Contact seller

Contact seller

By clicking here, you authorize Cars.com and its sellers/partners to contact you by text/calls which may include marketing and be by autodialer. Calls may be prerecorded. You also agree to our Privacy Notice. Consent is not required to purchase goods/services.

We value your privacy. Cars.com Privacy Notice

Customize your budget

Est. max vehicle price based on your desired monthly budget (...% APR*. and ...% sales tax)
$...*
See matching cars

*Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.

**Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.

About your privacy: Cars.com is asking for your ZIP and credit rating because it helps us to make an educated guess at your sales tax and loan interest. These two factors can greatly change your monthly payment.

Used Subaru cars for sale near Rutherford, NJ under $1,000,000

Filters 3 Year Model Price & payment Make Mileage Body style Ext. color All filters
1,364 matches 30 miles from 07070
Be the first to know!

Save your search and get notified when new inventory arrives.

Prequalify now

It only takes a few minutes and won't affect your credit.

Get Prequalified
Est. $400 /mo*
Down Payment
$0
Net trade-in value
$0
Months
72
APR
7.0%
Sales tax
0.0%

*Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.

**Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.

No photo available

Used

2018 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

88,958 mi.
$13,995 $4,000 price drop
Est. $254/mo*
NJ Auto Xchange
(0 reviews)
Atlantic Highlands, NJ (29 mi.)
Call Check availability Check availability

Vehicle information

Drivetrain: All-wheel Drive
MPG: 26-32
Fuel type: Gasoline
Transmission: Auto, CVT Lineartronic
Engine: 2.5L H-4 DOHC, variable valve control, regular unleaded, engine
Stock #: NJ-504186
VIN: JF2SJAEC1JH504186

Features

Convenience: Heated Seats, Keyless Entry
Entertainment: Bluetooth®, CD Player, USB Port, WiFi Hotspot
Exterior: Alloy Wheels, Sunroof/Moonroof
Safety: Automatic Emergency Braking, Backup Camera, Brake Assist, Stability Control

Reviews

2018 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium review

Great value considering the superior safety features, low

September 22, 2025
By Tony P. from New York
Owns this car

Great value considering the superior safety features, low maintenance and reliability. Rear wheel bearings have been replaced twice and just had the AC compressor and serpentine belt replaced. Albeit expensive repairs, all cars need something after the first 3 years. It's been 8 years and the car still run and drives like new.
No photo available

Used

2023 Subaru Crosstrek Limited

15,717 mi.
$25,995
Est. $473/mo*
NJ Auto Xchange
(0 reviews)
Atlantic Highlands, NJ (29 mi.)
Call Check availability Check availability

Vehicle information

Ext. color: Horizon Blue Pearl
Int. color: Black w/Orange Stitching
Drivetrain: All-wheel Drive
MPG: 27-34
Fuel type: Gasoline
Transmission: Automatic, CVT w/Lineartronic & 8-Spd Manual Mode
Engine: 2.5L H-4 gasoline direct injection, DOHC, variable valve control
Stock #: NJ-249110C
VIN: JF2GTHNC5PH249110

Features

Convenience: Adaptive Cruise Control, Heated Seats, Keyless Entry, Keyless Start, Remote Start
Entertainment: Android Auto®, Apple CarPlay®, Bluetooth®, CD Player, USB Port, WiFi Hotspot
Exterior: Alloy Wheels
Safety: Automatic Emergency Braking, Backup Camera, Blind Spot Monitor, Brake Assist, LED Headlights, Lane Departure Warning, Rear Cross Traffic Alert, Stability Control
Seating: Leather Seats

Reviews

2023 Subaru Crosstrek Limited review

My first Subaru and I love it.

August 14, 2025
By Susan from Walpole New Hampshire
Owns this car

My first Subaru and I love it. Drives wonderful and is just perfect ❤️❤️. Handles with ease and very comfortable. So very happy with this one

No photo available

Used

2012 Subaru Forester 2.5X Premium

170,627 mi.
$5,495
Est. $100/mo*
Preferred Motor Cars of New Jersey
Not rated Dealerships need five reviews in the past 24 months before we can display a rating. (12 reviews)
Keyport, NJ (30 mi.)
Call Check availability Check availability

Vehicle information

Ext. color: Marine Blue Pearl
Int. color: Black
Drivetrain: All-wheel Drive
MPG: 21-27
Fuel type: Gasoline
Transmission: Automatic
Engine: 2.5L H-4 DOHC, variable valve control, regular unleaded, engine
Stock #: CH421036STK
VIN: JF2SHADC5CH421036

Features

Convenience: Heated Seats, Keyless Entry
Entertainment: Bluetooth®, CD Player, Satellite Radio, USB Port
Exterior: Alloy Wheels, Sunroof/Moonroof
Safety: Automatic Emergency Braking, Brake Assist, Stability Control

Reviews

Preferred Motor Cars of New Jersey review

I had a good experience with Excellent service

August 26, 2019
By Anthony from Holmdel NJ

If you want a very good car go see John at Preferred. I picked an excellent car and John is honest and will provide you with a fair price

