Save your search and get notified when new inventory arrives.
Contact seller
Customize your budget
*Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.
**Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.
About your privacy: Cars.com is asking for your ZIP and credit rating because it helps us to make an educated guess at your sales tax and loan interest. These two factors can greatly change your monthly payment.
Used
2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium
for sale
near me
- Down Payment
- $0
- Net trade-in value
- $0
- Months
- 72
- APR
- 7.0%
- Sales tax
- 0.0%
*Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.
**Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.
Used
2019 Subaru Legacy Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Very pleased.
I drive eighty miles round trip to work. My Legacy is quiet, comfortable and the Eye Sight is great! I’m safe and secure knowing my Subaru has my back. I’d like better mpg but at 32 on average I guess I shouldn’t complain. Love my Subie!
Used
2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Had a gash on front right tire.
Had a gash on front right tire. The service rep told me bring it in they looked at it and set me up with a new tire on the spot! He was the lead guy, big smile and excellent service !!
Love it
I had this model/year as a loaner from the dealer last year and loved it so much, when a loaner became available, I bought it.
Used
2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
December 26,2025 (Pending Snow Storm) One of the most
December 26,2025 (Pending Snow Storm) One of the most overused phrases from a car salesperson is : “Our Service Department is the BEST!”. A pending snowstorm, like everyone else I depend on my car too much! Unfortunately, it’s towards the end of the work day and it’s an issue I can’t avoid. We all have certain family and friends that you have on “speed dial”. This is the sentiment I hold for Jamie Nussbaum and his wonderful staff at East Hill Subaru in Roslyn, New York. I made the call and Lisette answered. She immediately understood my issue and responded, “ You know there is a snow storm coming. You need to bring your car here and we’ll take care of it”. Lisette is another example of a true professional that takes great pride in her position. I arrived and was greeted by Service Advisor Justin Peralta. He did the intake and assured me the car would be thoroughly checked out and I would be updated throughout the process. In a short period of time, Lorrie Santiago came to inform me that my car was ready. Lorrie Santiago is always congenial, professional and laser focused on the task at hand. Lorrie’s area is highly efficient, the paperwork and fob were all ready to go. Lorrie informed me of what was completed, asked if I had any questions and personally thanked me for bringing my car to East Hills Subaru. Lorrie is very proud of this organization and it shows every time! Integrity begins at the top! Jamie Nussbaum is an extremely professional individual.His affect is always pensive yet gregarious in nature. Jamie’s attention to detail is reflected in every aspect of his Service Department. The amount of pressure with work orders, pending projects, emergency customer drop-ins could make this Service Department of “FRENETIC HOT ZONE”. However, to the contrary, Jamie’s strong but calming presence guides his ship through another day of success for his entire team. Philip Saccio and Justin Peralta are top Service Advisors. I’ve been most impressed by both of these professionals. These men take their positions most seriously. The initial intakes are thorough, the process is clearly layed out with potential cost and a clear timeline is presented. Philip Saccio and Justin Peralta assure me they are dedicated to success. The man behind the curtain where all the magic happens is Sandro! I call him the “Economist-Master Technician. Sandro always has a smile along with being extremely gifted. His videos that he takes of the work he performs are extremely informative. Sandro will always give suggestions to keep my vehicle at its peak performance. Sandro’s economic background is always integrated into his technical practice. It appears Sandro’s daily mission is to be the best “Economist-Master Technician” every day. Mission Accomplished Sandro! Finally, I have to acknowledge Jamie Nussbaum. He always takes a compliment and deflects to include his team. His conversations with me always demonstrate a pride he has of everyone on his team. I understand his pride in working with these great professionals. My wife Diane and I are most grateful for all you’ve done for our family. Diane and I wish you all the best NEW YEAR 2026 and may God continue to bless each and every one of you! Thank you! P.S. Your Service Department is one of the BEST! Your sales representatives should bring every potential purchaser to see Jamie and the Team. It’s the ultimate closer!
Wow Big Jon is Awesome
I buy all my cars from My Sales guy Big Jon he never steers me wrong and gives his honest option and not for the sale but for what I need..
Used
2019 Subaru Legacy Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Kristopher was fantastic and took great care of us
Kristopher was fantastic and took great care of us throughout the entire process. Pete in finance was a dream and streamlined the money part beautifully. God bless Ira Toyota of Manchester!
My daughter loves her new car
My daughters 2011 Subaru Legacy had 168,000 on it and it wasn't cost effective to repair it. She was broad sided by a high speed driver and survived in a 2010 legacy. She only wants LEGACY'S because it saved her life. We
Used
2019 Subaru Legacy Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Nicest car I have ever owned.
Has plenty of power, love the all wheel drive, not only for winter, but year around. Really like the color, and the wheels, as well as the ride, and interior leg room, and amenities.
Used
2019 Subaru Legacy Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Pete was great!
Pete P. was great! Pete helped us purchase certified preowned Toyota Highlander! Great customer service from start to finish. Casey handled the sale paperwork, seamless. It was a pleasure to do business with Greentree Toyota. The entire staff receptionist to sales exceptional! Be sure you ask for Pete.
Used
2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5I Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Will buy from them again.
Will buy from them again. The process from start to finish was easy and we’re happy with our purchase!!
Used
2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Greene’s sales representatives were extrmely helpful in
Greene’s sales representatives were extrmely helpful in guiding me toward the used car that my specifications called for. This is unlike what I have experienced elsewhere. I’d recommend Greene!
Used
2019 Subaru Legacy Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Elba me atendió muy bien!
Elba me atendió muy bien! Encantados con el servicio, muy bien todo el proceso súper rapido
Used
2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5I Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Great Employees and purchase experience!
