Skip to main content

Contact seller

Contact seller

By clicking here, you authorize Cars.com and its sellers/partners to contact you by text/calls which may include marketing and be by autodialer. Calls may be prerecorded. You also agree to our Privacy Notice. Consent is not required to purchase goods/services.

We value your privacy. Cars.com Privacy Notice

Customize your budget

Est. max vehicle price based on your desired monthly budget (...% APR*. and ...% sales tax)
$...*
See matching cars

*Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.

About your privacy: Cars.com is asking for your ZIP and credit rating because it helps us to make an educated guess at your sales tax and loan interest. These two factors can greatly change your monthly payment.

Used Toyota cars for sale near New Buffalo, MI

Filters 3 Year Model Price & payment Make Mileage Body style Ext. color All filters
164 matches 30 miles from 49117
Be the first to know!

Save your search and get notified when new inventory arrives.

Prequalify now

It only takes a few minutes and won't affect your credit.

Get Prequalified
Est. $400/mo*
Down Payment
$0
Net trade-in value
$0
Months
72
APR
7.0%
Sales tax
0.0%
Prev Next

*Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.

164 matches Clear
Clear
Basics
Toyota models
Price & payment Full Price Monthly
Monthly budget search results are estimated based on a 72-month loan term with $0 down payment, $0 trade-in value, 0.0% sales tax and 7.0% APR. Inputs can be personalized using the calculator.
Deal rating
Vehicle history
Style
Performance
Features
Seller info
Keyword
Update
Show only

