Save your search and get notified when new inventory arrives.
Contact seller
Customize your budget
    
  *Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.
  
  
  **Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.
  
About your privacy: Cars.com is asking for your ZIP and credit rating because it helps us to make an educated guess at your sales tax and loan interest. These two factors can greatly change your monthly payment.
  Used
  cars
  for sale
  
  
    near
Monticello, NY 
    
  
      - Down Payment
- $0
- Net trade-in value
- $0
- Months
- 72
- APR
- 7.0%
- Sales tax
- 0.0%
    
  *Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.
  
  
  **Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.
  
 
            
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2025 Hyundai SONATA SEL
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2025 Hyundai SANTA FE SEL 2.4
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2021 Toyota Venza Limited
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
These guys Rock!!!
They were able to take care of me with a Lexus GS 350. I had no idea I could afford my dream car, and they made it work for me without having a high monthly bill, or costing me an arm and a leg. They also fixed a few minor issues that came up during the inspection without a problem. Once again Thank you!
I purchased a low mileage pre owned venza xle and it is
I purchased a low mileage pre owned venza xle and it is the nicest car I have owned. Rides like a luxury car, phenomenal gas mileage, decent power, loads of bells and whistles. And top it off with Toyota reliability, I do not regret it at all.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2024 Jeep Compass Trailhawk
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
EXCELLENT EXPERIENCE
What a GREAT experience!!! After a NIGHTMARE dealing with DarCar Lexus of Englewood in NJ, I went right over to Orange County Lexus and am so glad I did!! My husband and I were greeted outside in the lot by Tyler Figueroa, who then proceeded to assist us in showing us a few options. He is very friendly & knowledgeable, making this experience a true pleasure. The whole environment is positive and the rest of the staff are all so friendly and helpful as well. The gentlemen who handles the finance paperwork is also wonderful to work with and I am very thankful to him & Tyler for making this happen. Like i said - the experience at Darcar in Englewood was horrible - Lexus of Orange County was able to erase the negativity felt walking out of that location and provide me with a feeling of complete satisfaction - very pleased with my decision to go here and purchase a vehicle from them. Happy to be part of the Lexus of Orange County family... Thank you!!
Quality car at affordable price.
We purchased a 2024 Jeep Compass Limited Elite. This vehicle has far surpassed our expectations for comfort, handling, road noise and quality. There is very little road noise we hear inside the vehicle, and this allows us to keep the radio turned down to a comfortable level. Handling is exceptional and very responsive. The driver safety features of lane guidance, adaptive cruise control (my favorite) and 360-degree backup camera are now features we will not go without after experiencing first hand performance. Thank you Jeep and Jeff Belzer CDJR of New Prague, MN
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Certified
2024 Toyota Camry LE
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
The service was great wonderful personal and excellent
The service was great wonderful personal and excellent customer service. The experience with Johnson was great I would recommend to other people or family members.
I purchased mine used with 15,000 miles.
I purchased mine used with 15,000 miles. She runs great and I get compliments on her often. Supersonic red with black top. The only reason I purchased this car is because my 2000 Camry is getting hard to find parts for. He still runs great. But, since I do not know when I will need to repair anything expensive on him, I had to get another Camry. For fear of not being able to repair my 2000 Camry (which still looks amazing new). I can vouch that gas powered Toyota's will last forever. Look at all of them on the road. So, I know this one will last forever.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Certified
