Sort

Used Subaru Forester for Sale in Middletown, NY

See all 24 photos
Used

2020 Subaru Forester

265 mi.
$26,299
GREAT DEAL $2,423 Under
  • Ext. Color: White
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
Hershey's Auto Inc.
() -
(845) 694-7994
4.8 (31 reviews)
16 mi. from 10940
Check Availability
Call
Hershey's Auto Inc. Review
2016 Ford Transit Wagon XLT 150
by Kevin F. from Boston, MA
November 6, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.8 (31 reviews)
I purchased my 2016 Ford Transit Wagon XLT 150 from Hershey's Auto Inc. in Monroe, NY. The van had less than 10000 miles on it and looks brand new. Hershey's beat the next closest used van by $5000 and they were better than the purchase price of a new van by $10000 (even after Ford's standard discount incentives). The van I was looking for was very specific. I wanted a passenger van with the short wheel base and a medium roof. Hershey's had the van on their lot and it was nicely equipped with the XLT package. The factory tinted windows are very important on a passenger van. I negotiated the deal on the phone with Joel. The price was exactly as Joel stated when I arrived at the dealership. Solomon picked me up at the bus station (I travelled in from Boston, MA). Hershey (the owner) personally thanked me for my purchased and followed up on any questions that I had. I was able to drive the van home with New York temporary plates.
See all 22 photos
Used

2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

82,885 mi.
$15,799
GOOD DEAL
  • Ext. Color: Silver
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
Hershey's Auto Inc.
() -
(845) 694-7994
4.8 (31 reviews)
16 mi. from 10940
Check Availability
Call
Hershey's Auto Inc. Review
Purchase
by ShaneGenna from DealerRater.com
December 3, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.8 (31 reviews)
I highly recommend Hershey auto for your next car buying. Very straight forward No Hidden fee plus they???ll help u get the best APR This was my third car financing and it???s the best experience and service I have ever had they making buying a car very easily Very friendly staff
2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium Review
Perfect for families
by Rodriguez from Reading
April 10, 2019
5
This car its all we were expecting. A lot of space in the back . Its perfect for families. I just loved everything off it.
See all 32 photos
Used

2011 Subaru Forester 2.5X Premium

67,813 mi.
$10,997
GOOD DEAL $365 Under
LOCAL HOME DELIVERY
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: Blue
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: Automatic
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX Report
Superior Auto Sales
() -
(845) 764-9523
4.8 (19 reviews)
17 mi. from 10940
Check Availability
Call
Superior Auto Sales Review
Superior Auto is the best place to go!!!!!!!!!!!!!
by John Newvine from New windsor NY
November 5, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.8 (19 reviews)
Was shopping around the area looking for a good, reliable used car and happen to stumble upon a dealership across the street from where I live. I walked in and felt very welcomed and everyone was happy to help especially Brandon he gave me everything I was looking for to buy a used truck and I couldn't be more happier with the outcome I went from driving a 1998 mercury sable to a 2003 ford f-150 for a very reasonable price and i recommend this dealership is you're looking for a good deal.
2011 Subaru Forester 2.5X Premium Review
Road warrior
by Gees subaru from New York
April 5, 2019
5
Excellent performer in bad weather. Has a terrific ride & it is very comfortable on long trips & can swallows all your gear. This is my go to vehicle for road trips
See all 47 photos
Used

2011 Subaru Forester 2.5X Premium

159,004 mi.
$6,859
GOOD DEAL $373 Under
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: Green
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: Automatic
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX Report
Ron Motor Inc.
() -
(973) 287-4458
2 (4 reviews)
19 mi. from 10940
Check Availability
Call
2011 Subaru Forester 2.5X Premium Review
Has done everything asked, I service it frequently
by Subaru guy from Arlington VA
March 15, 2019
5
Subaru made this car to last! I expect to have it another 10 years. Buy a used one if you can find one. Not as good gas mileage as the newer ones but solidly built
See all 32 photos
Used

2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Touring

30,903 mi.
$20,997
  • Ext. Color: Gray
  • Int. Color: Brown
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
Northway Auto Group
() -
(973) 552-4949
4.5 (15 reviews)
21 mi. from 10940
Check Availability
Call
2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Touring Review
Great car!
by Mark from Toano
May 12, 2019
5
This is a great vehicle and we're so glad that we purchased one. We've had a couple of minor things go wrong that should not have such as the drivers side visor starting to squeak loudly. All said we are very happy with this car. On the down side there is now standard technology out there that is not available. Automatic wipers are missing and items like remote start and subaru's safety and security package are extra when Honda includes them both free. But my biggest issue is not the car it's that there is no convenient dealersl or service anywhere near me. The nearest service is 45 minutes away. The next car will have to be available locally.
See all 32 photos
Used

