Used convertibles for sale near Central Islip, NY under $40,000
Applied filters and sort
Skip to Listings
Best match
Lowest price
Highest price
Lowest mileage
Highest mileage
Nearest location
Best deal
Newest year
Oldest year
Newest listed
Oldest listed
Filters
Skip to Filters
FAQs
-
-
$11,597
Est. $215/mo Stream Auto Outlet Valley Stream
Check Availability Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Bright White Clearcoat
- Int. color
- Light Frost Beige/Black
- Drivetrain
- Front-wheel Drive
- MPG
- 19-29
- Fuel type
- Gasoline
- Transmission
- 6-Speed Automatic
- Engine
- Pentastar 3.6L V-6 DOHC, VVT variable valve control, regular gas
- Stock #
- 7506K
- VIN
- 1C3BCBFG4DN650415
Features
- Convenience
- Heated Seats
- Keyless Entry
- Navigation System
- Remote Start
- Entertainment
- Bluetooth®
- CD Player
- DVD Player
- HomeLink
- Exterior
- Alloy Wheels
- Sunroof/Moonroof
- Safety
- Automatic Emergency Braking
- Brake Assist
- Stability Control
- Seating
- Leather Seats
Dealer
Stream Auto Outlet Valley Stream -
Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Melting Silver III Metallic
- Int. color
- Nightshade Blue
- Drivetrain
- Front-wheel Drive
- MPG
- 26-36
- Fuel type
- Gasoline
- Transmission
- 7-SPEED DUAL CLUTCH
- Engine
- 2L I-4 direct injection, DOHC, variable valve control, intercool
- Stock #
- LM352
- VIN
- WMW23GX02T2X77901
Features
- Convenience
- Heated Seats
- Heated Steering Wheel
- Keyless Entry
- Keyless Start
- Navigation System
- Remote Start
- Entertainment
- Apple CarPlay®
- Bluetooth®
- USB Port
- WiFi Hotspot
- Exterior
- Sunroof/Moonroof
- Safety
- Automatic Emergency Braking
- Backup Camera
- Blind Spot Monitor
- Brake Assist
- LED Headlights
- Lane Departure Warning
- Rear Cross Traffic Alert
- Stability Control
- Seating
- Leather Seats
Dealer
MINI of Darien -
Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- White Metallic
- Int. color
- Carbon Black
- Drivetrain
- Front-wheel Drive
- MPG
- 23-33
- Fuel type
- Gasoline
- Transmission
- 7-Speed Automatic with Auto-Shift
- Engine
- 2.0L I4 16V GDI DOHC Turbo
- Stock #
- R3R87398T
- VIN
- WMW43DL06R3R87398
Features
- Convenience
- Keyless Start
- Entertainment
- Apple CarPlay®
- Bluetooth®
- Satellite Radio
- USB Port
- Exterior
- Alloy Wheels
- Sunroof/Moonroof
- Safety
- Automatic Emergency Braking
- Backup Camera
- Brake Assist
- Lane Departure Warning
- Stability Control
- Seating
- Leather Seats
Dealer
BMW of Freeport -
Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Billet Silver Metallic Clearcoat
- Int. color
- Black
- Drivetrain
- Four-wheel Drive
- MPG
- 16-20
- Fuel type
- Gasoline
- Transmission
- Automatic
- Engine
- Regular Gasoline V-6 3.6 L/220
- Stock #
- U30602P
- VIN
- 1C4HJWEG0HL598819
Features
- Convenience
- Heated Seats
- Keyless Entry
- Navigation System
- Remote Start
- Entertainment
- Bluetooth®
- Satellite Radio
- Exterior
- Alloy Wheels
- Tow Hooks
- Safety
- Brake Assist
- LED Headlights
- Stability Control
Dealer
Penn Toyota -
$19,571
Est. $363/mo Stream Auto Outlet Valley Stream
Check Availability Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Diamond Silver Metallic
- Int. color
- Bengal Red/Black
- Drivetrain
- Rear-wheel Drive
- MPG
- 22-32
- Fuel type
- Gasoline
- Transmission
- 7G-TRONIC PLUS 7-Speed Automatic
- Engine