2024 Lexus NX 350 AWD
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
GREAT SERVICE AT LEXUS IN MIDDLETOWN, NY
We went to Lexus to buy a car and Tyler Figueroa was our salesman. He was perfect from start to finish. He ended up staying 2 hours after closing time to help us complete our sale. He was very knowledgeable and answered all of our questions. He was extremely patient and truly wanted us to be happy with our purchase. He explained all the details that we needed to know to utilize and enjoy our car to its fullest capacity. Amazing! Go see Tyler, you won’t be disappointed!
2024 NX 350 F Sport is a great ride.
2024 NX 350 F Sport has some great options I didn't know I'd ever need. Being able to customize just about everything is great. The Lexus system itself is easy to use but takes getting used to coming from a 2019 Jeep Compass Sport. Heads-up display, the large display screen is great, although I will say the climate controls are a bit awkward to use. It's easy enough to turn off, but turning it on is another issue. The safety features are awesome, from not being able to open the driver door if traffic is coming from behind to the lane assist, I am super happy with it. The F Sport has some giddy-up that is no joke, there are settings you can utilize; Eco, Normal, Sport, and Sport +. Each one has its advantages and disadvantages, but all are top-notch. The interior has a beautiful, sleek design that screams luxury. The only thing it is missing is the panoramic sunroof I am used to. That being said, I am very happy with my purchase.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2016 Lexus GS 350 Base
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Great dealership
Just bought 2021 Nissan Versa from them, couldn't be more pleased with the whole experience. I drove up from Moscow,PA. to make the purchase. Paul S. was great to work with, highly recommend!
Impressed with all the features and engine roar!!
Excellent car that looks awesome and performs even better. Comfortable, speedy and very reliable. Lexus did not go wrong with the GS and the F-Sport package is a MOST HAVE!!
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2025 Toyota Corolla SE
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Fast service and they keep you up to date on work
Fast service and they keep you up to date on work happening with your vehicle.
Decent but not outstanding.
Decent but not outstanding. Had a problem with the passenger side motor mount causing a rattle that was fixed under warranty at the 5000 mi service. The part was backordered, so there are probably more than a few with this problem. A discoloration of the dash appeared by 2000 miles. Since it read "Toy" it was likely from the factory. There is still a small bubble in the rear window tint film. It drives well. I like the automation now that I'm used to it. It brakes too hard using adaptive cruise control when traffic slows down, but I guess the radar is doing as well as it can. It's not particularly comfortable, but Toyotas aren't known for that. Had to turn the driver's headrest around, as it pushes my head too far forward. I think that's required by law. The infotainment center works fine. They started using a new one after the 2024 debacle. I bought the car to keep it for a few hundred thousand miles. We'll see.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2021 Toyota Highlander XLE
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
I had my Tundra serviced , oil change and oil filter, at
I had my Tundra serviced , oil change and oil filter, at Johnston Toyota. Blair is my Service Manager and is great to work with, explained what they were going to do and I was in and out of the shop in a reasonable amount of time. Will continue to use them for my service.
We switched from 4Runner to Highlander!
