Used Subaru for Sale in Toms River, NJ

I purchased a 2017 Subaru Legacy from another dealer last year. Pine Belt's pricing just over the phone forced that dealer to sharpen their pencil and I paid less than they wanted to charge me. We buy a new car almost every year. And car shopping is very time-consuming and very painful. But, a purchase of a car is one of our biggest purchases except for real estate. So, getting the best price is important because the money that we save is in after-tax dollars. This time, when it was time to get another car (we were an exclusive Ford/Lincoln family for 31 years), we visited Pine Belt Subaru (40 minutes from home) first because we are extremely satisfied with our 2017 Legacy Sport, which was purchased at a dealer very close to my home... We met their salesman, Matt Mazza, and explained to him that we were going to check four dealers pricing on exactly the same car with the same option package - even if the car was not in stock and we needed to order it. And that we would not be back unless the price was the lowest. We were not going to play one dealer against the other any more. So, I asked for his best price. The price that Matt gave us was so significantly lower than the price that I got from that other dealer on last year's purchase (equivalent MSRP), that I decided not to look further and signed the papers. Amazingly, not only was the model and options in that car on their lot, but the color was there too! They must have some large selection there! Once you go to Pine Belt Subaru, you'll never go to another dealer. Once you drive a Subaru and appreciate its attention to safety, you'll never buy another brand.

Price: Very fair. Although there was no real negotiation, I was happy given that the initial price was more than fair for what I was buying. The final cost before fees was $12,995 and after fees was $14,650. Service: I had my mechanic inspect my 2012 Ford Mustang V6 convertible, and he found it to be a high quality car. Nicky was kind enough to let us test drive it a second time at closing time, and allowed me a few days to secure financing with my credit union with only a verbal agreement and a deposit to purchase. Grade A service. Dealership setup: I recommend researching your potential car(s) and setting an appointment before visiting, because I test drove with a different salesman before closing the deal with Nicky. I even walked off the lot before coming back five minutes later to place a deposit. It may be a confusing setup to a casual walk-up impulse buyer. Overall experience: Although I am generally skeptical of non-affiliated used car dealerships, Auto Avenues did a fine job and my mechanic approved of my purchase. Hopefully the car lasts long with no major issues, but I’d be happy to return again if the car lasts.

This car is amazing . Driving it is an incredible experience . The only problem is that the rear seats part is a litle small.

I went to Automotive Avenues on the Saturday during Memorial Day Weekend 2018. The dealership was the second out of three that I had planned to visit that day. I had picked out selected GMC Acadias at different dealerships that I wanted to test drive. I wanted to look at and test drive two GMC Acadias at Automotive Avenues. I was nervous embarking upon this car buying journey since it had been 15 years since I purchased a new vehicle and that previous car buying experience was nerve racking. Plus, I was still so attached to my 2003 Chevy Suburban, but my beloved ???Bertha??? was falling apart. Hence, it was really past time to buy a new car. My Sales Consultant at Automotive Avenues was Greg Marotti. He was wonderful! I found him to be kind, straight-forward, helpful and informative. He was patient when explaining to me the inner workings of the vehicle and was not annoyed with the numerous questions I had about the vehicles I test drove. He understood that buying a car was a major purchase for me and he took his time to make me feel comfortable by giving me the time I needed to test drive both vehicles, look them over carefully and write down copious notes about the vehicles. The only reason I did not purchase a vehicle from Automotive Avenues is that I found a newer model for a great deal at the third dealership I visited that day. Buying a truck from a different dealership was a difficult decision for me because I really appreciated the ???honest??? vibes I received from Greg and would???ve liked him to have made the sale. I felt as though Greg really appreciated my business. Hands down Greg was the BEST sales professional I interacted with that day. I would definitely recommend Greg as a sales consultant at Automotive Avenues. Please request him when you go to Automotive Avenues. You won???t be sorry that you did.

Has a very comfortable ride. Sets up high enough to give you great visibility. Interior has less road noise than others. Good gas mileage for the size of the car and all wheel drive

We had a very pleasant, smooth and nice experience at Automotive Avenues. Bobby, Rad and Andrew were all wonderful in helping us get the car that we wanted. We got everything set in just afew hours. We are grateful for all their help.. you guys rock!! 🤘

The Ascent is a size upgrade in Subaru's offering that we have been waiting for. There isn't a thing I don't like about it. Love it!

