Sort

Used Subaru Legacy for Sale in Ithaca, NY

See all 33 photos
Used
$15,999 36,797 mi.

2018 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium

Great Deal
LOCAL HOME DELIVERY
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: Blue
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
Maguire Chevrolet Cadillac
() -
(888) 837-9485
4.9 (541 reviews)
2 mi. from 14850
Check Availability
Call
Maguire Chevrolet Cadillac Review
It can't be this easy!
by HockeyLife! from Syracuse, New York
December 3, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.9 (541 reviews)
Bought a 2017 Chevy Cruze from Colby Newlen at Maguire Chevy & Cadillac. They didn't have the pre-owned car I wanted but were confident they could find one for me. A few days later I drove home in my Cruze and in the color I wanted. Didn't know a dealership would do that! Colby and his manager couldn't have made it any easier!!!
2018 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Review
Very reliabe
by Zach from New York
March 2, 2019
5
Just purchased my new car. Already i feel a huge difference in comfort and how well it controls. I look forward to the years to come with it
See all 20 photos
Used
$19,799 18,677 mi.

2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium

Good Deal
LOCAL HOME DELIVERY
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: White
  • Int. Color: White
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
Maguire Hyundai Subaru
() -
(607) 216-9330
4.8 (169 reviews)
1 mi. from 14850
Authorized Subaru Dealer
Check Availability
Call
Maguire Hyundai Subaru Review
Excellent car purchased from an excellent dealer
by Geoff from ithaca, ny
November 5, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.8 (169 reviews)
I came in knowing that I wanted to buy a used Crosstrek. I originally came in to purchase a 2013 model with lots of miles, but got second thoughts after I test drove it. Shawn was very helpful, and showed me a newer model that rode a lot better. I was not pressured to make a day-of decision, and they didn't try to pressure me by phone afterwards. I ended up calling 4 days later to purchase the newer car. Shawn was very friendly and made the process very straightforward. While Maguire will not negotiate down the sticker price of used cars, I got a good deal on the warranty. I was expecting that I'd have to go to Syracuse or Rochester to find a good deal, but I ended up getting a good deal here in Ithaca.
2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Review
Love it so far.
by Rick F from Louisville
May 2, 2019
5
Looking forward to driving it for a long time and enjoying the great gas mileage and great comfort. Also love the all wheel drive for bad weather.
See all 19 photos
Used
$20,999 3,000 mi.

2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium

Good Deal
  • Ext. Color: Red
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free AutoCheck Report
Simmons-Rockwell GMC
() -
(866) 349-9818
4.5 (16 reviews)
28 mi. from 14850
Check Availability
Call
Simmons-Rockwell GMC Review
Simons Rockwell dealership
by Debora Sue Bump from Addison, NY
December 3, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.5 (16 reviews)
Had a really great experience with our sales rep. (Brian Butler). Things seemed to have changed at Simons Rockwell compared to 10 years ago. Simons would’ve been my last choice to deal with, but this time, great service and pleased with my desk and Simons !
2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Review
Great car, great value
by little general from SOUTH HADLEY, MA
April 28, 2019
5
love my new legacy can't wait to see how it handles the harsh New England winter. Great ride,Great on gas all the safety features you can think of
See all 20 photos
Used
$18,899 22,495 mi.

2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium

Good Deal
LOCAL HOME DELIVERY
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: Silver
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
Maguire Hyundai Subaru
() -
(607) 216-9330
4.8 (169 reviews)
1 mi. from 14850
Authorized Subaru Dealer
Check Availability
Call
Maguire Hyundai Subaru Review
Just bought a Subaru
by Casey from Freeville, NY
November 5, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.8 (169 reviews)
I was helped by Jon-Michael Ottenschot today, and the experience was easy (although lengthy--paperwork processing took a while, not his fault). Knowledgeable, friendly, and helpful!
2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Review
Excellent record for service and reliability.
by Craig from Beaverton, Oregon
April 16, 2019
4
Hope it will live up to its reputation. I am confident that it will! Have never seen so many Subaru vehicles in one place. Very good selection.
See all 11 photos
Used
$6,995 107,626 mi.

