Skip to main content

Contact seller

Contact seller

By clicking here, you authorize Cars.com and its sellers/partners to contact you by text/calls which may include marketing and be by autodialer. Calls may be prerecorded. You also agree to our Privacy Notice. Consent is not required to purchase goods/services.

We value your privacy. Cars.com Privacy Notice

Customize your budget

Est. max vehicle price based on your desired monthly budget (...% APR*. and ...% sales tax)
$...*
See matching cars

*Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.

**Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.

About your privacy: Cars.com is asking for your ZIP and credit rating because it helps us to make an educated guess at your sales tax and loan interest. These two factors can greatly change your monthly payment.

Used sedans for sale near New Paltz, NY under $99,994

Filters 3 Year Price & payment Make Mileage Body style Ext. color All filters
481 matches 30 miles from 12561
Be the first to know!

Save your search and get notified when new inventory arrives.

Prequalify now

It only takes a few minutes and won't affect your credit.

Get Prequalified
Est. $400 /mo*
Down Payment
$0
Net trade-in value
$0
Months
72
APR
7.0%
Sales tax
0.0%

Vehicle information

Ext. color: Midnight Black Metallic
Int. color: Moonstone
Drivetrain: Front-wheel Drive
MPG: 31-40
Fuel type: Gasoline
Transmission: Automatic
Engine: Dynamic Force 2L I-4 port/direct injection, DOHC, variable valve
Stock #: 73088
VIN: 5YFB4MCE8SP237968

Features

Convenience: Adaptive Cruise Control, Keyless Entry, Keyless Start, Navigation System
Entertainment: Android Auto®, Apple CarPlay®, Bluetooth®, USB Port, WiFi Hotspot
Exterior: Alloy Wheels
Safety: Automatic Emergency Braking, Backup Camera, Brake Assist, LED Headlights, Lane Departure Warning, Stability Control

Reviews

Johnstons Toyota review

Johnston Toyota is the only place I’d ever buy a car .

Johnston Toyota is the only place I’d ever buy a car . Always treated respect and loyalty. Their service is always on spot and this is our fifth vehicle bought from them. Totally appreciate everything they do to protect our vehicles.

2025 Toyota Corolla FX review

It is Corolla 2025 nice and smooth car with a good

It is Corolla 2025 nice and smooth car with a good specifications and up to date model a good shape really it is nice car

Vehicle information

Ext. color: Ice Cap
Int. color: Black
Drivetrain: Front-wheel Drive
MPG: 50-43
Fuel type: Hybrid
Transmission: Automatic
Engine: 1.8L I-4 DOHC, VVT-i variable valve control, regular unleaded, e
Stock #: 73160
VIN: JTDBCMFE2S3079456

Features

Convenience: Adaptive Cruise Control, Keyless Entry, Navigation System
Entertainment: Android Auto®, Apple CarPlay®, Bluetooth®, USB Port, WiFi Hotspot
Safety: Automatic Emergency Braking, Backup Camera, Brake Assist, LED Headlights, Lane Departure Warning, Stability Control

Reviews

Johnstons Toyota review

Blair Schiesser/ Service Advisor always keeps me updated

Blair Schiesser/ Service Advisor always keeps me updated during my vehicle service appointment. He always has my best interest in mind. Never tries to up sell. It is always a pleasure doing business with Blair and Johnston’s Toyota.

2025 Toyota Corolla Hybrid SE review

It’s kind of funny.

It’s kind of funny. It’s a Corolla Hybrid, but looks so sporty that I find a lot of people look to race me when the light turns green…it’s a Corolla, and it’s not quick…at all. But, that’s a testament to its appearance. It’s very nice looking in the SE trim. The performance and CVT are prohibitive to excitement, but it is economical and adequate for normal city and highway driving. The road noise is pretty bad, but the suspension supple and it absorbs road imperfections well. The seats in front and the rear are comfortable. It does lack storage space as well. The glove box is basically just big enough to hold your registration. The center console is very small as well. The base sound system is its biggest flaw. It is terrible. I don’t know if the upgraded stereo is much better or worth the upgrade, but with as much road noise as there is, a better/louder stereo is needed to hear the music and drown out the other noise. I am averaging about 44-45 MPG in the AWD SE Hybrid.

