Save your search and get notified when new inventory arrives.
Contact seller
Customize your budget
*Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.
**Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.
About your privacy: Cars.com is asking for your ZIP and credit rating because it helps us to make an educated guess at your sales tax and loan interest. These two factors can greatly change your monthly payment.
Used
cars
for sale
near
Middletown, NJ
under $5,000
- Down Payment
- $0
- Net trade-in value
- $0
- Months
- 72
- APR
- 7.0%
- Sales tax
- 0.0%
*Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.
**Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.






Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Great experience. Very helpful
Had a great experience very helpful. I was in need of a car fast and I’m glad I chose Brick city motors. I will definitely recommend this place to whoever want a reliable vehicle.
Very good vehicle
I bought a 2011 w/ 7k miles and now have 163k miles. Very few issues new water pump 5 years ago, 2 brake jobs, synthetic oil changes every 3k miles, replaced windshield wiper motor. Very good vehicle for the $. Buying slightly used saved me $7k.
Vehicle information
Reviews
Friendly honest dealership
The whole buying process was very easy here. Got a great deal here I was able to see under the car on the lift before purchasing and got to visually inspect before buying I would recommend buying a car here
Sick it was a awesome running vehicle until it
I'm sick i just sold this exact vehicle for $600.00 USD because I didn't know how to change a coil pack. I'm truly sad right now.Thank You
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Love this car!
Love my Prius. At first I thought it was ugly, but having owned it for so long, I love it! Get 52 miles to the gallon, but then I don't speed. I drive between 27-29 mph. in town, avoid freeways if I can to keep the mileage high. IU have only replaced the tires and the battery a couple of times. The car starts beautifully, responds well when driven. Is in good shape outside, except for a small "ding"on the bottom of the driver's side where I hit a curb.
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Danny was amazing thank you so much my car is so
Danny was amazing thank you so much my car is so beautiful he’s a very kind fair person again thank you so much !!!!
2007 Toyota Camry LE (after 17 years)
My grandma drove this car off the lot, brand new. Has been a great car. After a few years it was passed on to my mom, then my dad, and now me. I’ve driven this car for 3 years now but unfortunately there is too much maintenance to be done for the money. Around 160k miles for us it has had minimal issues so I’d say it’s a great car. It started when we got back from a trip and one of the cylinders were misfiring (which was a spark plug and an easy fix). Around 170k miles we were driving it and it ended up overheating. We got it towed and it ended up being the water pump going out (as well as the serpentine belt needing to be replaced). After that we drove it for a few weeks but it started running rough, then we went to go home from work one night and it was idling super rough so we drove it home and decided not to use it until we could get it towed to a mechanic. It was blowing out lots of white smoke. Turns out the head gasket has blown (which we think was from the overheating done originally). Car has officially made it to 173k miles. We were hoping more but it’s not horrible considering. Something to look out for is this also burns a lot of oil. Be sure to check it often, every two weeks depending on how much you drive. Wish the engine had a recall or something for that issue. Overall great car but from my reading, don’t get a 2007-2013 if used since these are the years for oil consumption issues.
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
I have owned a 2013 Rogue for 10 years.
I have owned a 2013 Rogue for 10 years. It has traveled north, south, east and west multiple times with no issues until just now. Catalytic Converter and a run in with a deer. Would i get another one? Absolutely.






Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Better than my 1991 Acura Legend L coupe 2000-2011
I've still owned my trusted 2006 Acura TL in maroon and cream interior with 156k miles. It still drives like when got it with 82K miles since 2011 and even better with the new front struts and lower control arms. It turns tighter and sharper than ever before and still gets about 27 mpg combined. The leather seats hold up very well with no tear except the well known cracked dashboard. The metallic paint is still shiny so are the 5 star wheel spokes, etc. Very dependable car and I love it!






Used
2008 Audi A6 3.2 Avant quattro
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
I am extremely happy with the maintenance service and the
I am extremely happy with the maintenance service and the sales department especially Mr Stacy Hopson. I have bring leasing my cars ever since 2016 and I have been very satisfied satisfied with the entire dealership.
used vehicle
The salesperson, Hailey, was pleasure to work with and it was a no pressure sales. I feel I got a great used vehicle for the money. Thank you, Hailey.






