I came in knowing that I wanted to buy a used Crosstrek. I originally came in to purchase a 2013 model with lots of miles, but got second thoughts after I test drove it. Shawn was very helpful, and showed me a newer model that rode a lot better. I was not pressured to make a day-of decision, and they didn't try to pressure me by phone afterwards. I ended up calling 4 days later to purchase the newer car. Shawn was very friendly and made the process very straightforward. While Maguire will not negotiate down the sticker price of used cars, I got a good deal on the warranty. I was expecting that I'd have to go to Syracuse or Rochester to find a good deal, but I ended up getting a good deal here in Ithaca.

never ending radio PROBLEMS since NEW-- 16 months

by FED UP from SASKATOON-SASKATCHEWAN-CANADA-

March 11, 2019

I've had my 2018 crosstrek sport eyesight for 16 months so far--- on my THIRD RADIO so far--- AND 10 other VISITS to dealership for UPDATES, UPGRADES, REPROGRAMMING, etc--- thinking of seeing a LAWYER to SUE subaru for a FULL REFUND ---THAT way they can keep GUESSING ON THIER ON TIME, NOT MINE ANYMORE--NASA can send a spaceship FASTER to the SPACESTATION than subaru can fix their RADIO PROBLEMS--- E M B A R R A S I N G

Used

$25,699 34,494 mi.

2019 Subaru Crosstrek 2.0i Limited

Good Deal

LOCAL HOME DELIVERY

VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS

Ext. Color: Silver
Int. Color: Black
Transmission: CVT
Drivetrain: AWD

Save

Compare

CARFAX Report

Maguire Hyundai Subaru

Authorized Subaru Dealer

Check Availability

Call

See more details

Just bought a Subaru

by Casey from Freeville, NY

November 5, 2018

4.8 (169 reviews)

I was helped by Jon-Michael Ottenschot today, and the experience was easy (although lengthy--paperwork processing took a while, not his fault). Knowledgeable, friendly, and helpful!

Favorite car ever!!!

by Kw2000 from Batesville , AR

May 16, 2019

It drives so smooth and the Interior is so sleek!! All my friends love my car! Big upgrade from the PT cruiser I used to have.

See all 21 photos

Used

$26,799 32,709 mi.

2019 Subaru Crosstrek 2.0i Limited

Good Deal

LOCAL HOME DELIVERY

VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS

Ext. Color: Orange
Int. Color: Gray
Transmission: CVT
Drivetrain: AWD

Save

Compare

CARFAX Report

Maguire Hyundai Subaru

Authorized Subaru Dealer

Check Availability

Call

See more details

Excellent experience buying a car at Maguire

by Suzanne from Ithaca, NY

November 5, 2018

4.8 (169 reviews)

We came looking for a specific set of features in a new car. We were greeted by John-Michael who spent a lot of time familiarizing us with the various features of the Subaru cars. He was patient and thorough in his process, and answered all our questions in good detail, finding out answers if he did not have them readily available. He had a warm and open approach and clearly knew a lot about the cars in the lot and the various features of each. We appreciated his sense of humor and quick wit. We had a test drive in a car that fit all our requirements and we were pleased to complete a purchase in a matter of only a few hours. The environment at the dealership was clean and friendly. It was all in all a very pleasant experience, even for people who are not crazy about automobile shopping. We appreciate Maguire and we appreciate John-Michael for helping us find just what we needed and wanted.

Love my Crosstrek

by Debi from New Hartford NY

May 16, 2019

Perfect size for me. Great handling and super safety features. Would like to have the car starter on the key remote. Maybe on my next one.

Used

$23,999 26,287 mi.

2018 Subaru Crosstrek 2.0i Limited

Good Deal

LOCAL HOME DELIVERY

VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS

Ext. Color: White
Int. Color: Black
Transmission: CVT
Drivetrain: AWD

Save

Compare

CARFAX Report

Maguire Ford Lincoln Nissan

Maguire Ford in Syracuse

by Sue S from North Syracuse, NY

November 6, 2018

4.6 (987 reviews)

I called Maguire to look at a vehicle that was at their Ithaca store, but I live in Syracuse and didn't want to travel to Ithaca. They happily brought it up to Syracuse the next day and I worked with Tom from Ithaca (sorry don't know his last name) and then completed the sale with Mike Bennett in Syracuse. Both guys were extremely friendly and helpful and no pressure to purchase anything I didn't want to. I think their pricing is really fair and friendly people, makes for a winning combo. Thanks for making this so easy!

