New and used 2026 Toyota Corolla for sale near North Codorus, PA

Scott Kulik was a pleasure to work with. He made the whole process easy and answered all of our questions. Thank you Scott.

Miscommunication on everyone’s part contributed to some hiccups when writing the contract. We cancelled a VIP clause and have been waiting 3 months for management to resolve the issue. We have management’s commitment that things are moving in the right direction. We love the car. It’s our first Toyota. Our sales team was very helpful getting us trained on the electronics.

This is the best dealership I have dealt with. Regardless of the problem, they fix it quickly and correctly. They are extremely easy to work with. Theu focus on getting it right and being fair.

Purchased a new Tundra from Anthony ( Josh ) Bruffy. Had a great experience with Anthony test driving vehicles and when I made final decision, he and Chris in finance we easy to work with. No pressure whatsoever. Great experience. When I got home, I even told my wife how easy everything went. The whole staff was great. Thank you!!

I can truly say that this was the best car buying experience I have ever had. From the time I walked in the door to completion it was less than three hours. I had the best salesman (Jackie). If you want a great car buying experience visit Sheehy Toyota, it's the best!

Certainly! Here’s a rephrased version: “From the moment I entered the building until the day I picked up my truck, Josh provided excellent service! I was impressed by the staff’s commitment to customer satisfaction. It was a pleasure working with everyone! 😊👍

Koons service is always stress free when going there . Service associate Molly is always on her A game with keeping you informed with your vehicle.

Always have a good experience getting our car serviced. Dave H. our service advisor is honest and professional.

The overall purchasing with test drive was very good . Of course we purchased a great car . No real surprises. Honest negotiation back and forth . A good experience.

The car-buying experience can be quite stressful, but Sheehy made the process smooth. The salesman, Brock, was down to earth, very accommodating and up front. Mike in financing was quite professional and explained the steps clearly. Caitlin, who handled some of the paperwork also was professional. Overall, it was a positive experience.

Took a bit long but the service and customer service was great. The service rep was polite, kind and helpful. I would recommend this shop to my friends and family

Lee went above and beyond to keep this customer coming back. I appreciate the fact that he listened and took care of the issue satisfactory

Was looking to buy a new 4Runner TRD Off-Road but none of the dealers in the area had what we were looking for. Not wanting to put in a build order and potentially wait another 4-6 months, we did an extended radius search online and found the exact one we wanted at Sheehy Toyota of Timonium – and for a great (almost too good to be true) price! I used the online form to request availability and got put in contact with Matt Ellis. Having never purchased a car out of state before, I wasn’t sure what to expect. But after a few emails and phone calls to iron out the details, Matt thoroughly explained the whole process and answered all of my questions – everything wound up being as smooth as could be. No surprises. No ‘gotchas’. No pressure. All the way through to the end including working with the Finance manager, Donna Hale – she was very informative, presented all of my options, didn’t try to pressure me on anything I declined, and was even able to beat the APR I was pre-approved for by a few fractions of a point. The whole experience was easily worth the time it took to travel there and back!

Great purchase experience. The dealership was extremely busy. But all the people who work there were friendly and helpful. My Salesperson Nial was a very professional, polite and knowledgeable man. I would highly recommend him.