- 1.8L I-4 direct injection, DOHC, variable valve control, interco
- Stock #
- T7276KA
- VIN
- WDDPK4HA2FF109164
Features
- Convenience
- Keyless Entry
- Entertainment
- Bluetooth®
- CD Player
- HomeLink
- USB Port
- WiFi Hotspot
- Exterior
- Alloy Wheels
- Sunroof/Moonroof
- Safety
- Automatic Emergency Braking
- Brake Assist
- Rain Sensing Wipers
- Stability Control
- Seating
- Leather Seats
- Memory Seat
Dealer
Stream Auto Outlet Valley Stream -
$11,597
Est. $215/mo Stream Auto Outlet Valley Stream
Check Availability Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Bright White Clearcoat
- Int. color
- Light Frost Beige/Black
- Drivetrain
- Front-wheel Drive
- MPG
- 19-29
- Fuel type
- Gasoline
- Transmission
- 6-Speed Automatic
- Engine
- Pentastar 3.6L V-6 DOHC, VVT variable valve control, regular gas
- Stock #
- 7506K
- VIN
- 1C3BCBFG4DN650415
Features
- Convenience
- Heated Seats
- Keyless Entry
- Navigation System
- Remote Start
- Entertainment
- Bluetooth®
- CD Player
- DVD Player
- HomeLink
- Exterior
- Alloy Wheels
- Sunroof/Moonroof
- Safety
- Automatic Emergency Braking
- Brake Assist
- Stability Control
- Seating
- Leather Seats
Dealer
Stream Auto Outlet Valley Stream -
-
Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Black
- Int. color
- BLACK
- Drivetrain
- Rear-wheel Drive
- MPG
- 26-36
- Fuel type
- Gasoline
- Transmission
- Automatic
- Engine
- Turbo Gas
- Stock #
- 70239270
- VIN
- WMW23GX09S2W90110
Features
- Convenience
- Heated Steering Wheel
- Navigation System
- Entertainment
- Android Auto®
- Apple CarPlay®
- Bluetooth®
- Satellite Radio
- Exterior
- Alloy Wheels
- Safety
- Backup Camera
- Blind Spot Monitor
- Lane Departure Warning
- Seating
- Leather Seats
Dealer
CarMax Smithtown -
Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Silver
- Int. color
- BLACK
- Drivetrain
- Rear-wheel Drive
- MPG
- 27-34
- Fuel type
- Gasoline
- Transmission
- Manual 6
- Engine
- Gas
- Stock #
- 70215823
- VIN
- JM1NDAD7XG0110426
Features
- Convenience
- Navigation System
- Entertainment
- Bluetooth®
- HomeLink
- Premium Sound System
- Satellite Radio
- Exterior
- Alloy Wheels
- Safety
- Blind Spot Monitor
- Lane Departure Warning
- Rain Sensing Wipers
- Seating
- Leather Seats
Dealer
CarMax East Meadow -
Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Copper Grey Metallic
- Int. color
- Beige
- Drivetrain
- Front-wheel Drive
- MPG
- 26-36
- Fuel type
- Gasoline
- Transmission
- 7-SPEED DUAL CLUTCH
- Engine
- 2L I-4 direct injection, DOHC, variable valve control, intercool
- Stock #
- LM354
- VIN
- WMW23GX05T2X72739
Features
- Convenience
- Heated Seats
- Heated Steering Wheel
- Keyless Entry
- Keyless Start
- Navigation System
- Remote Start
- Entertainment
- Apple CarPlay®
- Bluetooth®
- USB Port
- WiFi Hotspot
- Exterior
- Sunroof/Moonroof
- Safety
- Automatic Emergency Braking
- Backup Camera
- Blind Spot Monitor
- Brake Assist
- LED Headlights
- Lane Departure Warning
- Rear Cross Traffic Alert
- Stability Control
- Seating
- Leather Seats
Dealer
MINI of Darien -
$11,594
Est. $215/mo Subaru Stamford
Check Availability Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Dakar Beige Metallic
- Int. color
- Beige
- Drivetrain
- All-wheel Drive
- MPG
- 21-27
- Fuel type
- Gasoline
- Transmission
- 6-Speed Automatic with Tiptronic
- Engine
