Johnstons Subaru

(76 reviews)
3480 Route 6, Middletown, NY 10940
Sales hours: 9:00am to 5:00pm
Service hours: 8:00am to 4:00pm
View all hours
Sales Service
Monday 9:00am–8:00pm 7:00am–5:00pm
Tuesday 9:00am–8:00pm 7:00am–5:00pm
Wednesday 9:00am–8:00pm 7:00am–5:00pm
Thursday 9:00am–8:00pm 7:00am–5:00pm
Friday 9:00am–6:00pm 7:00am–5:00pm
Saturday 9:00am–5:00pm 8:00am–4:00pm
Sunday Closed Closed
20 matches
[{"search_type":"general-inventory-search","vehicle_array":[{"trim":"Wilderness","make":"Subaru","cat":"crossover_compact","year":"2022","model":"Forester","seller_type":"dealership","customer_id":"113956","vin":"JF2SKAMCXNH501758","listing_id":"5b4dd14b-7aaf-4a00-acb1-1dc0a2f622b2","stock_type":"Used","certified_preowned":true,"mileage":"35980","sponsored":true,"nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"White","fuel_type":null,"interior_color":"GREY","drivetrain":null,"dealer_name":"Johnstons Subaru","msrp":"30990","dealer_zip":"10940","price":"29490","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"SUV","cpo_indicator":true,"relevancy_score":null,"badges":["good_deal","cpo"],"canonical_mmt":"Subaru:Forester:Wilderness","canonical_mmty":"Subaru:Forester:Wilderness:2022","cpo_package":"Subaru","photo_count":3,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"Limited","make":"Subaru","cat":"crossover_compact","year":"2025","model":"Forester","seller_type":"dealership","customer_id":"113956","vin":"JF2SLDRC7SH447399","listing_id":"b5fcca49-ffac-4e4a-9330-41ed92e21612","stock_type":"Used","certified_preowned":true,"mileage":"20160","sponsored":true,"nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"Green","fuel_type":null,"interior_color":"BLACK","drivetrain":null,"dealer_name":"Johnstons Subaru","msrp":"34990","dealer_zip":"10940","price":"33990","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"SUV","cpo_indicator":true,"relevancy_score":null,"badges":["good_deal","cpo"],"canonical_mmt":"Subaru:Forester:Limited","canonical_mmty":"Subaru:Forester:Limited:2025","cpo_package":"Subaru","photo_count":3,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"Limited","make":"Subaru","cat":"crossover_compact","year":"2021","model":"Crosstrek","seller_type":"dealership","customer_id":"113956","vin":"JF2GTHNC6MH660365","listing_id":"f2fd3103-f805-494d-bd75-8f8f17dcfa9c","stock_type":"Used","certified_preowned":true,"mileage":"58397","sponsored":true,"nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"Grey","fuel_type":null,"interior_color":"BLACK","drivetrain":null,"dealer_name":"Johnstons Subaru","msrp":"25990","dealer_zip":"10940","price":"23990","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"SUV","cpo_indicator":true,"relevancy_score":null,"badges":["fair_deal","cpo"],"canonical_mmt":"Subaru:Crosstrek:Limited","canonical_mmty":"Subaru:Crosstrek:Limited:2021","cpo_package":"Subaru","photo_count":3,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"Limited","make":"Subaru","cat":"crossover_compact","year":"2024","model":"Forester","seller_type":"dealership","customer_id":"113956","vin":"JF2SKALCXRH497489","listing_id":"e6e0f0ab-f7b0-4328-a74b-c0c181add6b4","stock_type":"Used","certified_preowned":true,"mileage":"16281","sponsored":true,"nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"Silver","fuel_type":null,"interior_color":"BLACK","drivetrain":null,"dealer_name":"Johnstons