’re sitting right on the pavement. But that’s part of the charm. My 360 Modena has a manual gearbox, and the mechanical feel of the entire car is something you just don’t find anymore. The experience of shifting gears, with the engine purring right behind your ears, is pure magic. The look and feel of this car are unlike anything I’ve ever experienced—it’s no wonder it’s a collector’s dream. The 360 Modena is a perfect example of Ferrari’s engineering excellence from the early 2000s. For those who own one, hold onto it. These cars are only going to increase in value, and I wouldn’t be surprised if they surpass $200K in the coming years. The Ferrari 360 Modena is truly amazing, and owning one is a privilege.

Called the team after searching for the right car and found Danny helpful, knowledgeable and sincere about the relationship versus selling anything. Appreciated his time and effort to understand my needs and hence will be visiting from Los Angeles to find my next Porsche. Outstanding experience, Danny many thanks!!!

Coming from a long line of performance cars (i.e. Viper ACR, Corvette ZR1, Ford GT, 458 Italia), the 488 GTB blows them all away in terms of styling, performance, comfort, features and wow factor. Whether cruising or pushing the upper limits of performance, the 488 never ceases to amaze me with its docile/ferocious attributes and incredible technology. Buy one ..... YOLO!

A great experience, dealing with dedicated and professional people who truly care and are willing to help out anyway possible

Visceral, engaging, powerful, meant to be a reflection of the brand and it delivers. Considered by many to be one of the best models Ferrari has produced....that says volumes. You drive this car, you park it, you walk away and turn back to take another look and you think.....oh my God.

They were upfront and honest, and I got in touch with someone really easily. Even though the deal didn’t work out for me (mainly because I was hoping to pay below retail for a high-demand car), I still liked and respected the team. If I were in their shoes, I wouldn’t have sold the Targa GTS for less than what they listed it for either. It sold the week after I saw it, so they made the right call. When I’m ready to step up and pay for a car, I’ll definitely go back to them. I wish I could respond to the people leaving 1-star reviews just because no one got back to them. Sometimes leads get missed—it happens—but that doesn’t deserve a 1-star review. Just move on!

Truly one of the sexiest cars in the world, crazy fast and incredibly value to buy preowned. The perfect car for the discriminating driver who wants it all, sound, acceleration, cornering and drop-dead sexy looks!

Great job. They contacted me the next day to see if they could answer any questions i may have had. .

Fred was excellent in assisting me with purchasing my vehicle. He was patient, kind and professional. I had a great experience and would highly recommend him!

My first Ferrari! I’m awestruck by this car. Puts a smile on my face. Never felt g force like this before. This us a great car for cruising the BRP.

Great fast service. Nice friendly people. Very professional. The gentleman that handled my car was very polite and helpful

Fantastic selection and the car I bought was mint. Danny is a great no pressure salesman. This place is full of unicorn Porsches. Can’t wait to buy another.

After going to a few main stream dealers, Ferrari of Long Island, was a surprisingly great experience. Fred showed me the cars that I was interested in and made me feel like a regular customer. After the sale was made they went above and beyond anything that would be expected. I don't think I could ever go to another car dealership in the future.

So many times when I’ve emailed a dealership, I either have gotten no response or I’ve had eight different people respond. With Motorcar Classics I received one call and email with helpful info - from the owner himself.

My experience at Ferrari of Long Island was an excellent one. DJ was a very polite, conscientious, and knowledgeable salesman who was a pleasure to work with.

This is such an amazing car. Versatile, fun, reliable, fast, head turner. Always makes you smile. Fast, slow, standing still. Top up or down. Best Ferrari to own AND drive.