Sort

Used Subaru Forester for Sale in Tillson, NY

See all 18 photos
Used
$15,500 58,674 mi.

2014 Subaru Forester 2.5i Touring

Good Deal
  • Ext. Color: Blue
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
All Motor Cars
() -
(845) 658-4453
3.8 (45 reviews)
0 mi. from 12486
Check Availability
Call
All Motor Cars Review
Best carexperience
by Hickoryofnewpaltz from new paltz ny
November 5, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 3.8 (45 reviews)
BEST car buying experience I have ever had. Its was my 3nd car purchase in my life and I have never felt so comfortable and calm than I did at the end of this experience . wanted to wait until the end of the whole experience to make a review just to make sure nothing hit the fan and ruined it, but nothing did! These guys run a great operation among a whole bunch of crap dealers out there. They are honest and truly want to help you find the best car and deal for you. Thank you for my first good car buying experience.
2014 Subaru Forester 2.5i Touring Review
Its not a 05 thats for sure
by Number 444 from Oswego New York
March 28, 2019
5
Not a big fan of 7" screens you can't turn off, or that squirrelly feeling when in a cross wind. Thank god this has nither issue. Love the moon roof, the heated seats, the night vision is dead on. The cd player is nice maybe dated but nice. Its more a suv then the older models- not sure if that's good or bad depending on your take i guess.
See all 15 photos
Used
$10,300 99,323 mi.

2011 Subaru Forester 2.5X Limited

Good Deal
  • Ext. Color: Silver
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: Automatic
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
All Motor Cars
() -
(845) 658-4453
3.8 (45 reviews)
0 mi. from 12486
Check Availability
Call
All Motor Cars Review
Great with Subaru repairs
by Shannon from Lancaster PA
November 6, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 3.8 (45 reviews)
My husband and I visited 5 other Subaru dealers prior to All motor Cars ltd and I'm glad we waited. We knew exactly what we were looking for and Andrew took care of us like family. Their mechanics are top notch in subarus and explaining to us what to keep any eye on. I wish we lived closer to be able to use them for our maintenance needs. I would definitely recommend friends and family to this dealer looking for a used Subaru. we drove 3hrs to get here. Thank you Andrew my sales Rep.
2011 Subaru Forester 2.5X Limited Review
Fantastic and functional
by snowmageddon253 from Tacoma, WA
March 12, 2019
4
The 2011 Subaru Forester is very functional, comfortable, and easy and safe to drive. The best AWD system available, nimble, good power, and plenty of space.
See all 18 photos
Used
$6,900 134,470 mi.

2010 Subaru Forester 2.5X Premium

Great Deal
  • Ext. Color: Gray
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: Automatic
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
All Motor Cars
() -
(845) 658-4453
3.8 (45 reviews)
0 mi. from 12486
Check Availability
Call
All Motor Cars Review
All Good at All Motors
by Steve E. from Kingston, NY
November 5, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 3.8 (45 reviews)
I was grousing about the local Subaru dealers not to mention the prices they were getting for used Foresters. I found AM on the internet and went over there to look around. Andrew made it easy for my wife and I to try a number of cars and we chose a dk blue Forester. After buying it we realized the radio was dead. AM sent a guy over who replaced it with a new one in our driveway. There was also a small muffler problem which they fixed gratis even after the warranty ended. I really like the car and the fact that I didn't have to give blood to buy it. Well done All Motors. ps
2010 Subaru Forester 2.5X Premium Review
Still getting to know the new vehicle, but happy!
by NewToSubaru from Howell, Michigan
January 3, 2019
4
This car is meeting all of my needs, with only a few minor tweaks needed from initial purchase - and the seller (a dealer) has been fair, friendly, and open to offering good service packages to accompany sale. Glad I found them through Cars.com filtering options.
See all 19 photos
Used
$14,359 53,047 mi.

