Skip to main content

Selective Motors

(170 reviews)
Visit Selective Motors
Sales hours: 9:30am to 6:00pm
View all hours
Sales
Monday 9:30am–6:00pm
Tuesday 9:30am–6:00pm
Wednesday 9:30am–6:00pm
Thursday 9:30am–6:00pm
Friday 9:30am–6:00pm
Saturday 10:00am–7:00pm
Sunday Closed
2025 consumer dealer award
View 1 awards
2025 consumer dealer award
(317) 793-6416 (317) 793-6416

Inventory

See all 100 vehicles from this dealership.

About our dealership

This seller has been on Cars.com since March 2017.
Welcome to Selective Motors! Though we're a new dealership we have over 15 years of experience in the automotive industry. We aim to offer the best selection of pre-owned cars trucks and SUVs in Indianapolis. Our knowledgeable sales staff is here to assure you find the right vehicle for you and your family. Our mission is to provide the best customer service while facilitating a fun hassle-free car buying experience.

Reviews

(170 reviews)

A dealership's rating is based on all of their reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews. Includes reviews of Selective Motors from DealerRater.

Want to share your experience with this dealership?

Write a review

Paul was great and very accommodating salesman thanks for

Paul was great and very accommodating salesman thanks for the great sales. Excited to drive my new car!

Paul was great and very accommodating salesman thanks for

Paul was great and very accommodating salesman thanks for the great sales. Excited to drive my new car!

Rating breakdown (out of 5):
  • Customer service
  • Buying process
  • Quality of repair
  • Overall facilities
  • Overall experience 4.0
  • Does recommend this dealer
  • Shopped for a used car
  • Did make a purchase
0 people out of 0 found this review helpful. Did you?
Yes No
Show full review

Was interested in purchasing a vehicle Selective Motors

Was interested in purchasing a vehicle Selective Motors had listed. When I asked basic questions about the vehicle, Sam was vague in his answers. I asked for pictures of certain areas of the vehicle and he replied they could only send through text as they were too large to email. Everyone knows you can send larger files through email than you can through text. When I mentioned I couldn't find any maintenance records for the vehicle using a VIN search, he replied they didn't have any records. When I asked if they had run the vehicle through the shop to see if anything was wrong, Sam said they only service vehicles that need it. It is common practice among reputable legitimate dealers to have the service shop do an inspection on the vehicle, change the oil, check trans fluid, brakes, etc to see what the vehicle needs, are there any problems and how they should determine a price for the vehicle. It is bewildering how they could come up with a price without knowing anything about the vehicle. Based on this experience, it seems the negative reviews are accurate and the 5 star are more than likely AI generated in my opinion.

Was interested in purchasing a vehicle Selective Motors

Was interested in purchasing a vehicle Selective Motors had listed. When I asked basic questions about the vehicle, Sam was vague in his answers. I asked for pictures of certain areas of the vehicle and he replied they could only send through text as they were too large to email. Everyone knows you can send larger files through email than you can through text. When I mentioned I couldn't find any maintenance records for the vehicle using a VIN search, he replied they didn't have any records. When I asked if they had run the vehicle through the shop to see if anything was wrong, Sam said they only service vehicles that need it. It is common practice among reputable legitimate dealers to have the service shop do an inspection on the vehicle, change the oil, check trans fluid, brakes, etc to see what the vehicle needs, are there any problems and how they should determine a price for the vehicle. It is bewildering how they could come up with a price without knowing anything about the vehicle. Based on this experience, it seems the negative reviews are accurate and the 5 star are more than likely AI generated in my opinion.