- 2L I-4 direct injection, DOHC, variable valve control, intercool
- Stock #
- U19417
- VIN
- WAUDF48H09K010009
Features
- Convenience
- Keyless Entry
- Entertainment
- Bluetooth®
- CD Player
- Exterior
- Alloy Wheels
- Safety
- Automatic Emergency Braking
- Brake Assist
- Stability Control
- Seating
- Leather Seats
Dealer
Subaru Stamford -
Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Pearl White
- Int. color
- Black
- Drivetrain
- Rear-wheel Drive
- Fuel type
- Gasoline
- Transmission
- Automatic
- Engine
- VQ 3.7L V-6 DOHC, variable valve control, premium unleaded, engi
- Stock #
- 11380
- VIN
- JN1AZ4FH0FM430565
Features
- Convenience
- Keyless Entry
- Keyless Start
- Entertainment
- Apple CarPlay®
- Bluetooth®
- CD Player
- Exterior
- Alloy Wheels
- Safety
- Automatic Emergency Braking
- Backup Camera
- Brake Assist
- Stability Control
Dealer
AR Motorsports -
$39,889
New 2026 MINI Convertible Cooper 
$35,470
New 2026 Mazda MX-5 Miata Club 
$37,920
New 2026 Mazda MX-5 Miata Grand Touring 
$37,720
New 2026 Mazda MX-5 Miata Grand Touring 
$35,136
New 2026 Mazda MX-5 Miata Club 
$34,835
New 2026 Mazda MX-5 Miata Club 
$35,392
New 2026 Mazda MX-5 Miata Club 
$37,562
New 2026 Mazda MX-5 Miata Grand Touring 
$35,310
New 2026 Mazda MX-5 Miata Club 
$37,552
New 2026 Mazda MX-5 Miata Grand Touring 
$37,101
New 2026 Mazda MX-5 Miata Grand Touring 
$39,889
New 2026 MINI Convertible Cooper -
Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Black
- Int. color
- Black
- Transmission
- Manual
- Engine
- 2.9L C-Series i6
- Stock #
- 3073
- VIN
- 00000000HBT7L4235
Dealer
Motorcar Classics -
-
Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Black
- Int. color
- BLACK
- Drivetrain
- Rear-wheel Drive
- MPG
- 22-34
- Fuel type
- Gasoline
- Transmission
- Automatic
- Engine
- Turbo Gas
- Stock #
- 28168212
- VIN
- WBALL5C57FP557316
Features
- Convenience
- Navigation System
- Entertainment
- Bluetooth®
- HomeLink
- Satellite Radio
- Exterior
- Alloy Wheels
- Safety
- Rain Sensing Wipers
- Seating
- Leather Seats
- Memory Seat
Dealer
CarMax Smithtown -
Vehicle Information
- Drivetrain
- Front-wheel Drive
- MPG
- 22-29
- Fuel type
- Gasoline
- Transmission
- Automatic, 6-Spd w/Overdrive & Tiptronic
- Engine
- 2L I-4 gasoline direct injection, DOHC, variable valve control,
- Stock #
- 10129
- VIN
- WVWBA71F19V010957
Features
- Convenience
- Heated Seats
- Keyless Entry
- Entertainment
- CD Player
- Exterior
- Alloy Wheels
- Sunroof/Moonroof
- Safety
- Automatic Emergency Braking
- Brake Assist
- Stability Control
- Seating
- Leather Seats
Dealer
JR Auto & Truck Repair LLC -
Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Aggressive (Victory Red)
- Int. color
- Black
- Drivetrain
- Rear-wheel Drive
- Fuel type
- Gasoline
- Transmission
- Automatic
- Engine
- Ecotec 2L I-4 gasoline direct injection, DOHC, variable valve co
- Stock #
- 2979
- VIN
- 1G2MG35X37Y131363
Features
- Convenience
- Keyless Entry
- Entertainment
- CD Player
- Exterior
- Alloy Wheels
- Safety
- Stability Control
Dealer
Motorcar Classics -
$18,075
Est. $335/mo Motorcar Classics
Check Availability Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Diamond Silver Metallic
- Int. color
- Black
- Drivetrain
- Rear-wheel Drive
- MPG
- 17-23
- Fuel type
- Gasoline
- Transmission
- Automatic
- Engine
- 5L V-8 premium unleaded, engine with 302HP