My first Subaru

by Xtrek from Atlanta, GA

February 26, 2019

The safety features of this car have saved lives and thousand of dollars of accidental damage. Eyesight is amazing. The buying experience was great. The dealer we dealt with was one of the best I have ever visited.

Used

$19,888 47,488 mi.

2016 Subaru Crosstrek 2.0i Limited

Fair Price

HOT CAR

LOCAL HOME DELIVERY

VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS

Ext. Color: White
Int. Color: Black
Transmission: CVT
Drivetrain: AWD

Save

Compare

CARFAX Report

Maguire Automotive (Imports - Audi, VW, Volvo, Kia and Toyota)

Great service!

by Annie from Ithaca, NY

November 6, 2018

4.7 (2232 reviews)

Smart mechanics, timely turn around. I have a manual 98 jeep that is getting along in its life, and has suffered some wear and tear in the past few years. These guys always know exactly the issue I am facing when other mechanics are unsure. They have always been able to turn around the repair very quickly, with quality service, and their price point usually comes below their original quotes. I will miss this place when I leave Ithaca.

Disappointing Interior design

by Daphne from Newburgh, ny

March 6, 2019

I drive for my job. Door pockets aren't large enough or square to be useful. Center console is a C minus! I'm 5'5., must reach way back to lift storage cover. VERY BAD. there are 2 useless recesses in the center console --too shallow to hold a cell phone or pen -- what are they for? cup holders set too far back. and PS: never open the door if it's been Snowing!!! it all lands in the driver's seat. Obviously not designed by an outdoor team!

Used

Not Priced 28,269 mi.

2019 Subaru Crosstrek 2.0i Premium

LOCAL HOME DELIVERY

VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS

Ext. Color: White
Int. Color: Black
Transmission: CVT
Drivetrain: AWD

Save

Compare

CARFAX Report

Maguire Chevrolet Cadillac

It can't be this easy!

by HockeyLife! from Syracuse, New York

December 3, 2018

4.9 (539 reviews)

Bought a 2017 Chevy Cruze from Colby Newlen at Maguire Chevy & Cadillac. They didn't have the pre-owned car I wanted but were confident they could find one for me. A few days later I drove home in my Cruze and in the color I wanted. Didn't know a dealership would do that! Colby and his manager couldn't have made it any easier!!!

Best car I have ever owned. Everything I need

by SW from Dowagiac, MI

May 15, 2019

This car has everything I need & nothing I dont. Drive great. It has all the acceleration you need to get to speed on a highway or pass. No complaints here. First Subaru I have ever owned but won't be my last. The base model has all the technology & safety features need without all the extra nonsense that I dont need. By far the best car I have ever owned even better than my Malibu.

Used

Not Priced 29,894 mi.

2017 Subaru Crosstrek 2.0i

Ext. Color: Silver
Int. Color: Other
Transmission: Manual
Drivetrain: AWD

Save

Compare

CARFAX Report

Best small car in snow ....EVER!

by NL Hunter from Newfoundland

May 8, 2019

Got me home during the biggest snow storms of the year. People were even stuck in standard trucks and we still got through without any issues.

Used

Not Priced 36,122 mi.

2017 Subaru Crosstrek 2.0i Limited

Ext. Color: Red
Int. Color: Green
Transmission: CVT
Drivetrain: AWD

Save

Compare

CARFAX Report

Simons Rockwell dealership

by Debora Sue Bump from Addison, NY

December 3, 2018

4.5 (16 reviews)

Had a really great experience with our sales rep. (Brian Butler). Things seemed to have changed at Simons Rockwell compared to 10 years ago. Simons would’ve been my last choice to deal with, but this time, great service and pleased with my desk and Simons !

This is a GREAT car and the AWD is amazing! The w

by JaneC3 from Little Rock, AR

April 13, 2019

Love that this is a smaller SUV and great gas mileage but it also sits up high like a larger SUV. Can go off road but never have!

Used Subaru Crosstrek for Sale in Ithaca, NY

2018 Subaru Crosstrek 2.0i Premium

2019 Subaru Crosstrek 2.0i Limited

2019 Subaru Crosstrek 2.0i Limited

2018 Subaru Crosstrek 2.0i Limited

2016 Subaru Crosstrek 2.0i Limited

2019 Subaru Crosstrek 2.0i Premium

2017 Subaru Crosstrek 2.0i

2017 Subaru Crosstrek 2.0i Limited

Save Your Search

Search saved!

That's too many

You've reached your limit

Compare the Subaru Crosstrek to other Cars

Similar Cars

New Subaru Crosstrek By Year