2014 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

Good Deal
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: Blue
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
Ruge's Automotive Inc.
() -
(347) 868-6558
4.8 (45 reviews)
12 mi. from 12486
Check Availability
Call
Ruge's Automotive Inc. Review
Great Service and Friendly Staff
by Constance from New York, NY
November 6, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.8 (45 reviews)
The people at Ruge's are warm, accommodating and efficient. The buying process was layed back and the service has been excellent.
2014 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium Review
The car of the PNW for a reason
by PNW Subie Fanatic from Portland, OR
May 6, 2019
5
Solid and reliable car. You can take this car anywhere, whether up to the mountains or off the beaten path. Its comfortable and named CCR small SUV champion. It succeeds by focusing on the fundamentals with a space-efficient design, large windows, and big square doors. The result is the easiest access and the best view out of almost any vehicle tested. It also has one of the roomiest rear seats with copious amounts of head and leg room. It adapts various fuel-efficient technologies, including replacing the antiquated four-speed automatic transmission with a new continuously variable transmission (CVT), the Forester delivers quicker acceleration, as well as a class-leading 26 mpg overall and 35 mpg on the highway in our tests making it a solid adventure SUV or commuter.
See all 18 photos
Used
$8,913 108,079 mi.

2010 Subaru Forester 2.5X Premium

Good Deal
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: Silver
  • Int. Color: Other
  • Transmission: Automatic
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
Ruge's Automotive Inc.
() -
(347) 868-6558
4.8 (45 reviews)
12 mi. from 12486
Check Availability
Call
Ruge's Automotive Inc. Review
Great service
by Olga from Rhinebeck, new York
November 5, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.8 (45 reviews)
The service was excellent, fast. Great patience in explaining everything on what was going on with my jeep. The workers were pleasant and had a great smile when listening to the problems I was having.
2010 Subaru Forester 2.5X Premium Review
Great car to own
by Jamie from Boise idaho
February 22, 2019
4
This car is exactly what i was looking for. Despite the higher mileage, i am certain this car will last me the time that i need it to
See all 27 photos
Used
$9,995 86,546 mi.

2011 Subaru Forester 2.5X Premium

Good Deal
  • Ext. Color: Black
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: Automatic
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
Mag Auto Corp
() -
(845) 233-6507
4.5 (35 reviews)
12 mi. from 12486
Check Availability
Call
Mag Auto Corp Review
Absolutely Amazing experience!!!!!
by Anthony piliero from Eastchester ny
November 6, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.5 (35 reviews)
Amazing experience! I went up to the dealer and they were straight forward and helped me out. Let me test the truck I wanted and they are even dropped the truck off at my location so I didn't need to commute back to pick up the vehicle. Friendly nice amazing service with a smile!!!!!
2011 Subaru Forester 2.5X Premium Review
Road warrior
by Gees subaru from New York
April 5, 2019
5
Excellent performer in bad weather. Has a terrific ride & it is very comfortable on long trips & can swallows all your gear. This is my go to vehicle for road trips
See all 11 photos
Used
$19,880 61,840 mi.

2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Touring

Good Deal
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: Blue
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
Ruge's Automotive Inc.
() -
(347) 868-6558
4.8 (45 reviews)
12 mi. from 12486
Check Availability
Call
Ruge's Automotive Inc. Review
prompt, friendly service
by James from Rhinebeck, NY
November 6, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.8 (45 reviews)
Friendly service personnel, appointment easy to schedule, service was promptly provided and thoroughly explained. I would recommend Ruge's to others without hesitation.
2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Touring Review
Great all around suv
by jrgrey from Liberty, PA
April 11, 2019
5
Excellent vision in all directions from the Forester. We like the no non-sense styling of the Touring 2.5i. Easy to get into and out of which matters if getting a few years on you. Very good gas mileage and handling with excellent performance. The AWD is certainly one of many key selling points. Fit and finish is excellent with very good reliability so far. We think it is a excellent SUV and would definitely purchase another Subaru SUV if needed.
See all 18 photos
Used
$24,350 794 mi.