We switched from 4Runner to Highlander! Many years of Toyota loyalty in our family. Camrys to Tacoma’s we have had them all. I stole my wife’s 4Runner away from her and replaced it with a 2021 Highlander XSE. It’s been awesome. Bought it brand new. We just hit 65k. We drive from northern Idaho to Scottsdale Az all year and at anytime. Yes, anytime. AWD Snowmobile. It’s awesome in the snow! 22-28 MPG on the Hwy. For those worried about driving a wagon looking vessel around that does not have the great looks of the 4Runner? Don’t worry about it. The XSE has a great looking front end. The XSE Model handles great and boogies. Yes, it’s quick and drives like a sports car. Well, it handles well not quite a sports car. Don’t get the regular Highlander. XSE looks different, has the JBL stereo and drives great. AWD with a Snow Mode. Oh, and it had a third row for little ones. Reliability - been amazing. Zero issues.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2024 Toyota RAV4 XLE
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Great Service
Hats off to Melissa Horan for going above & beyond for making my experience in turning my lease in & getting a new car. She went step by step in the whole process, took her time, very friendly & professional. I truly appreciate it U ROCK!!♥️ & to Stephen Berkowitz for working them numbers. Truly magical. Thank you so much.
I went from a corolla cross le gas model to a rav 4
I went from a corolla cross le gas model to a rav 4 hybrid le and there is a major difference in the size and road noise. I love the gas mileage in the rav 4 hybrid. The cabin is very quiet in the rav 4 hybrid. I am glad to recommend the rav 4 hybrid over the corolla cross le gas model.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Certified
2022 Toyota RAV4 XLE
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Excellent experience with the Mackenzie who was not a
Excellent experience with the Mackenzie who was not a high pressure salesman. Very caring and understanding.
Hard to beat
Drove this '22 Rav4 throughout the US SW for over 3000 miles in 2 weeks without any problems and averaged 30+ mpg. Went through CO, UT, NV, CA, AZ, NM. Pleasant to drive and certainly comfortable enough. I have no complaints at the moment, and it doesn't have the CVT!
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2024 Toyota Grand Highlander Limited
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
This car is great for someone who has a small sized
This car is great for someone who has a small sized family. We enjoy the comfort of a large driver seat and captains chairs in the center. We can get a little stuffy in the back but my partner is almost 6 feet tall and most of his family is big too so that’s the only downside. Other than that i love it.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Certified
2020 Toyota Sienna LE
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Great service and it didn’t take long to complete the
Great service and it didn’t take long to complete the job. Very thorough work.
It does it all!
Love the car. Comfortable, reliable and practical! Love the 4 cup holders up front. The electric folding seats in back are also great (limited edition) I’d highly recommend this van
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Certified
2022 Toyota RAV4 Hybrid XLE
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
This is my 3rd RAV4 Hybrid XLE It's a well made vehicle.
This is my 3rd RAV4 Hybrid XLE It's a well made vehicle. Reliable. Comfortable. Efficient. Quiet It has all the comfort features I consider necessary.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2024 GMC Terrain SLT
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
I always bought the GMC Acadia (4 times) but decided to
I always bought the GMC Acadia (4 times) but decided to try the terrain. I absolutely love it and it's a great car for zipping around in town. I would take it for a weekend trip but not on a long trip as it doesn't have a lot of cab room, but for two people it is fine
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2025 BMW 228 Gran Coupe xDrive
Vehicle information
Features
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2022 Honda Odyssey EX-L
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
2022 Honda
Not a big fan of the breaking system which wears out the brakes if you follow vehicles close. Interior storage spaces are much smaller or non existent. Interior much more cheaply made and does not last nearly as long.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2024 Toyota Prius Prime SE
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
It's a fantastic vehicle, both inside and out.
