Skip to main content

2005
Subaru Legacy

Starts at:
$23,445
Shop options
New 2005 Subaru Legacy
See ratings
Consumer rating
Owner reviewed vehicle score
Not rated
Safety rating
NHTSA tested vehicle score
Consumer rating
Owner reviewed vehicle score
Not rated
Safety rating
NHTSA tested vehicle score
Shop Cars.com
Browse cars & save your favorites
Dealers near you
Find & contact a dealership near you
Listings near 43272
Change location See all listings

Available trims

See the differences side-by-side to compare trims.
  • 2.5i Manual
    Starts at
    $21,445
    23 City / 30 Hwy
    MPG
    5
    Seat capacity
    Gas Flat 4-Cyl
    Engine
    All Wheel Drive
    Drivetrain
    See all specs
  • 2.5i Manual
    Starts at
    $22,445
    23 City / 30 Hwy
    MPG
    5
    Seat capacity
    Gas Flat 4-Cyl
    Engine
    All Wheel Drive
    Drivetrain
    See all specs
  • 2.5i Auto
    Starts at
    $22,445
    22 City / 30 Hwy
    MPG
    5
    Seat capacity
    Gas Flat 4-Cyl
    Engine
    All Wheel Drive
    Drivetrain
    See all specs
  • 2.5i Auto
    Starts at
    $23,445
    22 City / 30 Hwy
    MPG
    5
    Seat capacity
    Gas Flat 4-Cyl
    Engine
    All Wheel Drive
    Drivetrain
    See all specs
  • 2.5i Ltd Manual
    Starts at
    $24,695
    23 City / 30 Hwy
    MPG
    5
    Seat capacity
    Gas Flat 4-Cyl
    Engine
    All Wheel Drive
    Drivetrain
    See all specs
  • 2.5i Ltd Auto
    Starts at
    $25,695
    22 City / 30 Hwy
    MPG
    5
    Seat capacity
    Gas Flat 4-Cyl
    Engine
    All Wheel Drive
    Drivetrain
    See all specs
  • 2.5i Ltd Manual
    Starts at
    $25,895
    23 City / 30 Hwy
    MPG
    5
    Seat capacity
    Gas Flat 4-Cyl
    Engine
    All Wheel Drive
    Drivetrain
    See all specs
  • 2.5 GT Manual
    Starts at
    $26,245
    19 City / 25 Hwy
    MPG
    5
    Seat capacity
    Turbo Gas 4-Cyl
    Engine
    All Wheel Drive
    Drivetrain
    See all specs
  • 2.5i Ltd Auto
    Starts at
    $26,895
    22 City / 30 Hwy
    MPG
    5
    Seat capacity
    Gas Flat 4-Cyl
    Engine
    All Wheel Drive
    Drivetrain
    See all specs
  • 2.5 GT Manual
    Starts at
    $27,245
    19 City / 25 Hwy
    MPG
    5
    Seat capacity
    Turbo Gas 4-Cyl
    Engine
    All Wheel Drive
    Drivetrain
    See all specs
  • 2.5 GT Auto
    Starts at
    $27,445
    19 City / 25 Hwy
    MPG
    5
    Seat capacity
    Turbo Gas 4-Cyl
    Engine
    All Wheel Drive
    Drivetrain
    See all specs
  • 2.5 GT Auto
    Starts at
    $28,445
    19 City / 25 Hwy
    MPG
    5
    Seat capacity
    Turbo Gas 4-Cyl
    Engine
    All Wheel Drive
    Drivetrain
    See all specs
  • 2.5 GT Ltd Manual Black Interior
    Starts at
    $28,745
    19 City / 25 Hwy
    MPG
    5
    Seat capacity
    Turbo Gas 4-Cyl
    Engine
    All Wheel Drive
    Drivetrain
    See all specs
  • 2.5 GT Ltd Manual Taupe Interior
    Starts at
    $28,745
    19 City / 25 Hwy
    MPG
    5
    Seat capacity
    Turbo Gas 4-Cyl
    Engine
    All Wheel Drive
    Drivetrain
    See all specs
  • 2.5 GT Ltd Manual Taupe Int
    Starts at
    $29,945
    19 City / 25 Hwy
    MPG
    5
    Seat capacity
    Turbo Gas 4-Cyl
    Engine
    All Wheel Drive
    Drivetrain
    See all specs
  • 2.5 GT Ltd Manual Black Int
    Starts at
    $29,945
    19 City / 25 Hwy
    MPG
    5
    Seat capacity
    Turbo Gas 4-Cyl
    Engine
    All Wheel Drive
    Drivetrain
    See all specs
  • 2.5 GT Ltd Auto Black Interior
    Starts at
    $29,945
    19 City / 25 Hwy
    MPG
    5
    Seat capacity
    Turbo Gas 4-Cyl
    Engine
    All Wheel Drive
    Drivetrain
    See all specs
  • 2.5 GT Ltd Auto Taupe Interior
    Starts at
    $29,945
    19 City / 25 Hwy
    MPG
    5
    Seat capacity
    Turbo Gas 4-Cyl
    Engine
    All Wheel Drive
    Drivetrain
    See all specs
  • 2.5 GT Ltd Auto Black Int
    Starts at
    $31,145
    19 City / 25 Hwy
    MPG
    5
    Seat capacity
    Turbo Gas 4-Cyl
    Engine
    All Wheel Drive
    Drivetrain
    See all specs
  • 2.5 GT Ltd Auto Taupe Int
    Starts at
    $31,145
    19 City / 25 Hwy
    MPG
    5
    Seat capacity
    Turbo Gas 4-Cyl
    Engine
    All Wheel Drive
    Drivetrain
    See all specs

