Contact seller

Contact seller

By clicking here, you authorize Cars.com and its sellers/partners to contact you by text/calls which may include marketing and be by autodialer. Calls may be prerecorded. You also agree to our Privacy Notice. Consent is not required to purchase goods/services.

We value your privacy. Cars.com Privacy Notice

Customize your budget

Est. max vehicle price based on your desired monthly budget (...% APR*. and ...% sales tax)
$...*
See matching cars

*Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.

**Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.

About your privacy: Cars.com is asking for your ZIP and credit rating because it helps us to make an educated guess at your sales tax and loan interest. These two factors can greatly change your monthly payment.

Used Ferrari 458 Italia for sale near Plainview, NY

Filters 3 Model Price & payment Make Mileage All filters
1 match 30 miles from 11803
Be the first to know!

Save your search and get notified when new inventory arrives.

Prequalify now

It only takes a few minutes and won't affect your credit.

Get Prequalified
Est. $400 /mo*
Down Payment
$0
Net trade-in value
$0
Months
72
APR
7.0%
Sales tax
0.0%

*Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.

**Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.

2012 Ferrari 458 Italia
2012 Ferrari 458 Italia
2012 Ferrari 458 Italia

Ferrari Certified

2012 Ferrari 458 Italia

20,756 mi.
$239,700
Est. $4,439/mo*
Ferrari of Long Island
(112 reviews)
Plainview, NY (2 mi.)
Call

Vehicle information

Ext. color: Nero
Int. color: Brown
Drivetrain: Rear-wheel Drive
Fuel type: Gasoline
Transmission: 7-Speed Automatic w/manual shift
Engine: Gas V8 4.5L/275
VIN: ZFF67NFA3C0186691

Features

Convenience: Keyless Entry
Entertainment: Bluetooth®, CD Player
Exterior: Alloy Wheels
Safety: Backup Camera, Stability Control
Seating: Leather Seats

Reviews

Ferrari of Long Island review

My experience at Ferrari of Long Island was an excellent

February 1, 2025
By Rob from Southampton, NY

My experience at Ferrari of Long Island was an excellent one. DJ was a very polite, conscientious, and knowledgeable salesman who was a pleasure to work with.

2012 Ferrari 458 Italia review

Most Fun Car

April 20, 2019
By fERRARI from Scottsdale
Owns this car

FAST, LUXURY, COMFORT, RELIABILITY, FUN, OUTDOOR, EXOTIC CAR, WHATEVER YOU ASK IS IN THIS CAR. tHIS CAR WILL SATISFY ALL YOUR NEEDS. THIS CAR WAS MY DREAM CAR BUT I JUST HAD TO LET IT GO DUE TO FAMILY

There are additional matching cars outside your search area.

Sorted by premium dealers first

Partial matches are generated by applying your search criteria to a larger search area. Our goal is to help you discover additional cars that match your search preferences.

As a benefit to some of our dealer customers, we display their listings first.
2010 Ferrari 458 Italia Base
2010 Ferrari 458 Italia Base
2010 Ferrari 458 Italia Base
2010 Ferrari 458 Italia Base
2010 Ferrari 458 Italia Base
2010 Ferrari 458 Italia Base View all 64 photos

Used

2010 Ferrari 458 Italia Base

37,627 mi.
$187,999
Est. $3,482/mo*
Status Auto Group
Staten Island, NY (35 mi.)

Vehicle information

Ext. color: Red
Int. color: Black
Drivetrain: Rear-wheel Drive
MPG: 12-18
Fuel type: Gasoline
Transmission: Automatic
Engine: 4.5L V-8 gasoline direct injection, DOHC, variable valve control
Stock #: 78302C
VIN: ZFF67NFA4A0174823

Features

Convenience: Keyless Entry
Entertainment: Bluetooth®, CD Player
Exterior: Alloy Wheels
Safety: Stability Control
Seating: Leather Seats
2015 Ferrari 458 Italia Base
2015 Ferrari 458 Italia Base
2015 Ferrari 458 Italia Base
2015 Ferrari 458 Italia Base
2015 Ferrari 458 Italia Base
2015 Ferrari 458 Italia Base View all 66 photos

Used

2015 Ferrari 458 Italia Base

11,196 mi.
$299,999
Est. $5,556/mo*
Status Auto Group
Staten Island, NY (35 mi.)