It's a fantastic vehicle, both inside and out. I get about 30-50 electric miles depending on whether I do freeway or side-street driving, what the outdoor temperature is, if I have AC on, etc. I get 50-60 mpg when the engine turns on. It gets to freeway speeds really fast in sport mode, but I normally stay on eco/normal mode - normal mode has more than enough power for my needs. Interior features lack the extra toys from the XSE and Premium trims, but I can live without them. Trunk space is adequate with the folding cover attached and only slightly better without it due to the sloped rear exterior. But I've never had a problem with trunk space since folding down the seats grants more than enough room for my needs. Cabin space is decent. No one in my family and friend group is over 182 cm tall so all of them can fit with ample head and leg room. I have no complaints with the handling, even at higher speeds. It's smooth, but outside noise does get a bit loud especially when the engine turns on. Charging is a tad over nine hours if using a standard 110v/120v L1 charger, and half that with a 220v/240v L2 charger. The Prius Prime is not built to handle DC charging, so don't bother with that. EV mode is good for up to 55 mph or so, and HV mode is good for speeds beyond that. The sweet spot speed for HV mode seems to be around 65-72 mph. Beyond that and efficiency takes a nosedive. The Prius Prime, or any plug-in hybrid (PHEV), isn't for everyone. It's the best of both worlds, but it's also the worst of both worlds. During EV mode, a PHEV is a less efficient battery electric vehicle (BEV) since it's carrying a heavy internal combustion engine (ICE) that isn't being used, along with all the other ICE components. It also has all the maintenance requirements of the standard HEV variant, unlike a true BEV. When the battery is depleted, a PHEV is a worse hybrid since it's carrying a big battery that isn't being used. Despite a PHEV's versatility between gasoline and electric usage, it isn't for everyone. It can run on gasoline only without ever charging the battery, but then you lose all the benefits of EV driving. You paid extra for the EV experience, so you might as well charge the battery. Final thoughts: the Prius Prime is a very good car, but only If you can charge at home. If not, then get the standard Prius since that one is an even more efficient hybrid.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2022 Subaru WRX Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
It's a great car.
It's a great car. Sports car with 4 doors, very maneuverable despite of the AWD. Fun in the mountains and the kids love it. Get the manual drive.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2022 Ford Maverick Lariat
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
I own the 2022 Ford Maverick XLT Hybrid and so far with
I own the 2022 Ford Maverick XLT Hybrid and so far with roughly 28,000 miles on it I love it. Cannot believe the gas mileage that I get. From April thru Nov I am in the upper 40's to low 50's. That is driving in the cities and highways between the cities. Any long travels on the expressway and my mileage drops to the mid to low 30's. When I purchesed it in 2022 I stayed with the standard XLT interior and I do not regred not upgrading it. It is comfortable for a vehicle and it is quiet. I have easily gotten 4 golf bags in the truck bed and 4 golfers in the cab with one of those golfers standing at 6 foot 8 inches. I've also been able to get 2 10 foot kayaks in the bed with no problem. Yes, they extended beyond the tailgate but had no problems. So far I rank my purchase of my 2022 SLT Ford Maverick Hybrid as one of the top two vehicles I've purchased in my life time, and I will be 74 in 2025.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
            Used
2012 Toyota Highlander Base
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Solid reliable SUV
Bought the '12 used with 30k miles on it 9 years ago. It now has 187k and is running great. Regular oil changes and typical maintenance, brakes, tires, etc. The AC did go last year and was fixed. Car is plenty cargo spacious and has been used to move many items, furniture, building materials etc. The only thing I'd like better from it is brighter headlights. If a HIghlander has been maintained I'd not hesitate to pick up a higher mileage used one and expect many more miles.
 