Photo & video gallery

2005 Subaru Legacy 2005 Subaru Legacy 2005 Subaru Legacy 2005 Subaru Legacy 2005 Subaru Legacy 2005 Subaru Legacy 2005 Subaru Legacy 2005 Subaru Legacy 2005 Subaru Legacy 2005 Subaru Legacy 2005 Subaru Legacy 2005 Subaru Legacy 2005 Subaru Legacy 2005 Subaru Legacy 2005 Subaru Legacy 2005 Subaru Legacy

Notable features

Standard AWD
Six airbags
Many accessories offered
Windshield wiper de-icer
Heated, power signaling side mirrors (GT)

The good & the bad

The good

Exceptional handling (GT)
Well-executed manual transmission
Gutsy turbocharged engine (GT)
Proven AWD
Distinctive styling

The bad

Automatic not recommended (GT)
Backseat doesn't fold
Interior tighter than competition
No electronic stability system
Premium gasoline recommended

Expert 2005 Subaru Legacy review

our expert's take
Our expert's take
By Bob Golfen
Full article
our expert's take

Sporty drivers seeking hot, upscale sedans might cruise past the neighborhood Subaru dealer.

That could be a mistake.

The Japanese company, best known for quirky all-wheel-drive vehicles that gained popularity in wintry climates, may have built street credibility among the sport-compact crowd with its Impreza WRX.

But for midsize sport sedans, BMW, Audi, Volvo or Infiniti seem more likely targets than Subaru.

So the Subaru Legacy 2.5 GT, revamped for 2005 with a sharply aggressive look, lush interior and performance upgrades, could be overlooked. But Legacy GT should satisfy even those snooty drivers who think the Europeans have a lock on poise and precision.

The latest Legacy, which includes Outback sedans and wagons, exemplifies Subaru’s new push into the upper crust as the automaker vies to establish a luxury/performance image akin to Acura or Infiniti. Like all Subarus, the GT is equipped with all-wheel drive and horizontally opposed “boxer” engine.

Comparing Legacy GT with its strongest competition, top versions of Toyota Camry and Honda Accord, the Subaru is more interesting to drive while retaining similar family-sedan capabilities.

The GT version of the Legacy sedan adds a turbocharger that boosts the “flat-four” engine to 250 horsepower, plus beefier disc brakes, firmer suspension and quicker steering. The result is an all-wheel-drive sports sedan with muscular power and solidly responsive handling. And a modest price tag that would make the Europeans blush.

Vehicle type: Five-passenger, four-door sedan, all-wheel drive.

– – –

The lowdown

PERFORMANCE: The 2.5-liter, four-cylinder “boxer” engine, in which two cylinders lie horizontally on either side, is sweetly tuned to crank out 250 turbocharged horsepower. There is some turbo lag at takeoff, but once under way, the engine pulls nicely.