Vehicle information

Ext. color: Underground
Int. color: Black
Drivetrain: Front-wheel Drive
MPG: 53-46
Fuel type: Hybrid
Transmission: Automatic
Engine: 1.8L I-4 DOHC, VVT-i variable valve control, regular unleaded, e
Stock #: 73238
VIN: JTDBCMFE1R3043848

Features

Convenience: Adaptive Cruise Control, Heated Seats, Keyless Entry, Keyless Start, Navigation System
Entertainment: Android Auto®, Apple CarPlay®, Bluetooth®, USB Port, WiFi Hotspot
Exterior: Alloy Wheels, Sunroof/Moonroof
Safety: Automatic Emergency Braking, Backup Camera, Blind Spot Monitor, Brake Assist, LED Headlights, Lane Departure Warning, Rear Cross Traffic Alert, Stability Control
Seating: Leather Seats

Reviews

Johnstons Toyota review

Was a wonderful experience people were friendly no

Was a wonderful experience people were friendly no real Pressure transaction was straight forward and really quite easy

2024 Toyota Corolla Hybrid XLE review

Great fuel economy, averaging 55+ MPGs most of the time.

Great fuel economy, averaging 55+ MPGs most of the time. Interior features are very nice for a vehicle in this price range. Some road noise at higher speeds, but not bad. Android Auto is very nice, but needs to be reconnected at times, which is easy to do.

Vehicle information

Ext. color: Ice Cap
Int. color: Black
Drivetrain: All-wheel Drive
MPG: 46-46
Fuel type: Gasoline
Transmission: Automatic
Engine: Dynamic Force 2.5L I-4 port/direct injection, DOHC, VVT-iE/VVT-i
Stock #: 73213
VIN: 4T1DBADK9SU538488

Features

Convenience: Adaptive Cruise Control, Heated Seats, Heated Steering Wheel, Keyless Entry, Keyless Start
Entertainment: Android Auto®, Apple CarPlay®, Bluetooth®, HomeLink, USB Port, WiFi Hotspot
Exterior: Alloy Wheels
Safety: Automatic Emergency Braking, Backup Camera, Blind Spot Monitor, Brake Assist, LED Headlights, Lane Departure Warning, Rear Cross Traffic Alert, Stability Control
Seating: Leather Seats

Reviews

Johnstons Toyota review

Very good experience and good communication with Ronal

Very good experience and good communication with Ronal Castillo. All time explains everything with me.

2025 Toyota Camry SE review

I'm totally satisfied with my camry.

I'm totally satisfied with my camry. It's the most advanced automobile I've ever driven.I commute 50 miles per day round trip and I get on average 53 miles per gallon. The traffic assist feature is my most used as I'm always in bumper to bumper traffic, this is when the camry hybrid shines best as it makes its own electricity. I've never owned a Toyota before. I traded my malibu for it & have never looked back.

Vehicle information

Ext. color: Ice Cap
Int. color: Black
Drivetrain: Front-wheel Drive
MPG: 32-41
Fuel type: Gasoline
Transmission: Automatic
Engine: Dynamic Force 2L I-4 port/direct injection, DOHC, variable valve
Stock #: 73234
VIN: 5YFB4MDE1SP313366

Features

Convenience: Adaptive Cruise Control, Keyless Entry, Navigation System
Entertainment: Android Auto®, Apple CarPlay®, Bluetooth®, USB Port, WiFi Hotspot
Safety: Automatic Emergency Braking, Backup Camera, Brake Assist, LED Headlights, Lane Departure Warning, Rear Cross Traffic Alert, Stability Control

Reviews

Johnstons Toyota review

Superb customer service and great mechanics.

Superb customer service and great mechanics. I was extremely pleased with the care they took

2025 Toyota Corolla LE review

Decent but not outstanding.

Decent but not outstanding. Had a problem with the passenger side motor mount causing a rattle that was fixed under warranty at the 5000 mi service. The part was backordered, so there are probably more than a few with this problem. A discoloration of the dash appeared by 2000 miles. Since it read "Toy" it was likely from the factory. There is still a small bubble in the rear window tint film. It drives well. I like the automation now that I'm used to it. It brakes too hard using adaptive cruise control when traffic slows down, but I guess the radar is doing as well as it can. It's not particularly comfortable, but Toyotas aren't known for that. Had to turn the driver's headrest around, as it pushes my head too far forward. I think that's required by law. The infotainment center works fine. They started using a new one after the 2024 debacle. I bought the car to keep it for a few hundred thousand miles. We'll see.

