Skip to main content

Casey Toyota

(422 reviews)
Visit Casey Toyota
Sales hours: 9:00am to 8:00pm
Service hours: 7:00am to 6:00pm
View all hours
Sales Service
Monday 9:00am–8:00pm 7:00am–6:00pm
Tuesday 9:00am–8:00pm 7:00am–6:00pm
Wednesday 9:00am–8:00pm 7:00am–6:00pm
Thursday 9:00am–8:00pm 7:00am–6:00pm
Friday 9:00am–8:00pm 7:00am–6:00pm
Saturday 9:00am–6:00pm 8:00am–5:30pm
Sunday 12:00pm–5:00pm Closed
2015 consumer dealer award
View 1 awards
2015 consumer dealer award

Contact seller

Select a Salesperson (optional)

Contact seller

By clicking here, you authorize Cars.com and its sellers/partners to contact you by text/calls which may include marketing and be by autodialer. Calls may be prerecorded. You also agree to our Privacy Notice. Consent is not required to purchase goods/services.

We value your privacy. Cars.com Privacy Notice

New (877) 468-2570 (877) 468-2570
Used (877) 468-4151 (877) 468-4151
Service (877) 468-5751 (877) 468-5751

Inventory

See all 138 vehicles from this dealership.

About our dealership

This seller has been on Cars.com since January 2012.
Casey Toyota Scion is located in beautiful Williamsburg. We provide new and pre-owned sales of all makes and models including Certified Toyotas & Scions and our service and parts departments offer monthly Toyota discounts. Visit us to view and test drive your next Toyota or Scion. At Casey Toyota Scion we strive to make buying or leasing your next new or used vehicle a pleasant and rewarding experience! Plus we offer the Casey Carefree Guarantee - a warranty on every pre-owned vehicle! You can trust Casey...family owned and operated since 1958.
Trust the name you know! Visit Casey Toyota in Williamsburg for a new or Certified Toyota!

Service center

Phone number (877) 468-5751

Service hours

Monday
7:00am–6:00pm
Tuesday
7:00am–6:00pm
Wednesday
7:00am–6:00pm
Thursday
7:00am–6:00pm
Friday
7:00am–6:00pm
Saturday
8:00am–5:30pm
Sunday
Closed

Meet our employees

Reviews

(422 reviews)

A dealership's rating is based on all of their reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews. Includes reviews of Casey Toyota from DealerRater.

Want to share your experience with this dealership?

Write a review

Bought a used car for my daughter. When signing, nothing was explained and then when we received all the information on a thumb drive instead of printed out and put in a folder, we find an extra 3500 in which we didn’t agree to that was added to the loan. We were told that we had to pick up the plates at the dealership and we then received a voicemail stating I had to contact the bank to get information on how to pay the car payment. This is all ridiculous, I’ve bought plenty of cars and I’ve never had to do most the work or received a “ thumb drive” instead of actual paperwork. Also, we only received 1 key for the car. Don’t go here these aren’t not professionals.

Bought a used car for my daughter. When signing, nothing was explained and then when we received all the information on a thumb drive instead of printed out and put in a folder, we find an extra 3500 in which we didn’t agree to that was added to the loan. We were told that we had to pick up the plates at the dealership and we then received a voicemail stating I had to contact the bank to get information on how to pay the car payment. This is all ridiculous, I’ve bought plenty of cars and I’ve never had to do most the work or received a “ thumb drive” instead of actual paperwork. Also, we only received 1 key for the car. Don’t go here these aren’t not professionals.

Rating breakdown (out of 5):
Customer service
Buying process
Quality of repair
Overall facilities
Overall experience
3.0
  • Does not recommend this dealer
  • Shopped for a used car
Worked with:
0 people out of 0 found this review helpful.
Show full review

DO NOT COME TO THIS CASEY TOYOTA AND BUY ANY VEHICLE ESPECIALLY FROM JOHN OGDEN!!!! This Casey Toyota has been nothing but a hassle for stuff that shouldn't happen. We first came in and bought a 2019 toyota tundra, great looking truck for a used one, also paid for heated seats and was told we'll receive a call the next day to to have the heated seats installed, nobody called and after 2 days of waiting we had to call, and get the appointment scheduled, the appointment was setup for the heated seats for Thursday 09/26 but when i show up, not only did they not even order the heated seats but our sales guy John Ogden dropped the ball and never got with the installer which he wasnt even here because he came the day before on 09/25, so we have to schedule ANOTHER APPOINTMENT and waste more gas and time and hopefully theyll have everything ready. had a small chip in the glass called and scheduled a repair and got a appointment setup for Tuesday but nobody decided to tell us the repair guy only comes on Thursday so we wasted gas just driving up there for them to look at the chip and say "yup you'll have to bring it back Thursday" go to another place and buy a car, even facebook marketplace!!!!