Used Toyota by price

Used Toyota by city

Used Toyota in New Buffalo, MI by model

Used Toyota by body style

[{"applied_filter_criteria":"{\"cpo_indicator\":false,\"make_model_trim\":[{\"make\":\"toyota\"}],\"search_range\":\"30\",\"sort_field\":\"searchRank1\",\"sort_order\":\"desc\",\"stock_type\":\"used\"}","search_type":"general-inventory-search","vehicle_array":[{"trim":"LE","make":"Toyota","cat":"crossover_compact","year":"2021","customer_id":"6035070","listing_id":"ee4411a6-9ea7-4353-8c31-5d0c1497c658","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"100136","sponsored":false,"stock_type":"Used","model":"C-HR","nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"Magnetic Gray Metallic","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Black","vin":"JTNKHMBX8M1112446","msrp":"0","drivetrain":"Front-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Michigan City Kia","dealer_zip":"46360","seller_type":"dealership","sponsored_type":"standard","price":"17495","bodystyle":"SUV","cpo_indicator":false,"vertical_position":1,"badges":["fair_deal","price_drop_in_cents"],"canonical_mmt":"Toyota:C-HR:LE","canonical_mmty":"Toyota:C-HR:LE:2021","photo_count":46,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"LE","make":"Toyota","cat":"hybrid_passenger","year":"2019","customer_id":"6063920","listing_id":"9fdf6d91-8879-4e78-a14f-e17b7ea83940","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"101191","sponsored":false,"stock_type":"Used","model":"Prius","nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"Magnetic Gray Metallic","fuel_type":"Hybrid","interior_color":"Black","vin":"JTDKARFU9K3080873","msrp":null,"drivetrain":"Front-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"S&H Auto Group South Bend","dealer_zip":"46637","seller_type":"dealership","sponsored_type":"standard","price":"15986","bodystyle":"Hatchback","cpo_indicator":false,"vertical_position":2,"badges":["good_deal","price_drop_in_cents"],"canonical_mmt":"Toyota:Prius:LE","canonical_mmty":"Toyota:Prius:LE:2019","photo_count":45,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"LE","make":"Toyota","cat":"wagonhatchback_hatchback","year":"2017","customer_id":"182925","listing_id":"ad7c6e44-c26c-4865-80aa-af107372fd5c","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"99491","sponsored":false,"stock_type":"Used","model":"Yaris","nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"Magnetic Gray Metallic","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Black w/Circle Design","vin":"VNKJTUD35HA072512","msrp":"0","drivetrain":"Front-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Lou Dominion's Deals on Wheels-Benton Harbor","dealer_zip":"49022","seller_type":"dealership","sponsored_type":"standard","price":"14900","bodystyle":"Hatchback","cpo_indicator":false,"vertical_position":3,"badges":["good_deal"],"canonical_mmt":"Toyota:Yaris:LE","canonical_mmty":"Toyota:Yaris:LE:2017","photo_count":26,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"XLE","make":"Toyota","cat":"crossover_compact","year":"2024","customer_id":"16000","listing_id":"425b8411-ff80-455f-93ab-d3ba07a29849","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"16900","sponsored":false,"stock_type":"Used","model":"RAV4","nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"Midnight Black Metallic","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Black","vin":"2T3P1RFVXRW423227","msrp":"0","drivetrain":"All-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Signature Dealer Group","dealer_zip":"49022","seller_type":"dealership","sponsored_type":"standard","price":"34990","bodystyle":"SUV","cpo_indicator":false,"vertical_position":4,"badges":["good_deal"],"canonical_mmt":"Toyota:RAV4:XLE","canonical_mmty":"Toyota:RAV4:XLE:2024","photo_count":15,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"XLE","make":"Toyota","cat":"crossover_compact","year":"2024","customer_id":"16000","listing_id":"ab0f933a-226b-48f8-a8aa-59bf017680b8","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"1331","sponsored":false,"stock_type":"Used","model":"RAV4","nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"Ice Cap","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Black","vin":"2T3P1RFV7RW428210","msrp":"0","drivetrain":"All-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Signature Dealer Group","dealer_zip":"49022","seller_type":"dealership","sponsored_type":"standard","price":"35900","bodystyle":"SUV","cpo_indicator":false,"vertical_position":5,"badges":["good_deal"],"canonical_mmt":"Toyota:RAV4:XLE","canonical_mmty":"Toyota:RAV4:XLE:2024","photo_count":22,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"Base","make":"Toyota","cat":"coupeconvertible_coupe","year":"2023","customer_id":"182925","listing_id":"c8d6ac9e-eafb-4f3e-806e-972887c3d348","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"19905","sponsored":false,"stock_type":"Used","model":"GR86","nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"Halo","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Black","vin":"JF1ZNBC11P8751313","msrp":"0","drivetrain":"Rear-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Lou Dominion's Deals on Wheels-Benton