Save your search and get notified when new inventory arrives.
Contact seller
Customize your budget
Est. max vehicle price based on your desired monthly budget (...% APR*. and ...% sales tax)
$...*
*Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.
**Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.
About your privacy: Cars.com is asking for your ZIP and credit rating because it helps us to make an educated guess at your sales tax and loan interest. These two factors can greatly change your monthly payment.
Used
sedans
for sale
near
Shelter Island Heights, NY
under $249,968
331 matches
30 miles from 11965
Be the first to know!
Est.
$400
/mo*
- Down Payment
- $0
- Net trade-in value
- $0
- Months
- 72
- APR
- 7.0%
- Sales tax
- 0.0%
*Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.
**Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.
Subaru Certified
2025 Subaru Legacy Premium
6,670 mi.
$27,093
Premier Subaru Kia
Vehicle information
Ext. color: Ice Silver Metallic
Int. color: Slate Black
Drivetrain: All-wheel Drive
MPG:
27-35
Fuel type: Gasoline
Transmission: Automatic
Engine: 2.5L H-4 gasoline direct injection, DOHC, variable valve control
Stock #: PSU6330
VIN: 4S3BWAF61S3004553
Features
Convenience:
Adaptive Cruise Control, Heated Seats, Keyless Entry, Keyless Start, Navigation System
Entertainment:
Android Auto®, Apple CarPlay®, Bluetooth®, Satellite Radio, USB Port, WiFi Hotspot
Exterior:
Alloy Wheels, Sunroof/Moonroof
Safety:
Automatic Emergency Braking, Backup Camera, Blind Spot Monitor, Brake Assist, LED Headlights, Lane Departure Warning, Rear Cross Traffic Alert, Stability Control
Reviews
Premier Subaru Kia review
2023 Subaru Ascent Limited 7-Passenger
Matt & Juan did excellent job with my lease process. They went above & beyond!! Excellent experience!!
2025 Subaru Legacy Premium review
I was planning to buy a luxury brand and test drove the
I was planning to buy a luxury brand and test drove the BMW 3 series, the Audi A4, and the Lexus ES300. I then, due to reviews on Consumer Reports, tested the Subaru Legacy in it's top form, the Touring XT with a 260 HP engine, and I was blown away. Almost as quick as the BMW but rode smoother and quieter. Not as smooth and quiet as the Lexus, but more fun to drive. The Audi seemed cramped and the dealer was a disappointment. The Legacy interior was the most attractive in my opinion, has 4 wheel drive, a great sound system, and ended up being my favorite of the 4 cars, regardless of price. When you consider how competitive (or better) the Legacy is compared to the other 3 cars, and that I saved $13,000 on the price, it was a no brainer. It's really sad the Legacy is being discontinue, but all my comments also apply to the Outback Touring XT. The Legacy is a great car at a bargain price.
Used
2022 Subaru Legacy Limited
51,402 mi.
$21,644
Premier Subaru Kia
Vehicle information
Ext. color: Abyss Blue Pearl
Int. color: Titanium Gray
Drivetrain: All-wheel Drive
MPG:
27-35
Fuel type: Gasoline
Transmission: Automatic
Engine: 2.5L H-4 gasoline direct injection, DOHC, variable valve control
Stock #: PSU6343
VIN: 4S3BWAN69N3012535
Features
Convenience:
Adaptive Cruise Control, Heated Seats, Heated Steering Wheel, Keyless Entry, Keyless Start, Navigation System, Remote Start
Entertainment:
Android Auto®, Apple CarPlay®, Bluetooth®, HomeLink, Premium Sound System, Satellite Radio, USB Port, WiFi Hotspot
Exterior:
Alloy Wheels, Sunroof/Moonroof
Safety:
Automatic Emergency Braking, Backup Camera, Blind Spot Monitor, Brake Assist, LED Headlights, Lane Departure Warning, Rear Cross Traffic Alert, Stability Control
Seating:
Leather Seats, Memory Seat
Reviews
Premier Subaru Kia review
Stellar Customer Service
Very friendly, honest dealers. Open about what we were paying for, and quite flexible in negotiations. Patiently and fully answered our questions. They went out of their way to make sure that we were completely satisfied with our purchase. Would highly recommend Premier Subaru to anyone shopping for a car.