DO NOT COME TO THIS CASEY TOYOTA AND BUY ANY VEHICLE ESPECIALLY FROM JOHN OGDEN!!!! This Casey Toyota has been nothing but a hassle for stuff that shouldn't happen. We first came in and bought a 2019 toyota tundra, great looking truck for a used one, also paid for heated seats and was told we'll receive a call the next day to to have the heated seats installed, nobody called and after 2 days of waiting we had to call, and get the appointment scheduled, the appointment was setup for the heated seats for Thursday 09/26 but when i show up, not only did they not even order the heated seats but our sales guy John Ogden dropped the ball and never got with the installer which he wasnt even here because he came the day before on 09/25, so we have to schedule ANOTHER APPOINTMENT and waste more gas and time and hopefully theyll have everything ready. had a small chip in the glass called and scheduled a repair and got a appointment setup for Tuesday but nobody decided to tell us the repair guy only comes on Thursday so we wasted gas just driving up there for them to look at the chip and say "yup you'll have to bring it back Thursday" go to another place and buy a car, even facebook marketplace!!!!

Rating breakdown (out of 5):
Customer service
Buying process
Quality of repair
Overall facilities
Overall experience
1.0
  • Does not recommend this dealer
  • Shopped for a used car
Worked with:
0 people out of 0 found this review helpful.
Dealer response

Nicholas, we're truly sorry to hear about the inconvenience you experienced with your recent purchase at Casey Toyota. We understand your frustration and we apologize for the issues you encountered. I understand we now have a date scheduled for the install. Please let me know should you need us to pick up and deliver back. Please feel free to reach out to us via text or call so we can assist you further. Best, Mark Shebelski, GM

Show full review

Ashley gave phenomenal customer service. She updated me on everything that was going on while my Volkswagon Gulf 2018 was being serviced on. While waiting, I watched as she interacted with each customer that came to her counter & her personality was just superb the way she handled each & every one. Give that woman a raise because we need more people like her.

Ashley gave phenomenal customer service. She updated me on everything that was going on while my Volkswagon Gulf 2018 was being serviced on. While waiting, I watched as she interacted with each customer that came to her counter & her personality was just superb the way she handled each & every one. Give that woman a raise because we need more people like her.

Rating breakdown (out of 5):
Customer service
Buying process
Quality of repair
Overall facilities
Overall experience
5.0
  • Does recommend this dealer
  • Came in for service or repair
Worked with:
0 people out of 0 found this review helpful.
Dealer response

phutchinson10028, Thank you for the 5 Star review! We are honored to serve you. Thank you, Mark Shebelski, GM

Show full review

Ashley explained all the work that needed to be done on my 2020 Tacoma in detail

Ashley explained all the work that needed to be done on my 2020 Tacoma in detail

Rating breakdown (out of 5):
Customer service
Buying process
Quality of repair
Overall facilities
Overall experience
5.0
  • Does recommend this dealer
  • Came in for service or repair
0 people out of 0 found this review helpful.
Dealer response

Thank you for the 5 Star review! We are honored to serve you. Thank you, Mark Shebelski, GM

Show full review

Playing efficient knowledgeable and short wait period, what do business with them again thank you

Playing efficient knowledgeable and short wait period, what do business with them again thank you

Rating breakdown (out of 5):
Customer service
Buying process
Quality of repair
Overall facilities
Overall experience
5.0
  • Does recommend this dealer
  • Shopped for a used car
0 people out of 0 found this review helpful.
Dealer response

edwin.anderson67, thank you for the 5 Star review! We appreciate your business! Honored we were able to serve you again. Best, Mark Shebelski, GM

Show full review

Markis and Casey Toyota are the absolute best. I am a repeat customer with Casey, but specifically for Markis. He’s made every transaction a joy and we always reach an agreement that all parties are very happy with. I will continue seeking out Markis for any future vehicle purchases!

Markis and Casey Toyota are the absolute best. I am a repeat customer with Casey, but specifically for Markis. He’s made every transaction a joy and we always reach an agreement that all parties are very happy with. I will continue seeking out Markis for any future vehicle purchases!

Rating breakdown (out of 5):
Customer service
Buying process
Quality of repair
Overall facilities
Overall experience
5.0
  • Does recommend this dealer
  • Shopped for a new car
Worked with:
0 people out of 0 found this review helpful.
Dealer response

Carl9, Thank you for the 5 Star review. We appreciate that Markis has taken such good care of you. We look forward to a long relationship! Best, Mark Shebelski, GM

Show full review

I named my car Koop after Eric Wynkoop! I had an outstanding experience at Casey Toyota in Williamsburg with Eric. I bought my car within 2 days of meeting Eric. Eric helped me find the perfect white Toyota RAV4. Eric was so kind to drive the car up to me from VA to NC. I would recommend anyone looking to buy a car to hit up Eric! He will find you just what you are looking for. An incredible salesman, but an even more incredible man. He loves Jesus too! 10/10 for Eric!

