Used Subaru cars for sale near Mastic, NY
-





$31,543
Est. $585/mo East Hills Subaru of Sayville
Check Availability Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Magnetite Gray Metallic
- Int. color
- Gray
- Drivetrain
- All-wheel Drive
- MPG
- 26-32
- Fuel type
- Gasoline
- Transmission
- Automatic CVT
- Engine
- 2.5L H4 16V GDI DOHC
- Stock #
- 9370BB
- VIN
- 4S4BTALC6S3212121
Features
- Convenience
- Adaptive Cruise Control
- Heated Seats
- Heated Steering Wheel
- Keyless Entry
- Power Liftgate
- Entertainment
- Apple CarPlay®
- Bluetooth®
- HomeLink
- Premium Sound System
- Satellite Radio
- Exterior
- Alloy Wheels
- Roof Rack
- Sunroof/Moonroof
- Safety
- Backup Camera
- Brake Assist
- Stability Control
- Seating
- Leather Seats
Dealer
East Hills Subaru of SayvilleReviews
2025 Subaru Outback review
I have owned Subaru wagons both used and new from 1984 until present. I own a 2012 Subaru Outback Limited 2.5 which I bought new. It has 220,000 miles. Other than routine maintenance and a couple rear wheel bearings, it is doing great! I also own a 2025 Subaru Outback Limited 2.5, I currently have 24,000 miles in it. Only real nuisances are the center tablet and no buttons or dials for hvac. It’s frankly a safety issue to play with a screen just to change hvac settings-dumb. 2026 they got smarter but changed the style for the worse. Additionally, the OEM tires are starting to sing at 24,000 miles. The first 24k the car was whisper quiet. Now I have to blast the radio to drown out the hum. Subaru needs to quit playing with cheap OEM tires. Throw a set of Michelins on there to start… The seats are comfortable-a great improvement over the seat design used from 2015-2019. I got rid of a new 2017 Outback after 95,000 miles because the seating was like sitting on slate. A complaint I have is the overuse of “safety nannies” which are too sensitive and could cause an accident rather than prevent one. Case in point, car can slam on the brakes for you if it thinks you are doing something abnormal that you probably do all the time. I dislike the 8 speed trans. My 6 speed is better on the 2012. 8 speeds are too many. No issues shifting or anything, CVT “shifts” fine. I still get 30 mpg Hwy on the 2012 and 32-34 on the 2025 Hwy. Subarus are wonderful vehicles but they better watch out so they don’t get too much more expensive or start following the crowd too much. Cars in general are too high priced…
-


Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Crystal Black Silica
- Int. color
- Black
- Engine
- 4 Cyl - 2.5 L
- Stock #
- U23642F
- VIN
- JF2SKADCXPH549845
Dealer
Competition Subaru of Smithtown -


Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Crystal Black Silica
- Int. color
- Black
- Engine
- 4 Cyl - 2.5 L
- Stock #
- U22840L
- VIN
- 4S4SLDD65T3018210
Dealer
Competition Subaru of SmithtownReviews
Competition Subaru of Smithtown review
Jesse and the whole team at Competition Subaru was great and made the buying process painless. Thank you for such a great and easy experience
2026 Subaru Forester review
Dwayne Pruit is one of the best sales person I've met. Answered all of the questions I had were answered and it was a smooth and easy process. Thanks Dwayne and Crown Subaru of Chattanooga, TN.
-


Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Ice Silver Metallic
- Int. color
- Black
- Engine
- 4 Cyl - 2.5 L
- Stock #
- U22847L
- VIN
- 4S4SLDD65T3033113
Dealer
Competition Subaru of SmithtownReviews
Competition Subaru of Smithtown review
I had a great experience helping my mother buy a Crosstrek at Competition Subaru. The sales consultant, John O’Donnell was knowledgeable, friendly, empathetic, and patient. He guided us through the entire process with a smile. I also very much appreciated the lack of hidden fees and all around professionalism that we experienced at this dealership. Highly recommended!
2026 Subaru Forester review
Chose the Forester Wilderness for my first new car purchase and I could not recommend it more. It has everything as a mom of 1 that I could need. Space, comfort, safety features, ground clearance for adventures, easy to clean interiors, cargo space, and the ease of owning a reliable and highly rated safety car. The visibility is unmatched and the adventure exterior is eye catching everywhere. Had it for 2 months and no complaints. Screen can be lagging as others can attest, but it is not a detrimental feature. It still has everything you need!
-


Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Crystal White Pearl
- Int. color
- Black
- Engine
- 4 Cyl - 2.5 L
- Stock #
- U23498F
- VIN
- JF2SKADC9RH406761
Dealer
Competition Subaru of Smithtown -


Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Horizon Blue Pearl
- Int. color
- Gray
- Engine
- 4 Cyl - 2.5 L
- Stock #
- U23516F
- VIN
- JF2SKADC9RH484778
Dealer
Competition Subaru of SmithtownReviews
2024 Subaru Forester review
I just bought my 3rd Forester from Freehold Subaru. I had a great sales experience with Yuliya and explanation of the car from John. Very happy with this dealership since moving to Freehold.
-


Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- River Rock Pearl
- Int. color
- Black
- Engine
- 4 Cyl - 2.5 L
- Stock #
- U22878L
- VIN
- 4S4SLDB64T3032098
Dealer
Competition Subaru of Smithtown -


Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Crimson Red Pearl
- Int. color
- Gray
- Engine
- 4 Cyl - 2.5 L
- Stock #
- U22901L
- VIN
- 4S4SLDD62T3034719
Dealer
Competition Subaru of Smithtown -


Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Gray Metallic
- Int. color
- Black
- Engine
- 4 Cyl - 2.5 L
- Stock #
- U23576F
- VIN
- JF2SKALC8RH440014
Dealer
Competition Subaru of SmithtownReviews
2024 Subaru Forester review
Next to top rating in Consumer Reports. Lives up to its rating 100%. Only concerns thus far, after three weeks of use. 1) takes time to learn use of various electrical and mechanical controls -- after 20+plus years of VW Jetta ownership, "a lot is different." Just have to be patient learning all the new features. 2) Auto-safety features (staying in lanes, braking distance warning, etc.) are helpful to some less-attentive drivers but annoying to this long-experienced user. Fortunately, they can be turned off and stop the chirping.
-


Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- River Rock Pearl
- Int. color
- Black
- Engine
- 4 Cyl - 2.5 L
- Stock #
- U22904L
- VIN
- 4S4SLDD63T3018965
Dealer
Competition Subaru of Smithtown -


Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Autumn Green Metallic
- Int. color
- Black
- Engine
- 4 Cyl - 2.5 L
- Stock #
- U23644F
- VIN
- JF2SKACC3RH417899
Dealer
Competition Subaru of SmithtownReviews
2024 Subaru Forester review
Very dependable and reliable vehicle regardless of the terrain traveled. The perfect vehicle for older folks or those with knee problems. Seat height is perfect, you can slide in and out of the seat with ease. Smooth ride and overall great vehicle.
-


Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Autumn Green Metallic
- Int. color
- Black
- Engine
- 4 Cyl - 2.5 L
- Stock #
- U23643F
- VIN
- JF2SKARC1PH544106
Dealer
Competition Subaru of SmithtownReviews
Competition Subaru of Smithtown review
It was great. The whole process. I would recommend them to anyone. Very caring. Very supportive. Explained everything. Very knowledgeable. Was available whenever I called or texted with a question.
2023 Subaru Forester review
Likes: spacious interior despite modest exterior dimensions, easy to maneuver, great visibility all around, comfortable ride, good traction, handling, and braking, nice interior finish on sport model, strong steering responsive headlights yet they don't blind opposing traffic, very good optional Harmon sound system, numerous effective safety features, low insurance premiums, adequate acceleration..a few cons: actual economy slightly under EPA estimates, seat may be a bit too firm for some but easy to address by adding a thin seat cushion, mandatory sunroof on all but the base model..I wish Subaru would just make that a single option..rough engine start-stop ..however I disable it each time I start engine so it can be a non issue...no reliability issues yet but since this has a cvt and fairly complex safety features, long term reliability is unknown..
-
$48,020
New 2025 Subaru Ascent Onyx Edition Touring
$32,482
New 2027 Subaru Crosstrek Premium
$34,655
New 2026 Subaru Forester Premium
$37,423
New 2026 Subaru Forester Premium
$37,032
New 2027 Subaru Crosstrek Limited
$50,460
New 2027 Subaru Ascent Limited
$39,896
New 2026 Subaru Forester Limited
$32,609
New 2026 Subaru Forester
$33,631
New 2027 Subaru Crosstrek Premium
$32,759
New 2026 Subaru Forester
$29,316
New 2027 Subaru Crosstrek Base
$37,497
New 2027 Subaru Crosstrek Limited -


Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Crystal White Pearl
- Int. color
- Black
- Engine
- 4 Cyl - 2.5 L
- Stock #
- U22911L
- VIN
- 4S4SLDD64T3039176
Dealer
Competition Subaru of SmithtownReviews
Competition Subaru of Smithtown review
My experience at competition subaru of Smithtown has always been of excellence. The facility is always clean, the parking lot debris free. The staff is always very friendly and accommodating. Jeff Barkan is the main reason I keep returning to this dealership he's a true professional and great individual in frequently recommend him and this dealership to associates
2026 Subaru Forester review
I bought this 2026 Subaru Forester Premium to replace the 2026 KIA Sportage that we had bought back in November 25. The KIA wasn't bad but the service department sucks. It had peeling paint on the bumper, and they denied the warranty claim, I started thinking if they are going to deny peeling paint what happens when something goes wrong with the engine or transmission. So much for their 10-year 100,000-mile warranty, what a joke. We currently own a 2024 Subaru Outback and now the 2026 Subaru Forester. All of the Subarus that we have own have treated us good, just make sure that keep up with maintenance and they last a long time. Landers Mclartys Subaru in Huntsville, AL, treated very fair with our trade-in and price on both vehicles,
-


Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Ice Silver Metallic
- Int. color
- Black
- Engine
- 4 Cyl - 2.5 L
- Stock #
- U23535F
- VIN
- JF2SKALC8RH456987
Dealer
Competition Subaru of SmithtownReviews
2024 Subaru Forester review
I’ve owned this car for about 18 months. It has I bought it new and it now has about 17,000 miles on it. I love driving it. The safety features are excellent! The performance is good. I’m getting around 32 MPG for all around driving. I have the car maintained at the dealership and haven’t had any mechanical issues. I would definitely recommend this car.
-


Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Ice Silver Metallic
- Int. color
- Black
- Engine
- 4 Cyl - 2.5 L
- Stock #
- U23470T
- VIN
- JF2SKADC1PH441985
Dealer
Competition Subaru of SmithtownReviews
Competition Subaru of Smithtown review
I just purchased a used 2021 Outback from Competition Subaru. I called the dealer about the vehicle I was interested and made an appointment for the next day. I met with John O'Donnell. He was a consummate professional. He told me all about the vehicle and then we test-drove it. He then worked up some numbers for me. No pressure, no B.S. The same goes for Adrian in finance. I will seriously consider them for my next vehicle purchase.
2023 Subaru Forester review
Overall, at 60k miles, I’ve had no problems and am very happy. I average around 34 mpg’s with mixed driving. I’m happy with the acceleration as well, even though Subaru’s without a turbo are sometimes labeled as slow. I have no problem merging onto highways. The Forester is an easy to live with SUV/car. The rear room is adequate, although the CRV offers about 10 cubic feet more rear capacity. Visibility is excellent. The CVT is smooth and has simulated shifts, just make sure you change the fluid every 30k! I own the Limited with leather seats that are very comfortable. Sometimes the response time on the radio/touch screen can feel a little delayed. I also opted for the dimming driver/rear view mirrors which is great during winter commuting. It saves your eyes from glare. Very view cars offer this which is why I went with the Subaru. My only “major” complaint with the car is a slight rattle coming from the dash board area. It isn’t always there, but is present enough to bother me. Aside from that it is an excellent vehicle and value for the money!
-


Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Crystal White Pearl
- Int. color
- Black
- Engine
- 4 Cyl - 2.5 L
- Stock #
- U22876L
- VIN
- 4S4SLDD61T3014719
Dealer
Competition Subaru of Smithtown -


Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Gray Metallic
- Int. color
- Black
- Engine
- 4 Cyl - 2.5 L
- Stock #
- U23623T
- VIN
- JF2SKAPC6NH504166
Dealer
Competition Subaru of SmithtownReviews
2022 Subaru Forester review
My purchase history has been that of a General Motors enthusiast. My wife worked with Subaru owners; they had no complaints. Decades of commercial truck driving exposed me to witnessing the site's of too many bad accidents. The Subaru safety record has earned my loyalty.
-


Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Cascade Green Silica
- Int. color
- Saddle Brown
- Engine
- 4 Cyl - 2.5 L
- Stock #
- U23659T
- VIN
- JF2SKARCXPH483323
Dealer
Competition Subaru of SmithtownReviews
2023 Subaru Forester review
This is our second Forester. Our first was a 2011 Premium we bought as a CPO in 2014 and unfortunately went through the headache of excessive oil consumption within months of buying it. Subaru did eventually replace the engine short block on their dime, but only after repeated oil consumption tests and being told by the dealer service department that it was within normal limits. Calling Subaru of America was the only way we got it resolved. I was impressed that they approved the service, and that's the reason we bought another Subaru. We also have a 2018 Outback Premium in our garage--no oil consumption, and no major issues except replacing the radio for failed lighting behind the volume knob and a minor leak in the oil pan (no dripping underneath the car though) at about 42k miles. We like our 2023 Forester Sport overall, and first and foremost we like its excellent safety ratings and features. I will say the ride is much firmer than our Outback which is only a couple hundred pounds heavier. Wish it had a little more storage in the center console and beneath the climate controls. We look forward to many years of driving with the Forester (and our Outback). Based on our experience, I do feel getting a Subaru-backed extended warranty is worth it for peace of mind (we bought them for our first Forester and now our Outback and both eventually paid for themselves). You DON'T have to buy the warranty when you purchase the vehicle. Call different dealers in your state and ask for their price on an extended warranty for your vehicle--we saved hundreds of dollars by doing this. You have until your manufacturer warranty expires to add an extended warranty.
-


Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Crystal White Pearl
- Int. color
- Touring Brown
- Engine
- 4 Cyl - 2.5 L
- Stock #
- U22914L
- VIN
- 4S4SLDT63T3018563
Dealer
Competition Subaru of Smithtown -


Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Magnetite Gray Metallic
- Int. color
- Gray
- Transmission
- CVT Lineartronic
- Engine
- 2.5L H-4 cyl
- Stock #
- 26486
- VIN
- 4S4BTAFC5N3266803
Dealer
Riverhead Bay MotorsReviews
Riverhead Bay Motors review
My salesman Eric Mamay at Riverhead Bay Subaru is the best in the business. He always returns my calls and follows through with every question I have. While there I met another woman in her eighties who told me that she bought 4 cars from Eric and that she was tremendously pleased with their relationship over the years, He was the Best!!! she told me and I have to agree. I am so blessed to have found him and I can't tell you how helpful he has been to me in every respect. Moreover he is a great solid guy and a friend. He knows what he's doing and exercises a great deal of patience in dealing with first time Subaru owners like myself. He is a credit to Riverhead Bay Subaru and an asset to Subaru. Hip hip hooray!
2022 Subaru Outback review
We purchased the Touring model. We absolutely love this car. 2022 was the first year the Touring model had cooling seats. Cooling seats should be a necessity for people with neurodegenerative disorders who have difficulty regulating their body temperature.
-


Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Crystal White Pearl
- Int. color
- Black
- Transmission
- CVT Lineartronic
- Engine
- 2.5L H-4 cyl
- Stock #
- 26487
- VIN
- 4S4BTANC3R3163919
Dealer
Riverhead Bay MotorsReviews
Riverhead Bay Motors review
Jimmy Delatola is the best! Will always go to him, the best customer service, always finds what I need/want even in tighter circumstances. Very thankful to have found him!
2024 Subaru Outback review
This is the eleventh Subaru I have owned, the third outback; the Outback wilderness is by far the best performer of all of the others I have had. I have been happy with subarus from the first one I bought a 1978 Brat; sure wish i still had it.
-


Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Crystal Black Silica
- Int. color
- Gray
- Transmission
- CVT Lineartronic
- Engine
- 2.4L H-4 cyl
- Stock #
- 26523
- VIN
- 4S4BTGSD4R3165209
Dealer
Riverhead Bay MotorsReviews
2024 Subaru Outback review
The acceleration lag that this car has is immediately outweighed by everything else. This car is super smooth and granny sedan comfy, and it has more utility than any equally priced SUV. The roof rails have built-in cross bars that stow, it tows 3500 pounds, and the Harmon-Kardon sound system kicks. It has butt fans, people. Additionally, the aftermarket base is thick, so accessories, customization, and reflashing options abound. The tech is old, the powertrain is old, but you see 300 of them a day for a reason.
-


Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Cosmic Blue Pearl
- Int. color
- Gray
- Transmission
- CVT Lineartronic
- Engine
- 2.5L H-4 cyl
- Stock #
- 26488
- VIN
- 4S4BTADC5R3170016
Dealer
Riverhead Bay MotorsReviews
Riverhead Bay Motors review
Riverhead Bay Subaru is a solid dealership with professional and courteous staff. From buying to servicing my Outback, it?s been a positive experience
2024 Subaru Outback review
The Subaru Outback is one of the best cars on the road. This car is definitely worth every penny that it costs. Performance at reliability cannot be underestimated. The company stands behind its warranty in every way. It’s like having a more expensive car without the hassle and expense!
-


Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Crimson Red Pearl
- Int. color
- Black
- Transmission
- CVT Lineartronic
- Engine
- 2.5L H-4 cyl
- Stock #
- 26499L
- VIN
- JF2BUPAD9TY505548
Dealer
Riverhead Bay MotorsReviews
Riverhead Bay Motors review
Tayler Fichtner kept in touch with me as I considered purchasing a new car. He was very informative, professional and responsive to my questions without being pushy or aggressive.
2026 Subaru Outback review
Its been 10 years since we shopped for a new Subaru and the technical advancements are amazing. Adaptive cruise control, lane control, distance to other vehicle controls, turbo charged 2.4 liter 4 cylinder engine feels like a V6 and the Wilderness model is perfect for the rugged area we live in. Thanks, Subaru!
-


Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Crystal White Pearl
- Int. color
- Gray
- Transmission
- Lineartronic CVT
- Engine
- 2.4L H-4 cyl
- Stock #
- 26474
- VIN
- 4S4WMAKD4P3456026
Dealer
Riverhead Bay MotorsReviews
Riverhead Bay Motors review
Daniel Burawa was very helpful, gave us information without expectations or pressure to buy immediately. We really appreciated his genuineness and non-aggressive manner in the process.
2023 Subaru Ascent review
I recently traded in my 2022 Ascent for a similar 2023 model. The 2022 model had brakes issues/noises right from the beginning of ownership. Subaru gave me a great deal on the 2023 model. A number of improvement were found on the 2023 model. Obvious one is the exterior styling with new front grille, headlights and taillights. Interior improvements include updated Eyesight, quieter ride, better steering and brakes, larger multimedia screen including front and backup camera screens, driver profile system. A few other tweaks here and there, making the 2023 Ascent Touring a decent and very safe SUV. Not necessarily sporty or thrilling but perfect vehicle for commuting in town and long road trips.
-





Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Elemental Red Pearl
- Int. color
- Black
- Drivetrain
- All-wheel Drive
- Fuel type
- Electric
- Transmission
- 1-Speed Automatic
- Engine
- Electric
- Stock #
- 23A2700
- VIN
- JTMABABA6PA022700
Features
- Convenience
- Adaptive Cruise Control
- Heated Seats
- Keyless Entry
- Keyless Start
- Navigation System
- Entertainment
- Apple CarPlay®
- Bluetooth®
- Satellite Radio
- USB Port
- Exterior
- Alloy Wheels
- Safety
- Backup Camera
- Blind Spot Monitor
- Brake Assist
- Lane Departure Warning
- Rear Cross Traffic Alert
- Stability Control
Dealer
Imperial SubaruReviews
Imperial Subaru review
My wife and I leased a forester for 3 years and decided to buy a CROSTREK 2025 . WE decided our joints couldn't quite get used to getting in and out so we went back and purchased a 2026 Forester. We had a stress less experience buying a car with Emily Messier who walked us through a great experience. Rmilu is professional and very friendly. I would recommend any interested new car buyer to visit Imperial Subaru in Foxborough and seeing Emily for a great car buying experience. We were so pleased with Emily and I am sure we would go back again. Thank you EMILY.
2023 Subaru Solterra review
I bought the car at Sabaru of Englewood. First the car didn't came with the originals tires. I asked the seller if the car qualified for the $7000. 00 insentive and I thrust them. The car did not qualify for the gov. incentive because it was built outside the US. The sonterra is a very reliable vehicle. We like it a lot.
-





Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Blue
- Int. color
- BLACK
- Drivetrain
- Four-wheel Drive
- MPG
- 21-27
- Fuel type
- Gasoline
- Transmission
- Manual 6
- Engine
- Turbo Gas
- Stock #
- 70286531
- VIN
- JF1VA1A64J9822217
Features
- Entertainment
- Bluetooth®
- HomeLink
- Satellite Radio
- Exterior
- Alloy Wheels
- Safety
- Backup Camera
Dealer
CarMax WayneReviews
2018 Subaru WRX review
This car has been nothing short of a pleasure to own. Its so much fun to drive, handles well, pulls hard, and just puts a smile on my face all the time. Its practical with good storage space and good back seat room. The AWD system on the car is great and offers endless grip. The car does have its quirks, it is a little noisy on the highway (wind noise), and the interior quality is just so-so (materials aren't bad, but aren't great either), and there are a couple of creaks and rattles. Even so, this vehicle has been great.