2018 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

28,275 mi.
$20,000
  • Ext. Color: Gray
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
Northway Auto Group
() -
(973) 552-4949
4.5 (15 reviews)
21 mi. from 10940
Check Availability
Call
2018 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium Review
My 2nd Subaru Forester
by Dave in Mansfield from Mansfield, TXD
May 16, 2019
5
My 1st Forester is a 2009 turbocharged model which is still going strong with 110,000 miles. The newer Foresters offer safety and convenience features mine doesn't have so I decided to upgrade. The 2019 Forester no longer offers the turbocharged version so I opted for a certified pre-owned 2018 XT Touring which has a turbocharger. I love the vehicle but because the turbo is no longer available, the used turbo versions have become quite pricey. I am keeping the old one for hauling dogs, lawn equipment and towing my utility trailer. The new one will be just for people for now. The vehicle is just the right size. I am 6'4" and would appreciate a little more leg room and thigh support but the Forester is as comfortable as any other small SUV I checked. There is plenty of headroom. The turbo does require premium fuel and has a lower mileage rating. With the turbo and sports tuned suspension, it is a fun vehicle to drive and worth the money to me. In over 10 years, the older one left me stranded only once when a drive belt broke after 100,000 miles. Based on reviews, I expect the same reliability from the newer one.
See all 32 photos
Used

2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

36,832 mi.
$17,777
  • Ext. Color: Green
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
Northway Auto Group
() -
(973) 552-4949
4.5 (15 reviews)
21 mi. from 10940
Check Availability
Call
2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium Review
Subaru is the new Volvo!
by aaallrighty from Cape May NJ
May 3, 2019
5
Have owned 2 Volvos and the company lost it's spark. Subaru has that spot in my heart now. From the 5 star crash rating (except front passenger seat is 4 star) to great reliability records and good tech stuff I am thrilled.
See all 32 photos
Used

2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

29,601 mi.
$17,797
  • Ext. Color: Red
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
Northway Auto Group
() -
(973) 552-4949
4.5 (15 reviews)
21 mi. from 10940
Check Availability
Call
2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium Review
Great all around suv
by jrgrey from Liberty, PA
April 11, 2019
5
Excellent vision in all directions from the Forester. We like the no non-sense styling of the Touring 2.5i. Easy to get into and out of which matters if getting a few years on you. Very good gas mileage and handling with excellent performance. The AWD is certainly one of many key selling points. Fit and finish is excellent with very good reliability so far. We think it is a excellent SUV and would definitely purchase another Subaru SUV if needed.
See all 32 photos
Used

2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Limited

51,886 mi.
$18,697
  • Ext. Color: Silver
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
Northway Auto Group
() -
(973) 552-4949
4.5 (15 reviews)
21 mi. from 10940
Check Availability
Call
2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Limited Review
All Around Quality
by FeliciaG. from Brooklyn NY
April 7, 2019
5
This car is reliable, sturdy, comfortable and has many safety features. It still looks and drives like new after 2 years . Low maintenance and great gas mileage !
See all 17 photos
Used

2012 Subaru Forester 2.5X

102,334 mi.
$9,000
GOOD DEAL $566 Under
LOCAL HOME DELIVERY
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: White
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: Automatic
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
Cervone's Auto Sales
() -
(845) 206-4777
24 mi. from 10940
Check Availability
Call
2012 Subaru Forester 2.5X Review
Beautiful and durable vehicle.
by Rebecca from Minnetonka
December 15, 2018
5
This car meets and exceeds all of my needs. I looked an numerous wagon-like models, because my old car was . VW Passat wagon. I looked at the Outback and the Forester, and immediately chose the Forester because of the feeling of space (more head room, bigger windows, and the moon roof).
See all 16 photos
Used

2010 Subaru Forester 2.5X

86,864 mi.
$8,995
GREAT DEAL $1,259 Under
  • Ext. Color: Silver
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: Automatic
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX Report
Sound Motors
() -
(800) 837-1790
3.5 (4 reviews)
27 mi. from 10940
Check Availability
Call
2010 Subaru Forester 2.5X Review
Great car to own
by Jamie from Boise idaho
February 22, 2019
4
This car is exactly what i was looking for. Despite the higher mileage, i am certain this car will last me the time that i need it to
See all 18 photos
Used