Used
2010 Subaru Tribeca 3.6 R Limited
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Great deals
They had fantastic service fast and easy help and great cars they even helped me set up my insurance very friendly people i would recommend to my family and friends
Very solid, safe, reliable family car
Very comfortable ride, peppy and fun to drive. No problems with driving this car through the mountains, around the city , long road trips. Lots of rooms for skis, luggage, family dog, etc
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Its a professional and well run dealership could not get
Its a professional and well run dealership could not get any better,very pleased and happy
Great sporty SUV
Great vehicle! Very reliable! Sporty! Gorgeous interior and killer Bose sound system. No problems till the car hit around 120k then I started to have problems but at that mileage problems are expected. Right sub frame needed replaced at $2500, replaced suspension $1500, replaced radiator $600. Not great on gas. I got about 17 around town and 25 on the highway but that’s pretty much what all the mid size SUV’s get.






Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
06 H3 bill
I have an 06. So-called worst year. 172k miles. Absolutely no problems. Had it for 6 years. No leaks. Engine does idle kinda rough but not a problem. Replaced one coil. Misfire. #3. The thing will go anywhere. Been in some deep beach sand. No prob. I don't really like the back door. Would rather it lift up like other SUVs. But ? So what. Got the yellow one ! Cool ! Paint is like brand new. Actually, I have no intention of getting rid of it. Does everything I wanted it to do.
Used
2009 Nissan Altima 2.5 S
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Manager
Just bought a new car from John. He was one of the best salesmen I have ever worked with, no pressure. Exactly what I was looking for and really helped with my budget! Thanks again John!!
Great Car
My 2009 Altima SE still runs great. Although the paint is dull from years under California sun. It has no problem wantsoever. I have all windows tinted to keep cool.
Used
2017 Volkswagen Touareg V6 Wolfsburg Edition
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Toms River, is the only place I go!
Great customer service! Tony, the salesman answered all our questions and got everything done pretty quick. No waiting around in the car dealership all day�� everyone was very friendly and helpful. Would highly recommend this place to anyone! Would give 10 �� if I could!
Not terrible not great 2012 sport
Tranny is dodgy on my 2012 v6...sport mode is worse....this suv needs a v8...sorry. I'm tall - the seats are not that great for me especially on long trips. Bought it 2020 so it was reasonably priced but now I'm looking for a Merc.
Used
2009 Mazda CX-9 Touring
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Administrative
Their team was quick to respond, and follow up on any questions I had, they are still in the process of helping me find the right vehicle, I'm confident I'll be in my new wheels soon.
Fan goes on when off at any time
Nice car but annoying to hear it’s fan going on at anytime while not in use. Have not been able to find any remedies. Any input helps...
Used
2005 BMW X5 3.0i
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Would highly recommend
True professionality and immediate willingness to help! They resolved an urgent and desperate situation for my family in no time. I can't say enough, and special thanks to Ryan. I am a journalist from Rome and was skeptical before coming in, but I couldn't have been more pleased after an impeccable experience. Grazie to everyone!
BMW X5 3.0i.
The E53 X5 is based on the near legendary E39 5 series chassis. Because of this it drives and handles more like a sports car than any other SUV of its time, and more so than most current SUVs. Ours is the 3.0i, with BMW’s awesome straight six, which will run forever if not neglected. We’ve had no major trouble with it at all, and really no minor trouble either. Regular maintenance, and now that it has over 100,000 miles on it, suspension bushings and things like that. It’s been properly maintained so its reliability has been pretty bulletproof. The styling is still very good even at its age, and the interior is still one of the nicer designs and more comfortable interiors that you’ll find in an SUV. Highly recommended as a used SUV, but find one that was well-maintained to avoid issues that any neglected car can have.






Used
2012 Subaru Forester 2.5X Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
My wife and I visited the dealer and met with Tommy M.
My wife and I visited the dealer and met with Tommy M. Fantastic experience. He was extremely knowledgeable. He helped us find the car that was perfect for our family at a fair price. The first time I purchased a car without stress or frustration. The experience is how car buying should be.
I’m the 3rd owner of a 2012 Subaru Forester purchased at
I’m the 3rd owner of a 2012 Subaru Forester purchased at approx 175,000 miles and it still runs pretty good! It does burn oil up pretty quickly and mine has issues with reading the levels and won’t give me a warning light so i check the dip stick often. Mine did have exhaust issues and had to replace a rested out piping from the cat back, but mufflers were still good. Also the Oxygen sensor was a problem for awhile, which you can only use on brand for it to work properly. Gas mileage is decent for the size of the vehicle and its age. Only wish the front seats went back more bc my taller girlfriend who is 5’11 with long legs struggles to fit and be comfortable in the passenger seat.
There are additional matching cars outside your search area.
Partial matches are generated by applying your search criteria to a larger search area. Our goal is to help you discover additional cars that match your search preferences.
As a benefit to some of our dealer customers, we display their listings first.