Great selection, good overviews of each vehicle, and Greg helped compare both the different options in each vehicle as well as the carfax. Downside - most of the Foresters I looked at had been in accidents. The upside - most were all well repaired and in great shape. Very transparent dealer, no hidden fees (non-negotiable sticker price, but only $389 dealer/document fee, $189 vin etching, state tax, and registrastion). In and out in under 3 hours. Thanks Greg!

Ask for Brian !!!! You can't beat this dealer ! Traveling from Ct To get our dream car was well worth the time and drive . We wrapped up a sale quicker then any local dealership . Over 500 cars on their lot So you can shop in one place to get what your looking for . Wholesale prices was another plus . Upfront & Honest . Best car buying experience We have ever had . Quick / simple / honest / friendly / newer car selections only . No junk here. Extremely professional . AAAAA+ Love my new BMW

It was time for something bigger than my Tacoma, which I LOVED. A friend of mine had just bought her new Ascent so I was intrigued. She has a family like mine and loves her Ascent, it is easy to see why after owning mine for the last month. I couldn't be happier, great car! Highly recommend!

AMAZING EXPERIENCE!!! My wife and I put in an online request to test drive a 2013 VW Tiguan the next day. When we arrived at Automotive Avenues, we were beyond impressed with the service. We dealt with Mike Rich who went above and beyond to help us get exactly what we wanted. Just 2.5 hours later, we left with the car! They made sure the car was cleaned and spotless before we drove off. We didn't think we would leave with a car that day! Quickest car buying experience ever. We've had the car for a couple weeks now, and Mike followed up with a courtesy call to see how we feel about the car and to thank us for our business. In fact, going to pick up my plates today. My wife will be needing a car soon, so we will definitely revisit Automotive Avenues. I've literally been ranting and raving to everyone about this place.

I drove home and it was amazing. The vehicle rode so smooth and it was a nice ride back home. I am so glad that I went to speak with Pamela, she helped me so much. She was patient and very nice to us.

We saw a car a 2015 Honda Civic on the dealers website. Then decided to go to right to the dealership. Max was are salesman. He helped us right away and got us the car we were looking for. He was patient and very knowledgeable. It was the best car experience I've had in a long time. I would recommend Automotive Avenues and Max any day.

This car is amazing and so much fun to drive. Too many features to name here. Can’t even pick a favorite. For a three row seater it handles like a sedan but has room room galore. The third row is so comfortable and has its own vents. Cup holders everywhere. This is a must drive. You will be blown away. Subaru has thought of everything

Was worth the stress of the unknown! Im from NY about 4 hours away and found AA online and a tahoe i really liked. I contacted Mike and and he gave me all the info. On a whim i took a ride one day to see it, it wasn't there - it was in their shop being looked over. They were very apologetic, and tried to go to shop but they were closed already. I didn't tell them i was coming so i couldn't be to mad about it. Drove home and decided to give up - the price seemed to good to be true and maybe it was a sign. But it bothered me, i really wanted it (against my better judgement)... convinced myself that if it was meant to be it will be. and put in a loan application. Even if i did get approved im sure interest will be high and i can feel better passing it up. Not only did they approve me - but a phenomenal rate. Guess i can't pass it up now. Mike called me and told me the news - i said i cant be there for another two weeks. He held it for me. Drove there to pick it up and see it for first time, they asked me if im still interested after finally driving it for first time as if there was no pressure at all to be locked in. Signed papers and drove it home... Its been 2 years now and its still driving great! With cheaper prices i expected to have to put a little more money into it after getting it but surprisingly all costs have been normal wear... Very happy I went through with it. It was a super stressful 3 weeks for me buying a car I never seen or drove, worrying about EVERYTHING, but it was well worth it.

My 1st Forester is a 2009 turbocharged model which is still going strong with 110,000 miles. The newer Foresters offer safety and convenience features mine doesn't have so I decided to upgrade. The 2019 Forester no longer offers the turbocharged version so I opted for a certified pre-owned 2018 XT Touring which has a turbocharger. I love the vehicle but because the turbo is no longer available, the used turbo versions have become quite pricey. I am keeping the old one for hauling dogs, lawn equipment and towing my utility trailer. The new one will be just for people for now. The vehicle is just the right size. I am 6'4" and would appreciate a little more leg room and thigh support but the Forester is as comfortable as any other small SUV I checked. There is plenty of headroom. The turbo does require premium fuel and has a lower mileage rating. With the turbo and sports tuned suspension, it is a fun vehicle to drive and worth the money to me. In over 10 years, the older one left me stranded only once when a drive belt broke after 100,000 miles. Based on reviews, I expect the same reliability from the newer one.