With its low center of gravity and typical smooth operation, the durable engine raises an aggressive roar under acceleration but settles down to whisper-quiet cruising.

Five-speed stickshift is available, with the test car equipped with a five-speed automatic that always feels on top of its game with precise shifts when you want them. For self shifting, there is a choice of steering-wheel buttons or “slap shift” on the console.

That seems redundant. Steering-wheel audio controls would be better.

DRIVABILITY: All-wheel drive, excellent balance, refined steering and low-profile performance tires put the Legacy GT right up with the top brands in handling and response. A joy to drive on back roads, smooth and compliant on city streets.

STYLING: With its rakish stance and aggressive hood scoop to feed the turbocharger’s intercooler, Legacy GT is a sporty attention grabber. The test car looked bland in white, though.

Gratefully left off: no adolescent rear spoiler on this grown-up sport sedan.

INTERIOR: The stylish new interior with standard leather seating and wood accents, along with a sporty Momo brand leather steering wheel, help raise the luxury/performance bar. The Legacy comes just one way: fully equipped.

The back seat is too tight for a midsize.

BOTTOM LINE: Legacy GT is a full-bore performance sedan with all the trimmings, but it lacks one thing: bragging rights. The name Subaru doesn’t carry the panache of BMW or Audi, but one ride should convince any doubters.

– – –

Related

Engine: 2.5-liter horizontally opposed four, turbocharged, 250 horsepower at 6,000 rpm, 250 pound-feet of torque at 3,600 rpm.

Transmission: Five-speed automatic.

Wheelbase: 105.1 inches.

Overall length: 186.2 inches.

Curb weight: 3,435.

EPA rating: 19 city, 25 highway.

Highs: Sporty performance, sharp styling, lush interior.

Lows: Too many ways to shift, engine roar, tight back seat.

Pricing

Base price: $28,595.

Price as tested: $30,651.

OPTIONS

* Five-speed automatic with sportshift, $1,200.

* Auto-dimming mirror, compass and security system, $281.

* Shipping, $575.

– – –

Read more

For more on the Subaru Legacy GT, go to autos.azcentral.com.

2005 Subaru Legacy review: Our expert's take
By Bob Golfen

Sporty drivers seeking hot, upscale sedans might cruise past the neighborhood Subaru dealer.

That could be a mistake.

The Japanese company, best known for quirky all-wheel-drive vehicles that gained popularity in wintry climates, may have built street credibility among the sport-compact crowd with its Impreza WRX.

But for midsize sport sedans, BMW, Audi, Volvo or Infiniti seem more likely targets than Subaru.

So the Subaru Legacy 2.5 GT, revamped for 2005 with a sharply aggressive look, lush interior and performance upgrades, could be overlooked. But Legacy GT should satisfy even those snooty drivers who think the Europeans have a lock on poise and precision.

The latest Legacy, which includes Outback sedans and wagons, exemplifies Subaru’s new push into the upper crust as the automaker vies to establish a luxury/performance image akin to Acura or Infiniti. Like all Subarus, the GT is equipped with all-wheel drive and horizontally opposed “boxer” engine.

Comparing Legacy GT with its strongest competition, top versions of Toyota Camry and Honda Accord, the Subaru is more interesting to drive while retaining similar family-sedan capabilities.

The GT version of the Legacy sedan adds a turbocharger that boosts the “flat-four” engine to 250 horsepower, plus beefier disc brakes, firmer suspension and quicker steering. The result is an all-wheel-drive sports sedan with muscular power and solidly responsive handling. And a modest price tag that would make the Europeans blush.

Vehicle type: Five-passenger, four-door sedan, all-wheel drive.

– – –

The lowdown

PERFORMANCE: The 2.5-liter, four-cylinder “boxer” engine, in which two cylinders lie horizontally on either side, is sweetly tuned to crank out 250 turbocharged horsepower. There is some turbo lag at takeoff, but once under way, the engine pulls nicely.

With its low center of gravity and typical smooth operation, the durable engine raises an aggressive roar under acceleration but settles down to whisper-quiet cruising.

Five-speed stickshift is available, with the test car equipped with a five-speed automatic that always feels on top of its game with precise shifts when you want them. For self shifting, there is a choice of steering-wheel buttons or “slap shift” on the console.

