Used Cars for Sale in Monticello, NY

$16,995 41,608 mi.

2019 Nissan Altima 2.5 SR

Ext. Color: Blue
Int. Color: Other
Transmission: CVT
Drivetrain: FWD

Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report

Port Jervis Automall Review

Great team!

by Rachel from Port Jervis, NY

December 3, 2018

4.9 (459 reviews)

Everyone is always so helpful and friendly. I recommend PJA to everyone! I wish I purchased my car from them, because it would have saved so many headaches - but I will certainly be purchasing my next vehicle from them!! If their sales department is even half as good as their service department I’ll be happy!!!

2019 Nissan Altima 2.5 SR Review

we love our nissan altima

by amele from hoboken nj

May 14, 2019

our nissan altima is very modern and chic and we are absolutely happy with your decision to lease it. it drives smoothly and we feel comfortable and safe driving it.

See all 20 photos

$14,916 22,250 mi.

2018 Honda Civic LX

Ext. Color: Silver
Int. Color: Black
Transmission: CVT
Drivetrain: FWD

Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report

Compass Motors Review

Love the car and the dealership

by Satisfied buyer from Montgomery, NY

November 5, 2018

2.3 (85 reviews)

I shopped for 4 different makes/models of small SUVs, both by lots of reading and by test driving all of them. I really liked the Mazda CX-5 that I ended up buying. Undoubtedly, my reaction to the car was reinforced by the fact that I also liked the salesperson, Justin, and the finance person, Richard. Both of them made me feel comfortable, answered my many questions, and gave me tons of information without making me feel pressured. All in all, a very positive experience.

2018 Honda Civic LX Review

Great car for the money.

by angelo from PALM BEACH GARDENS

May 14, 2019

Perfect for this stage of my life: dependable, sporty looking, great performance, great mileage and comfortable. the buying experience and price of the vehicle was worth driving to Davie, Fl.

See all 21 photos

$19,237 3,895 mi.

2019 Mazda CX-3 Sport

Ext. Color: Gray
Int. Color: Black
Transmission: Automatic
Drivetrain: AWD

Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report

Authorized Mazda Dealer

Check Availability

Call

See more details

Compass Motors Review

Excellent service

by Dieter Langendorf from Hampstead MD

November 5, 2018

2.3 (85 reviews)

We bought over the years 3 cars from Compass. Their service is outstanding. Even though we live in Baltimore we go back to Compass. Last service visit was on 5/31/16. We got an appointment on 24 hour notice. In Baltimore we called a dealer 3 times left word but no one called back. Finally we were able to get a live person who told us the earliest available date was in 3 weeks. Compass sent a confirming message and even followed up with a telephone call. The service adviser thoroughly explained the service work and suggested when to do future work. The car went in with one of the tire valve cover missing. When I got it back a new one had been put on. I never expected such attention to detail. They performed all work perfectly. Dieter Langendorf

2019 Mazda CX-3 Sport Review

Great

by Whalerjohn from Saint Augustine FL

April 22, 2019

I have had this car for a few months and very happy. Great gas mileage and comfortable No problems and my son bought a cx3 touring and he has been happy also

See all 3 photos

$7,495 81,535 mi.

2009 Saab 9-3 2.0T

HOT CAR

Ext. Color: Gray
Int. Color: Black
Transmission: Automatic
Drivetrain: FWD

Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report

Lexus of Orange County Review

I'm driving my dream car!!

by -nicole from DealerRater.com

December 3, 2018

4.7 (550 reviews)

Melissa and the entire team at prestige that was involved in helping me during the process of getting a brand new 2018 IS 350 were so nice, and made my experience very quick and easy! I have been trying to buy a new car for about a year now and no other dealership was able to get me the car i wanted in my price range. Within the first 15 min of sitting with Melissa she was able to get me the exact car I wanted (in an even better upgraded model) in my price range. Melissa even took the time to sit with me in the car and connected my phone and showed me how everything works. I could not have asked for a better experience!! Prestige Lexus of middletown was for sure the easiest and best car buying experience i have ever had! I highly recommend them!!

