Reviews
Write a reviewI brought my Mini in with a free diagnostic coupon, having been a loyal customer for 6 years. I worked with Daniel Martinez because of a slight ticking noise, which I suspected might be the spark plugs. Daniel confirmed the plugs were fine, but the rest of the experience was incredibly frustrating. Throughout my visit, I felt constantly pressured to authorize additional inspections and services. I had to repeat myself three or four times, stating I only wanted to diagnose the ticking noise so I could prioritize repairs. While Daniel was polite, the aggressive upselling made me put my guard up. I left my car on Friday morning, and though the mechanic sent a video pointing out other issues, he couldn’t identify the source of the ticking. After playing phone tag, Daniel informed me on Monday that it would cost an additional $450 just to "explore" the cause of the noise—and that fee would not go toward the actual repair. I declined and picked up my car, only to be subjected to yet another upsell attempt for air filters. The lack of expertise and constant sales pressure completely eroded my trust. On my drive home from Pleasanton to Oakland, the slight ticking escalated into a severe, full knock. I texted Daniel immediately to voice my concerns but received absolutely no response. The following week, I took my car to an independent specialist in German cars. Within two and a half hours, they diagnosed the issue perfectly: a failing water pump was disrupting belt tension and causing the knock. The diagnostic fee was a reasonable $103 (waived if repaired there), and the service was entirely pressure-free. The contrast was night and day. As a 6-year customer, I expected to be valued and respected. Instead, I felt like a target for upsells. I will never bring my car back to East Bay Mini.
I brought my Mini in with a free diagnostic coupon, having been a loyal customer for 6 years. I worked with Daniel Martinez because of a slight ticking noise, which I suspected might be the spark plugs. Daniel confirmed the plugs were fine, but the rest of the experience was incredibly frustrating. Throughout my visit, I felt constantly pressured to authorize additional inspections and services. I had to repeat myself three or four times, stating I only wanted to diagnose the ticking noise so I could prioritize repairs. While Daniel was polite, the aggressive upselling made me put my guard up. I left my car on Friday morning, and though the mechanic sent a video pointing out other issues, he couldn’t identify the source of the ticking. After playing phone tag, Daniel informed me on Monday that it would cost an additional $450 just to "explore" the cause of the noise—and that fee would not go toward the actual repair. I declined and picked up my car, only to be subjected to yet another upsell attempt for air filters. The lack of expertise and constant sales pressure completely eroded my trust. On my drive home from Pleasanton to Oakland, the slight ticking escalated into a severe, full knock. I texted Daniel immediately to voice my concerns but received absolutely no response. The following week, I took my car to an independent specialist in German cars. Within two and a half hours, they diagnosed the issue perfectly: a failing water pump was disrupting belt tension and causing the knock. The diagnostic fee was a reasonable $103 (waived if repaired there), and the service was entirely pressure-free. The contrast was night and day. As a 6-year customer, I expected to be valued and respected. Instead, I felt like a target for upsells. I will never bring my car back to East Bay Mini.
- Customer service
- —
- Buying process
- —
- Quality of repair
- —
- Overall facilities
- —
- Overall experience
- 1.0
- Does not recommend this dealer
- Came in for service or repair
We would like the opportunity to address your concerns. Please reach out to us directly at (925) 251-3802 when you have a chance. Thank you, and we look forward to hearing from you.
Jeff is my service guy, he always make my visits/service enjoyable and pleasant! It was great as always!
Jeff is my service guy, he always make my visits/service enjoyable and pleasant! It was great as always!
- Customer service
- 5.0
- Buying process
- —
- Quality of repair
- 5.0
- Overall facilities
- —
- Overall experience
- 5.0
- Does recommend this dealer
- Came in for service or repair
- Did make a purchase
Hi Margaret Cohen, Thank you for your 5-star review of Jeff Killoran, our Service Advisor, and your overall experience. We appreciate it!
It is the BEST service center we have ever been in our lives!!! In terms of staff knowledge and courteousness-topnotch. Will and Jeff went above and beyond to help us with our Mini Cooper brake pads. to make things more impressive, they CLEANED the car after the service. They notified us on time and did the best they could to help us with our concerns. If only Mini has a SUV, I would give up my Ford Explorer ST so I could avoid dealing with other service centers. HIGHLY RECCOMENDED!!!
It is the BEST service center we have ever been in our lives!!! In terms of staff knowledge and courteousness-topnotch. Will and Jeff went above and beyond to help us with our Mini Cooper brake pads. to make things more impressive, they CLEANED the car after the service. They notified us on time and did the best they could to help us with our concerns. If only Mini has a SUV, I would give up my Ford Explorer ST so I could avoid dealing with other service centers. HIGHLY RECCOMENDED!!!
- Customer service
- 5.0
- Buying process
- —
- Quality of repair
- 5.0
- Overall facilities
- —
- Overall experience
- 5.0
- Does recommend this dealer
- Came in for service or repair
Hello Ful H, Thanks so much for your awesome review and kind words to our teammates Jeff Killoran and Willie Walker at East Bay MINI. We are very appreciative of your enthusiasm for our team and recognize their professionalism and care. Thanks for choosing us and watch out, MINI Cooper might be getting even bigger than the Countryman in the future!
