Save your search and get notified when new inventory arrives.
Contact seller
Customize your budget
*Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.
**Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.
About your privacy: Cars.com is asking for your ZIP and credit rating because it helps us to make an educated guess at your sales tax and loan interest. These two factors can greatly change your monthly payment.
Used
cars
for sale
near
Bay Shore, NY
- Down Payment
- $0
- Net trade-in value
- $0
- Months
- 72
- APR
- 7.0%
- Sales tax
- 0.0%
*Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.
**Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.






Volvo Certified
2025 Volvo XC90 B5 Plus






Volvo Certified
2025 Volvo XC60 B5 Core






Used
2022 Kia Sorento SX
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Their ratings are high because it is definitely well
Their ratings are high because it is definitely well deserved usually I would be skeptic thinking it would be many fake reviews but after our own experience at Hillside Toyota their reviews are truly legit!!! Their cars, trucks are amazing. Their customer service especially the one who helped us whose name is Valentina is excellent, professional, helpful and she is so cool. Any questions we had was answered. Anything we did not understand she went beyond to help us from beginning to end. Definitely ask for her for above and beyond service and assistance. On top of that first day got some awesome yummy popcorn and the last day bagels and coffee. We are new to the new technologies in our truck and she explained everything and even set up everything for us. Thank you Valentina and Hillside Toyota.
Very happy with our purchase!
Very happy with our purchase! It's got lots of power & very comfortable. With 2nd row folded down we can get 24 bags of groceries in it. Seats are comfortable & my husband who's 6'6" has plenty of leg room. Now I understand why I see so many Kias on the road!!! It's a joy to drive!






Used
2022 Volkswagen Atlas 3.6L SE w/Technology
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
I purchased my 2022 Kia Sorrento Hybrid last week.
I purchased my 2022 Kia Sorrento Hybrid last week. Karol Sanchez was my sales person and I can't begin to tell you how incredibly nice she was. She was very informative about the car we purchased and answered all of our questions without being pushy. She never made us feel rushed even when we were asking questions about different cars on the lot. Karol was instrumental in us deciding to purchase that day. Lawrence in finance was very helpful as well. Will definitely be returning their for our next family care.
At Last my ATLAS has come along!
Great car! Overpaid a bit; but, bought top of the line with only 23k miles. Loved it and didn't want to dicker over price. Rudes well. Acceleration is good. Roomy, spacious passenger cabin and cargo bay. Amazing technology. I recommend this vehicle highly. Take a serious look at this one. You wont be disappointed.






BMW Certified
2023 BMW X3 xDrive30i
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Go to BMW of Freeport...
Our experience at BMW of Freeport was great! We are first time customers and our experience couldn't have been better! Marleny was wonderful! She was with us through the process from inquiring about our car until we drove off the lot! She knows her vehicles! Everyone at BMW Freeport made this an enjoyable experience. I would recommend Marleny and BMW of Freeport!






Used
2024 Lexus RX 350 F SPORT Handling
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Technically
The technician was very helpful( Max) easy to talk to and was very Polite make our transaction easy and quickly and mannerly will go again to him for assistance
Just picked up 2024 RX350 Premium+.
Just picked up 2024 RX350 Premium+. Overall a nice car. I’m not a big fan of the 4 cyl. Powertrain however. Rather noisy and fuel economy is about the same as the 6 cyl. In my old 2019 RX with premium fuel required. Not a great trade off. New technology is pretty good and touch screen is much. Etter than the old RX touch pad. I think this is a better value than BMW X5 or Genesis GV80 with much better resale value.






Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Excellent dealership experience—helpful, patient
Excellent dealership experience—helpful, patient knowledgeable staff, no pressure, and willing to work a deal!
I got the 2025 Subaru Forester Touring.
I got the 2025 Subaru Forester Touring. I stayed with Subaru because I loved my 2017 Touring. I'm familiar with the layout. Hybrid was not available, but I heard the battery cuts into the cargo space.