Subaru","msrp":"36990","dealer_zip":"10940","price":"35490","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"SUV","cpo_indicator":true,"relevancy_score":null,"badges":["fair_deal","cpo"],"canonical_mmt":"Subaru:Forester:Limited","canonical_mmty":"Subaru:Forester:Limited:2024","cpo_package":"Subaru","photo_count":3,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"Touring","make":"Subaru","cat":"crossover_compact","year":"2023","model":"Forester","seller_type":"dealership","customer_id":"113956","vin":"JF2SKARC0PH480995","listing_id":"44730ffe-5fa1-4a30-a162-bfbd42d35bf8","stock_type":"Used","certified_preowned":true,"mileage":"46750","sponsored":true,"nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"Blue","fuel_type":null,"interior_color":"BLACK","drivetrain":null,"dealer_name":"Johnstons Subaru","msrp":"30490","dealer_zip":"10940","price":"29490","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"SUV","cpo_indicator":true,"relevancy_score":null,"badges":["good_deal","cpo"],"canonical_mmt":"Subaru:Forester:Touring","canonical_mmty":"Subaru:Forester:Touring:2023","cpo_package":"Subaru","photo_count":3,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"Sport","make":"Subaru","cat":"crossover_compact","year":"2024","model":"Forester","seller_type":"dealership","customer_id":"113956","vin":"JF2SKAGC9RH514079","listing_id":"0e2f25b8-79fa-4145-8a0f-23aa61ca93b2","stock_type":"Used","certified_preowned":true,"mileage":"15695","sponsored":true,"nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"White","fuel_type":null,"interior_color":"GREY","drivetrain":null,"dealer_name":"Johnstons Subaru","msrp":"34990","dealer_zip":"10940","price":"32490","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"SUV","cpo_indicator":true,"relevancy_score":null,"badges":["fair_deal","cpo"],"canonical_mmt":"Subaru:Forester:Sport","canonical_mmty":"Subaru:Forester:Sport:2024","cpo_package":"Subaru","photo_count":3,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"Limited","make":"Subaru","cat":"crossover_compact","year":"2025","model":"Crosstrek","seller_type":"dealership","customer_id":"113956","vin":"4S4GUHM60S3704423","listing_id":"d47548b5-3881-41cb-8563-c7ef47b80ee2","stock_type":"Used","certified_preowned":true,"mileage":"9065","sponsored":true,"nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"Red","fuel_type":null,"interior_color":"BLACK","drivetrain":null,"dealer_name":"Johnstons Subaru","msrp":"35444","dealer_zip":"10940","price":"33990","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"SUV","cpo_indicator":true,"relevancy_score":null,"badges":["fair_deal","american_made_index_ranking","cpo"],"canonical_mmt":"Subaru:Crosstrek:Limited","canonical_mmty":"Subaru:Crosstrek:Limited:2025","cpo_package":"Subaru","photo_count":3,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"Limited","make":"Subaru","cat":"wagonhatchback_wagon","year":"2022","model":"Outback","seller_type":"dealership","customer_id":"113956","vin":"4S4BTANC0N3271201","listing_id":"489daeb4-17c9-45c2-bee7-2a515ebf4978","stock_type":"Used","certified_preowned":true,"mileage":"31000","sponsored":true,"nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"White","fuel_type":null,"interior_color":null,"drivetrain":null,"dealer_name":"Johnstons Subaru","msrp":"27490","dealer_zip":"10940","price":"26490","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"SUV","cpo_indicator":true,"relevancy_score":null,"badges":["good_deal","cpo"],"canonical_mmt":"Subaru:Outback:Limited","canonical_mmty":"Subaru:Outback:Limited:2022","cpo_package":"Subaru","photo_count":3,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"Premium","make":"Subaru","cat":"crossover_compact","year":"2025","model":"Forester","seller_type":"dealership","customer_id":"113956","vin":"JF2SLDDC2SH495948","listing_id":"6d88ab7a-5c53-4565-9a78-3c2c679790ea","stock_type":"Used","certified_preowned":true,"mileage":"8996","sponsored":true,"nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"Black","fuel_type":null,"interior_color":"BLACK","drivetrain":null,"dealer_name":"Johnstons