Vehicle information

Ext. color: Gray
Int. color: Black
Drivetrain: All-wheel Drive
MPG: 16-25
Fuel type: Gasoline
Transmission: Automatic 9-Speed
Engine: AMG 4L V-8 gasoline direct injection, DOHC, variable valve contr
Stock #: H57467
VIN: W1K6G7GB1NA157467

Features

Convenience: Adaptive Cruise Control, Cooled Seats, Heated Seats, Keyless Entry, Keyless Start, Navigation System, Remote Start
Entertainment: Android Auto®, Apple CarPlay®, Bluetooth®, HomeLink, Premium Sound System, USB Port, WiFi Hotspot
Exterior: Alloy Wheels, Sunroof/Moonroof
Safety: Automatic Emergency Braking, Backup Camera, Blind Spot Monitor, Brake Assist, LED Headlights, Lane Departure Warning, Rear Cross Traffic Alert, Stability Control
Seating: Leather Seats, Memory Seat

Reviews

Hershey's Auto Inc. review

Zinaida

in Hershey's auto inc I got great service, very professional , outstanding service, they are very nice good with personality, professional, especially, Joel Grunwald salesman. I definitely will recommend this people to my friends and relative.

2022 Mercedes-Benz S-Class S 580 4MATIC review

MBZ S-class always 5 ***** vehicle.

MBZ S-class always 5 ***** vehicle. The most luxurious , comfortable, car I ever drove . I highly recommend it . My old Mercedes S-class has 200,000 miles and not a single problem.

Vehicle information

Ext. color: Black
Int. color: Black
Drivetrain: All-wheel Drive
MPG: 20-28
Fuel type: Gasoline
Transmission: Automatic 8-Speed
Engine: AMG 2L I-4 port/direct injection, DOHC, variable valve control,
Stock #: H05625
VIN: W1K5J5DB2NN305625

Features

Convenience: Heated Seats, Keyless Entry, Keyless Start, Navigation System, Remote Start
Entertainment: Android Auto®, Apple CarPlay®, Bluetooth®, USB Port, WiFi Hotspot
Exterior: Alloy Wheels, Sunroof/Moonroof
Safety: Automatic Emergency Braking, Backup Camera, Blind Spot Monitor, Brake Assist, LED Headlights, Stability Control
Seating: Leather Seats, Memory Seat

Reviews

Hershey's Auto Inc. review

Best service good prices 5 star

It’s not the first time I’m dealing now with Hersheys. There service is amazing thy have great deals on used and brand new cars. I personal got an amazing finance rate. very nice ppl highly recommended.

2022 Mercedes-Benz AMG CLA 45 AMG CLA 45 4MATIC review

What else can I say about a true race car?

What else can I say about a true race car? With a redesigned engine, the most powerful four-cylinder on the planet. Unique styling inside and out. How this car grips the road! With an updated power plant at your feet? The exhilaration is hard to describe. The amount of control you feel in this car has to be experienced; you cannot describe it in words. I know there are many reliable, fun automobiles out there, but there is just something special about the racing line of Mercedes-Benz. Especially this car. Again, the M139 engine was developed in 2019, following AMG's "one man, one engine" philosophy. When you sit in the cabin, you are in a capsule. With more power than you know what to do with, but you do it. It grips to save your a**, and you are reborn.

Vehicle information

Ext. color: Pearl White Multi-Coat
Drivetrain: All-wheel Drive
Fuel type: Electric
Transmission: Automatic
Engine: Electric Motor
Stock #: 049745
VIN: 5YJ3E1EC9MF049745

Features

Convenience: Adaptive Cruise Control, Heated Seats, Heated Steering Wheel, Keyless Start, Navigation System
Entertainment: Bluetooth®, Premium Sound System, USB Port, WiFi Hotspot
Exterior: Alloy Wheels, Sunroof/Moonroof
Safety: Automatic Emergency Braking, Backup Camera, Blind Spot Monitor, Brake Assist, LED Headlights, Lane Departure Warning, Rear Cross Traffic Alert, Stability Control
Seating: Leather Seats, Memory Seat

Reviews

Freedom Chevrolet review

I had an awesome experience.

I had an awesome experience. Myles was very attentive and knowledgeable. Amazing customer service all around. They also have a nice selection of cars!!

2021 Tesla Model 3 Performance review

This car has been the best I’ve owned so far.

This car has been the best I’ve owned so far. Even if you aren’t looking at a Tesla, EVs in general are so much fun! I’ve had little maintenance in the three years I’ve had this car so far (tire rotations, wiper blades). Every major software update brings either new features or improvements.

*Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.

**Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.

481 matches Clear
Reset
Basics
Price & payment Full Price Monthly
Monthly budget search results are estimated based on a 72-month loan term with $0 down payment, $0 trade-in value, 0.0% sales tax and 7.0% APR. Inputs can be personalized using the calculator.
Financing
Deal rating
Vehicle history
Awards
Style
Body style
Vehicle size
Cab type
Exterior color
Interior color
Performance
Transmission
Drivetrain
Cylinders
Fuel type
EV range
EV charge time
Features
Convenience
Entertainment
Exterior
Safety
Seating
Door count
Seller info
Seller type
Keyword
Update
Show only
[{"applied_filter_criteria":"{\"bodystyle\":[\"sedan\"],\"cpo_indicator\":false,\"max_price_range\":99994,\"min_price_range\":0,\"search_range\":\"30\",\"shippable\":true,\"sort_field\":\"searchRank1\",\"sort_order\":\"desc\",\"stock_type\":\"used\"}","search_type":"general-inventory-search","sponsored_type_eligible":["inventory_ad"],"vehicle_array":[{"customer_id":"5431","relevancy_score":null,"badges":["american_made_index_ranking"],"certified_preowned":false,"trim":"FX","stock_type":"Used","sponsored":false,"msrp":"0","mileage":"4","cpo_indicator":false,"dealer_zip":"10958","vertical_position":1,"listing_id":"2b533508-6e66-4c93-89ef-dbe69546ae51","canonical_mmt":"Toyota:Corolla:FX","vin":"5YFB4MCE8SP237968","model":"Corolla","nvi_program":false,"fuel_type":"Gasoline","canonical_mmty":"Toyota:Corolla:FX:2025","cpo_package":null,"drivetrain":"Front-wheel Drive","make":"Toyota","bodystyle":"Sedan","interior_color":"Moonstone","year":"2025","seller_type":"dealership","sponsored_type":"standard","price":"27584","stock_sub":"","dealer_name":"Johnstons Toyota","cat":"sedan_compact","exterior_color":"Midnight Black Metallic","photo_count":17},{"customer_id":"5431","relevancy_score":null,"badges":["great_deal","cpo"],"certified_preowned":true,"trim":"SE","stock_type":"Used","sponsored":true,"msrp":"0","mileage":"18993","cpo_indicator":true,"dealer_zip":"10958","vertical_position":2,"listing_id":"3abefdd0-8e45-48e3-bdc1-bc9100a18dbd","canonical_mmt":"Toyota:Corolla Hybrid:SE","vin":"JTDBCMFE2S3079456","model":"Corolla Hybrid","nvi_program":false,"fuel_type":"Hybrid","canonical_mmty":"Toyota:Corolla Hybrid:SE:2025","cpo_package":"Toyota","drivetrain":"Front-wheel Drive","make":"Toyota","bodystyle":"Sedan","interior_color":"Black","year":"2025","seller_type":"dealership","sponsored_type":"standard","price":"23995","stock_sub":"","dealer_name":"Johnstons Toyota","cat":"hybrid_passenger","exterior_color":"Ice Cap","photo_count":20},{"customer_id":"5431","relevancy_score":null,"badges":["great_deal","cpo"],"certified_preowned":true,"trim":"XLE","stock_type":"Used","sponsored":true,"msrp":"0","mileage":"30539","cpo_indicator":true,"dealer_zip":"10958","vertical_position":3,"listing_id":"f3e6a0d4-4b96-4111-b014-dab2198c3685","canonical_mmt":"Toyota:Corolla Hybrid:XLE","vin":"JTDBCMFE1R3043848","model":"Corolla Hybrid","nvi_program":false,"fuel_type":"Hybrid","canonical_mmty":"Toyota:Corolla Hybrid:XLE:2024","cpo_package":"Toyota","drivetrain":"Front-wheel Drive","make":"Toyota","bodystyle":"Sedan","interior_color":"Black","year":"2024","seller_type":"dealership","sponsored_type":"standard","price":"25789","stock_sub":"","dealer_name":"Johnstons Toyota","cat":"hybrid_passenger","exterior_color":"Underground","photo_count":1},{"customer_id":"5431","relevancy_score":null,"badges":["american_made_index_ranking"],"certified_preowned":false,"trim":"SE","stock_type":"Used","sponsored":false,"msrp":"0","mileage":"5","cpo_indicator":false,"dealer_zip":"10958","vertical_position":4,"listing_id":"68ee58db-4d74-4aa5-8435-4893cb015af9","canonical_mmt":"Toyota:Camry:SE","vin":"4T1DBADK9SU538488","model":"Camry","nvi_program":false,"fuel_type":"Gasoline","canonical_mmty":"Toyota:Camry:SE:2025","cpo_package":null,"drivetrain":"All-wheel