2022 Subaru Legacy Limited review
love my Subaru
from the first day I had it I haven’t had any issues with it as it handles great and gas economy is awesome. I don’t have a negative to write. I drove Lincoln’s for the last 20 or more years and because they stopped making cars and only Crossovers or SVU’s, I searched high and low to find an equivalent car and googled all the options that were a must and the Subaru Legacy Elite came up and my husband and I went to look and drove out with our new car and couldn’t be happier. The ride is comfortable and the car is just great.
Used
2024 Chevrolet Malibu FWD 1LT
7 mi.
$26,755
$190 price drop
Bob Valenti Chevrolet
Vehicle information
Ext. color: Mosaic Black Metallic
Int. color: Jet Black
Drivetrain: Front-wheel Drive
MPG:
28-36
Fuel type: Gasoline
Transmission: Automatic
Engine: ECOTEC 1.5L I-4 gasoline direct injection, DOHC, VVT variable va
Stock #: 8838P
VIN: 1G1ZD5ST4RF224634
Features
Convenience:
Heated Seats, Keyless Entry, Keyless Start, Navigation System, Remote Start
Entertainment:
Android Auto®, Apple CarPlay®, Bluetooth®, Satellite Radio, USB Port, WiFi Hotspot
Exterior:
Alloy Wheels
Safety:
Automatic Emergency Braking, Backup Camera, Brake Assist, Lane Departure Warning, Stability Control
Reviews
Bob Valenti Chevrolet review
Excellent service very kind and helpful staff thank you
Excellent service very kind and helpful staff thank you very much . Everything went well and great service I highly recommend this dealership . Thanks again .
2024 Chevrolet Malibu FWD 1LT review
This is my fourth Malibu, first one was a 2004 Maxx,
This is my fourth Malibu, first one was a 2004 Maxx, second one was a 2017 Malibu LS, third one was a 2022 LS and now I have a 2024 RS, all four have been good cars with excellent fuel economy and space inside, maybe not as refined as some Japanese models but great cars regardless, give one a try....
Used
2025 Chevrolet Malibu FWD 1LT
36 mi.
$26,890
$574 price drop
Bob Valenti Chevrolet
Vehicle information
Ext. color: Mineral Gray Metallic
Int. color: Dark Atmosphere/Medium Ash Gray
Drivetrain: Front-wheel Drive
MPG:
28-36
Fuel type: Gasoline
Transmission: Automatic
Engine: ECOTEC 1.5L I-4 gasoline direct injection, DOHC, VVT variable va
Stock #: 8775P
VIN: 1G1ZD5ST0SF149615
Features
Convenience:
Heated Seats, Keyless Entry, Keyless Start, Navigation System, Remote Start
Entertainment:
Android Auto®, Apple CarPlay®, Bluetooth®, USB Port, WiFi Hotspot
Exterior:
Alloy Wheels
Safety:
Automatic Emergency Braking, Backup Camera, Brake Assist, Lane Departure Warning, Stability Control
Reviews
2025 Chevrolet Malibu FWD 1LT review
Out of all the cars that I have taken for a test drive.
Out of all the cars that I have taken for a test drive. The 2025 Chevy Malibu is the best. It has style, it drives and handles well, and has some awesome features to go along with it. But more importantly it is a by name it is one of the most reliable vehicles you can buy and never go wrong.
There are additional matching cars outside your search area.
Partial matches are generated by applying your search criteria to a larger search area. Our goal is to help you discover additional cars that match your search preferences.
As a benefit to some of our dealer customers, we display their listings first.
Vehicle information
Ext. color: Silver
Drivetrain: Front-wheel Drive
MPG:
29-35
Fuel type: Gasoline
Transmission: Automatic CVT
Engine: 1.5L I4 16V GDI DOHC Turbo
Stock #: Z5344
VIN: 1HGCV1F3XMA099613
Features
Convenience:
Adaptive Cruise Control, Keyless Entry, Keyless Start
Entertainment:
Apple CarPlay®, Bluetooth®, USB Port
Exterior:
Alloy Wheels
Safety:
Automatic Emergency Braking, Backup Camera, Brake Assist, Lane Departure Warning, Stability Control
Seating:
Leather Seats
Used
2022 Honda Civic Touring
34,639 mi.