I named my car Koop after Eric Wynkoop! I had an outstanding experience at Casey Toyota in Williamsburg with Eric. I bought my car within 2 days of meeting Eric. Eric helped me find the perfect white Toyota RAV4. Eric was so kind to drive the car up to me from VA to NC. I would recommend anyone looking to buy a car to hit up Eric! He will find you just what you are looking for. An incredible salesman, but an even more incredible man. He loves Jesus too! 10/10 for Eric!

Rating breakdown (out of 5):
Customer service
Buying process
Quality of repair
Overall facilities
Overall experience
5.0
  • Does recommend this dealer
  • Shopped for a used car
Worked with:
0 people out of 0 found this review helpful.
Dealer response

Thank you for choosing Casey Toyota and sharing your amazing experience with Eric! We appreciate your recommendation and are delighted to hear about the exceptional service you received. Best, Mark Shebelski, GM

Show full review

Rude service people. Damaged/removed a college sticker from wind shield. No feedback on service.

Rude service people. Damaged/removed a college sticker from wind shield. No feedback on service.

Rating breakdown (out of 5):
Customer service
Buying process
Quality of repair
Overall facilities
Overall experience
1.0
  • Does not recommend this dealer
  • Came in for service or repair
0 people out of 0 found this review helpful.
Dealer response

Thank you for the review. We apologize for your experience here at Casey Toyota. Please feel free to reach out so we can discuss further. Thank you, Mark Shebelski, GM

Show full review

I would not recommend this place and will not be returning. I was a customer of theirs for about 3 years, and over the course of that 3 years service continued to deteriorate. The nail in the coffin was my last interaction with a sales manager who was extremely disrespectful to us over the phone. I have never been spoken to that way by anyone, let alone a person in sales and was truly shocked. He continuously interrupted us, talked over us, and yelled at us as we tried to calmly discuss the status of my car, and explain to him what his employee had apparently not filled him in on. Despite our complaints to Casey upper management and Toyota, this person appears to still work here (via the website). My advice is to tread carefully.

I would not recommend this place and will not be returning. I was a customer of theirs for about 3 years, and over the course of that 3 years service continued to deteriorate. The nail in the coffin was my last interaction with a sales manager who was extremely disrespectful to us over the phone. I have never been spoken to that way by anyone, let alone a person in sales and was truly shocked. He continuously interrupted us, talked over us, and yelled at us as we tried to calmly discuss the status of my car, and explain to him what his employee had apparently not filled him in on. Despite our complaints to Casey upper management and Toyota, this person appears to still work here (via the website). My advice is to tread carefully.

Rating breakdown (out of 5):
Customer service
Buying process
Quality of repair
Overall facilities
Overall experience
3.0
  • Does not recommend this dealer
  • Shopped for a new car
Worked with:
0 people out of 0 found this review helpful.
Dealer response

We apologize for the negative experience you had with our sales manager. We understand how important respectful and attentive customer service is, and we apologize for any frustration or shock caused by this interaction. We take your feedback seriously and will address this matter internally. Please feel free to reach out to us via text or call so we can further assist you. Best, Mark Shebelski, GM

Show full review

Contacted to ensure the car we wanted to look at was on the lot. Told it was so we drove over 1 hr to see the vehicle (even had an appt). Got there and our name was on the board for appts but they seemed confused as to what we wanted. Then we were told the car was sold 4 days before. Given some crap story that internet sales people don’t always know what is on the lot. We didn’t contact internet sales. I spoke directly to a sales person (allegedly). Overall not a good feeling that they even know what cars they have. Sorry…cannot recommend since there are so many other dealers around.

Contacted to ensure the car we wanted to look at was on the lot. Told it was so we drove over 1 hr to see the vehicle (even had an appt). Got there and our name was on the board for appts but they seemed confused as to what we wanted. Then we were told the car was sold 4 days before. Given some crap story that internet sales people don’t always know what is on the lot. We didn’t contact internet sales. I spoke directly to a sales person (allegedly). Overall not a good feeling that they even know what cars they have. Sorry…cannot recommend since there are so many other dealers around.

Rating breakdown (out of 5):
Customer service
Buying process
Quality of repair
Overall facilities
Overall experience
2.0
  • Does not recommend this dealer
  • Shopped for a new car
Worked with:
0 people out of 0 found this review helpful.
Dealer response

Not happy, thank you for the review and I apologize for the poor treatment received. Please feel free to reach out to me to discuss further. Thank you, Mark Shebelski, GM

Show full review
See all 422 reviews