2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i

58,386 mi.
$15,995
GOOD DEAL $134 Under
HOT CAR
  • Ext. Color: Silver
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
Sound Motors
() -
(800) 837-1790
3.5 (4 reviews)
27 mi. from 10940
Check Availability
Call
2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i Review
Third Subaru I have owned
by cwvaughan48 from Tioga, Texas
April 29, 2019
5
Great dependable cars...I have one with 265K on it and as soon as I have the radiator replaced I will give to the grandkids. Comment
See all 26 photos
Used

2020 Subaru Forester Sport

12,059 mi.
$29,382
GOOD DEAL
HOT CAR
LOCAL HOME DELIVERY
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: White
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free AutoCheck Report
Healey Chevrolet
() -
(845) 827-1088
4.9 (236 reviews)
28 mi. from 10940
Check Availability
Call
Healey Chevrolet Review
I had a great experience with my salesman Joe Vasq
by Corrine Stuetzle from Wingdale, N.Y.
December 3, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.9 (236 reviews)
I purchased a 2017 Chevrolet Trax from the salesman Joe Vasquez. I would recommend him to everyone, he explained everything to me. Great salesman
See all 19 photos
Used

2015 Subaru Forester 2.5i Limited

95,367 mi.
$13,500
GOOD DEAL $850 Under
  • Ext. Color: Green
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free AutoCheck Report
Dutchess Chrysler Jeep Dodge RAM Mitsubishi Kia
() -
(845) 244-6063
3.3 (30 reviews)
29 mi. from 10940
Check Availability
Call
Dutchess Chrysler Jeep Dodge RAM Mitsubishi Kia Review
Loyal Customer for a reason
by W. Burtchell from Westtown, NY
November 6, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 3.3 (30 reviews)
Leased two vehicles here so far and sent several friends here who also purchased. Prices are unbeatable, Service was top notch and I will be returning in the future. No need to look anywhere else.
2015 Subaru Forester 2.5i Limited Review
Very reliable
by Mr suburu 1 from Kcmo
May 10, 2019
5
Dream car.love it .plenty of space, comfortable, powerful vehicle as well. I see my self recommending the same vehicle to other ppeople as well.why not..?
See all 30 photos
Used

2018 Subaru Forester 2.5i

26,223 mi.
$19,900
GOOD DEAL
LOCAL HOME DELIVERY
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: Blue
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
Friendly Ford
() -
(866) 505-9533
4.9 (121 reviews)
29 mi. from 10940
Check Availability
Call
Friendly Ford Review
Ford F150 - new car purchase review
by Arthur Dziekan from Hannacroix, NY
December 3, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.9 (121 reviews)
I live an hour and 20 minutes away and I'm glad I made the trip. I was shopping for a new Ford F150 for a while and I was disappointed with the dealerships closer to home. At Friendly Ford, I found better selection, better deals and friendly and helpful Staff. I'm very happy with my purchase and the way I was treated at Friendly Ford. The salesperson who worked with me was Kharhy Ghee (his name is not available in the drop down below).
2018 Subaru Forester 2.5i Review
Steer clear of Bloomington Subaru
by AimeeJ from Minneapolis MN
May 8, 2019
4
Great car, but battery died after 6 months and Bloomington Subaru didn't make it easy to get it replaced. This is a known issue with Foresters.
See all 31 photos
Used

2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

144,854 mi.
$12,795
GREAT DEAL $2,007 Under
  • Ext. Color: Black
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
613Auto.com
() -
(888) 537-3877
4.5 (32 reviews)
17 mi. from 10940
Check Availability
Call
613Auto.com Review
GREAT CUSTOMER SERVICE
by Aryeh from ellenville, ny
November 5, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.5 (32 reviews)
I reached out for a quite and info regarding one of the cars on their lot. So far have received amazing service. I intend on going in to buy next week and will leave another review then!
2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium Review
Feel that this is a very safe and comfortable car
by CAL from Alameda, CA
March 19, 2019
5
I like the comfort and the visibility of this car. All who have ridden in it feel that it’s comfortable too. Love the eyesight package which gives warnings regarding blind spots and so forth. Find it very easy to parallel park. My only complaint is that the audio controls aren’t intuitive to use, at least for me.
See all 25 photos
Used

2015 Subaru Forester 2.5i

52,148 mi.
$15,100
FAIR PRICE
  • Ext. Color: White
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
Reliable Auto Sales
() -
(914) 906-2147
4.9 (27 reviews)
28 mi. from 10940
Check Availability
Call
Reliable Auto Sales Review
Great Service, great people.
by Henry A. from Middletown NY
November 6, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.9 (27 reviews)
Bought a 2003 Acura TL from here, and it was a very great experience. The man who owns it treated us very well and I got a great deal on the car. I've never been to an auto/repair shop that takes so much great care of the customers that come there and I would definitely recommend this place to anyone looking for repairs or even looking for a nice car.
2015 Subaru Forester 2.5i Review
Subaru Forester 2015
by Angie from Buff ny
April 20, 2019
5
Reliable, attractive, durable, safe, comfortable, all weather, slick design. All my cars have been from the Subaru family and all of my family has owned Subaru’s
JUST ADDED
Used