2009 Saab 9-3 2.0T Review

Insane not to buy a SAAB!!

by 'SAAB STORIES' from Greenwood, SC

January 4, 2019

The SAAB 9 3 is an amazing little sports car! As nice as any Acura or BMW. Great handling, quick and responsive, and the best part, you won't see another sitting across from you at the traffic light. You would have to be insane not to purchase a low mileage SAAB, they are a quarter of the price of any other luxury sedan. Better enjoy now before all the good ones are gone!

See all 3 photos

$7,795 86,794 mi.

2012 Volkswagen Jetta SE

HOT CAR

Ext. Color: Gray
Int. Color: Black
Transmission: Automatic
Drivetrain: FWD

Free CARFAX Report

Lexus of Orange County Review

Tokyo...We have a problem!

by R Hoskins from DealerRater.com

December 3, 2018

4.7 (550 reviews)

Vehicles today are technologically complex pieces of (hopefully) highly efficient machinery. When there is a problem, one needs to be able to depend on the experts nearby. Introducing Joseph Scalo and the experts that work with him. My RX350 had a problem that just a handful of vehicles have had in the US. The technicians at Prestige Lexus of Middletown worked tirelessly to resolve the issue, but even the best need to call on those with a more in-depth knowledge of the technical idiosyncrasies that arise. They brought in a cou[ple of engineers from Japan, where my Lexus was built, to assess the situation. Smart move! With a painstaking, multi-facitted approach, coupled with ???state of the art??? equipment, the issue was put to rest. I am happy to say that I have my beautiful RX back where it belongs...home. It takes a team of true professionals to recognize and resolve problems, working outside the normal comfort zone of ???in house??? talent. There is plenty of talent at Middletown Lexus, and it shines...especially when they have to think ???outside the box.??? Thanks to you Joe, and the entire Lexus team around the world.

2012 Volkswagen Jetta SE Review

TDI Kicks a$$

by HarryVaner from Baja, Georgia

May 7, 2019

A very refined car and engine considering it’s a diesel. Drives well and the interior was immaculate. The outside has some very minor paint flaws but overall this car was well worth 10K. Only 32000 miles. Excellent fuel mileage. Very happy with this purchase for a first car teen. Great six speed gear box too. Full manufacturers bumper to bumper warranty for peace of mind.

See all 21 photos

$7,991 112,529 mi.

2015 Hyundai Elantra Sport

Ext. Color: Silver
Int. Color: Gray
Transmission: Automatic
Drivetrain: FWD

W. S. Healey Chevrolet, Buick

Free AutoCheck Report

W. S. Healey Chevrolet, Buick Review

Healey saved the day for us

by Chris Chorney from Meriden, CT

December 3, 2018

4.8 (307 reviews)

Gotta give huge shout-out to the hero of the day, Dan the service tech genius at Healey Brothers Chevy Buick in Middletown, NY. While installing a 5th wheel hitch on my new GMC Sierra Saturday, the tech at a nearby RV place accidentally severed some of the wires that power the back end of the truck...suddenly we had no gas gauge, ABS brakes, tail lights, blinkers, brake lights or trailer brake controller. Without trailer brakes, we cannot tow a camper. So there we were, unable to tow the camper we just bought, the RV dealership unable to resolve the problem and the nearest GMC dealership already closed. We were "this close" to going home empty handed and broken hearted. Healey was on the way home so we stopped in without an appointment to see if they would even look at our GMC and if they could find the problem and fix it before they closed. Seth Goldberg took is in and 90 minutes later, Dan had replaced 9 severed wires in the wiring harness and we had our truck back to health. This allowed us to go back and take our RV home... 2 hours away in central Ct. That's right, they took us in and repaired our truck and we weren't a customer who had bought our truck from them, we had a vehicle that they don't even carry, we didn't have an appointment, and we came in an hour and a half before close on a Saturday. Great customer service makes all the difference in the world.

2015 Hyundai Elantra Sport Review

owned Hyundai previously and loved it.

by Mary Moore from Evington, VA

February 8, 2019

Have not had it long enough to make an informed decision about the car, but so far am loving it and enjoying driving it. Looks really great.

See all 73 photos

Acura Certified

$24,496 19,101 mi.