That seems redundant. Steering-wheel audio controls would be better.

DRIVABILITY: All-wheel drive, excellent balance, refined steering and low-profile performance tires put the Legacy GT right up with the top brands in handling and response. A joy to drive on back roads, smooth and compliant on city streets.

STYLING: With its rakish stance and aggressive hood scoop to feed the turbocharger’s intercooler, Legacy GT is a sporty attention grabber. The test car looked bland in white, though.

Gratefully left off: no adolescent rear spoiler on this grown-up sport sedan.

INTERIOR: The stylish new interior with standard leather seating and wood accents, along with a sporty Momo brand leather steering wheel, help raise the luxury/performance bar. The Legacy comes just one way: fully equipped.

The back seat is too tight for a midsize.

BOTTOM LINE: Legacy GT is a full-bore performance sedan with all the trimmings, but it lacks one thing: bragging rights. The name Subaru doesn’t carry the panache of BMW or Audi, but one ride should convince any doubters.

– – –

Related

Engine: 2.5-liter horizontally opposed four, turbocharged, 250 horsepower at 6,000 rpm, 250 pound-feet of torque at 3,600 rpm.

Transmission: Five-speed automatic.

Wheelbase: 105.1 inches.

Overall length: 186.2 inches.

Curb weight: 3,435.

EPA rating: 19 city, 25 highway.

Highs: Sporty performance, sharp styling, lush interior.

Lows: Too many ways to shift, engine roar, tight back seat.

Pricing

Base price: $28,595.

Price as tested: $30,651.

OPTIONS

* Five-speed automatic with sportshift, $1,200.

* Auto-dimming mirror, compass and security system, $281.

* Shipping, $575.

– – –

Read more

For more on the Subaru Legacy GT, go to autos.azcentral.com.

Available cars near you

Factory warranties

New car program benefits

Basic
3 years / 36,000 miles
Corrosion
5 years
Powertrain
5 years / 60,000 miles
Roadside Assistance
3 years / 36,000 miles

Certified Pre-Owned program benefits

Age / mileage
5 years / 80,000 miles
Basic
Coverage available for purchase
Dealer certification
152-point inspection

Compare similar vehicles

Select cars to compare for more detailed info.
  • 2005
    4.5
    Subaru Legacy
    Starts at
    $21,445
    23 City / 30 Hwy
    MPG
    5
    Seat capacity
    Gas Flat 4-Cyl
    Engine
    All-wheel drive
    Drivetrain
    Compare
  • 1999
    4.1
    Subaru Legacy
    Starts at
    $16,895
    22 City / 29 Hwy
    MPG
    5
    Seat capacity
    Gas Flat 4 Cyl
    Engine
    All-wheel drive
    Drivetrain
    Compare
  • 1993
    4.5
    Nissan Altima
    Starts at
    $12,999
    -
    MPG
    -
    Seat capacity
    -
    Engine
    -
    Drivetrain
    Compare
  • 2011
    4.7
    Subaru Impreza Outback Sport
    Starts at
    $19,995
    20 City / 27 Hwy
    MPG
    5
    Seat capacity
    Gas Flat 4
    Engine
    All-wheel drive
    Drivetrain
    Compare
  • 2000
    4.2
    Subaru Impreza
    Starts at
    $15,895
    23 City / 29 Hwy
    MPG
    5
    Seat capacity
    Gas Flat 4 Cyl
    Engine
    All-wheel drive
    Drivetrain
    Compare
  • Compare more options
    Use our comparison tool to add any vehicle of your choice and see a full list of specifications and features side-by-side.
    Try it now

Consumer reviews

4.5 / 5
Based on 48 reviews
Write a review
Comfort 4.2
Interior 4.3
Performance 4.7
Value 4.6
Exterior 4.4
Reliability 4.6

Most recent

  • What a wonderful birthday present!

    This vehicle was purchased for me by my dad. He went thru Lyman Motors. They did an engine rebuild on this vehicle. So, even though its 15 years old, and has quite a few miles, it was for a fair price! And, with the engine rebuilt I know it will go for another 100k miles easy! Lyman made this buying experience so much fun for us! He is such a wondering person! I recommend Lyman Motors to everyone whether you are looking for a new or used car, he will help you find exactly what you are looking for!
    • Purchased a Used car
    • Used for Commuting
    • Does recommend this car
    Comfort 5.0
    Interior 5.0
    Performance 5.0
    Value 5.0
    Exterior 5.0
    Reliability 5.0
    5 people out of 7 found this review helpful. Did you?
    Yes No
  • Best car I have ever owned!!!