2009 Subaru Legacy 2.5i

Good Deal
LOCAL HOME DELIVERY
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: Blue
  • Int. Color: Beige
  • Transmission: Automatic
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
Snell Auto Sales - Elmira
() -
(570) 485-3082
26 mi. from 14850
Check Availability
Call
2009 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Review
will not die
by shnooginsss from Westchester, NY
March 11, 2019
4
bought my 2009 limited pzev 2.5i with 23k, one owner. I broke 4 wheel bearings, 2 cats (recalled), the radiator, and an oil sensor. there were 9 recalls which is a bit sketchy. I bought the car as a test really - to see if subaru's really are unbreakable, reliable, and cheap to maintain...im not exactly disappointed... the car currently has 160k of HARD miles. I purposely put a beating on this thing. I tried to get it stuck in deep snow and NOT ONCE would it get stuck. every morning hot or cold it turns right over. engine light came on one time at 150k for an oil pressure sensor ($120), but that's it. the drive train feels invincible - I literally cant break it - I see another 160k added with ease. as for reliability - anything that broke was my fault, or recalled. I think the front end is ugly, its a little long for a car, and everything about it is incredibly basic, but for an overall review I can honestly say this car is great. a little expensive for the basic features, wish I got the GT, but as reliable as they say Subaru's are. 11/10 in terms of mechanics and reliability.
See all 20 photos
Used
$19,799 36,290 mi.

2017 Subaru Legacy 3.6R Limited

Good Deal
LOCAL HOME DELIVERY
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: Black
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
Maguire Hyundai Subaru
() -
(607) 216-9330
4.8 (169 reviews)
1 mi. from 14850
Authorized Subaru Dealer
Check Availability
Call
Maguire Hyundai Subaru Review
Excellent experience buying a car at Maguire
by Suzanne from Ithaca, NY
November 5, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.8 (169 reviews)
We came looking for a specific set of features in a new car. We were greeted by John-Michael who spent a lot of time familiarizing us with the various features of the Subaru cars. He was patient and thorough in his process, and answered all our questions in good detail, finding out answers if he did not have them readily available. He had a warm and open approach and clearly knew a lot about the cars in the lot and the various features of each. We appreciated his sense of humor and quick wit. We had a test drive in a car that fit all our requirements and we were pleased to complete a purchase in a matter of only a few hours. The environment at the dealership was clean and friendly. It was all in all a very pleasant experience, even for people who are not crazy about automobile shopping. We appreciate Maguire and we appreciate John-Michael for helping us find just what we needed and wanted.
2017 Subaru Legacy 3.6R Limited Review
I love the car.
by Virginia from Poughkeepsie, n y
May 10, 2019
5
I really enjoy almost everything about the car. It drives well, good features, good mileage for AWD. I wish the body was not so low to the ground ( easy to scrape on curbs etc ) but I want a sedan and it seems all sedans now are low like this one nowadays.
See all 12 photos
Used
$8,995 144,000 mi.

2012 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Limited

Fair Price
  • Ext. Color: Gray
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
Greg's Auto Sales
() -
(607) 354-4938
4.9 (54 reviews)
27 mi. from 14850
Check Availability
Call
Greg's Auto Sales Review
Great car buying experience
by Dom D from Endicott/Owego, NY
November 6, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.9 (54 reviews)
I emailed Greg about an 06 Honda Pilot on a Saturday or Sunday, heard back from him Monday via phone call, and we set up for me to look at after the dealerships hours to check it out. Test drove it, and came back the next day and drove it off the lot, again after hours. Greg was really accommodating with flexible hours, a great price on the super clean vehicle, and did me a few favors to ensure a quick process that Thursday night. When the time comes for a new car, and if Greg has a vehicle I'm interested in, I wouldn't hesitate a bit to buy here again.
2012 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Limited Review
Good Reliable Car
by Traveling Man from Falls, PA
May 5, 2019
5
Bought it new in Oct 2011, fantastic in snow, I live in a hilly area of PA and still get 28 mpg local and 33 mpg on trips, only issue I had with it was had to replace front wheel bearing, which i did myself. Takata air bag issue was fixed promptly by dealer, very satisfied with car and dealer, Minooka Subaru Moosic PA.
See all 11 photos
Used
$6,995 130,366 mi.

2009 Subaru Legacy 2.5i

Good Deal
LOCAL HOME DELIVERY
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: Red
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: Automatic
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
Snell Auto Sales - Elmira
() -
(570) 485-3082
26 mi. from 14850
Check Availability
Call
2009 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Review
My Second Legacy
by My Legacy from Baltimore, Maryland
March 8, 2019
5
After my Subaru was totaled in an accident, I wanted to replace my 2006 Legacy with one from the same era (2005-2009). I ended up purchasing a pre owned 2009 Legacy Limited and really love it. It is a much heavier car than the 2006 by 145 pounds, but it rides just as smooth. The car has a classic sports sedan style to it, and gets decent gas mileage. I wish Subaru would go back and redesign the Legacy to the more sportier, compact size of the Legacy series from 2005-2009.
See all 22 photos
Used
$18,995 41,291 mi.