Vehicle information

Ext. color: Bianco Avus
Int. color: Brown
Drivetrain: Rear-wheel Drive
MPG: 13-17
Fuel type: Gasoline
Transmission: Automatic
Engine: 4.5L V-8 gasoline direct injection, DOHC, variable valve control
Stock #: 78323
VIN: ZFF67NFA2F0210032

Features

Convenience: Keyless Entry
Entertainment: Bluetooth®, CD Player
Exterior: Alloy Wheels
Safety: Lane Departure Warning, Stability Control
Seating: Leather Seats
2011 Ferrari 458 Italia Base
2011 Ferrari 458 Italia Base
2011 Ferrari 458 Italia Base
2011 Ferrari 458 Italia Base
2011 Ferrari 458 Italia Base
2011 Ferrari 458 Italia Base View all 23 photos

Used

2011 Ferrari 458 Italia Base

17,619 mi.
$244,999
Est. $4,537/mo*
Brooklyn Auto Sales
Staten Island, NY (36 mi.)
Call Check availability Check availability

Vehicle information

Ext. color: Yellow
Int. color: Black
Drivetrain: Rear-wheel Drive
MPG: 12-18
Fuel type: Gasoline
Transmission: Automatic
Engine: 4.5L V8 DOHC 32V
Stock #: 180278
VIN: ZFF67NFA0B0180278

Features

Convenience: Keyless Entry
Entertainment: Bluetooth®, CD Player
Exterior: Alloy Wheels
Safety: Stability Control
Seating: Leather Seats
2011 Ferrari 458 Italia Base

Used

2011 Ferrari 458 Italia Base

25,543 mi.
Not Priced
Status Auto Group
Staten Island, NY (35 mi.)

Vehicle information

Ext. color: Argento Nurburgring Metallic
Int. color: Grigio Scuro
Drivetrain: Rear-wheel Drive
MPG: 12-18
Fuel type: Gasoline
Transmission: Automatic
Engine: 4.5L V-8 gasoline direct injection, DOHC, variable valve control
Stock #: 78330
VIN: ZFF67NFA3B0180775

Features

Convenience: Keyless Entry
Entertainment: Bluetooth®, CD Player
Exterior: Alloy Wheels
Safety: Backup Camera, Stability Control
Seating: Leather Seats
  • Prev
  • 1
  • Next

About the Ferrari 458 Italia

FAQs

How much does the Ferrari 458 Italia cost?

The Ferrari 458 Italia price depends on several factors, including the trim level, optional features, mileage, vehicle history and location. The nationwide average price for the 458 Italia is $234,078, with pricing starting at $139,995.

What is the MPG of the Ferrari 458 Italia?

The Ferrari 458 Italia with traditional internal combustion engine offers up to 13 MPG city and 17 MPG highway for a combined rating of 15 MPG.

These figures are based on EPA mileage ratings and are for comparison purposes only. The actual mileage will vary depending on the selected vehicle model year, trim, driving conditions, driving habits, vehicle maintenance, and other factors.

What are some similar vehicles and competitors of the Ferrari 458 Italia?

The Ferrari 458 Italia compares to and/or competes against the following vehicles:

What trim levels are available for the Ferrari 458 Italia?

The Ferrari 458 Italia is available in the following trim levels:

What model years are available for the Ferrari 458 Italia?

Ferrari 458 Italia inventory is available for the 2012 model year.

*Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.

**Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.

1 match Clear
Reset
1 match
Be the first to know!