I was looking for a newer car for my Daughter. I did a lot of research. Checked out a lot of new car dealerships. You know how that goes. Some called back some didn't. I am a very busy person so I didn't want to run around to a lot of dealerships. Like everyone else I just wanted a good Idea of how much is the car going to cost me.Lets face it isn't that what matters most besides Safety of course.. Well after several New Car dealerships and hearing when can you come in when can you come in. I came across Automotive Avenues. You talk about selection you will see Everything. I mean everything. My daughter was looking for the new Accord. I went on the website and saw a BEAUTIFUL 2017 Accord Sport with only 5 thousand miles. This car looks nice on the site but when I got there it was even nicer.. I mean Mint.. I saved Thousands of dollars buying a pre-owned car from Auto Ave My salesman was Tom Brennan. He was a true gentleman and a wonderful salesperson. I met Alan Carter and also 2 of the owners. The staff was even friendly to us.. I am not one to write reviews but this had to be put out there. Check this place out. Not my fault if you buy 2 cars.. Worth the trip Trust Me P. S. My daughter loves the car That's the most important thing to me. Thanks Guys keep doing what your doing. Like Arnold says" ILL BE BACK" Michael H Freehold NJ

The only concern that I had was the fact my leg room may have been less then I had hoped for. Other then that it was an outstanding auto.

Easily Called ahead to make an appointment, and from the moment of arrival, you are greeted by friendly smiling faces. We worked with Greg who was personable and listened to what we had to say. He made the process smooth and easy and quick! We were in and out in under two hours and that???s with waiting about 20 minutes for a heavy rainfall to stop. No pressure, just information to make the best decision. Truly felt like family! It was well worth the two hour drive from home.

When it comes to safety, reliability, value for the money, and best of all it's performance in the snow, Subaru is hands down the VERY BEST. I would challenge any other car brand to beat any of these qualities in a car . . . no matter what the price!!!

I drove from Ct to New Jersey to buy a car from Automotive Avenues which was recommended by USAA. The experience was great. Barry made the process smooth and quick which is what I was looking for. Great customer service and honest from the start. Very organized and systematic. I would recommend this dealership to my family and friends. Great job!!

The rear automatic braking system kills my love for this car. If the eyesight thinks you're going to hit something (a wall, another car, etc), it sounds a brief warning, then slams on the brakes. You might just be backing into or out of a steep driveway though. It scares the daylights out of you if you're not expecting it. Literally, the brakes will lock up. There is no instant kill switch for it, and it takes a while to turn it off while holding your finger on the button. I can't back into my own driveway without this thing slamming on the brakes unless I hold up traffic while pushing and holding a button to clear. It resets every time you put the car into reverse. I hate this "feature" so badly. I wish I could permanently disable it.

Had a great experience buying the car, everything was simple and easy and the price was fantastic (lowest I was able to find on this particular model nationwide). I am an out of state buyer, buying the car from MA and having it shipped from NJ. I had a bit of difficulty understanding the titling/registration process, but this was purely due to my ignorance in the way our RMV system works. There were some kinks to work out in terms of the title/registration, but Bill (the owner) personally helped me resolve the issue the same day! I couldn't be more happy with the car and wouldn't hesitate to purchase from automotive avenues again. They did everything possible to ensure a smooth transaction and their prices truly can't be beat.

This car just keeps getting better. Eyesight, Appleplay, auto door locks, improved display......I thought I loved my 2017 Outback!! Subaru continuously strives to improve upon what they have instead of trying to razzle dazzle you. I will never own anything but a Subaru.

Hands down the best place to buy a used car. The salesman Tom was so honest n into what we were looking for and our needs. 100%. Billy the owner went over n beyond to help us for what we wanted. No pressure only making our decision so easy n accommodating. Cannot say enough nice things about our experience. My daughter who is turning 17???next week her first car n she knew exactly what she wanted when she saw the car and you guys made that happen for her.. it was beyond what I thought I would of gotten for my Daughters first vehicle. Thank You For making this a great purchase!!!

After two Outbacks we sized up to Ascent. So far, great, as we have only had it a few days. The Subaru reputation for reliability, style, handling, comfort and details is why we keep coming back.