2017 Acura RDX Base

Ext. Color: Black
Int. Color: Black
Transmission: Automatic
Drivetrain: AWD

Friendly Acura Of Middletown

Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report

Authorized Acura Dealer

Friendly Acura Of Middletown Review

Sales

by Dan from Monroe, NY

December 3, 2018

3.9 (8 reviews)

Came in to test drive and was treated very fairly by the sales stuff...also had a good selection of cars to choose from. I would recommend this dealer.

2017 Acura RDX Base Review

Classy and Sporty SUV

by JenMcc from Huntington Beach, CA

March 3, 2019

I love the way the RDX drives and feels. I just bought one with 13K miles on it and it looks brand new. The interior feels nice and not cheap. The seats are perfect for long drives and the heated seats are a must have. It has very capable horsepower when you need it. I love the 6 cyl. engine and the handling is amazing. It can turn on a dime and the steering is effortless. My only complaint is the infotainment system. I feel like Acura could have put a better stereo system and a touch screen infotainment system in the car. I didn't get the Tech Package because I didn't like the navigation. It was not user friendly and wasn't a touch screen display. I feel like the price for the Tech Package wasn't worth it. Hopefully Acura will address this on their RDX models in the future. Overall, I feel like I paid a great price for a luxury SUV that performs better than the competition. The interior and exterior is good quality and looks beautiful. Most of my friends that have BMWs were very impressed with my RDX. I hope it last me many years.

See all 28 photos

$28,991 54,270 mi.

2011 Dodge Ram 2500 ST

Ext. Color: Green
Int. Color: Gray
Transmission: Automatic
Drivetrain: 4x4/4-wheel drive

W. S. Healey Chevrolet, Buick

Free AutoCheck Report

W. S. Healey Chevrolet, Buick Review

New Car Experience

by Phillip from Slate Hill, NY

November 5, 2018

4.8 (307 reviews)

All representatives were knowledgable, courteous and kind. The experience was efficient and quick. No pressure and very good deal. Will return with future business.

2011 Dodge Ram 2500 ST Review

Best truck ever

by Diesel girl from GRAY

February 3, 2019

I'm so excited today because I was able to use my 4 wheel drive to pull my brother dodge 2500 plus camper hooked up to his truck out from being stuck in moist yard.. my truck is my baby it's a xxxx good truck..my truck is a 2014 but it wouldn't let me put it up there..

See all 3 photos

$15,995 93,404 mi.

2008 Toyota Sequoia SR5

Ext. Color: Silver
Int. Color: Gray
Transmission: Automatic
Drivetrain: 4x4/4-wheel drive

Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report

Lexus of Orange County Review

Wonderful Team

by Nancy651 from DealerRater.com

November 6, 2018

4.7 (550 reviews)

We leased our Lexus in March 2017, car was totaled 3 months later on a Tuesday in June. Scott and Kevin had us in our new lease by Saturday. Unbelievable how smoothly and quickly we were taken care of. What a great group of people to work with👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👏👏👏👏👏👏

2008 Toyota Sequoia SR5 Review

I was amazed at the condition of this vehicle

by Peppy from Allentown p.a.

April 2, 2019

The motor and physical appearance both in and out looked amazing! This 2008 Toyota Sequoia ran like it was never used even though it has 80,000 miles my family and I love it and will enjoy it for sure

See all 29 photos

$23,995 23,154 mi.

2017 Volvo XC60 T5 Dynamic

Great Deal

Ext. Color: Red
Int. Color: Other
Transmission: Automatic
Drivetrain: AWD

Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report

Lexus of Orange County Review

Great service

by LIUHUIZI999 from DealerRater.com

December 3, 2018

4.7 (550 reviews)

I have visited this dealer several times and everytime I feel very comfortable about the service. Joe is always friendly and professional. I look forward to having my new car serviced here for many years to come. Melissa helped me get my pre-owned ES350. I just like her a lot, and didn???t even bargain about the displayed price, not even one penny.😉

2017 Volvo XC60 T5 Dynamic Review

2018 Volvo XC60

by Bart K. from Kansas City, MO

December 23, 2018

Just downsized from an XC90 and I just love this SUV. Has many features I have in an S60. Very sporty and easy to maneuver.

See all 5 photos

$4,000 117,000 mi.