We have had multiple great experiences with this location. Steve, a sales manager was great and so helpful! We had mechanical issues with one of our cars and they took it back within the 30-day warranty with no issue!! I highly recommend this CarMax location for your car buying purchases!!
Used
2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5I Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
I had a vehicle shipped from this location.
I had a vehicle shipped from this location. There was no direct contact with the dealer
Used
2019 Subaru Legacy Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Very professional, efficient, and no-nonsense.
Very professional, efficient, and no-nonsense. Vehicles are well serviced for safety, legality, comfort, and longevity ! Of course there will always be idiosyncrasies involved with any used car purchase, but you’ll be happy in the end !
Used
2019 Subaru Legacy Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
This place is great!
Bryan provided excellent service. He was honest, and helped us get into the perfect car for us! Thanks Bryan! You are a great example of a good salesman.
Used
2019 Subaru Legacy Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Used
2019 Subaru Legacy Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
I had a great experience from start to finish.
I had a great experience from start to finish. Carlos answered all of my questions and was patient with me. They even got me better financing options which surprised me. So far I love my new car. Thanks!!
Used
2019 Subaru Legacy Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
What a wonderful place to purchase a car!
What a wonderful place to purchase a car! You will feel right at home with the staffing. David worked with us as well as Justin. Both are very easy to talk to, and they worked with us and got us back on the road. Thank you!
Used
2019 Subaru Legacy Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Was connected directly to the Seller and got all of my
Was connected directly to the Seller and got all of my questions answered. Will continue to stay in touch as I prepare to make a purchase offer. DLF
Used
2019 Subaru Legacy Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Unique Ford buying experience
Since 2013 we've bought four new vehicles from Unique Ford and we keep coming back. We like the friendly, low pressure, professional sales staff at Unique, in particular, Marvin Martin our sales rep. who has sold Ford products for over 30 years. Unique takes the pain out of buying a vehicle.
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
buyer
So thankful I choose to come to Moto Zone ! Kevin Farrell fought a good fight for me to get the best DEAL !! I’m so happy ! I appreciate them so muchhhhhhh A wonderful TEAM !!! Got a 2016 for a wonderful deal recommend for anyone looking for a used car
Used
2019 Subaru Legacy Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
I have bought two vehicles from this place, and the
I have bought two vehicles from this place, and the vehicles are always immaculate, in excellent condition. Both the dealer's service and that of Sharon, the person who sold me both vehicles, are excellent. They explain everything, they help you, they are always available if you have any questions, they give you recommendations... everything is very transparent. It's an excellent place, and Sharon's service is exceptional!
Subaru Legacy prices by year
| Model year | Average price | Deals |
|---|---|---|
| 2018 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium | $13,799 | 37 Good deals |
| 2017 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium | $12,136 | 14 Great deals |
| 2016 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium | $11,326 | 13 Great deals |
| 2015 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium | $9,751 | 10 Great deals |
| 2014 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium | $8,410 | 7 Great deals |
| 2013 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium | $7,644 | 6 Great deals |
About the 2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium
2.5i Premium shown.
- Seating
- 5
- Door count
- 4
- Drivetrain
- All Wheel Drive
- Combined MPG
- 29
- Transmission
- CVT Transmission
- Engine
- 175.0-hp, 2.5-liter, 4 Cylinder Engine (Gasoline Fuel)
How much does the 2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium cost?
The 2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium price depends on several factors, including optional features, mileage, vehicle history and location. The nationwide average price for a 2019 Legacy 2.5i Premium is $15,545, with pricing starting at $10,295.
What is the MPG of the 2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium?
The 2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium offers up to 25 MPG in city driving and 34 MPG on the highway for a combined rating of 29 MPG.
These figures are based on EPA mileage ratings and are for comparison purposes only. The actual mileage will vary depending on the selected vehicle options, driving conditions, driving habits, vehicle maintenance, and other factors.
What are some similar vehicles and competitors of the 2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium?
The 2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium compares to and/or competes against the following vehicles:
Is the 2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium reliable?
The 2019 Subaru Legacy has an average reliability rating of 4.6 out of 5 according to Cars.com consumers. Find real-world reliability insights within consumer reviews from 2019 Legacy owners.
91% of drivers recommend this car
- Comfort 4.7
- Interior 4.8
- Performance 4.5
- Value 4.6
- Exterior 4.7
- Reliability 4.6
Premium (1 style)
| Style |
|---|
| 2.5i Premium |
| Inventory price |
| Starting at $24,695 |
| Combined MPG |
| 29 |
| Engine |
| 175.0-hp, 2.5-liter, 4 Cylinder Engine (Gasoline Fuel) |
*Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.
**Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.
Subaru Legacy trims
-
Subaru Legacy 2019 2.5i Limited
5 Great Deals out of 73 listings starting at $8,942
-
Subaru Legacy 2019 2.5i Sport
2 Great Deals out of 20 listings starting at $9,990
- ${price_badge()}
- ${ami_badge()}
- ${battery_badge()}${ev_report_link()}
- ${hot_car_badge()}
- ${award_badge()}
- ${cpo_badge()}
${price_badge_description}
${ami_badge_description}
The EV Battery Rating is based on this vehicle's current expected range relative to the vehicles expected range when new. ${battery_badge_text}
This vehicle is certified pre-owned, backed by a manufacturer warranty, and typically undergoes a rigorous multi-point inspection to ensure quality and reliability.
This vehicle is currently in high demand given its competitive price, desirable features, and overall condition, and may have a higher chance of selling quickly.