2017 Subaru Legacy 3.6R Limited

Good Deal
  • Ext. Color: Gray
  • Int. Color: White
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
Pritchard Automotive
() -
(607) 216-6467
4.9 (182 reviews)
0 mi. from 14850
Check Availability
Call
Pritchard Automotive Review
Very satisfied customer
by Nancy M. from Marathon NY
November 6, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.9 (182 reviews)
My vehicle needed an inspection and it had a sound in front end that I needed to have checked. They got me right in, did the inspection and checked out the problem. They were great and very efficient. They contacted manufacturer dealer to see if vehicle was still under warranty. It was so I have to take it else where to be fixed. If it wasn't under warranty, I would have totally trusted the mechanic at Pritchards that did my inspection to do any repairs on my vehicle.
2017 Subaru Legacy 3.6R Limited Review
Modern safety features with great style
by SaveTheHippos from San Diego
April 19, 2019
5
Talk about a sleek car with available iSight camera system that helps ensure the safety of everyone in the vehicle. Comes with adaptive cruise control and lane keep assist. Automatic braking to avoid front end collion. Reverse camera with automatic braking and sensors to alert you of oncoming objects usually not in your immediate view when reversing. The day time running lamps are the sharpest looking thing on the road, I prefer them over my BMW LED day time running lamps. In terms of comfort you have all premium leather heated seats with a wood grain front panel that gives off a modern style. Steering wheel paddle shifters with AWD give you superb control. Keyless entry and push to start engine means you can quickly get in and go! Has the new shark fin antenna that flows with the vehicle. Automatic on/off headlamps and awesome fog lamps that individually turn on when making a turn to increase your visibility of the immediate low ground road which allows you to dodge every pothole.
PRICE DROP
Used
$14,590 $2,400 price drop! 24,353 mi.

2015 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium

Good Deal
ONLINE HOME DELIVERY
VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS
  • Ext. Color: Red
  • Int. Color: White
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
Carvana-Touchless Delivery To Your Home
() -
(877) 468-4173
4.3 (2947 reviews)
Online seller
Check Availability
Call
Home Delivery

Vehicle available to be shipped to your home. Contact the dealership for details.

2015 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Review
Very good car to date
by Jeff W from Lawrence, ks
May 13, 2019
5
Bought car for my son. Has features he was looking for and the safety and awd I was looking for. Happy with decision to buy.
Used
Not Priced 57,986 mi.

2017 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium

  • Ext. Color: Red
  • Int. Color: Other
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
Royal Motor Company
() -
(607) 218-3420
1 (4 reviews)
18 mi. from 14850
Check Availability
Call
2017 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Review
Happier with my Legacy more than any previous cars
by Hockeydad from Columbia, MD
January 23, 2019
5
I love the look, performance, features, comfort and reliability. I have owned VW's, Ford Pinto, Audi Fox, Honda Accord, Toyota Tercel, Chevy Malibu, Chevy Impala and a 1942 Pontiac that was a gift from an old neighbor who went into a Nursing Home in 1964. I had the most fun in the '42 but my Legacy is by far the nicest car I have ever owned.
Used
Not Priced 64,435 mi.

2017 Subaru Legacy

  • Ext. Color: Blue
  • Int. Color: Other
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
Royal Motor Company
() -
(607) 218-3420
1 (4 reviews)
18 mi. from 14850
Check Availability
Call
2017 Subaru Legacy Review
Reliable. Affordable. Excellent utility.
by No Screen Name from Brooklyn, New York
January 10, 2019
4
Amazing sedan for the snow! Drives well. Great features. Really the only thing that’s missing for me is the automatic lock once the car is in drive and moving. You have to remember to lock the doors. Otherwise, I love it!
See all 23 photos
Used
$20,999 5,000 mi.

2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium

Good Deal
  • Ext. Color: Blue
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free AutoCheck Report
Simmons-Rockwell GMC
() -
(866) 349-9818
4.5 (16 reviews)
28 mi. from 14850
Check Availability
Call
Simmons-Rockwell GMC Review
Service
by Terri L Pierce from Elmira Heights ,NY
December 3, 2018
5 5 5 5 5 4.5 (16 reviews)
Quick and excellent service provided pleasure to do business with
2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Review
Great car!
by Bmth from Danville, pa
April 2, 2019
5
The Legacy is great value for the price. Great gas mileage, great looks and great reliability. What more can you ask for? Oh yeah, plenty roomy as well!
Used
Not Priced 81,776 mi.