2012 Jeep Patriot Sport

Ext. Color: Gray
Int. Color: Black
Transmission: CVT
Drivetrain: 4x4/4-wheel drive

CARFAX Report

Adam (Private Seller)

22 mi. from 12701

Check Availability

See more details

2012 Jeep Patriot Sport Review

Car has low miles and still a terrific vehicle.

by weiercd from Wake Forest,NC

January 18, 2019

This car is a great commuter vehicle and good on gas. It has room for 4 people comfortably or 5 if needed. The rear of the vehicle has plenty of open space for storage travel. The jeep is still clean, in good condition and has a like new set of tires on it.

$17,489 22,850 mi.

2017 Kia Optima LX

Ext. Color: Black
Int. Color: Other
Transmission: Automatic
Drivetrain: FWD

Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report

Nissan Kia of Middletown

Authorized Kia Dealer

Check Availability

Call

See more details

Nissan Kia of Middletown Review

Secretary

by Melonie from Ellenville, New York

November 6, 2018

4.2 (53 reviews)

Staff members were very friendly and helpful. They helped me find a car that was best for me. They accommodated my work schedule and answered all of my questions. It was a positive experience.

2017 Kia Optima LX Review

Very reliable car

by Shelton from San diego

May 6, 2019

This was a great car! Amazing gas mileage and very reliable. I highly recommend this car for anyone that's looking for a affordable car that has great gas mileage.

See all 25 photos

$10,989 40,179 mi.

2018 Ford Fiesta SE

Ext. Color: White
Int. Color: Black
Transmission: Automatic
Drivetrain: FWD

Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report

Nissan Kia of Middletown

Nissan Kia of Middletown Review

Ray Purvis is a car guru!

by Arlene S. from Otisville, NY

November 5, 2018

4.2 (53 reviews)

Walked into Nissan Kia half knowing and half not knowing what I wanted. Took poor Ray on a roller coaster ride of ideas and thoughts going on in my head. Want the safety of a subaru as my 11 yo daughter drives everywhere with me, but wanted the bigger space of the Kia Sorrento to be able to move things if needed. I was so confused about exactly what I wanted plus being a single mom had a limit on funds to spend. I thought for sure Ray was going to think I was nuts. He sat there quietly for awhile and did some research on his own. Within 10 minutes, he walked me to the car of my dreams and affordable at that! Walked into the dealership with my head spinning and walked out with my head on cloud nine driving away in a car just right for me and my Abby Girl! Thank you Ray! You rocked our world!!!!!!! LOL!

2018 Ford Fiesta SE Review

Love this car

by cowhit9443 from Menifee, CA

April 30, 2019

I look at a lot of reviews before I picked a car. This car is the one that meant all my needs. The only down side is that the back set isn't very roomy.

See all 26 photos

$11,995 103,817 mi.

2014 Volkswagen CC VR6 Executive 4Motion

Ext. Color: Blue
Int. Color: Beige
Transmission: Automatic
Drivetrain: AWD

Healey Ford Lincoln & Mitsubishi

Free AutoCheck Report

Healey Ford Lincoln & Mitsubishi Review

Alex Marrero - (Classical Piano Lessons)

by Alexander from Blooming Grove, New York

November 5, 2018

4.8 (375 reviews)

Although I did not have an appointment, Joseph Kruger accommodated me immediately, and within 2 hours of my visit, I had a driver's side low beam headlight replaced on my Oxford White 2011 Ford Fiesta SES Sedan.

2014 Volkswagen CC VR6 Executive 4Motion Review

Under-rated beautiful fun vehicle

by MaxiFFTSB from Arlington, TX

April 14, 2019

This is just an awesome car. I own 2 of them. Whoever wrote you should skip the AWD and the 3.6L engine should not write any more inaccurate reviews. The only truth in the article is that the rear seat area is a bit small. Ok- now show me anothe similar size - Audi, Mercedes, MMW that isn’t. Buy it because it is dependable , fun to drive, fast and maneuverable, safe, and gets about 17 mpg. It’s also nowhere as expensive as the other 3 listed here, and looks better than most of them too. Don’t buy a car for the label, like a Merecedes , I drove the Mercedes and then bought the VW. Better performance and was more comfortable for my wife and I. I view it as a 2 seat car- room for small adults in back seat. But an exceptionally good purchase. Both my cars have about 100k miles, have been well cared for , and look and drive like new. I’m not sure why cut downs on this but don’t be fooled. This is a sleeper, a hidden gem. Drive the 3.6L 4-motion and you’ll never look back at the 2.0. I have also owned a TT coupe, and still have a2006 A4. This is the fastest and most comfortable car.