2019 Subaru Forester

Good Deal
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: Blue
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
Ruge's Automotive Inc.
() -
(347) 868-6558
4.8 (45 reviews)
12 mi. from 12486
Check Availability
Call
Ruge's Automotive Inc. Review
great service from nice and competent people
by Maryann from rhinebeck,ny
November 6, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.8 (45 reviews)
very pleasant and efficient staff took care of my problem quickly at an exceptionally reasonable charge. i have used this service department many times with positive results.
2019 Subaru Forester Review
leased 7 of them. never had a problem.
by John A from fIELDSBORO N.J.
May 12, 2019
5
I like this vehicle except for the engine shutting off when stopped. it does have an override switch, but if I forget to set it the engine will automatically shut off. that's the only thing I don't like about this car.
See all 19 photos
Used
$19,821 22,802 mi.

2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

Good Deal
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: Red
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
Ruge's Automotive Inc.
() -
(347) 868-6558
4.8 (45 reviews)
12 mi. from 12486
Check Availability
Call
Ruge's Automotive Inc. Review
Great service
by Sara from Rhinebeck, ny
November 5, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.8 (45 reviews)
Short wait time and the staff are so pleasant! The quality of service and the knowledge of staff are remarkable.
2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium Review
Third Subaru I have owned
by cwvaughan48 from Tioga, Texas
April 29, 2019
5
Great dependable cars...I have one with 265K on it and as soon as I have the radiator replaced I will give to the grandkids. Comment
See all 19 photos
Used
$15,870 56,105 mi.

2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

Great Deal
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: White
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX Report
Ruge's Automotive Inc.
() -
(347) 868-6558
4.8 (45 reviews)
12 mi. from 12486
Check Availability
Call
Ruge's Automotive Inc. Review
Excellent Service
by Cathy from Rhinebeck NY
November 5, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.8 (45 reviews)
My car was serviced at my appointment time. The staff is always friendly. I also like that they give a printout of everything done, and what may need to be done in the coming months.
2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium Review
Perfect for families
by Rodriguez from Reading
April 10, 2019
5
This car its all we were expecting. A lot of space in the back . Its perfect for families. I just loved everything off it.
See all 12 photos
Used
$19,231 37,212 mi.

2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

Good Deal
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: Gray
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
Ruge's Automotive Inc.
() -
(347) 868-6558
4.8 (45 reviews)
12 mi. from 12486
Check Availability
Call
Ruge's Automotive Inc. Review
Great Service
by Daphne from Rhinebeck, NY
November 5, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.8 (45 reviews)
Krissy on the service desk was very friendly and quick to get me booked in. appointment was on time and done in a very acceptable amount of time as I waited.
2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium Review
Feel that this is a very safe and comfortable car
by CAL from Alameda, CA
March 19, 2019
5
I like the comfort and the visibility of this car. All who have ridden in it feel that it’s comfortable too. Love the eyesight package which gives warnings regarding blind spots and so forth. Find it very easy to parallel park. My only complaint is that the audio controls aren’t intuitive to use, at least for me.
See all 19 photos
Used
$16,507 74,781 mi.

2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i Limited

Good Deal
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: Red
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
Ruge's Automotive Inc.
() -
(347) 868-6558
4.8 (45 reviews)
12 mi. from 12486
Check Availability
Call
Ruge's Automotive Inc. Review
Friendly, knowledgeable staff
by Darrelle from Rhinebeck, New York
November 5, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.8 (45 reviews)
Friendly, knowledgeable and helpful staff. The staff was very friendly and knowledgeable about the vehicles and the different packages available on the vehicles
2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i Limited Review
Once You Go Subaru, You Will Never Go Back.
by David from Wilmington
March 27, 2019
5
The Subaru manufacturer produces top quality cars at common man prices. My used 2016 Forester 2.5i is a base trim model, however, it has what I really need in a car without the up charge. The engine is well sized for the the vehicle; it is paired with a CVT transmission. The combined effect is that with little pressure on the gas peddle, the car springs into action. (No more holding up the line when the light turns green.) Last weekend I took the car on a camping trip. Some of the roads of the campground were muddy and uneven with 2 inch stones. The high suspension and symmetric 4 wheel drive of the Forester handled the roads effortlessly. On the highway to and from the campground, the Forester was a smooth well handling ride, even over the winter torn roads. There is plenty of torque at highway speeds for highway acceleration. The cabin interior layout places the major controls at easy reach. The operation of the infotainment system is reasonably user friendly, and there are quick controls on the steering column. In summary, my Subaru Forester is is a well equipment, quality vehicle, especially considering it is the entry model. Based on Consumer Reports I expect a long and trouble free (reliable) service life. Good quality, reliable, reasonable price = valve, value, value.
See all 18 photos
Used
$21,257 33,529 mi.