Subaru","msrp":"35502","dealer_zip":"10940","price":"34490","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"SUV","cpo_indicator":true,"relevancy_score":null,"badges":["fair_deal","cpo"],"canonical_mmt":"Subaru:Forester:Premium","canonical_mmty":"Subaru:Forester:Premium:2025","cpo_package":"Subaru","photo_count":3,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"Premium","make":"Subaru","cat":"crossover_compact","year":"2025","model":"Forester","seller_type":"dealership","customer_id":"113956","vin":"JF2SLDBC6SH504122","listing_id":"d7b7e00d-67b5-4ae2-b091-7d45bf90c4e8","stock_type":"Used","certified_preowned":true,"mileage":"12160","sponsored":true,"nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"GY","fuel_type":null,"interior_color":null,"drivetrain":null,"dealer_name":"Johnstons Subaru","msrp":"34241","dealer_zip":"10940","price":"34241","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"SUV","cpo_indicator":true,"relevancy_score":null,"badges":["fair_deal","cpo"],"canonical_mmt":"Subaru:Forester:Premium","canonical_mmty":"Subaru:Forester:Premium:2025","cpo_package":"Subaru","photo_count":0,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"Sport","make":"Subaru","cat":"crossover_compact","year":"2021","model":"Forester","seller_type":"dealership","customer_id":"113956","vin":"JF2SKARC5MH456980","listing_id":"dcdeb6cf-6ebd-40fe-8d2f-105bf20c497d","stock_type":"Used","certified_preowned":true,"mileage":"48157","sponsored":true,"nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"Blue","fuel_type":null,"interior_color":"GRAY","drivetrain":null,"dealer_name":"Johnstons Subaru","msrp":"25990","dealer_zip":"10940","price":"24990","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"SUV","cpo_indicator":true,"relevancy_score":null,"badges":["good_deal","cpo"],"canonical_mmt":"Subaru:Forester:Sport","canonical_mmty":"Subaru:Forester:Sport:2021","cpo_package":"Subaru","photo_count":0,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"Premium","make":"Subaru","cat":"wagonhatchback_wagon","year":"2025","model":"Outback","seller_type":"dealership","customer_id":"113956","vin":"4S4BTAFC6S3237662","listing_id":"46b3735a-4216-421b-98b5-d5fcb81a614f","stock_type":"Used","certified_preowned":true,"mileage":"9070","sponsored":true,"nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"BK","fuel_type":null,"interior_color":"Black","drivetrain":null,"dealer_name":"Johnstons Subaru","msrp":"36962","dealer_zip":"10940","price":"35990","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"SUV","cpo_indicator":true,"relevancy_score":null,"badges":["fair_deal","cpo"],"canonical_mmt":"Subaru:Outback:Premium","canonical_mmty":"Subaru:Outback:Premium:2025","cpo_package":"Subaru","photo_count":0,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"Sport","make":"Subaru","cat":"crossover_compact","year":"2025","model":"Forester","seller_type":"dealership","customer_id":"113956","vin":"JF2SLDHC6SH505813","listing_id":"b5fec4e6-4699-475f-94d4-31fbc2c14bfd","stock_type":"Used","certified_preowned":true,"mileage":"9111","sponsored":true,"nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"River","fuel_type":null,"interior_color":"GRAY","drivetrain":null,"dealer_name":"Johnstons Subaru","msrp":"38836","dealer_zip":"10940","price":"36990","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"SUV","cpo_indicator":true,"relevancy_score":null,"badges":["fair_deal","cpo"],"canonical_mmt":"Subaru:Forester:Sport","canonical_mmty":"Subaru:Forester:Sport:2025","cpo_package":"Subaru","photo_count":0,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"Sport","make":"Subaru","cat":"crossover_compact","year":"2023","model":"Crosstrek","seller_type":"dealership","customer_id":"113956","vin":"JF2GTHRC5PH295479","listing_id":"8db44fbe-1b4a-4969-8c46-637692cb8dbc","stock_type":"Used","certified_preowned":true,"mileage":"28815","sponsored":true,"nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"White","fuel_type":null,"interior_color":null,"drivetrain":null,"dealer_name":"Johnstons