Rating breakdown (out of 5):
  • Customer service
  • Buying process
  • Quality of repair
  • Overall facilities
  • Overall experience 1.0
  • Does not recommend this dealer
  • Shopped for a used car
  • Did not make a purchase
0 people out of 0 found this review helpful. Did you?
Yes No
Show full review

Was interested in purchasing a vehicle Selective Motors

Was interested in purchasing a vehicle Selective Motors had listed. When I asked basic questions about the vehicle, Sam was vague in his answers. I asked for pictures of certain areas of the vehicle and he replied they could only send through text as they were too large to email. Everyone knows you can send larger files through email than you can through text. When I mentioned I couldn't find any maintenance records for the vehicle using a VIN search, he replied they didn't have any records. When I asked if they had run the vehicle through the shop to see if anything was wrong, Sam said they only service vehicles that need it. It is common practice among reputable legitimate dealers to have the service shop do an inspection on the vehicle, change the oil, check trans fluid, brakes, etc to see what the vehicle needs, are there any problems and how they should determine a price for the vehicle. It is bewildering how they could come up with a price without knowing anything about the vehicle. Based on this experience, it seems the negative reviews are accurate and the 5 star are more than likely AI generated in my opinion.

Was interested in purchasing a vehicle Selective Motors

Was interested in purchasing a vehicle Selective Motors had listed. When I asked basic questions about the vehicle, Sam was vague in his answers. I asked for pictures of certain areas of the vehicle and he replied they could only send through text as they were too large to email. Everyone knows you can send larger files through email than you can through text. When I mentioned I couldn't find any maintenance records for the vehicle using a VIN search, he replied they didn't have any records. When I asked if they had run the vehicle through the shop to see if anything was wrong, Sam said they only service vehicles that need it. It is common practice among reputable legitimate dealers to have the service shop do an inspection on the vehicle, change the oil, check trans fluid, brakes, etc to see what the vehicle needs, are there any problems and how they should determine a price for the vehicle. It is bewildering how they could come up with a price without knowing anything about the vehicle. Based on this experience, it seems the negative reviews are accurate and the 5 star are more than likely AI generated in my opinion.

Rating breakdown (out of 5):
  • Customer service
  • Buying process
  • Quality of repair
  • Overall facilities
  • Overall experience 1.0
  • Does not recommend this dealer
  • Shopped for a used car
0 people out of 0 found this review helpful.
Show full review

Excellent service highly recommend Selective motors was

Excellent service highly recommend Selective motors was very nice and the staff been so much helpful

Excellent service highly recommend Selective motors was

Excellent service highly recommend Selective motors was very nice and the staff been so much helpful

Rating breakdown (out of 5):
  • Customer service
  • Buying process
  • Quality of repair
  • Overall facilities
  • Overall experience 5.0
  • Does recommend this dealer
  • Shopped for a used car
  • Did make a purchase
0 people out of 0 found this review helpful. Did you?
Yes No
Show full review

I recently purchased a vehicle from Selective Motors,

I recently purchased a vehicle from Selective Motors, and my experience has been extremely disappointing. Within just 30 days of the purchase, the car started exhibiting significant mechanical issues. Unfortunately, the dealership's response and handling of the repairs have been completely inadequate. When I reached out for assistance, I was met with delays and a lack of accountability. To make matters worse, the warranty company refused to cover the repairs, attributing the fault to the dealer. This left me with a defective car and no support from either party. Given the circumstances, I am seeking a refund of my down payment and first payment, and I wish to return the car to the dealer. I strongly advise potential customers to exercise caution and thoroughly investigate before making any purchases from Selective Motors. My experience has been nothing short of frustrating and disappointing.

I recently purchased a vehicle from Selective Motors,

I recently purchased a vehicle from Selective Motors, and my experience has been extremely disappointing. Within just 30 days of the purchase, the car started exhibiting significant mechanical issues. Unfortunately, the dealership's response and handling of the repairs have been completely inadequate. When I reached out for assistance, I was met with delays and a lack of accountability. To make matters worse, the warranty company refused to cover the repairs, attributing the fault to the dealer. This left me with a defective car and no support from either party. Given the circumstances, I am seeking a refund of my down payment and first payment, and I wish to return the car to the dealer. I strongly advise potential customers to exercise caution and thoroughly investigate before making any purchases from Selective Motors. My experience has been nothing short of frustrating and disappointing.