$24,523
Executive Honda
Vehicle information
Ext. color: Platinum White Pearl
Int. color: Gray
Drivetrain: Front-wheel Drive
MPG:
31-38
Fuel type: Gasoline
Transmission: Automatic
Engine: 1.5L I-4 gasoline direct injection, DOHC, VTEC variable valve co
Stock #: 251261A
VIN: 2HGFE1F93NH328783
Features
Convenience:
Adaptive Cruise Control, Heated Seats, Keyless Entry, Keyless Start, Navigation System, Remote Start
Entertainment:
Android Auto®, Apple CarPlay®, Bluetooth®, HomeLink, Premium Sound System, USB Port
Exterior:
Alloy Wheels, Moonroof
Safety:
Automatic Emergency Braking, Backup Camera, Blind Spot Monitor, Brake Assist, LED Headlights, Lane Departure Warning, Rain Sensing Wipers, Rear Cross Traffic Alert, Stability Control
Seating:
Leather Seats
Honda Certified
2019 Honda Accord Sport
28,389 mi.
$22,997
Mariano Rivera Honda
Vehicle information
Ext. color: Platinum White Pearl
Int. color: Black
Drivetrain: Front-wheel Drive
MPG:
29-35
Fuel type: Gasoline
Transmission: Automatic
Engine: 1.5L I-4 gasoline direct injection, DOHC, VTEC variable valve co
Stock #: U2606T
VIN: 1HGCV1F38KA147820
Features
Convenience:
Adaptive Cruise Control, Keyless Entry, Keyless Start
Entertainment:
Android Auto®, Apple CarPlay®, Bluetooth®, USB Port
Exterior:
Alloy Wheels
Safety:
Automatic Emergency Braking, Backup Camera, Brake Assist, LED Headlights, Lane Departure Warning, Stability Control
Seating:
Leather Seats
Used
2024 Honda Accord EX 1.5T
10,616 mi.
$25,980
Executive Honda
Vehicle information
Ext. color: Radiant Red Metallic
Int. color: Black
Drivetrain: Front-wheel Drive
MPG:
29-37
Fuel type: Gasoline
Transmission: Automatic
Engine: 1.5L I-4 gasoline direct injection, DOHC, i-VTEC variable valve
Stock #: L24634
VIN: 1HGCY1F38RA049436
Features
Convenience:
Adaptive Cruise Control, Heated Seats, Keyless Entry, Keyless Start, Remote Start
Entertainment:
Android Auto®, Apple CarPlay®, Bluetooth®, USB Port, WiFi Hotspot
Exterior:
Alloy Wheels, Moonroof
Safety:
Automatic Emergency Braking, Backup Camera, Blind Spot Monitor, Brake Assist, LED Headlights, Lane Departure Warning, Rear Cross Traffic Alert, Stability Control
Used
2023 Nissan Altima 2.5 SV
21,621 mi.
$21,997
Executive Jeep
Vehicle information
Ext. color: Black
Int. color: Charcoal
Drivetrain: All-wheel Drive
MPG:
26-36
Fuel type: Gasoline
Transmission: Automatic CVT
Engine: 2.5L I4 16V GDI DOHC
Stock #: MZ9613
VIN: 1N4BL4DW5PN413072
Features
Convenience:
Heated Seats, Keyless Entry, Keyless Start, Remote Start
Entertainment:
Apple CarPlay®, Bluetooth®, Satellite Radio, USB Port
Exterior:
Alloy Wheels
Safety:
Automatic Emergency Braking, Backup Camera, Blind Spot Monitor, Brake Assist, Lane Departure Warning, Stability Control
Vehicle information
Ext. color: Cayenne Red
Int. color: Charcoal
Drivetrain: Front-wheel Drive
MPG:
27-38
Fuel type: Gasoline
Transmission: Automatic CVT
Engine: 2.5L I4 16V MPFI DOHC
Stock #: 4657RRC
VIN: 1N4AL3AP5EC318023
Features
Convenience:
Keyless Entry, Keyless Start, Remote Start
Entertainment:
Bluetooth®, CD Player, Satellite Radio
Exterior:
Alloy Wheels
Safety:
Backup Camera, Brake Assist, Stability Control
Used
2021 Mazda Mazda3 2.5 Turbo Premium Plus
31,015 mi.