    If you need lots of room and back seats that fold completely, then the subaru legacy wagon is the right car for you! I have had mine for 5 year now and I'm the second owner of the car. It has already had a new engine put in shortly before I purchased it. The Legacy wagon has never let me down and always keeps on going. I highly recommend The Subaru Legacy Wagon
    • Purchased a Used car
    • Used for Commuting
    • Does recommend this car
    Comfort 5.0
    Interior 4.0
    Performance 5.0
    Value 5.0
    Exterior 5.0
    Reliability 5.0
    1 person out of 1 found this review helpful. Did you?
    Yes No
  • Proven reliable during the short time we've had it

    Strong motor for a 2.5L 4 cyl, runs great, smooth ride, comfortable and practical interior. Second Subaru we have owned. It is important to keep up with the gaskets as they tend to leak given time. Easy fix.
    • Purchased a Used car
    • Used for Transporting family
    • Does recommend this car
    Comfort 5.0
    Interior 5.0
    Performance 5.0
    Value 5.0
    Exterior 5.0
    Reliability 5.0
    4 people out of 6 found this review helpful. Did you?
    Yes No
  • please stay away from older modelss

    i bough this 05 i limited from a private seller who showed me all the service records, but after 8 months of owning it was nothing but nightmare one problem after another till this day i mean car runs well but i gave up not gonna spend anymore money. Sad but true
    • Purchased a Used car
    • Used for Commuting
    • Does not recommend this car
    Comfort 2.0
    Interior 2.0
    Performance 3.0
    Value 2.0
    Exterior 3.0
    Reliability 2.0
    2 people out of 2 found this review helpful. Did you?
    Yes No
  • One of the last over-designed cars

    I have had two Subarus, and read an article in Business Week that the Legacy station wagons 2005-2007 were over-designed, and they were right, it drives like a poor man's Porsche, and with very good gas mileage. Only design flaw is the Porsche aspect, the boxer engine means it will need a new gasket if you wish to keep it more than 5 years.
    • Purchased a Used car
    • Used for Commuting
    • Does recommend this car
    Comfort 4.0
    Interior 4.0
    Performance 5.0
    Value 5.0
    Exterior 4.0
    Reliability 4.0
    0 people out of 0 found this review helpful. Did you?
    Yes No
  • Snow Machine

    Awesome car that is reliable if taken care of and is fast from factory, and even quicker when tuned. The car is comfortable and has good features for older technology. The best mechanics are the Symetrical All-wheel drive system with a center & rear differential and the VF40 turbo which is bigger than the WRX STi. Overall, great all season vehcile for practicality, as well as, some fun on backroads.
    • Purchased a Used car
    • Used for Commuting
    • Does recommend this car
    Comfort 4.0
    Interior 4.0
    Performance 5.0
    Value 4.0
    Exterior 4.0
    Reliability 4.0
    0 people out of 0 found this review helpful. Did you?
    Yes No
  • Added fun to commuting !

    Fun from day 1, I loved this car! Comfortable seats, great audio system and instrument cluster. Cabin lighting is perfect?convenient and not distracting when it?s needed most
    • Purchased a New car
    • Used for Commuting
    • Does recommend this car
    Comfort 5.0
    Interior 5.0
    Performance 5.0
    Value 5.0
    Exterior 5.0
    Reliability 5.0
    0 people out of 0 found this review helpful. Did you?
    Yes No
  • I'm Gonna Miss This Car

    Absolutely an excellent vehicle. Mine is a 2.5GT Wagon, and there's nothing like it under $60k. Fast, fun, practical, everything you need rolled into one car.
    • Purchased a Used car
    • Used for Commuting
    • Does recommend this car
    Comfort 5.0
    Interior 5.0
    Performance 5.0
    Value 5.0
    Exterior 4.0
    Reliability 3.0
    1 person out of 1 found this review helpful. Did you?
    Yes No
  • Love Subaru legacy