Used
2025 MINI Countryman Cooper S ALL4
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Mini of Fairfield for the WIN
Mini of Fairfield provided one of the best car shopping experiences I ever had. I'm grateful to have met Fabrizio and Joy since they made the experience fun, educational and effortless.
I have had my Countryman S for about 7 months and 2000
I have had my Countryman S for about 7 months and 2000 miles (I have two other cars). It’s Chili Red with Petrol Blue interior. My favorite points are 1. The interior. If you love interesting fun interiors as I do then you will love it. If you try to avoid black interiors and exteriors you eliminate 90% of the cars other make. With Mini, you can get perhaps the most fun interiors anywhere and the Vescin seems comfortable enough. Just with they had ventilated seats. 2. Power, FINALLY Mini got a full BMW tune given you pay about the same price. It is plenty quick and I get 33-36mpg on the highway all the time. Drops much lower zooming around town. 3. Appearance and layout. I like the unique appearance, low roof line for kayaks and plenty of room for the kind of car it is. Negatives: 1. Electronics. Had several updates since I bought it and it has improved a lot but will take some getting used to. Use the favorites menu. Everything is pretty much forced onto the center screen. Sometimes Mini does things to be cute rather than practical. Rather than a start button it uses a flag toggle key you turn off and on like an old fashioned key. If you have to change cars like I do it’s confusing. 2. Center console. Basically, there is not one. There’s a little clam shaped compartment the size of a clutch purse. The armrest doesn’t open. Wasted potential. You will hate this if you are used to piling layers of stuff in a huge center console. Glove box is minimal, too. Neutral. 1. There’s no screen behind the wheel but there is a heads up display. Frankly, after awhile I don’t miss it at all. The heads up is excellent but it takes a little getting used to. 2. Suspension is a bit stiff like all Mini’s. Makes it sporty but trade off is feeling most road imperfections. It does take the top off bumps well but it’s a trade off. In summary, the reliability has been good AFTER the electronics updates and most things work well. It is just so fun to drive and look at inside and out that really I am not sure what I’d rather drive. You might cross shop the BMW X1 and see which works better for you. You cannot beat Mini interiors though for just pure fun and the driving matches on what is a practical Mini for a family. Oh, I got it to tow a camper but I have yet to do that. That is a great new addition in my book. I will probably get a kayak trailer.






BMW Certified
2023 BMW X3 xDrive30i
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
A pleasure to deal with .
A pleasure to deal with . Walked in saw the exact car in the color and style I wanted in the showroom. Met with my salesman and set up the financing and purchase . No silly games . Everything was straight forward and easy . Went back a few hours later and met with the wonderful finance person and drove home in exactly the BMW I wanted . What more can anyone ask for !!






BMW Certified
2023 BMW X3 xDrive30i
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Audra is the best everything went smooth one of the best
Audra is the best everything went smooth one of the best leasing experiences, Couldn’t have asked for a better experience, very professional






Used
2025 MINI Countryman Cooper S ALL4
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
I"ll Never Trust My Car to Anyone Else
I've been taking my car to the Mini Dealership since I purchased it. I've always been treated with kindness, respect, and the job is always well done. I've heard horror stories about people dealing with the dealership and with Mini of Fairfield County, that couldn't be furthest from the truth. I feel that my car is always in good hands and I'm always satisfied with the work. They always go above and beyond and I can't recommend them enough to anyone looking to purchase a Mini. I've recommended this dealership to friends as a result of the customer service I've received.






Used
2024 Hyundai PALISADE Limited
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Rob and Joe were amazing and the car was in perfect
Rob and Joe were amazing and the car was in perfect condition. I drive 3.5 hours and they were very courteous and professional.
I have had the car for almost three months.
I have had the car for almost three months. I used it when my son’s family and others visited so I often used every seat. I have a Limited Trim with a tow hitch. I got the car for visiting family and also to be able to tow a small to medium sized camper. I have owned many Mercedes, BMW’s, Mini’s and other brands and this is the most luxurious. It is as good or better than the German cars on equipment and comfort, just not as fast. Ventilated seats, three rows of power and heated seats and all the tech you can want, which I love. My favorite is the amazing lane keep assist which practically drives the car by itself and the 360 camera for parking and not hitting things. Try to price a Mercedes or BMW 3-row with the same features and you will be at least $85-90k if not more. You could buy his and hers Palisades for the same money, the Calligraphy even has the massage seats. The car is quiet, smooth and absolutely gorgeous interior. I can afford most any car I want and I personally love the value proposition of this car and the low maintenance costs. The car plays a musical tune every time you close the door like a welcome. All my camping gear fits into the back with room to spare (and third row down). The only quirk is the rain sensing wipers do not seem too sensitive. I don’t mind no wireless Car Play as a plugged in phone stays charged. Once I tow with it I will write another review but if you want this feature know it comes with a hitch, ball, prewired with the wire kit for trailer brakes and a tow mode! That’s pretty cool. Full sized spare, too. If you want luxury, space, lots of seats and good towing capacity run and get one. You don’t need to shop the competition unless it’s the Telluride. I got a great year end deal on mine, too. Hyundai is improving its vehicles every single year. I have had three now (Kona, Tucson and Palisade) and they have all been great. Oh, I have gotten up to 26mpg on the highway but most the time my mileage is exactly like the ratings. As low as teens in the city doing errands. Not bad for a two ton car.