2012 Subaru Forester 2.5X Premium review

I’m the 3rd owner of a 2012 Subaru Forester purchased at

May 13, 2024
By Raven
Owns this car

I’m the 3rd owner of a 2012 Subaru Forester purchased at approx 175,000 miles and it still runs pretty good! It does burn oil up pretty quickly and mine has issues with reading the levels and won’t give me a warning light so i check the dip stick often. Mine did have exhaust issues and had to replace a rested out piping from the cat back, but mufflers were still good. Also the Oxygen sensor was a problem for awhile, which you can only use on brand for it to work properly. Gas mileage is decent for the size of the vehicle and its age. Only wish the front seats went back more bc my taller girlfriend who is 5’11 with long legs struggles to fit and be comfortable in the passenger seat.

*Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.

**Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.

1,364 matches Clear
Reset
1,364 matches
Be the first to know!

Save your search and get notified when new inventory arrives.
Basics
Subaru models
Price & payment Full Price Monthly
‡Monthly budget search results are estimated based on a 72-month loan term with $0 down payment, $0 trade-in value, 0.0% sales tax and 7.0% APR. Inputs can be personalized using the calculator.
Financing
Deal rating
Vehicle history
Awards
Style
Body style
Vehicle size
Cab type
Exterior color
Interior color
Performance
Transmission
Drivetrain
Cylinders
Fuel type
EV range
EV charge time
Features
Convenience
Entertainment
Exterior
Safety
Seating
Door count
Seller info
Seller type
Keyword
Update
Show only
[{"applied_filter_criteria":"{\"cpo_indicator\":false,\"make_model_trim\":[{\"make\":\"subaru\"}],\"max_price_range\":1000000,\"search_range\":\"30\",\"shippable\":true,\"sort_field\":\"searchRank1\",\"sort_order\":\"desc\",\"stock_type\":\"used\"}","search_type":"general-inventory-search","sponsored_type_eligible":["inventory_ad"],"vehicle_array":[{"badges":["price_drop_in_cents","good_deal"],"cpo_indicator":false,"customer_id":"6071844","trim":"2.5i Premium","sponsored_type":"standard","msrp":"0","seller_type":"dealership","exterior_color":null,"cat":"crossover_compact","model":"Forester","listing_id":"ecebc65e-ba28-41ce-9a1f-880b3cb87a81","certified_preowned":false,"cpo_package":null,"relevancy_score":null,"vertical_position":1,"price":"13995","year":"2018","drivetrain":"All-wheel Drive","mileage":"88958","fuel_type":"Gasoline","canonical_mmt":"Subaru:Forester:2.5i Premium","stock_sub":"","dealer_name":"NJ Auto Xchange","photo_count":0,"nvi_program":false,"stock_type":"Used","canonical_mmty":"Subaru:Forester:2.5i Premium:2018","vin":"JF2SJAEC1JH504186","dealer_zip":"07716","bodystyle":"SUV","make":"Subaru","interior_color":null,"sponsored":false},{"badges":["good_deal"],"cpo_indicator":false,"customer_id":"6071844","trim":"Limited","sponsored_type":"standard","msrp":"0","seller_type":"dealership","exterior_color":"Horizon Blue Pearl","cat":"crossover_compact","model":"Crosstrek","listing_id":"31822fa6-17bc-4b3a-bd91-5d7eb88cbe2d","certified_preowned":false,"cpo_package":null,"relevancy_score":null,"vertical_position":2,"price":"25995","year":"2023","drivetrain":"All-wheel Drive","mileage":"15717","fuel_type":"Gasoline","canonical_mmt":"Subaru:Crosstrek:Limited","stock_sub":"","dealer_name":"NJ Auto Xchange","photo_count":0,"nvi_program":false,"stock_type":"Used","canonical_mmty":"Subaru:Crosstrek:Limited:2023","vin":"JF2GTHNC5PH249110","dealer_zip":"07716","bodystyle":"SUV","make":"Subaru","interior_color":"Black w/Orange Stitching","sponsored":false},{"badges":["hot_car"],"cpo_indicator":false,"customer_id":"5344285","trim":"2.5X Premium","sponsored_type":"standard","msrp":"0","seller_type":"dealership","exterior_color":"Marine Blue Pearl","cat":"crossover_compact","model":"Forester","listing_id":"bdb2a79f-fabc-4d39-9239-808464d08cee","certified_preowned":false,"cpo_package":null,"relevancy_score":null,"vertical_position":3,"price":"5495","year":"2012","drivetrain":"All-wheel Drive","mileage":"170627","fuel_type":"Gasoline","canonical_mmt":"Subaru:Forester:2.5X Premium","stock_sub":"","dealer_name":"Preferred Motor Cars of New Jersey","photo_count":0,"nvi_program":false,"stock_type":"Used","canonical_mmty":"Subaru:Forester:2.5X Premium:2012","vin":"JF2SHADC5CH421036","dealer_zip":"07735","bodystyle":"SUV","make":"Subaru","interior_color":"Black","sponsored":false}]}]