Save your search and get notified when new inventory arrives.
Basics
Ferrari models
458 Italia trims
Price & payment Full Price Monthly
‡Monthly budget search results are estimated based on a 72-month loan term with $0 down payment, $0 trade-in value, 0.0% sales tax and 7.0% APR. Inputs can be personalized using the calculator.
Financing
Deal rating
Vehicle history
Awards
Style
Body style
Vehicle size
Cab type
Exterior color
Interior color
Performance
Transmission
Drivetrain
Cylinders
Fuel type
EV range
EV charge time
Features
Convenience
Entertainment
Exterior
Safety
Seating
Door count
Seller info
Seller type
Keyword
Update
Show only
[{"applied_filter_criteria":"{\"cpo_indicator\":false,\"make_model_trim\":[{\"make\":\"ferrari\",\"model\":\"458_italia\"}],\"search_range\":\"30\",\"shippable\":true,\"sort_field\":\"searchRank1\",\"sort_order\":\"desc\",\"stock_type\":\"used\"}","search_type":"general-inventory-search","sponsored_type_eligible":["inventory_ad"],"vehicle_array":[{"model":"458 Italia","photo_count":3,"listing_id":"ce0f3486-de32-4026-8a42-525e31a2183b","mileage":"20756","drivetrain":"Rear-wheel Drive","canonical_mmty":"Ferrari:458 Italia::2012","certified_preowned":true,"dealer_zip":"11803","sponsored":false,"bodystyle":"Coupe","canonical_mmt":"Ferrari:458 Italia:","interior_color":"Brown","cat":"sportscar_standard","stock_type":"Used","fuel_type":"Gasoline","vertical_position":1,"year":"2012","badges":["cpo"],"msrp":"0","relevancy_score":null,"sponsored_type":"standard","nvi_program":false,"seller_type":"dealership","stock_sub":"","make":"Ferrari","dealer_name":"Ferrari of Long Island","customer_id":"6050790","cpo_package":"Ferrari","exterior_color":"Nero","trim":null,"vin":"ZFF67NFA3C0186691","price":"239700","cpo_indicator":true},{"model":"458 Italia","photo_count":64,"listing_id":"d8e137be-200c-44dd-9a63-79a00a8da10e","mileage":"37627","drivetrain":"Rear-wheel Drive","canonical_mmty":"Ferrari:458 Italia:Base:2010","certified_preowned":false,"dealer_zip":"10305","sponsored":true,"bodystyle":"Coupe","canonical_mmt":"Ferrari:458 Italia:Base","interior_color":"Black","cat":"sportscar_standard","stock_type":"Used","fuel_type":"Gasoline","vertical_position":2,"year":"2010","badges":["great_deal"],"msrp":"0","relevancy_score":null,"sponsored_type":"search_expansion|radius_paid","nvi_program":false,"seller_type":"dealership","stock_sub":"","make":"Ferrari","dealer_name":"Status Auto Group","customer_id":"6033361","cpo_package":null,"exterior_color":"Red","trim":"Base","vin":"ZFF67NFA4A0174823","price":"187999","cpo_indicator":false},{"model":"458 Italia","photo_count":66,"listing_id":"46d1cf45-9e6e-42ff-91a6-f3b412c12dda","mileage":"11196","drivetrain":"Rear-wheel Drive","canonical_mmty":"Ferrari:458 Italia:Base:2015","certified_preowned":false,"dealer_zip":"10305","sponsored":true,"bodystyle":"Coupe","canonical_mmt":"Ferrari:458 Italia:Base","interior_color":"Brown","cat":"sportscar_standard","stock_type":"Used","fuel_type":"Gasoline","vertical_position":3,"year":"2015","badges":[],"msrp":"0","relevancy_score":null,"sponsored_type":"search_expansion|radius_paid","nvi_program":false,"seller_type":"dealership","stock_sub":"","make":"Ferrari","dealer_name":"Status Auto Group","customer_id":"6033361","cpo_package":null,"exterior_color":"Bianco Avus","trim":"Base","vin":"ZFF67NFA2F0210032","price":"299999","cpo_indicator":false},{"model":"458 Italia","photo_count":23,"listing_id":"9a589ad6-b127-43a3-8016-5d938b05065c","mileage":"17619","drivetrain":"Rear-wheel Drive","canonical_mmty":"Ferrari:458 Italia:Base:2011","certified_preowned":false,"dealer_zip":"10310","sponsored":false,"bodystyle":"Coupe","canonical_mmt":"Ferrari:458 Italia:Base","interior_color":"Black","cat":"sportscar_standard","stock_type":"Used","fuel_type":"Gasoline","vertical_position":4,"year":"2011","badges":["good_deal"],"msrp":"0","relevancy_score":null,"sponsored_type":"search_expansion|radius_non_paid","nvi_program":false,"seller_type":"dealership","stock_sub":"","make":"Ferrari","dealer_name":"Brooklyn Auto Sales","customer_id":"191250","cpo_package":null,"exterior_color":"Yellow","trim":"Base","vin":"ZFF67NFA0B0180278","price":"244999","cpo_indicator":false},{"model":"458 Italia","photo_count":1,"listing_id":"f5dae35d-236e-4a01-bf65-1b8e5f60ccb2","mileage":"25543","drivetrain":"Rear-wheel Drive","canonical_mmty":"Ferrari:458 Italia:Base:2011","certified_preowned":false,"dealer_zip":"10305","sponsored":true,"bodystyle":"Coupe","canonical_mmt":"Ferrari:458 Italia:Base","interior_color":"Grigio Scuro","cat":"sportscar_standard","stock_type":"Used","fuel_type":"Gasoline","vertical_position":5,"year":"2011","badges":[],"msrp":"0","relevancy_score":null,"sponsored_type":"search_expansion|radius_paid","nvi_program":false,"seller_type":"dealership","stock_sub":"","make":"Ferrari","dealer_name":"Status Auto Group","customer_id":"6033361","cpo_package":null,"exterior_color":"Argento Nurburgring Metallic","trim":"Base","vin":"ZFF67NFA3B0180775","price":"0","cpo_indicator":false}]}]