- Stock #
- 3175
- VIN
- WDBTK75G15T043658
Features
- Convenience
- Keyless Entry
- Entertainment
- CD Player
- HomeLink
- Exterior
- Alloy Wheels
- Sunroof/Moonroof
- Safety
- Automatic Emergency Braking
- Brake Assist
- Stability Control
- Seating
- Leather Seats
- Memory Seat
Dealer
Motorcar Classics -
$9,750
Est. $181/mo Acura of Stamford
Check Availability Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Magma Red
- Int. color
- Charcoal
- Drivetrain
- Rear-wheel Drive
- MPG
- 17-24
- Fuel type
- Gasoline
- Transmission
- 5-Speed Automatic
- Engine
- 4.3L V-8 premium gasoline, engine with 275HP
- Stock #
- 8681
- VIN
- WDBLK70G5YT037681
Features
- Convenience
- Keyless Entry
- Entertainment
- HomeLink
- Exterior
- Alloy Wheels
- Safety
- Automatic Emergency Braking
- Brake Assist
- Stability Control
- Seating
- Leather Seats
- Memory Seat
Dealer
Acura of Stamford -
Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Black
- Int. color
- BLACK
- Drivetrain
- Rear-wheel Drive
- MPG
- 22-34
- Fuel type
- Gasoline
- Transmission
- Automatic
- Engine
- Turbo Gas
- Stock #
- 70187884
- VIN
- WBALL5C58EJ105926
Features
- Convenience
- Heated Steering Wheel
- Navigation System
- Entertainment
- Bluetooth®
- HomeLink
- Exterior
- Alloy Wheels
- Safety
- Rain Sensing Wipers
- Seating
- Leather Seats
- Memory Seat
Dealer
CarMax East Meadow -
Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Ice Silver Metallic
- Int. color
- Black/Red
- Drivetrain
- All-wheel Drive
- MPG
- 18-26
- Fuel type
- Gasoline
- Transmission
- 7-Speed Automatic S tronic
- Engine
- 3.0L TFSI V6 DOHC
- Stock #
- L26318B
- VIN
- WAUVGAFH9EN014118
Features
- Convenience
- Adaptive Cruise Control
- Heated Seats
- Keyless Entry
- Keyless Start
- Navigation System
- Entertainment
- Bluetooth®
- CD Player
- DVD Player
- HomeLink
- Premium Sound System
- Exterior
- Alloy Wheels
- Safety
- Automatic Emergency Braking
- Backup Camera
- Blind Spot Monitor
- Brake Assist
- Rain Sensing Wipers
- Stability Control
- Seating
- Leather Seats
- Memory Seat
Dealer
Land Rover Fairfield -
Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Red
- Drivetrain
- Rear-wheel Drive
- MPG
- 20-28
- Fuel type
- Gasoline
- Transmission
- 5-Speed Manual
- Engine
- 3.2L I6 24V MPFI DOHC
- Stock #
- 8433
- VIN
- WBSCK9332WLC86258
Features
- Convenience
- Heated Seats
- Exterior
- Alloy Wheels
- Seating
- Leather Seats
Dealer
Beverly Hills Auto Group -
Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Tan
- Int. color
- Medium Parchment
- Drivetrain
- Rear-wheel Drive
- MPG
- 15-23
- Fuel type
- Gasoline
- Transmission
- Manual
- Engine
- 4.6L V-8 variable valve control, regular unleaded, engine with 3
- Stock #
- X7984
- VIN
- 1ZVHT85H085150029
Features
- Convenience
- Keyless Entry
- Entertainment
- CD Player
- Premium Sound System
- Exterior
- Alloy Wheels
- Seating
- Leather Seats
Dealer
Blasius South -
Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Black Sapphire Metallic
- Int. color
- Beige
- Drivetrain
- Rear-wheel Drive
- MPG
- 17-26
- Fuel type
- Gasoline
- Transmission
- 6-Speed Manual
- Engine
- 3.0L I6 24V GDI DOHC Twin Turbo
- Stock #
- T15129
- VIN
- WBS3U9C54FJ968238
Features
- Convenience
- Heated Seats
- Heated Steering Wheel
- Keyless Entry
- Navigation System
- Entertainment
- Bluetooth®
- CD Player