$24,998
CarMax East Haven
Vehicle information
Ext. color: Black
Int. color: BLACK
Drivetrain: Four-wheel Drive
MPG:
25-33
Fuel type: Gasoline
Transmission: Automatic
Engine: Turbo Gas
Stock #: 27200356
VIN: 3MZBPBEY8MM254375
Features
Convenience:
Heated Steering Wheel, Navigation System, Remote Start
Entertainment:
Apple CarPlay®, Bluetooth®, Premium Sound System, Satellite Radio
Exterior:
Alloy Wheels, Sunroof/Moonroof
Safety:
Backup Camera, Blind Spot Monitor, Lane Departure Warning, Rain Sensing Wipers
Seating:
Leather Seats, Memory Seat
Used
2020 Honda Accord Sport 1.5T
72,847 mi.
$18,794
Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep Dodge RAM
Vehicle information
Ext. color: Modern Steel Metallic
Int. color: Black
Drivetrain: Front-wheel Drive
MPG:
29-35
Fuel type: Gasoline
Transmission: Automatic
Engine: 1.5L I-4 gasoline direct injection, DOHC, i-VTEC variable valve
Stock #: U8489
VIN: 1HGCV1F31LA144890
Features
Convenience:
Adaptive Cruise Control, Keyless Entry, Keyless Start
Entertainment:
Android Auto®, Apple CarPlay®, Bluetooth®, USB Port
Exterior:
Alloy Wheels
Safety:
Automatic Emergency Braking, Backup Camera, Brake Assist, LED Headlights, Lane Departure Warning, Stability Control
Seating:
Leather Seats
Vehicle information
Ext. color: Modern Steel Metallic
Drivetrain: Front-wheel Drive
MPG:
31-40
Fuel type: Gasoline
Transmission: CVT
Engine: 2L I-4 DOHC, variable valve control, regular unleaded, engine wi
Stock #: MM25116A
VIN: 2HGFC2F54HH521845
Features
Convenience:
Keyless Entry
Entertainment:
Bluetooth®, USB Port
Safety:
Automatic Emergency Braking, Backup Camera, Brake Assist, Stability Control
Used
2017 Honda Accord LX
75,832 mi.
$16,998
CarMax East Haven
Vehicle information
Ext. color: Gray
Int. color: BLACK
Drivetrain: Rear-wheel Drive
MPG:
27-36
Fuel type: Gasoline
Transmission: Automatic
Engine: Gas
Stock #: 27973287
VIN: 1HGCR2F30HA137138
Features
Entertainment:
Bluetooth®
Exterior:
Alloy Wheels
Safety:
Backup Camera
*Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.
**Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.
Find great prices by city
-
Sedans under $249,968 in Shelter Island Heights, NY
65 Great Deals out of 292 listings starting at $6,820
-
Sedans under $249,968 in Shelter Island, NY
65 Great Deals out of 292 listings starting at $6,820
-
Sedans under $249,968 in Greenport West, NY
82 Great Deals out of 363 listings starting at $6,820
-
Sedans under $249,968 in East Marion, NY
73 Great Deals out of 353 listings starting at $6,820
-
Sedans under $249,968 in North Haven, NY
52 Great Deals out of 231 listings starting at $6,820
-
Sedans under $249,968 in Southold, NY
85 Great Deals out of 353 listings starting at $5,795
-
Sedans under $249,968 in Orient, NY
69 Great Deals out of 321 listings starting at $6,820
-
Sedans under $249,968 in Sag Harbor, NY
48 Great Deals out of 217 listings starting at $6,820
-
Sedans under $249,968 in Noyack, NY
45 Great Deals out of 183 listings starting at $6,995
-
Sedans under $249,968 in Peconic, NY
82 Great Deals out of 320 listings starting at $5,795
-
Sedans under $249,968 in Northwest Harbor, NY
52 Great Deals out of 248 listings starting at $6,820
-
Sedans under $249,968 in Cutchogue, NY
74 Great Deals out of 307 listings starting at $4,800
Find great prices on used Sedans in Shelter Island Heights, NY
- ${price_badge()}
- ${ami_badge()}
- ${battery_badge()}${ev_report_link()}
- ${hot_car_badge()}
- ${award_badge()}
- ${cpo_badge()}
${price_badge_description}
${ami_badge_description}
The EV Battery Rating is based on this vehicle's current expected range relative to the vehicles expected range when new. ${battery_badge_text}
This vehicle is certified pre-owned, backed by a manufacturer warranty, and typically undergoes a rigorous multi-point inspection to ensure quality and reliability.
This vehicle is currently in high demand given its competitive price, desirable features, and overall condition, and may have a higher chance of selling quickly.