Kia Certified
2022 Kia Telluride SX
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Took my car in for service and was helped by Eric at the
Took my car in for service and was helped by Eric at the service desk. He helped me with what I needed done and kept me updated as work proceeded. Offered me coffee and bagels. Service was completed in less than an hour. Nice experience.
If you want a comfortable, stylish, and affordable suv
If you want a comfortable, stylish, and affordable suv for your family this is the car for you. Makes me feel proud when driving it and holds its own compared to other luxury suvs that cost a lot more. My only complaints are that it’s a gas guzzler and at this price point all models should come with the digital speedometer dashboard and not just the highest trim levels.






Jeep Certified
2022 Jeep Grand Cherokee Laredo
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
I think they were all fantastic, in the fantastic way
I think they were all fantastic, in the fantastic way they treated you stood out you couldn't help but notice, the only thing that was wrong was that the Jeep renegade was just so far away that I wouldn't be able to afford the fee to get it delivered to me
My opinion of 2022 Jeep Grand Cherokee
This is my first Jeep I have ever owned. I always liked the looks of the Grand Cherokee. I’m happy with the vehicle. No complaints except it does like to drink gasoline. My previous 4 vehicles were all 8 cylinder full size pickup trucks. The Jeep being a 6 cylinder eats more gas. The Other than that, I’m very happy with my purchase of my 2022 Jeep Grand Cherokee. Good looks, drives well, comfortable and safe.






Subaru Certified
2022 Subaru Forester Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Employees are all, attentive, helpful, friendly and
Employees are all, attentive, helpful, friendly and cordial. Customer service is great! Mechanics all well trained and experienced. Waiting time is reasonable I Highly recommend
Beyond Satisfied!
This is my third Subaru Forrester. I like the newer safety features and ease of handling. The size is perfect for me, not too small or too big! I would recommend if you’re looking for a midsize vehicle.






Used
2025 Nissan Altima SR
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Project Manager
Came in to purchase a new car after 12 years and the team at Jeep Chrysler Dodge City was very attentive, not pushy and very informed. Christina Granchelli provided a stress free car buying experience. She was especially helpful the day i picked up my Cherokee and was well informed on all the features. Would definitely recommend this dealership.
Surprising power on the highway.
Surprising power on the highway. Great gas mileage. Very roomy interior, and the dash and radio buttons and components are very easy to see and use. We chose this over an Accord, initially because the local Honda dealer is crazy, but we like everything about it.






Used
2018 Volkswagen Atlas 3.6L SE
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Vehicle was sold before I was able to speak to a sales
Vehicle was sold before I was able to speak to a sales person. No problem! They were working on it before I inquired about it.
Black beauty
I have had my Altas for over 4 years and I keep on falling in love with it each and very day. Extremely comfortable space and overall a perfect size SUV for a family of 5. We have had and continue to have amazing long road trips with this beauty and we will carry the memories we continue to make in our heart for the rest of our lives.






Used
2022 Audi Q5 45 S line Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
I had a fantastic experience at Audi Great Neck, thanks
I had a fantastic experience at Audi Great Neck, thanks to Kit! He was incredibly knowledgeable and made the entire process easy. The only problem I had was selecting the car I wanted because the dealership has a huge and possibly the best selection of pre-owned vehicles, and Kit went above and beyond to help me find the perfect fit. At the end of the purchase, I got to meet Ali, one of the directors at the dealership. Ali was very professional and ensured me that if I had any issues, he would see to it that all my issues are resolved. I Highly recommend Audi Great Neck for anyone looking for a car!
Luxury Performance
The black 2022 Audi Q5 is great looking and has amazing performance! My only complaint would be I've had a couple of small problems you wouldn't expect from a brand new car! I.e.- Rear hatch doesn't close all the way sometimes & pops up. It stays closed but not tight and the dash light comes on, tire pressure doesn't consistently stay the same?(No idea why but definitely unusual)