$8,900 86,400 mi.

2011 Buick Regal CXL

Ext. Color: Blue
Int. Color: Beige
Transmission: Automanual
Drivetrain: FWD

CARFAX Report

2011 Buick Regal CXL Review

This would be the car for me if I just drove.

by Biff98 from Thunder Bay, ON

April 13, 2019

My father bought this car new and I inherited it. Had it for about 4 years. Ours was the base 2.4 L. I loved driving it once I was in it. If you are 6 ft or over you'll probably bonk your head a lot getting in. Even that was OK but if you want a roof rack or want to tow something forget it. This car is for getting from point A to point B and back. There are threaded holes intended for a GM roof rack but I learned that the plan for that rack was dropped. This car never let us down. Started every day in the winter and we never plugged in the block heater. Often -30 C. We put snows on it and maybe because of it's weight the Regal almost seemed happy going thru snowy conditions. Great handling car. Only selling it to a friend (which is meaningful) because we are getting an SUV. I know Buick will hate this, but if I were my father's age when he bought (82) it I buy another one in a minute.

See all 18 photos

$10,995 61,679 mi.

2016 Nissan Sentra SV

Ext. Color: White
Int. Color: Gray
Transmission: CVT
Drivetrain: FWD

CARFAX Report

2016 Nissan Sentra SV Review

Great reliability. Lot's of room

by Scott dod from SAN DIEGO

May 15, 2019

This car was bought to get me to work. 100 miles rt each day. Also took it sightseeing throughout southwest. Averaged 34 mpg or more. So great on gas. Enjoyed the sound and comfort. Love the backup camera. Good roomy trunk with fold down back seats. All around solid car.

See all 28 photos

$36,995 16,218 mi.

2017 Lincoln Continental Reserve

Ext. Color: Black
Int. Color: Black
Transmission: Automatic
Drivetrain: AWD

Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report

Wayne County Ford Review

Didn't have what I was looking for but good experi

by Scott from Walnutport, pa

November 6, 2018

2.8 (21 reviews)

Nice people to deal with, didn't have what I was looking for and didn't try to push anything else

2017 Lincoln Continental Reserve Review

The American luxury car is back

by PaulinAL from Anniston, AL

May 15, 2019

From the moment I first saw the Continental on the turntable at the 2016 auto show I knew I had to have one. Had to wait until someone else took the initial depreciation on one of the first 2017s to be able to afford to make it happen. Acquired mine 10 days ago and I’m completely blown away by Ford’s flawless execution of this awesome vehicle. Every day spent behind the wheel it impresses me in some new unexpected way. So glad to see this amazing machine get the recognition it deserves w the recent #1 rating in the luxury category - if that doesn’t impress you, let me remind you of a couple of “slightly” more expensive sedans it beat out for those bragging rights: Mercedes S Series, BMW 7 series, etc. And did I mention I get 25 mpg on the highway burning REGULAR fuel w its nimble 335 hp twin turbo EcoBoost V6?? Go back to American luxury and buy a stunningly beautiful Lincoln Continental - you will NOT be disappointed

See all 16 photos

Chevrolet Certified

$24,900 5,000 mi.

2017 Chevrolet Malibu Premier

Ext. Color: Gray
Int. Color: Beige
Transmission: Automatic
Drivetrain: FWD

Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report

Edw. J. Schwarz, Inc.

Edw. J. Schwarz, Inc. Review

Edward Osnick

by Edward Osnick from Atco, Pa.

December 3, 2018

4.9 (28 reviews)

Excellent service as always. Totally satisfied and plan to return for service as needed.

2017 Chevrolet Malibu Premier Review

I'm loving it

by Nikki from Dallas, tx

April 27, 2019

This car has so far met my needs with gas mileage, comfort, leg room. It's very spacious and I must say I love that as soon as you turn off the car it reminds you to check the rear seats. No child left behind

See all 15 photos

Buick Certified

$20,500 24,000 mi.

2019 Buick Encore Sport Touring

Great Deal

Ext. Color: White
Int. Color: Black
Transmission: Automatic
Drivetrain: AWD