- DVD Player
- Premium Sound System
- Satellite Radio
- Exterior
- Alloy Wheels
- Safety
- Backup Camera
- Brake Assist
- Rain Sensing Wipers
- Stability Control
- Seating
- Leather Seats
- Memory Seat
Dealer
Porsche Greenwich -
Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Green
- Int. color
- Medium Parchment
- Drivetrain
- Rear-wheel Drive
- MPG
- 17-25
- Fuel type
- Gasoline
- Transmission
- Manual
- Engine
- 4.6L V-8 variable valve control, regular unleaded, engine with 3
- Stock #
- X7804
- VIN
- 1ZVHT85H275341756
Features
- Convenience
- Keyless Entry
- Entertainment
- CD Player
- Exterior
- Alloy Wheels
Dealer
Blasius South -
Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- White Metallic
- Int. color
- Black
- Drivetrain
- Rear-wheel Drive
- MPG
- 17-26
- Fuel type
- Gasoline
- Transmission
- 6-Speed Manual
- Engine
- 3L I-6 direct injection, DOHC, variable valve control, twin turb
- Stock #
- 8694
- VIN
- WBS3U9C54GP969131
Features
- Convenience
- Heated Seats
- Heated Steering Wheel
- Keyless Entry
- Keyless Start
- Navigation System
- Entertainment
- Bluetooth®
- CD Player
- DVD Player
- Premium Sound System
- Satellite Radio
- USB Port
- WiFi Hotspot
- Exterior
- Alloy Wheels
- Sunroof/Moonroof
- Safety
- Automatic Emergency Braking
- Backup Camera
- Blind Spot Monitor
- Brake Assist
- LED Headlights
- Lane Departure Warning
- Rain Sensing Wipers
- Stability Control
- Seating
- Leather Seats
- Memory Seat
Dealer
Acura of Stamford -
Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Red
- Int. color
- BLACK
- Drivetrain
- Rear-wheel Drive
- MPG
- 21-28
- Fuel type
- Gasoline
- Transmission
- Automatic
- Engine
- Gas
- Stock #
- 70053907
- VIN
- JM1NC2LF6E0235857
Features
- Entertainment
- Satellite Radio
- Exterior
- Alloy Wheels
Dealer
CarMax East Meadow -
$32,998
Est. $612/mo CarMax East Haven
Check Availability Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- White
- Int. color
- CREAM
- Drivetrain
- Rear-wheel Drive
- MPG
- 26-34
- Fuel type
- Gasoline
- Transmission
- Manual 6
- Engine
- Gas
- Stock #
- 70075031
- VIN
- JM1NDAM72R0600331
Features
- Entertainment
- Android Auto®
- Apple CarPlay®
- Bluetooth®
- HomeLink
- Premium Sound System
- Satellite Radio
- Exterior
- Alloy Wheels
- Safety
- Backup Camera
- Blind Spot Monitor
- Lane Departure Warning
- Rain Sensing Wipers
- Seating
- Leather Seats
Dealer
CarMax East Haven -
Vehicle Information
- Ext. color
- Iridium Silver Metallic
- Int. color
- Black/Classic Red
- Drivetrain
- All-wheel Drive
- MPG
- 20-26
- Fuel type
- Gasoline
- Transmission
- 9 speed automatic
- Engine
- AMG 3L I-6 gasoline direct injection, DOHC, variable valve contr
- Stock #
- 089063
- VIN
- WDD1K6BB8KF089063
Features
- Convenience
- Adaptive Cruise Control
- Cooled Seats
- Heated Seats
- Keyless Entry
- Keyless Start
- Navigation System
- Remote Start
- Entertainment
- Android Auto®
- Apple CarPlay®
- Bluetooth®
- HomeLink
- Premium Sound System
- USB Port
- WiFi Hotspot
- Exterior
- Alloy Wheels
- Sunroof/Moonroof
- Safety
- Automatic Emergency Braking
- Backup Camera
- Blind Spot Monitor
- Brake Assist
- LED Headlights
- Lane Departure Warning
- Rear Cross Traffic Alert
- Stability Control
- Seating
- Leather Seats
- Memory Seat
Dealer
Merlex Auto Group
About convertibles
What is the cheapest convertible available?