Used
2020 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 High Country
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
I recently had a wonderful experience at Mazda 112.
I recently had a wonderful experience at Mazda 112. My sales person Bonnie was amazing. Bonnie was extremely knowledgeable, friendly, professional and helpful. She answered all my questions, listened to what I needed and wanted, and put me in the perfect vehicle!
I have a 2020 1500 RST with the 5.
I have a 2020 1500 RST with the 5.3 engine and 8 speed transmission. My truck now has 67,000 miles. The acceleration is outstanding and smooth from gears 3-8. Probably could use more torque for gears 1-2, but not weak by any means. I have had no mechanical problems outside of the clunking rear suspension which was fixed by retorqueing the rear leaf spring suspension bolts. Other than that minor issue, it has been very reliable. I have heard these transmissions have had issues, but nothing that has caused issues for me. It has the 60-70 MPH shutter that is common to these transmissions, but I have learned how to drive to avoid the shutter, as I did with my 2011 1500. Overall pretty satisfied at this point. Comfort and amenities could be better for the front seats for the price, but I bought it knowing that. FYI my front brakes at this point are still 50%, and I have invested very little outside of a few fluid exchanges and routine maintenance. Excellent fuel mileage: 20 mpg with 50% highway vs city driving.






Used
2022 Volkswagen Atlas 3.6L SE w/Technology
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Good for older people
My Grandmother loves her new Atlas 2.0T, its also easy to get in and out of for Her and Gramps, and great mpg with the 2.0T, and power is very plenty for a tiny engine






Used
2022 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 Custom
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
They did the most possible deal and more for me.
They did the most possible deal and more for me. Kevin and manager are so nice and want the best for me. I love the delealership.
very good truck it is the best car i jave bought since my
very good truck it is the best car i jave bought since my opd one was broken this help me alot and thanks for seeing this