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
       
          
        
      Used
2023 Kia Sportage LX
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Excellent SUV for a mid-size used vehicle the comfort and
Excellent SUV for a mid-size used vehicle the comfort and the way it drives are great very roomy on the inside two thumbs 👍🏾👍🏾 okay KIA
    
  *Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.
  
  
  **Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.
  
Used cars by city
- 
  
    Used cars in Monticello, NY
  
  194 Great Deals out of 949 listings starting at $1,750 
- 
  
    Used cars in Thompson, NY
  
  148 Great Deals out of 782 listings starting at $1,750 
- 
  
    Used cars in South Fallsburg, NY
  
  139 Great Deals out of 714 listings starting at $1,750 
- 
  
    Used cars in Rock Hill, NY
  
  265 Great Deals out of 1309 listings starting at $1,750 
- 
  
    Used cars in Smallwood, NY
  
  168 Great Deals out of 764 listings starting at $3,500 
- 
  
    Used cars in Woodridge, NY
  
  145 Great Deals out of 745 listings starting at $1,750 
- 
  
    Used cars in Forestburgh, NY
  
  288 Great Deals out of 1302 listings starting at $1,500 
- 
  
    Used cars in Fallsburg, NY
  
  136 Great Deals out of 703 listings starting at $1,750 
- 
  
    Used cars in Loch Sheldrake, NY
  
  110 Great Deals out of 523 listings starting at $1,750 
- 
  
    Used cars in Bethel, NY
  
  168 Great Deals out of 764 listings starting at $3,500 
- 
  
    Used cars in Mamakating, NY
  
  317 Great Deals out of 1586 listings starting at $1,750 
- 
  
    Used cars in Wurtsboro, NY
  
  393 Great Deals out of 1994 listings starting at $1,500 
Cars in Monticello, NY by make
- 
  
    Hyundai in Monticello, NY
  
  17 Great Deals out of 119 listings starting at $9,499 
- 
  
    Toyota in Monticello, NY
  
  36 Great Deals out of 113 listings starting at $8,295 
- 
  
    Jeep in Monticello, NY
  
  26 Great Deals out of 105 listings starting at $1,750 
- 
  
    Ford in Monticello, NY
  
  21 Great Deals out of 94 listings starting at $3,500 
- 
  
    Subaru in Monticello, NY
  
  4 Great Deals out of 64 listings starting at $7,000 
- 
  
    Mazda in Monticello, NY
  
  10 Great Deals out of 51 listings starting at $16,402 
- 
  
    Chevrolet in Monticello, NY
  
  6 Great Deals out of 42 listings starting at $10,599 
- 
  
    Honda in Monticello, NY
  
  7 Great Deals out of 39 listings starting at $11,295 
- 
  
    Lexus in Monticello, NY
  
  2 Great Deals out of 39 listings starting at $15,998 
- 
  
    RAM in Monticello, NY
  
  6 Great Deals out of 37 listings starting at $18,500 
- 
  
    Volkswagen in Monticello, NY
  
  14 Great Deals out of 37 listings starting at $7,295 
- 
  
    Nissan in Monticello, NY
  
  10 Great Deals out of 32 listings starting at $4,899 
- 
  
    Mitsubishi in Monticello, NY
  
  26 listings starting at $19,233 
- 
  
    GMC in Monticello, NY
  
  5 Great Deals out of 25 listings starting at $12,500 
- 
  
    Kia in Monticello, NY
  
  2 Great Deals out of 23 listings starting at $12,699 
Find great prices on used cars in Monticello, NY
Fuel types in Monticello, NY
- 
  
    Hybrid cars in Monticello, NY
  
  10111 Great Deals out of 185215 listings 
- 
  
    Electric cars in Monticello, NY
  
  7807 Great Deals out of 94728 listings 
Dealer inventory in Monticello, NY
- 
  
    Nissan Kia of Middletown
  
  25 Great Deals out of 364 listings starting at $4,899 
- 
  
    Honesdale Chrysler Dodge Jeep RAM
  
  44 Great Deals out of 287 listings starting at $15,240 
- 
  
    Middletown Mazda
  
  4 Great Deals out of 285 listings starting at $7,295 
- 
  
    Suresky Chrysler Dodge Jeep Ram
  
  14 Great Deals out of 217 listings starting at $15,595 
- 
  
    Johnstons Toyota
  
  32 Great Deals out of 201 listings starting at $14,589 
- 
  
    Middletown Volkswagen
  
  18 Great Deals out of 196 listings starting at $7,295 
- 
  
    Wayne County Ford
  
  9 Great Deals out of 167 listings starting at $13,995 
- 
  
    Port Jervis Automall
  
  13 Great Deals out of 138 listings starting at $9,649 
- 
  
    Lexus of Orange County
  
  13 Great Deals out of 90 listings starting at $7,998 
- 
  
    Edw. J. Schwarz, Inc.
  
  2 Great Deals out of 53 listings starting at $17,900 
- 
  
    Johnstons Subaru
  
  2 Great Deals out of 45 listings starting at $23,990 
- 
  
    SURESKY HYUNDAI
  
  3 Great Deals out of 44 listings starting at $18,995 
Body styles in Monticello, NY
- ${price_badge()}
- ${ami_badge()}
- ${battery_badge()}${ev_report_link()}
- ${hot_car_badge()}
- ${award_badge()}
- ${cpo_badge()}
${price_badge_description}
${ami_badge_description}
The EV Battery Rating is based on this vehicle's current expected range relative to the vehicles expected range when new. ${battery_badge_text}
This vehicle is certified pre-owned, backed by a manufacturer warranty, and typically undergoes a rigorous multi-point inspection to ensure quality and reliability.
This vehicle is currently in high demand given its competitive price, desirable features, and overall condition, and may have a higher chance of selling quickly.