Subaru","msrp":"25990","dealer_zip":"10940","price":"25490","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"SUV","cpo_indicator":true,"relevancy_score":null,"badges":["good_deal","cpo"],"canonical_mmt":"Subaru:Crosstrek:Sport","canonical_mmty":"Subaru:Crosstrek:Sport:2023","cpo_package":"Subaru","photo_count":0,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"Touring XT","make":"Subaru","cat":"wagonhatchback_wagon","year":"2023","model":"Outback","seller_type":"dealership","customer_id":"113956","vin":"4S4BTGPD9P3106856","listing_id":"a782adf8-8721-4541-bc9b-6e1eff69f132","stock_type":"Used","certified_preowned":true,"mileage":"37260","sponsored":true,"nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"Black","fuel_type":null,"interior_color":null,"drivetrain":null,"dealer_name":"Johnstons Subaru","msrp":"0","dealer_zip":"10940","price":"0","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"SUV","cpo_indicator":true,"relevancy_score":null,"badges":["cpo"],"canonical_mmt":"Subaru:Outback:Touring XT","canonical_mmty":"Subaru:Outback:Touring XT:2023","cpo_package":"Subaru","photo_count":0,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"Limited","make":"Subaru","cat":"wagonhatchback_wagon","year":"2023","model":"Outback","seller_type":"dealership","customer_id":"113956","vin":"4S4BTAMC7P3139203","listing_id":"f5e05fe2-928e-4e7b-be87-2f89fc84e392","stock_type":"Used","certified_preowned":true,"mileage":"39732","sponsored":true,"nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"Gray","fuel_type":null,"interior_color":null,"drivetrain":null,"dealer_name":"Johnstons Subaru","msrp":"27990","dealer_zip":"10940","price":"26990","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"SUV","cpo_indicator":true,"relevancy_score":null,"badges":["good_deal","cpo"],"canonical_mmt":"Subaru:Outback:Limited","canonical_mmty":"Subaru:Outback:Limited:2023","cpo_package":"Subaru","photo_count":0,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"Sport","make":"Subaru","cat":"sedan_midsize","year":"2022","model":"Legacy","seller_type":"dealership","customer_id":"113956","vin":"4S3BWAH6XN3006190","listing_id":"50301183-1ae2-4012-98f3-09139e29cfe4","stock_type":"Used","certified_preowned":true,"mileage":"56635","sponsored":true,"nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"Silver","fuel_type":null,"interior_color":"GRAY","drivetrain":null,"dealer_name":"Johnstons Subaru","msrp":"24990","dealer_zip":"10940","price":"23990","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"Sedan","cpo_indicator":true,"relevancy_score":null,"badges":["good_deal","cpo"],"canonical_mmt":"Subaru:Legacy:Sport","canonical_mmty":"Subaru:Legacy:Sport:2022","cpo_package":"Subaru","photo_count":0,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"Limited","make":"Subaru","cat":"wagonhatchback_wagon","year":"2023","model":"Outback","seller_type":"dealership","customer_id":"113956","vin":"4S4BTANC5P3147900","listing_id":"a23f9335-a91b-4c4b-8f73-c3bfa12ae9b9","stock_type":"Used","certified_preowned":true,"mileage":"25618","sponsored":true,"nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"GY","fuel_type":null,"interior_color":null,"drivetrain":null,"dealer_name":"Johnstons