Harbor","dealer_zip":"49022","seller_type":"dealership","sponsored_type":"standard","price":"29900","bodystyle":"Coupe","cpo_indicator":false,"vertical_position":6,"badges":["great_deal"],"canonical_mmt":"Toyota:GR86:Base","canonical_mmty":"Toyota:GR86:Base:2023","photo_count":20,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"Plus","make":"Toyota","cat":"hybrid_passenger","year":"2017","customer_id":"182925","listing_id":"3243dedf-0ba3-48d8-ae74-554e3c79a67e","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"33165","sponsored":false,"stock_type":"Used","model":"Prius Prime","nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"Blizzard Pearl","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Black","vin":"JTDKARFP6H3038258","msrp":"0","drivetrain":"Front-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Lou Dominion's Deals on Wheels-Benton Harbor","dealer_zip":"49022","seller_type":"dealership","sponsored_type":"standard","price":"24900","bodystyle":"Hatchback","cpo_indicator":false,"vertical_position":7,"badges":["fair_deal"],"canonical_mmt":"Toyota:Prius Prime:Plus","canonical_mmty":"Toyota:Prius Prime:Plus:2017","photo_count":32,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"Two","make":"Toyota","cat":"hybrid_passenger","year":"2013","customer_id":"16000","listing_id":"2a616434-8402-4022-8d33-3b08d6df6b37","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"74858","sponsored":false,"stock_type":"Used","model":"Prius","nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"Sea Glass Pearl","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Misty Gray","vin":"JTDKN3DU7D1688684","msrp":"0","drivetrain":"Front-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Signature Dealer Group","dealer_zip":"49022","seller_type":"dealership","sponsored_type":"standard","price":"13990","bodystyle":"Hatchback","cpo_indicator":false,"vertical_position":8,"badges":["good_deal","hot_car"],"canonical_mmt":"Toyota:Prius:Two","canonical_mmty":"Toyota:Prius:Two:2013","photo_count":20,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"Four Touring","make":"Toyota","cat":"hybrid_passenger","year":"2016","customer_id":"16000","listing_id":"649af736-cb78-45c6-aa94-0c838ad8b74b","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"46846","sponsored":false,"stock_type":"Used","model":"Prius","nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"Blizzard Pearl","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Black","vin":"JTDKARFU5G3026722","msrp":"0","drivetrain":"Front-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Signature Dealer Group","dealer_zip":"49022","seller_type":"dealership","sponsored_type":"standard","price":"20990","bodystyle":"Hatchback","cpo_indicator":false,"vertical_position":9,"badges":["good_deal"],"canonical_mmt":"Toyota:Prius:Four Touring","canonical_mmty":"Toyota:Prius:Four Touring:2016","photo_count":24,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"Limited","make":"Toyota","cat":"suv_fullsize","year":"2021","customer_id":"191737","listing_id":"10a2c67e-5b76-41a4-96ba-087ca0af4b16","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"93938","sponsored":false,"stock_type":"Used","model":"Sequoia","nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"Blizzard Pearl","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Sand Beige","vin":"5TDFY5B16MS182618","msrp":null,"drivetrain":"Four-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Gates Toyota","dealer_zip":"46614","seller_type":"dealership","sponsored_type":"standard","price":"42186","bodystyle":"SUV","cpo_indicator":false,"vertical_position":10,"badges":["good_deal","price_drop_in_cents"],"canonical_mmt":"Toyota:Sequoia:Limited","canonical_mmty":"Toyota:Sequoia:Limited:2021","photo_count":40,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"Nightshade","make":"Toyota","cat":"suv_midsize","year":"2021","customer_id":"191737","listing_id":"7efcbb4c-6504-4713-be98-47573724c2a1","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"18167","sponsored":false,"stock_type":"Used","model":"4Runner","nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"Midnight Black Metallic","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Black / Graphite","vin":"JTECU5JR1M5246250","msrp":null,"drivetrain":"Rear-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Gates Toyota","dealer_zip":"46614","seller_type":"dealership","sponsored_type":"standard","price":"43125","bodystyle":"SUV","cpo_indicator":false,"vertical_position":11,"badges":["good_deal"],"canonical_mmt":"Toyota:4Runner:Nightshade","canonical_mmty":"Toyota:4Runner:Nightshade:2021","photo_count":39,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"TRD Pro","make":"Toyota","cat":"suv_midsize","year":"2020","customer_id":"6034608","listing_id":"0935be1d-8ec4-4753-a9d9-be95aef27958","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"54535","sponsored":false,"stock_type":"Used","model":"4Runner","nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"Army Green","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Black/Graphite","vin":"JTEBU5JR3L5793613","msrp":"0","drivetrain":"Four-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Gurley Leep Buick GMC","dealer_zip":"46545","seller_type":"dealership","sponsored_type":"standard","price":"44801","bodystyle":"SUV","cpo_indicator":false,"vertical_position":12,"badges":["good_deal"],"canonical_mmt":"Toyota:4Runner:TRD Pro","canonical_mmty":"Toyota:4Runner:TRD Pro:2020","photo_count":34,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"TRD