Oh my!!! Thank you❤️
Jeff K. Is always awesome. Fast, super helpful and knowledgeable. The service guys always go above and beyond.
Jeff K. Is always awesome. Fast, super helpful and knowledgeable. The service guys always go above and beyond.
- Customer service
- 5.0
- Buying process
- —
- Quality of repair
- 5.0
- Overall facilities
- —
- Overall experience
- 5.0
- Does recommend this dealer
- Came in for service or repair
- Did make a purchase
Hello Susie F., Thanks for leaving a review for our Service Advisor, Jeff Killoran. He is a true pro. We appreciate you choosing East Bay MINI as your service center!
Friendly service (from sales to Finance to the Service department) and quality work. For some reason after 300 miles my tires lost air and the dash said to bring in the car to the service department. So that's what I did. My wait was quick and the waiting area had chairs/tables spaced 6 feet apart--which I appreciated.
Friendly service (from sales to Finance to the Service department) and quality work. For some reason after 300 miles my tires lost air and the dash said to bring in the car to the service department. So that's what I did. My wait was quick and the waiting area had chairs/tables spaced 6 feet apart--which I appreciated.
- Customer service
- 5.0
- Buying process
- 5.0
- Quality of repair
- 5.0
- Overall facilities
- —
- Overall experience
- 5.0
- Does recommend this dealer
- Came in for service or repair
- Did make a purchase
Hello Debbie, We appreciate your review of East Bay MINI and letting us know how your experience went. Your time is valuable and we do our best to get things done efficiently for our clients. Thank you for your recommendation!
Excellent service and customer care/satisfaction was completed on time and within the day I brought the car in. Problem solved and explanation given and understood
Excellent service and customer care/satisfaction was completed on time and within the day I brought the car in. Problem solved and explanation given and understood
- Customer service
- 5.0
- Buying process
- 5.0
- Quality of repair
- 5.0
- Overall facilities
- —
- Overall experience
- 5.0
- Does recommend this dealer
- Came in for service or repair
- Did not make a purchase
Hello Michael Amo, Thank you for taking the time and letting us know how we did with your service at East Bay MINI. We truly appreciate your recommendation and business!
Justin was particularly helpful and a pleasure to do business with.
Justin was particularly helpful and a pleasure to do business with.
- Customer service
- 5.0
- Buying process
- —
- Quality of repair
- 5.0
- Overall facilities
- —
- Overall experience
- 5.0
- Does recommend this dealer
- Came in for service or repair
- Did not make a purchase
Hello Stuart kahn, We appreciate your review of Justin Perry, our Service Advisor. Thanks for choosing East Bay MINI as your service center!
Excellent customer and car service, thank you for taking care of me and my mini!!!
Excellent customer and car service, thank you for taking care of me and my mini!!!
- Customer service
- 5.0
- Buying process
- —
- Quality of repair
- 5.0
- Overall facilities
- —
- Overall experience
- 5.0
- Does recommend this dealer
- Came in for service or repair
- Did not make a purchase
Hello Shiely Sison, Thanks for taking the time to let us know how we did with service on your MINI. We appreciate your recommendation!
The service department is thorough, friendly and efficient. They kept me informed through the time the car was being serviced, including a short video of the battery diagnostic that was run.
The service department is thorough, friendly and efficient. They kept me informed through the time the car was being serviced, including a short video of the battery diagnostic that was run.
- Customer service
- 5.0
- Buying process
- —
- Quality of repair
- 5.0
- Overall facilities
- —
- Overall experience
- 5.0
- Does recommend this dealer
- Came in for service or repair
Hello Stephenplind, We're so glad to hear your service experience was great. Thanks for letting us know you like the video of your diagnostic. A great tool for keeping our clients informed. We certainly hope to serve you again in the future!
I was shopping around for a new Mini Cooper and contacted a few dealerships in my area. From the initial contact my sales person Jakob and the manager Phil were super helpful and responsive to my questions even before I went in for a test drive. I knew that I'd love my Mini but the experience was made better by the East Bay Mini team. I was able to trade in my vehicle at the same time and the whole process was transparent and hassle free. Will definitely recommend to anyone looking for a Mini!
I was shopping around for a new Mini Cooper and contacted a few dealerships in my area. From the initial contact my sales person Jakob and the manager Phil were super helpful and responsive to my questions even before I went in for a test drive. I knew that I'd love my Mini but the experience was made better by the East Bay Mini team. I was able to trade in my vehicle at the same time and the whole process was transparent and hassle free. Will definitely recommend to anyone looking for a Mini!
- Customer service
- 5.0
- Buying process
- 5.0
- Quality of repair
- —
- Overall facilities
- —
- Overall experience
- 5.0
- Does recommend this dealer
- Shopped for a new car
- Did make a purchase
Hi Amy Lynn, So glad to hear your over all experience was top notch working with Jakob Aini and Phil Wiltz. Both great professionals and team members. Congrats on your MINI Cooper and we hope to serve you again in the future!