Subaru","msrp":"30990","dealer_zip":"10940","price":"29990","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"SUV","cpo_indicator":true,"relevancy_score":null,"badges":["good_deal","cpo"],"canonical_mmt":"Subaru:Outback:Limited","canonical_mmty":"Subaru:Outback:Limited:2023","cpo_package":"Subaru","photo_count":0,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"Wilderness","make":"Subaru","cat":"crossover_compact","year":"2025","model":"Crosstrek","seller_type":"dealership","customer_id":"113956","vin":"4S4GUHU60S3706754","listing_id":"ea321afb-01a5-4c6a-bbe4-929e4073d09c","stock_type":"Used","certified_preowned":true,"mileage":"9047","sponsored":true,"nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"WH","fuel_type":null,"interior_color":null,"drivetrain":null,"dealer_name":"Johnstons Subaru","msrp":"36779","dealer_zip":"10940","price":"35990","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"SUV","cpo_indicator":true,"relevancy_score":null,"badges":["fair_deal","american_made_index_ranking","cpo"],"canonical_mmt":"Subaru:Crosstrek:Wilderness","canonical_mmty":"Subaru:Crosstrek:Wilderness:2025","cpo_package":"Subaru","photo_count":0,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"Premium","make":"Subaru","cat":"sedan_compact","year":"2023","model":"Impreza","seller_type":"dealership","customer_id":"113956","vin":"4S3GTAV65P3710500","listing_id":"d7310014-2a8c-4697-9c21-8647438b70e2","stock_type":"Used","certified_preowned":true,"mileage":"28306","sponsored":true,"nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"BK","fuel_type":null,"interior_color":null,"drivetrain":null,"dealer_name":"Johnstons Subaru","msrp":"22990","dealer_zip":"10940","price":"21990","sponsored_type":"standard","bodystyle":"Hatchback","cpo_indicator":true,"relevancy_score":null,"badges":["good_deal","cpo"],"canonical_mmt":"Subaru:Impreza:Premium","canonical_mmty":"Subaru:Impreza:Premium:2023","cpo_package":"Subaru","photo_count":0,"stock_sub":""}]}]
White 2022 Subaru Forester Wilderness SUV
Subaru Certified
2022 Subaru Forester Wilderness
35,980 mi.
$29,490
Green 2025 Subaru Forester Limited SUV
Subaru Certified
2025 Subaru Forester Limited
20,160 mi.
$33,990
Grey 2021 Subaru Crosstrek Limited SUV
Subaru Certified
2021 Subaru Crosstrek Limited
58,397 mi.
$23,990
Silver 2024 Subaru Forester Limited SUV
Subaru Certified
2024 Subaru Forester Limited
16,281 mi.
$35,490
Blue 2023 Subaru Forester Touring SUV
Subaru Certified
2023 Subaru Forester Touring
46,750 mi.
$29,490
White 2024 Subaru Forester Sport SUV
Subaru Certified
2024 Subaru Forester Sport
15,695 mi.
$32,490
Red 2025 Subaru Crosstrek Limited SUV
Subaru Certified
2025 Subaru Crosstrek Limited
9,065 mi.
$33,990
White 2022 Subaru Outback Limited SUV
Subaru Certified
2022 Subaru Outback Limited
31,000 mi.
$26,490
Black 2025 Subaru Forester Premium SUV
Subaru Certified
2025 Subaru Forester Premium
8,996 mi.
$34,490
No photo available
Subaru Certified
2025 Subaru Forester Premium
12,160 mi.
$34,241
No photo available
Subaru Certified
2021 Subaru Forester Sport
48,157 mi.
$24,990
No photo available
Subaru Certified
2025 Subaru Outback Premium
9,070 mi.
$35,990
No photo available
Subaru Certified
2025 Subaru Forester Sport
9,111 mi.
$36,990
No photo available
Subaru Certified
2023 Subaru Crosstrek Sport
28,815 mi.
$25,490
No photo available
Subaru Certified
2023 Subaru Outback Touring XT
37,260 mi.
Not Priced
No photo available
Subaru Certified
2023 Subaru Outback Limited
39,732 mi.
$26,990
No photo available
Subaru Certified
2022 Subaru Legacy Sport
56,635 mi.
$23,990
No photo available
Subaru Certified
2023 Subaru Outback Limited
25,618 mi.
$29,990
No photo available
Subaru Certified
2025 Subaru Crosstrek Wilderness
9,047 mi.
$35,990
No photo available
Subaru Certified
2023 Subaru Impreza Premium
28,306 mi.
$21,990
  • Prev
  • 1
  • Next

Used cars for sale by city

Used cars for sale in Middletown, NY by make