Off Road Premium","make":"Toyota","cat":"suv_midsize","year":"2020","customer_id":"6036950","listing_id":"c46efcc2-be45-44b3-96e0-bda42093fc99","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"75998","sponsored":false,"stock_type":"Used","model":"4Runner","nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"Classic Silver Metallic","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Black/Graphite","vin":"JTEBU5JR3L5778383","msrp":"0","drivetrain":"Four-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Gurley Leep Volkswagen","dealer_zip":"46545","seller_type":"dealership","sponsored_type":"standard","price":"35356","bodystyle":"SUV","cpo_indicator":false,"vertical_position":13,"badges":["good_deal","price_drop_in_cents"],"canonical_mmt":"Toyota:4Runner:TRD Off Road Premium","canonical_mmty":"Toyota:4Runner:TRD Off Road Premium:2020","photo_count":31,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"SR5 Premium","make":"Toyota","cat":"suv_midsize","year":"2021","customer_id":"203664","listing_id":"4cb39c01-4c03-49f7-9736-4bb718ee23a5","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"36842","sponsored":false,"stock_type":"Used","model":"4Runner","nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"Barcelona Red Metallic","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":null,"vin":"JTENU5JRXM5867916","msrp":"0","drivetrain":"Four-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Gurley Leep Kia","dealer_zip":"46545","seller_type":"dealership","sponsored_type":"standard","price":"37199","bodystyle":"SUV","cpo_indicator":false,"vertical_position":14,"badges":["great_deal","hot_car"],"canonical_mmt":"Toyota:4Runner:SR5 Premium","canonical_mmty":"Toyota:4Runner:SR5 Premium:2021","photo_count":32,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"SE","make":"Toyota","cat":"sedan_midsize","year":"2022","customer_id":"203965","listing_id":"87d2e790-bc07-4b93-bcde-9ab60a1428d9","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"61017","sponsored":false,"stock_type":"Used","model":"Camry","nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"Predawn Gray Mica","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Black","vin":"4T1G11AK0NU053102","msrp":null,"drivetrain":"Front-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Gurley Leep Subaru","dealer_zip":"46545","seller_type":"dealership","sponsored_type":"standard","price":"24891","bodystyle":"Sedan","cpo_indicator":false,"vertical_position":15,"badges":["fair_deal","price_drop_in_cents"],"canonical_mmt":"Toyota:Camry:SE","canonical_mmty":"Toyota:Camry:SE:2022","photo_count":30,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"XLE","make":"Toyota","cat":"crossover_midsize","year":"2022","customer_id":"6036950","listing_id":"9685efe3-c6dc-42ed-942e-3a690c543240","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"45479","sponsored":false,"stock_type":"Used","model":"Highlander","nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"Midnight Black Metallic","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Harvest Beige","vin":"5TDGZRBH2NS185586","msrp":"0","drivetrain":"All-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Gurley Leep Volkswagen","dealer_zip":"46545","seller_type":"dealership","sponsored_type":"standard","price":"36480","bodystyle":"SUV","cpo_indicator":false,"vertical_position":16,"badges":["good_deal"],"canonical_mmt":"Toyota:Highlander:XLE","canonical_mmty":"Toyota:Highlander:XLE:2022","photo_count":32,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"SR5 Premium","make":"Toyota","cat":"suv_midsize","year":"2019","customer_id":"6053160","listing_id":"9759681f-216a-4bb2-a2d5-77fd09fbf3e9","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"51000","sponsored":false,"stock_type":"Used","model":"4Runner","nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"Magnetic Gray Metallic","fuel_type":"Gasoline","interior_color":"Charcoal","vin":"JTEBU5JR4K5701102","msrp":"0","drivetrain":"Four-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Jordan Toyota","dealer_zip":"46545","seller_type":"dealership","sponsored_type":"standard","price":"34499","bodystyle":"SUV","cpo_indicator":false,"vertical_position":17,"badges":["great_deal"],"canonical_mmt":"Toyota:4Runner:SR5 Premium","canonical_mmty":"Toyota:4Runner:SR5 Premium:2019","photo_count":32,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"LE","make":"Toyota","cat":"hybrid_suv","year":"2022","customer_id":"6053160","listing_id":"bd709df4-05d6-42ea-bf07-2c2674a4136b","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"24781","sponsored":false,"stock_type":"Used","model":"RAV4 Hybrid","nvi_program":false,"exterior_color":"White","fuel_type":"Hybrid","interior_color":"Black","vin":"4T3MWRFV8NU073949","msrp":"0","drivetrain":"All-wheel Drive","dealer_name":"Jordan Toyota","dealer_zip":"46545","seller_type":"dealership","sponsored_type":"standard","price":"30598","bodystyle":"SUV","cpo_indicator":false,"vertical_position":18,"badges":["good_deal","hot_car"],"canonical_mmt":"Toyota:RAV4 Hybrid:LE","canonical_mmty":"Toyota:RAV4 Hybrid:LE:2022","photo_count":32,"stock_sub":""},{"trim":"LE","make":"Toyota","cat":"hybrid_passenger","year":"2021","customer_id":"6053160","listing_id":"4afd55b3-07d7-40c0-8ee1-1ba7baa12cb0","certified_preowned":false,"mileage":"40061","sponsored":false,"stock_type":"Used","model":&quo