    This is the 3rd used Subaru legacy I've ever bought. I love this car. It needed some work when I bought this used one specifically, but that wasn't because of the car, it was because if the owner before having lack of care for the car. But overall this car is amazing and it's strong! I feel safer in this car than I did in my SUV and my sedan before it. Legacy's are reliable, durable, and all around amazing! Not to mention one of the best cars to own in Colorado.
    • Purchased a New car
    • Used for Commuting
    • Does recommend this car
    Comfort 4.0
    Interior 4.0
    Performance 5.0
    Value 5.0
    Exterior 5.0
    Reliability 5.0
    0 people out of 0 found this review helpful. Did you?
    Yes No
  • Most reliable car i have owned!

    Purchased this car at 83k miles and drove it to 100k with absolutely no problems! It drives great in the snow and has never had any problems. Definitely the most practical and reliable car I have ever owned.
    • Purchased a Used car
    • Used for Commuting
    • Does recommend this car
    Comfort 5.0
    Interior 5.0
    Performance 5.0
    Value 5.0
    Exterior 5.0
    Reliability 5.0
    0 people out of 0 found this review helpful. Did you?
    Yes No
  • Best car I?ve ever owned

    This vehicle is reliable and quick. More space than a wrx but the same performance. Interior styling and finish is nicely done
    • Purchased a Used car
    • Used for Commuting
    • Does recommend this car
    Comfort 5.0
    Interior 4.0
    Performance 5.0
    Value 5.0
    Exterior 5.0
    Reliability 5.0
    0 people out of 0 found this review helpful. Did you?
    Yes No
  • A Car So Great Im Buying Another!

    Best vehicle I?ve ever driven! I?ve been driving my 05 legacy for 10 years now and after 148k of very reliable miles and many fun trips in inclement weather its time I pass it along to my 17 year old (new driver) nephew! I couldn?t think of a safer more reliable vehicle for him! I think the car will EASILY get to 200k miles, and maybe even 250k if he continues to maintain it right (oil changes, etc.)! I am buying a new (slightly used) Subaru Legacy with all the bells and whistles and I can?t wakt to spend my next 150k miles in it! My niece just turned 7 and my 2014 Legacy will be handed down to her in abt a decade!
    • Purchased a Used car
    • Used for Commuting
    • Does recommend this car
    Comfort 4.0
    Interior 4.0
    Performance 4.0
    Value 5.0
    Exterior 4.0
    Reliability 5.0
    0 people out of 0 found this review helpful. Did you?
    Yes No

Latest news from cars.com

See all news

Subaru dealers near you

FAQ

What trim levels are available for the 2005 Subaru Legacy?

The 2005 Subaru Legacy is available in 4 trim levels:

  • (4 styles)
  • GT (4 styles)
  • GT Ltd (8 styles)
  • Ltd (4 styles)

What is the MPG of the 2005 Subaru Legacy?

The 2005 Subaru Legacy offers up to 23 MPG in city driving and 30 MPG on the highway. These figures are based on EPA mileage ratings and are for comparison purposes only. The actual mileage will vary depending on vehicle options, trim level, driving conditions, driving habits, vehicle maintenance, and other factors.

What are some similar vehicles and competitors of the 2005 Subaru Legacy?

The 2005 Subaru Legacy compares to and/or competes against the following vehicles:

Is the 2005 Subaru Legacy reliable?

The 2005 Subaru Legacy has an average reliability rating of 4.6 out of 5 according to cars.com consumers. Find real-world reliability insights within consumer reviews from 2005 Subaru Legacy owners.

Is the 2005 Subaru Legacy a good Sedan?

Below are the cars.com consumers ratings for the 2005 Subaru Legacy. 93.8% of drivers recommend this vehicle.

4.5 / 5
Based on 48 reviews
  • Comfort: 4.2
  • Interior: 4.3
  • Performance: 4.7
  • Value: 4.6
  • Exterior: 4.4
  • Reliability: 4.6

Subaru Legacy history

Your list was successfully saved.
 
 
 
 
Save list Compare
[{"cat":"sedan_midsize","stock_type":"used","bodystyle":"Sedan","page_type":"research/make-model-year","oem_page":false,"search_fuel_types":["Gasoline Fuel"]}]