2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Limited

Good Deal
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: Black
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
Ruge's Automotive Inc.
() -
(347) 868-6558
4.8 (45 reviews)
12 mi. from 12486
Check Availability
Call
Ruge's Automotive Inc. Review
Great Service
by Gary from Rhinebeck,NY
November 5, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.8 (45 reviews)
Everybody was neat and organized and took care of me fast and efficient I wouldn't want to go any where else
2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Limited Review
3rd Time Subaru Buyer
by AdinaT from Stuart, FL
February 22, 2019
5
Just bought a new to me Forester and I couldn't be happier. Subaru hasn't let me down yet...this is my 3rd one and I can't imagine driving anything else. It's safe, reliable and sporty!
See all 20 photos
Used
$17,000 30,034 mi.

2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i

Good Deal
  • Ext. Color: White
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free AutoCheck Report
Dutchess Chrysler Jeep Dodge RAM Mitsubishi Kia
() -
(845) 244-6063
3.3 (29 reviews)
14 mi. from 12486
Check Availability
Call
Dutchess Chrysler Jeep Dodge RAM Mitsubishi Kia Review
Loyal Customer for a reason
by W. Burtchell from Westtown, NY
November 6, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 3.3 (29 reviews)
Leased two vehicles here so far and sent several friends here who also purchased. Prices are unbeatable, Service was top notch and I will be returning in the future. No need to look anywhere else.
2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Review
Great car!
by Mark from Toano
May 12, 2019
5
This is a great vehicle and we're so glad that we purchased one. We've had a couple of minor things go wrong that should not have such as the drivers side visor starting to squeak loudly. All said we are very happy with this car. On the down side there is now standard technology out there that is not available. Automatic wipers are missing and items like remote start and subaru's safety and security package are extra when Honda includes them both free. But my biggest issue is not the car it's that there is no convenient dealersl or service anywhere near me. The nearest service is 45 minutes away. The next car will have to be available locally.
See all 31 photos
Used
$13,495 76,468 mi.

2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i

Good Deal
  • Ext. Color: Gray
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
613Auto.com
() -
(888) 537-3877
4.5 (31 reviews)
19 mi. from 12486
Check Availability
Call
613Auto.com Review
GREAT CUSTOMER SERVICE
by Aryeh from ellenville, ny
November 5, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.5 (31 reviews)
I reached out for a quite and info regarding one of the cars on their lot. So far have received amazing service. I intend on going in to buy next week and will leave another review then!
2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i Review
My 3rd subaru love it
March 11, 2019
5
Just what I look for in a car nice size all wheel drive and on and on. After 3 subies I don't need to say anymore
PRICE DROP
See all 23 photos
Used
$17,000 $959 price drop! 69,448 mi.

2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Limited

Good Deal
LOCAL HOME DELIVERY
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: White
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free AutoCheck Report
Healey Hyundai
() -
(845) 245-2011
4.7 (160 reviews)
22 mi. from 12486
Check Availability
Call
Healey Hyundai Review
Great Dealership, Great People
by Leslie from Poughkeepsie, NY
November 5, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.7 (160 reviews)
Well, my salesperson Darrell Greenhill was just great. The kind of person who is really easy to talk too. He tried his best to get me in the car that I wanted and he did. Everything worked out and now I'm the proud owner of a 2016 Hyundai Elantra. When I talked to Matthew Gallagher about the extra insurance, he did everything he could to keep it my ballpark and he did. Was a perfect gentleman. Made me feel comfortable. Tayler Peets who showed me how to operate certain functions inside the car was a sweetheart. Was right on the money and very pleasant. Great girl!
2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Limited Review
All Around Quality
by FeliciaG. from Brooklyn NY
April 7, 2019
5
This car is reliable, sturdy, comfortable and has many safety features. It still looks and drives like new after 2 years . Low maintenance and great gas mileage !
See all 17 photos
Used
$8,799 102,334 mi.