2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Limited

69,000 mi.
$18,000
  • Ext. Color: Green
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
Premier Auto Sales
() -
(845) 245-2419
4.3 (29 reviews)
18 mi. from 10940
Check Availability
Call
Premier Auto Sales Review
Great Car, Great Experience
by Jferguson from New York
November 6, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.3 (29 reviews)
I purchased a nice clean Nissan Altima from these guys a few months ago. They were able to get me a great approval for financing and even an extended warranty that will cover me for quite some time. I'll definitely be back when it's time for my next car.
2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Limited Review
3rd Time Subaru Buyer
by AdinaT from Stuart, FL
February 22, 2019
5
Just bought a new to me Forester and I couldn't be happier. Subaru hasn't let me down yet...this is my 3rd one and I can't imagine driving anything else. It's safe, reliable and sporty!
Subaru Certified

2018 Subaru Forester

40,195 mi.
Not Priced
  • Ext. Color: Blue
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
Johnstons Subaru
() -
(845) 394-2377
3.6 (33 reviews)
2 mi. from 10940
Call
Johnstons Subaru Review
Problem fixed!
by RichPat from Highland, NY
December 3, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 3.6 (33 reviews)
Problem removing ignition key from 1917 Outback. Dealer where car was purchased did not fix it as they could not make it happen over a full day of trying. Problem continued intermittently, so we went to another Subaru dealer which identified the problem and fixed it. Very pleased.
2018 Subaru Forester Review
Best car for everyday driving in the PNW
by TAG from PNW from Eugene Or
April 22, 2019
5
The best example of why I love this car: passing all the stuck in the snow giant four wheel drive trucks in the parking lot at work to easily park and leave as well. Bravo Subaru
Subaru Certified

2018 Subaru Forester

33,739 mi.
Not Priced
  • Ext. Color: Gray
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
Johnstons Subaru
() -
(845) 394-2377
3.6 (33 reviews)
2 mi. from 10940
Call
Johnstons Subaru Review
Great Experience - Love My Certified Pre-Owned
by Michael Briggs from Middletown, NY
December 3, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 3.6 (33 reviews)
I was able to buy a Certified Pre-Owned 2015 BRZ two weeks ago. I had been searching for this car for months and finally found one in great condition, with decent mileage and inside by budget. Tim R. was my salesman and he was very helpful in every step of the way. His manager, Michelle H,. was wonderful and was able to come up with a deal that we both felt was a fair shake regarding the sale price and the value of my trade-in. I would recommend this experience to anyone looking for a quality Subaru buying experience.
2018 Subaru Forester Review
A terrific combination
by amsquare from Windermere, FL
April 18, 2019
5
This car is perfect for me. It combines comfort, reliability, styling and exceptional performance on all types of roads. I have the Touring turbo model which is very quick off the line and hustles down the road easily when prodded. Combine all of that with the practicality of an SUV and you can understand why I am in love with it. I prefer to drive it over my other car (which I also love), a 3 series BMW, because it is as quick but much more versatile.
* Title, other fees, and incentives are not included in this calculation, which is an estimate only. Monthly payment estimates are for illustrative purposes only and do not represent a financing offer from the seller. Other taxes may apply.
The information on vehicles provided in this service is supplied by the seller or other third parties; Cars.com is not responsible for the accuracy of such information. Cars.com provides this service and materials without representations or warranties of any kind, either expressed or implied. See our terms of service for more details.
29 results
Save Search
  • Location
    • Search within
  • Shop from Home
  • New/Used
  • Year
    Min
     
    to
    Max
  • Model
  • Trim
  • Price
    Min
     
    to
    Max
  • Mileage
  • Deal Rating
  • Features
  • Body Style
  • Exterior Color
  • Interior Color
  • Drivetrain
  • Transmission
  • Cylinders
  • Photos
  • Fuel
  • Door Count
  • Dealer Ratings
  • Listing Date
  • Seller Type
  • Keywords
New Search

Save Your Search

Search saved!

You can manage your searches in your profile.

That's too many

You can only compare up to 4 cars at a time.

You've reached your limit

Sorry, you've saved the maximum amount of favorites for your account. Please unsave some if you wish to save others.