Leah the receptionist was so helpful and pleasant . Rad I didn't realize came in on his day off today after I spoke w him Saturday stating I wanted to place a deposit and test drive the Chevy Equinox that I bought this morning. I have bought three cars ( kids) in the last 2 years and have never experienced such a great experience! I will need another car in two years and plan to return! No need to look elsewhere! This place is the BEST! Thank you Rad and Leah!!!

This is my 4th STI and I have tried to buy other cars for daily driving like m3, m4 ,911, GTI yer none of them have the same feeling as an STI. I think most STI owners understand what I’m referring to. From the community, the drivability, the versatility, the safety all these thing but there is still some unexplainable feeling you get from driving these cars that I just don’t get from other manufacturers. I will always be an STI owner and can’t wait for the new generation to be unveiled!

One week ago I purchased a 2015 CAD Luxury SRX with less than 30K miles. Max was informative and very accommodating. I would recommend Automotive Avenues.

car was full of creature comforts, from heated seats and mirrors,to back up camera and paddle shifters. some road noise but its the nature of the beast for this model. i didn't buy it for comfort. Its a sports car with a budget that gives you AWD, turbo and great styling!

If you want to be treated with respect & compassion in your quest for a new vehicle, I highly recommend Bryan Hughes, who was vitaL in helping me acquire a 2018 B5 BLUE 392 T/A CHALLENGER. Back when I was 20 years old I had a 1972 Challenger and wanted another one as a retirement present to myself.It is a 2018 color that wasn't available until mid-March and I got a very superlative deal and price from Bryan Hughes that was way better than any other NJ dealer. If I wanted a better deal I would have had to go to North Carolina. I planted seeds with Bryan approximately 2 years ago, with my quest to buy this specific color Challenger. He was like a younger brother(that I never had), to me and treated me with the utmost respect and knew how compassionate I was to acquire this car. Buying here was a treasure & pleasure I'll remember, 4 the rest of my life

I really enjoy almost everything about the car. It drives well, good features, good mileage for AWD. I wish the body was not so low to the ground ( easy to scrape on curbs etc ) but I want a sedan and it seems all sedans now are low like this one nowadays.

I had the best expierence here ever Kyle dulcimer helped me out a lot. When I didn’t think I would. Be able to find help.

This car has a lot of the features I loved. I love this car a lot. It has more leg room than my old car did.

The sales rep, Bob Simons, made the registration process and delivery of my XC60 trouble free. He gave a detailed explanation of the XC60's features and offered a follow-up orientation after I have the vehicle for a few weeks.

THIS CAR HAS DEVELOPED TOO MANY PROBLEMS; TWO ARE RELATED TO THE A/C SYSTEM; OTHERS ARE RELATED TO WHEEL BEARINGS, AND AXLES. THE VEHICLE MAKES "POPPING NOISES" IN THE DASHBOARD. IN ADDITION, THE REAR HATCH DOESN'T GO UP ANYMORE WITHOUT HELP, AND THE EXTERIOR MIRRORS MOVE AROUND INSIDE THEIR FRAMES WHILE DRIVING ON THE HIGHWAY.

I recently purchased a car from Highline Motor Cars in South Hampton. This was the best car buying experience I have ever had. Saeed was very professional. It was a pleasure dealing with him. There was no pressure from him nor were there any hidden fees. I really appreciated the calmness and honesty from Saeed from the first time I contacted him inquiring about the car, to the last hand shake before driving off in my new car. The car was just as described in the ad and was very competitively priced. I recommend this dealership to anybody in the market for a used car. Don't hesitate about this place. It's the real deal, family owned business. Very respectful, courteous, and polite. 2 thumbs up. 5 stars all the way!!

So I'd always been a subaru fan. As I got older I made my way through the subaru family, beginning with a forester to a wrx 2003 to a liberty gt 2005 another few subarus until my 2012 wrx. Which is basically the same as the 2013. I had an accident and decided to 'grow up' and got my bmw. It was a good car, fast, comfortable and attractive. But I missed my wrx. It came to upgrading my bmw and I saw my current 2013 wrx for sale, one owner and a few tasteful mods. I knew it was the car for me. I saved money (which I did not care about) but I got that feeling back. The rumble back and the connection to driving that I'd lost in the bmw. I felt like myself again. The rex is quick, reliable, good on fuel, fits the family for small trips and always puts a smile on my face. I love this car much more than a vehicle 5 times its price. My mates with their range rovers, one an m3 and another an m5 to me have sold out. I know they love the sound and the woosh and they secretly wish their wives would let them have some jdm fun. I wont sell this car. It's my future classic.