Vehicle information
Features
Vehicle information
Features






Used
2014 Subaru Legacy Premium
Vehicle information
Features






Vehicle information
Features






Vehicle information
Features






Vehicle information
Features






Vehicle information
Features






Vehicle information






Vehicle information
Features






Vehicle information
Features
Cars under $5,000 in Middletown, NJ by make
-
Nissan under $5,000 in Middletown, NJ
28 Great Deals out of 77 listings starting at $1,950
-
Toyota under $5,000 in Middletown, NJ
22 Great Deals out of 65 listings starting at $1,200
-
Honda under $5,000 in Middletown, NJ
14 Great Deals out of 52 listings starting at $1,995
-
Chevrolet under $5,000 in Middletown, NJ
19 Great Deals out of 42 listings starting at $2,475
-
Hyundai under $5,000 in Middletown, NJ
16 Great Deals out of 37 listings starting at $1,600
-
Ford under $5,000 in Middletown, NJ
8 Great Deals out of 28 listings starting at $1,500
-
Jeep under $5,000 in Middletown, NJ
8 Great Deals out of 25 listings starting at $1,950
-
Subaru under $5,000 in Middletown, NJ
6 Great Deals out of 21 listings starting at $1,995
-
Volkswagen under $5,000 in Middletown, NJ
10 Great Deals out of 21 listings starting at $1,999
Find great prices by city
-
Cars under $5,000 in Middletown, NJ
179 Great Deals out of 531 listings starting at $1,200
-
Cars under $5,000 in Leonardo, NJ
187 Great Deals out of 557 listings starting at $599
-
Cars under $5,000 in Navesink, NJ
182 Great Deals out of 546 listings starting at $599
-
Cars under $5,000 in Belford, NJ
194 Great Deals out of 569 listings starting at $599
-
Cars under $5,000 in Fair Haven, NJ
175 Great Deals out of 510 listings starting at $1,200
-
Cars under $5,000 in Red Bank, NJ
175 Great Deals out of 508 listings starting at $1,200
-
Cars under $5,000 in Atlantic Highlands, NJ
184 Great Deals out of 553 listings starting at $599
-
Cars under $5,000 in Port Monmouth, NJ
199 Great Deals out of 580 listings starting at $599
-
Cars under $5,000 in North Middletown, NJ
198 Great Deals out of 579 listings starting at $599
-
Cars under $5,000 in Lincroft, NJ
175 Great Deals out of 501 listings starting at $1,200
-
Cars under $5,000 in Little Silver, NJ
155 Great Deals out of 459 listings starting at $1,200
-
Cars under $5,000 in Rumson, NJ
175 Great Deals out of 509 listings starting at $1,200
Find great prices on used cars in Middletown, NJ
- Used cars for sale under $2,500
- Used cars for sale under $3,000
- Used cars for sale under $4,000
- Used cars for sale under $5,000
- Used cars for sale under $6,000
- Used cars for sale under $7,000
- Used cars for sale under $8,000
- Used cars for sale under $9,000
- Used cars for sale under $10,000
- Used cars for sale under $15,000
- Used cars for sale under $20,000
- Used cars for sale under $25,000
- Used cars for sale under $30,000
- Used cars for sale under $40,000
- Used cars for sale under $50,000
- Used cars for sale under $100,000
Used cars by body style and price
- ${price_badge()}
- ${ami_badge()}
- ${battery_badge()}${ev_report_link()}
- ${hot_car_badge()}
- ${award_badge()}
- ${cpo_badge()}
${price_badge_description}
${ami_badge_description}
The EV Battery Rating is based on this vehicle's current expected range relative to the vehicles expected range when new. ${battery_badge_text}
This vehicle is certified pre-owned, backed by a manufacturer warranty, and typically undergoes a rigorous multi-point inspection to ensure quality and reliability.
This vehicle is currently in high demand given its competitive price, desirable features, and overall condition, and may have a higher chance of selling quickly.