Jeep Certified
2023 Jeep Grand Cherokee Laredo
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Excellent!
Excellent! Everybody here was honest helpful and transparent. I definitely recommend buying a used vehicle from them.
Natural upgrade choice
Runs smooth. Very comfortable. Always loved the Jeep brand so this was a natural upgrade. Love the options too. The adaptive cruise control is amazing.
*Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.
**Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.
Private seller in Bay Shore, NY
Used cars by city
-
Used cars in Brightwaters, NY
3938 Great Deals out of 15055 listings starting at $800
-
Used cars in West Bay Shore, NY
3931 Great Deals out of 15069 listings starting at $800
-
Used cars in North Bay Shore, NY
4050 Great Deals out of 15476 listings starting at $800
-
Used cars in Baywood, NY
4444 Great Deals out of 16390 listings starting at $800
-
Used cars in West Islip, NY
4045 Great Deals out of 15493 listings starting at $800
-
Used cars in Islip, NY
3563 Great Deals out of 13350 listings starting at $800
-
Used cars in East Islip, NY
3508 Great Deals out of 13181 listings starting at $800
-
Used cars in Islip Terrace, NY
3593 Great Deals out of 13559 listings starting at $800
-
Used cars in Brentwood, NY
4086 Great Deals out of 15581 listings starting at $800
-
Used cars in North Babylon, NY
4567 Great Deals out of 16778 listings starting at $800
-
Used cars in Deer Park, NY
4610 Great Deals out of 16926 listings starting at $800
-
Used cars in Central Islip, NY
3859 Great Deals out of 14711 listings starting at $800
Cars in Bay Shore, NY by make
-
BMW in Bay Shore, NY
411 Great Deals out of 1481 listings starting at $4,300
-
Mercedes-Benz in Bay Shore, NY
421 Great Deals out of 1167 listings starting at $3,000
-
Honda in Bay Shore, NY
235 Great Deals out of 1116 listings starting at $2,200
-
Toyota in Bay Shore, NY
156 Great Deals out of 1085 listings starting at $2,000
-
Jeep in Bay Shore, NY
291 Great Deals out of 1022 listings starting at $2,812
-
Ford in Bay Shore, NY
234 Great Deals out of 907 listings starting at $3,750
-
Chevrolet in Bay Shore, NY
312 Great Deals out of 864 listings starting at $800
-
Nissan in Bay Shore, NY
208 Great Deals out of 789 listings starting at $3,000
-
Hyundai in Bay Shore, NY
146 Great Deals out of 541 listings starting at $2,999
-
Subaru in Bay Shore, NY
81 Great Deals out of 442 listings starting at $6,500
-
RAM in Bay Shore, NY
127 Great Deals out of 434 listings starting at $7,995
-
Dodge in Bay Shore, NY
138 Great Deals out of 418 listings starting at $2,999
-
Audi in Bay Shore, NY
131 Great Deals out of 401 listings starting at $4,400
-
Porsche in Bay Shore, NY
127 Great Deals out of 399 listings starting at $6,695
-
Lexus in Bay Shore, NY
45 Great Deals out of 381 listings starting at $6,300
-
Kia in Bay Shore, NY
113 Great Deals out of 356 listings starting at $2,900
-
Acura in Bay Shore, NY
91 Great Deals out of 313 listings starting at $4,500
-
Volkswagen in Bay Shore, NY
53 Great Deals out of 304 listings starting at $5,500
-
Volvo in Bay Shore, NY
58 Great Deals out of 250 listings starting at $4,297
-
Cadillac in Bay Shore, NY
48 Great Deals out of 231 listings starting at $4,200
-
GMC in Bay Shore, NY
50 Great Deals out of 224 listings starting at $6,750
-
Mazda in Bay Shore, NY
50 Great Deals out of 211 listings starting at $2,600
-
MINI in Bay Shore, NY
44 Great Deals out of 174 listings starting at $5,985
-
Land Rover in Bay Shore, NY
62 Great Deals out of 164 listings starting at $6,995
-
Lincoln in Bay Shore, NY
31 Great Deals out of 147 listings starting at $6,985
-
Genesis in Bay Shore, NY
41 Great Deals out of 135 listings starting at $12,977
-
INFINITI in Bay Shore, NY
45 Great Deals out of 132 listings starting at $2,777
-
Ferrari in Bay Shore, NY
1 Great Deal out of 81 listings starting at $92,900
-
Tesla in Bay Shore, NY
40 Great Deals out of 80 listings starting at $14,995
-
Maserati in Bay Shore, NY
13 Great Deals out of 73 listings starting at $17,445
-
Alfa Romeo in Bay Shore, NY
19 Great Deals out of 61 listings starting at $13,995
-
Buick in Bay Shore, NY
20 Great Deals out of 61 listings starting at $9,295
-
Chrysler in Bay Shore, NY
13 Great Deals out of 51 listings starting at $3,995
-
Bentley in Bay Shore, NY
9 Great Deals out of 46 listings starting at $26,900
-
Mitsubishi in Bay Shore, NY
9 Great Deals out of 44 listings starting at $5,495
-
Jaguar in Bay Shore, NY
7 Great Deals out of 29 listings starting at $5,500
-
Aston Martin in Bay Shore, NY
4 Great Deals out of 26 listings starting at $59,900
-
McLaren in Bay Shore, NY
3 Great Deals out of 24 listings starting at $114,999
Find great prices on used cars in Bay Shore, NY
- Used cars for sale under $4,000
- Used cars for sale under $5,000
- Used cars for sale under $6,000
- Used cars for sale under $7,000
- Used cars for sale under $8,000
- Used cars for sale under $9,000
- Used cars for sale under $10,000
- Used cars for sale under $15,000
- Used cars for sale under $20,000
- Used cars for sale under $25,000
- Used cars for sale under $30,000
- Used cars for sale under $40,000
- Used cars for sale under $50,000
- Used cars for sale under $100,000
Fuel types in Bay Shore, NY
-
Hybrid cars in Bay Shore, NY
8655 Great Deals out of 177066 listings
-
Electric cars in Bay Shore, NY
7100 Great Deals out of 98677 listings
Dealer inventory in Bay Shore, NY
-
Mazda 112
32 Great Deals out of 866 listings starting at $14,999
-
Hillside Toyota
13 Great Deals out of 747 listings starting at $9,797
-
Atlantic Chevrolet Cadillac
51 Great Deals out of 695 listings starting at $8,850
-
Habberstad BMW of Huntington
32 Great Deals out of 659 listings starting at $10,876
-
Lexus of Freeport
8 Great Deals out of 636 listings starting at $15,000
-
Nissan 112
83 Great Deals out of 633 listings starting at $12,495
-
Advantage Hyundai
21 Great Deals out of 609 listings starting at $9,885
-
BMW of Freeport
30 Great Deals out of 546 listings starting at $15,998
-
Hillside Honda
21 Great Deals out of 483 listings starting at $6,729
-
Legend Nissan
26 Great Deals out of 455 listings starting at $7,669
-
King O'Rourke Auto Group
9 Great Deals out of 451 listings starting at $18,995
-
Mercedes-Benz of Massapequa
27 Great Deals out of 446 listings starting at $17,000
Body styles in Bay Shore, NY
- ${price_badge()}
- ${ami_badge()}
- ${battery_badge()}${ev_report_link()}
- ${hot_car_badge()}
- ${award_badge()}
- ${cpo_badge()}
${price_badge_description}
${ami_badge_description}
The EV Battery Rating is based on this vehicle's current expected range relative to the vehicles expected range when new. ${battery_badge_text}
This vehicle is certified pre-owned, backed by a manufacturer warranty, and typically undergoes a rigorous multi-point inspection to ensure quality and reliability.
This vehicle is currently in high demand given its competitive price, desirable features, and overall condition, and may have a higher chance of selling quickly.