Rating breakdown (out of 5):
  • Customer service
  • Buying process
  • Quality of repair
  • Overall facilities
  • Overall experience 1.0
  • Does not recommend this dealer
  • Shopped for a used car
1 person out of 1 found this review helpful.
Show full review

Sam was wonderful to work with.

Sam was wonderful to work with. We definitely recommend Selective Motors and Sam as your salesman!

Sam was wonderful to work with.

Sam was wonderful to work with. We definitely recommend Selective Motors and Sam as your salesman!

Rating breakdown (out of 5):
  • Customer service
  • Buying process
  • Quality of repair
  • Overall facilities
  • Overall experience 5.0
  • Does recommend this dealer
  • Shopped for a used car
  • Did make a purchase
0 people out of 0 found this review helpful. Did you?
Yes No
Show full review

I bought a vehicle from this dealership a year a go ,

I bought a vehicle from this dealership a year a go , everyone was nice and financig was so easy, I am still happy about the vehicle and Thankfully never hade any mechanical issues so I decided to come back to purchase a vehicle for my husband and it was a success , they had what I was looking for , even though I had so many questions they were not bothered at all , I am so satisfied with my husband new vehicle and well definitely come back in the future 😊

I bought a vehicle from this dealership a year a go ,

I bought a vehicle from this dealership a year a go , everyone was nice and financig was so easy, I am still happy about the vehicle and Thankfully never hade any mechanical issues so I decided to come back to purchase a vehicle for my husband and it was a success , they had what I was looking for , even though I had so many questions they were not bothered at all , I am so satisfied with my husband new vehicle and well definitely come back in the future 😊

Rating breakdown (out of 5):
  • Customer service
  • Buying process
  • Quality of repair
  • Overall facilities
  • Overall experience 5.0
  • Does recommend this dealer
  • Shopped for a used car
0 people out of 0 found this review helpful.
Show full review

Bought a beautiful Mercedes from here.

Bought a beautiful Mercedes from here. The staff was very nice and knowledgeable about their inventory. Car was very clean and priced very competitively to the market. I also was pre approved with my bank. But selective motors gave me a better deal with their finance and also better deal on their warranty. Over all 10/10 I highly recommend and will be coming back soon

Bought a beautiful Mercedes from here.

Bought a beautiful Mercedes from here. The staff was very nice and knowledgeable about their inventory. Car was very clean and priced very competitively to the market. I also was pre approved with my bank. But selective motors gave me a better deal with their finance and also better deal on their warranty. Over all 10/10 I highly recommend and will be coming back soon

Rating breakdown (out of 5):
  • Customer service
  • Buying process
  • Quality of repair
  • Overall facilities
  • Overall experience 5.0
  • Does recommend this dealer
  • Shopped for a used car
0 people out of 0 found this review helpful.
Show full review

Great service Sam was very helpful Nice selection of

Great service Sam was very helpful Nice selection of cars and had a great deal

Great service Sam was very helpful Nice selection of

Great service Sam was very helpful Nice selection of cars and had a great deal

Rating breakdown (out of 5):
  • Customer service
  • Buying process
  • Quality of repair
  • Overall facilities
  • Overall experience 5.0
  • Does recommend this dealer
  • Shopped for a used car
  • Did make a purchase
0 people out of 1 found this review helpful. Did you?
Yes No
Show full review

I found this car on car.

I found this car on car.com and the process of getting it ready and filling out paper work made it seem like a breeze.

I found this car on car.

I found this car on car.com and the process of getting it ready and filling out paper work made it seem like a breeze.

Rating breakdown (out of 5):
  • Customer service
  • Buying process
  • Quality of repair
  • Overall facilities
  • Overall experience 5.0
  • Does recommend this dealer
  • Shopped for a used car
  • Did make a purchase
0 people out of 0 found this review helpful. Did you?
Yes No
Show full review
See all 170 reviews