2012 Subaru Forester 2.5X

Great Deal
LOCAL HOME DELIVERY
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: White
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: Automatic
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
Cervone's Auto Sales
() -
(845) 206-4777
23 mi. from 12486
Check Availability
Call
2012 Subaru Forester 2.5X Review
Beautiful and durable vehicle.
by Rebecca from Minnetonka
December 15, 2018
5
This car meets and exceeds all of my needs. I looked an numerous wagon-like models, because my old car was . VW Passat wagon. I looked at the Outback and the Forester, and immediately chose the Forester because of the feeling of space (more head room, bigger windows, and the moon roof).
See all 26 photos
Used
$18,897 55,846 mi.

2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

Good Deal
LOCAL HOME DELIVERY
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: Gray
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
Sawyer Chevrolet
() -
(518) 291-4639
4.8 (32 reviews)
27 mi. from 12486
Check Availability
Call
Sawyer Chevrolet Review
Car service
by Yep a name from Rhinebeck, NY
December 3, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.8 (32 reviews)
It went fine there were no problems except getting to 50 characters for this review.
2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium Review
Subaru is the new Volvo!
by aaallrighty from Cape May NJ
May 3, 2019
5
Have owned 2 Volvos and the company lost it's spark. Subaru has that spot in my heart now. From the 5 star crash rating (except front passenger seat is 4 star) to great reliability records and good tech stuff I am thrilled.
See all 22 photos
Used
$14,997 81,880 mi.

2015 Subaru Forester 2.5i Limited

Good Deal
LOCAL HOME DELIVERY
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: Brown
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
Sawyer Chevrolet
() -
(518) 291-4639
4.8 (32 reviews)
27 mi. from 12486
Check Availability
Call
Sawyer Chevrolet Review
good place to do business
by Barbara Peduzzi from Chatham, NY
December 3, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.8 (32 reviews)
Nice place to do business, I did not feel pressured,I felt they wanted to help me find the car I wanted - and I did. Just as nice to go back to get the car serviced, make me feel they care about how the car and I are getting along.
2015 Subaru Forester 2.5i Limited Review
Very reliable
by Mr suburu 1 from Kcmo
May 10, 2019
5
Dream car.love it .plenty of space, comfortable, powerful vehicle as well. I see my self recommending the same vehicle to other ppeople as well.why not..?
* Title, other fees, and incentives are not included in this calculation, which is an estimate only. Monthly payment estimates are for illustrative purposes only and do not represent a financing offer from the seller. Other taxes may apply.
The information on vehicles provided in this service is supplied by the seller or other third parties; Cars.com is not responsible for the accuracy of such information. Cars.com provides this service and materials without representations or warranties of any kind, either expressed or implied. See our terms of service for more details.
55 results
Save Search
  • Location
    • Search within
  • Shop from Home
  • New/Used
  • Year
    Min
     
    to
    Max
  • Model
  • Trim
  • Price
    Min
     
    to
    Max
  • Mileage
  • Deal Rating
  • Features
  • Body Style
  • Exterior Color
  • Interior Color
  • Drivetrain
  • Transmission
  • Cylinders
  • Photos
  • Fuel
  • Door Count
  • Dealer Ratings
  • Listing Date
  • Seller Type
  • Keywords
New Search

Save Your Search

Search saved!

You can manage your searches in your profile.

That's too many

You can only compare up to 4 cars at a time.

You've reached your limit

Sorry, you've saved the maximum amount of favorites for your account. Please unsave some if you wish to save others.