2013 Subaru Legacy 2.5i

  • Ext. Color: Blue
  • Int. Color: Beige
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
Simmons-Rockwell GMC
() -
(866) 349-9818
4.5 (16 reviews)
28 mi. from 14850
Check Availability
Call
2013 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Review
Reliable but Brash
by Jakob from Rochester Hills
April 25, 2019
4
The Subaru Legacy is an excellent vehicle. Subaru has nailed the practicality formula with this vehicle. It is large inside, gets excellent fuel economy, has strong mechanical components (engine, trans, AWD system), and is a perfect family vehicle, though the engine is lacking in power. However, and this is a big, however, the Subarus are NOT built for your comfort. The seats are comfortable enough, as is the ride comfort, but the lack of refinement is alarming. The vehicle is loud, brash, and has little concern for luxury. The interior trim is cheap plastic and rough to the touch. There is very little sound deadening, a decibel meter read 79 decibels at only 50 mph, unacceptable in modern vehicles. Reliability is something great to be concerned about, and Subaru offers an excellent package for reliability and practicality, however, the lack of concern for refinement and quality engineering, especially in todays market, is bad enough to make me sell the car. In a modern market, reliability is something that can be found in most vehicles, but modern interiors have improved far past where Subaru is currently. Want reliability, get a Toyota. Need AWD, get a Toyota RAV4. Your comfortable bottom will thank you for it.
Used
Not Priced 154,367 mi.

2007 Subaru Legacy 2.5i

  • Ext. Color: Black
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: Automatic
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
Simmons-Rockwell GMC
() -
(866) 349-9818
4.5 (16 reviews)
28 mi. from 14850
Check Availability
Call
2007 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Review
Love my car!
by Diana from Lebanon, PA
January 10, 2019
5
This car was everything that I wanted. I'm happy that I was able to find it at I-deal. These people were helpful and professional. I would recommend for sure.
Used
$19,999 9,000 mi.

2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium

Good Deal
  • Ext. Color: Red
  • Int. Color: Green
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
Simmons-Rockwell GMC
() -
(866) 349-9818
4.5 (16 reviews)
28 mi. from 14850
Check Availability
Call
2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Review
First Subaru
by Doug G from Tampa fl
March 27, 2019
5
Comfy interior, bought sport trim with nav, sunroof. Only drove 10 miles so far. Lots of tech. Exterior looks nice. High rating in CR annual. Road noise good, less than my last 3 Acura RDX's.
See all 23 photos
Used
$19,999 10,000 mi.

2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium

Good Deal
HOT CAR
  • Ext. Color: Red
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • CARFAX Report
Simmons-Rockwell GMC
() -
(866) 349-9818
4.5 (16 reviews)
28 mi. from 14850
Check Availability
Call
2019 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Review
Best car I have owned
by Alícia from Orange County, CA
March 25, 2019
5
I love my Legacy. It is super comfortable with plenty of room. The safety features on it are great. It is sporty yet elegant. I highly recommend this vehicle.
* Title, other fees, and incentives are not included in this calculation, which is an estimate only. Monthly payment estimates are for illustrative purposes only and do not represent a financing offer from the seller. Other taxes may apply.
The information on vehicles provided in this service is supplied by the seller or other third parties; Cars.com is not responsible for the accuracy of such information. Cars.com provides this service and materials without representations or warranties of any kind, either expressed or implied. See our terms of service for more details.
18 results
Save Search
  • Location
    • Search within
  • Shop from Home
  • New/Used
  • Year
    Min
     
    to
    Max
  • Model
  • Trim
  • Price
    Min
     
    to
    Max
  • Mileage
  • Deal Rating
  • Features
  • Body Style
  • Exterior Color
  • Interior Color
  • Drivetrain
  • Transmission
  • Cylinders
  • Photos
  • Fuel
  • Door Count
  • Dealer Ratings
  • Listing Date
  • Seller Type
  • Keywords
New Search

Save Your Search

Search saved!

You can manage your searches in your profile.

That's too many

You can only compare up to 4 cars at a time.

You've reached your limit

Sorry, you've saved the maximum amount of favorites for your account. Please unsave some if you wish to save others.