The Mercedes-Benz CLK-Class is the cheapest available convertible by average Cars.com listing price, with an average listing price of $10,544.
Which convertible has the best MPG?
The FIAT 500C has the best MPG among traditional internal combustion convertibles and offers up to 31 MPG city and 40 MPG highway for a combined rating of 34 MPG. The Mercedes-Benz AMG SL 43 has the best MPG amongst convertibles with hybrid powertrains, reaching 21 MPG city and 27 MPG highway for a combined rating of 23 MPG.
These figures are based on EPA mileage ratings and are for comparison purposes only. The actual mileage will vary depending on the selected vehicle model year, trim, driving conditions, driving habits, vehicle maintenance, and other factors.
Which convertible has the longest range?
The Tesla Roadster has the longest range among convertibles and can travel up to 245 miles on a single charge depending on electric motor and battery options.
EPA-estimated range is the distance, or predicted distance, a new plug-in vehicle will travel on electric power before its battery charge is exhausted. Actual range will vary depending on model year, driving conditions, driving habits, elevation changes, weather, accessory usage (lights, climate control), vehicle condition and other factors.
Which automaker has the most convertible deals?
Ford has the most available convertible deals on Cars.com with 753 great deals out of 2497 listings starting at $2,119.
Where can I find the most convertible deals?
The most convertible deals can be found near Brentwood, NY with 20 great deals out of 160 listings starting at $5,822.
Find great prices by city
-
Convertibles under $40,000 in Islandia, NY
18 Great Deals out of 157 listings starting at $5,822
-
Convertibles under $40,000 in North Great River, NY
18 Great Deals out of 142 listings starting at $5,822
-
Convertibles under $40,000 in Islip Terrace, NY
18 Great Deals out of 143 listings starting at $5,822
-
Convertibles under $40,000 in Hauppauge, NY
19 Great Deals out of 162 listings starting at $5,822
-
Convertibles under $40,000 in Brentwood, NY
20 Great Deals out of 160 listings starting at $5,822
-
Convertibles under $40,000 in Islip, NY
18 Great Deals out of 143 listings starting at $5,822
-
Convertibles under $40,000 in Bohemia, NY
14 Great Deals out of 134 listings starting at $5,822
-
Convertibles under $40,000 in Ronkonkoma, NY
14 Great Deals out of 138 listings starting at $5,822
-
Convertibles under $40,000 in North Bay Shore, NY
19 Great Deals out of 153 listings starting at $5,822
-
Convertibles under $40,000 in East Islip, NY
18 Great Deals out of 142 listings starting at $5,822
-
Convertibles under $40,000 in Oakdale, NY
11 Great Deals out of 121 listings starting at $5,822
-
Convertibles under $40,000 in Bay Shore, NY
19 Great Deals out of 149 listings starting at $5,822