Drive","make":"Toyota","bodystyle":"Sedan","interior_color":"Black","year":"2025","seller_type":"dealership","sponsored_type":"standard","price":"34873","stock_sub":"","dealer_name":"Johnstons Toyota","cat":"sedan_midsize","exterior_color":"Ice Cap","photo_count":20},{"customer_id":"5431","relevancy_score":null,"badges":["fair_deal","american_made_index_ranking"],"certified_preowned":false,"trim":"LE","stock_type":"Used","sponsored":false,"msrp":"0","mileage":"5590","cpo_indicator":false,"dealer_zip":"10958","vertical_position":5,"listing_id":"e6622e91-4f0e-41c6-a563-d15dbee99de0","canonical_mmt":"Toyota:Corolla:LE","vin":"5YFB4MDE1SP313366","model":"Corolla","nvi_program":false,"fuel_type":"Gasoline","canonical_mmty":"Toyota:Corolla:LE:2025","cpo_package":null,"drivetrain":"Front-wheel Drive","make":"Toyota","bodystyle":"Sedan","interior_color":"Black","year":"2025","seller_type":"dealership","sponsored_type":"standard","price":"23987","stock_sub":"","dealer_name":"Johnstons Toyota","cat":"sedan_compact","exterior_color":"Ice Cap","photo_count":1},{"customer_id":"5242874","relevancy_score":null,"badges":["great_deal"],"certified_preowned":false,"trim":"S 580 4MATIC","stock_type":"Used","sponsored":false,"msrp":"0","mileage":"21902","cpo_indicator":false,"dealer_zip":"10950","vertical_position":6,"listing_id":"1d2bd69f-0e10-47ef-8271-1a752e90a0e6","canonical_mmt":"Mercedes-Benz:S-Class:S 580 4MATIC","vin":"W1K6G7GB1NA157467","model":"S-Class","nvi_program":false,"fuel_type":"Gasoline","canonical_mmty":"Mercedes-Benz:S-Class:S 580 4MATIC:2022","cpo_package":null,"drivetrain":"All-wheel Drive","make":"Mercedes-Benz","bodystyle":"Sedan","interior_color":"Black","year":"2022","seller_type":"dealership","sponsored_type":"standard","price":"66999","stock_sub":"","dealer_name":"Hershey's Auto Inc.","cat":"luxurypassenger_plus","exterior_color":"Gray","photo_count":22},{"customer_id":"5242874","relevancy_score":null,"badges":["good_deal","hot_car"],"certified_preowned":false,"trim":"AMG CLA 45 4MATIC","stock_type":"Used","sponsored":false,"msrp":"0","mileage":"32929","cpo_indicator":false,"dealer_zip":"10950","vertical_position":7,"listing_id":"ef305a27-a6f1-4cd3-b412-583b9e233c76","canonical_mmt":"Mercedes-Benz:AMG CLA 45:AMG CLA 45 4MATIC","vin":"W1K5J5DB2NN305625","model":"AMG CLA 45","nvi_program":false,"fuel_type":"Gasoline","canonical_mmty":"Mercedes-Benz:AMG CLA 45:AMG CLA 45 4MATIC:2022","cpo_package":null,"drivetrain":"All-wheel Drive","make":"Mercedes-Benz","bodystyle":"Sedan","interior_color":"Black","year":"2022","seller_type":"dealership","sponsored_type":"standard","price":"39999","stock_sub":"","dealer_name":"Hershey's Auto Inc.","cat":"luxurypassenger_standard","exterior_color":"Black","photo_count":27},{"customer_id":"6066462","relevancy_score":null,"badges":["great_deal","american_made_index_ranking",{"battery_badge_score":"Excellent","battery_badge_text":"The expected range is similar to normal when new."}],"certified_preowned":false,"trim":"Performance","stock_type":"Used","sponsored":false,"msrp":"0","mileage":"73258","cpo_indicator":false,"dealer_zip":"10922","vertical_position":8,"listing_id":"9782c791-afdf-431e-8b77-97d52acfe839","canonical_mmt":"Tesla:Model 3:Performance","vin":"5YJ3E1EC9MF049745","model":"Model 3","nvi_program":false,"fuel_type":"Electric","canonical_mmty":"Tesla:Model 3:Performance:2021","cpo_package":null,"drivetrain":"All-wheel Drive","make":"Tesla","bodystyle":"Sedan","interior_color":null,"year":"2021","seller_type":"dealership","sponsored_type":"standard","price":"21995","stock_sub":"","dealer_name":"Freedom Chevrolet","cat":"ev_sedan_compact","exterior_color":"Pearl White Multi-Coat","photo_count":0}]}]