Subaru Forester for Sale in Buffalo, NY

69 vehicles found
Get the latest listings by email

You have created an alert for this search

When a new relevant car is added to our site, we will email you!

Currently in stock: New CPO Used
PRICE DROP
See all 35 photos
Used
$16,991 $17,991 34,350 mi.

2015 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

Good Deal
  • Ext. Color: White
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
Mike Barney Nissan
() -
(888) 901-4305
5 (52 reviews)
0 mi. from 14226
Check Availability
() -
(888) 901-4305
Dealer Review
Trustworthy & My Go to Dealer
by Walter K from Orchard Park NY
October 29, 2018
5 5 (52 reviews)
You'll find honest people who work hard here, and nobody tries to make the customer happier. It's not a perfect place and customers are not perfect either.
3 years old and it looks brand new
by BarriH from Silsbee Texas
January 15, 2019
5
This car had my must-haves. It was not silver or gray, has a moon roof and a good carfax history. I feel pampered in the leather HEATED seats. I can filly say I have a hot behind!
See all 25 photos
Used
$19,000 34,019 mi.

2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

Good Deal
  • Ext. Color: Silver
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
Ray Laks Acura of Buffalo
() -
(833) 209-4051
4.7 (44 reviews)
5 mi. from 14226
Check Availability
() -
(833) 209-4051
Dealer Review
Great customer service!
by Lisa Matthews from East Aurora, NY
December 4, 2018
5 4.7 (44 reviews)
Excellent customer service and attention to detail.
Solid 4-wheel drive SUV
by tah9 from Erie PA
January 29, 2019
4
Positive: Very solid 4-wheel drive medium-size SUV. Great interior, wonderful visibility through large windows for safe turning, changing lanes and backing up. Handy rear video backup camera. Good traction for winters, even without snow tires. Eyesight package is a comforting feature, even for short local highway drives, since it helps keep you in pace with traffic without going over your set limit. Heated front seats are sweet. Negative: Rubber pad on back bumper (part of winter package) seems to come unglued (body shops have reattached it twice). Plastic cowls (about 8" long) next to wipers on left and right sides of windshield rattle in the wind. Lacks low-oil indicator on dash display, so only way to know is to manually check oil level.
See all 32 photos
Used
$30,909 8,922 mi.

2018 Subaru Forester 2.5i Touring

Good Deal
HOT CAR
  • Ext. Color: Silver
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
West Herr Nissan INFINITI of Williamsville
() -
(716) 406-4511
4.9 (357 reviews)
5 mi. from 14226
Check Availability
() -
(716) 406-4511
Dealer Review
Everything you’d hope for when buying a vehicle
by Aaron S from Webster, NY
September 22, 2018
5 4.9 (357 reviews)
I can’t say enough about this dealership so I’ll make it simple. West Herr is TOP NOTCH! Great staff, facilities, customer service, selection and prices. I worked with Chris Nash in sales, who was very knowledgeable and personable. They got me a great deal on a 2018 Pathfinder. I will definitely be referring people to West Herr and will be back again for my next vehicle.
Very sporty, handles great
by Landry from Haverhill
January 29, 2019
5
Meets every need, roomy, drives great in snow, handles better than any suv I've driven. Look, design, USB portals, road side assistance, bluetooth, all great features
See all 42 photos
Subaru Certified
$26,904 4,861 mi.

2019 Subaru Forester Premium

Good Deal
  • Ext. Color: Gray
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
West Herr Subaru
() -
(585) 687-4028
4.8 (606 reviews)
13 mi. from 14226
Authorized Subaru Dealer
Check Availability
() -
(585) 687-4028
Dealer Review
The Best!
by Michael Murrin from Hamburg, NY
November 30, 2018
5 4.8 (606 reviews)
If you are in the market for a Subaru, by all means checkout West Herr. I believe this is now our fifth Subaru from their dealership and the experience seems to get better each and every time. Not only do we know we are getting a wonderful deal, but the people are fantastic to work with--never high pressure, always accommodating, and they treat you as if you are their only customer.
Most Innovated Car I have Ever Owned
by ottob from Rocky Point, New York
January 29, 2019
5
The safety features on this car are far beyond anything I ever expected. This car has " facial recognition" , adaptive cruise, lane change warning, front collision stop as well as rear stop. The headlights steer with the car, the auto dimming mirrors, rear & side, protect you from glare at night, automatic high beam on & off & an unbelievable amount of air bags. The rear seats are heated & so much more. Look up the Subaru Forester Touring to see how much more it offers.
See all 38 photos
Used
$18,919 19,430 mi.

2015 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

Good Deal
  • Ext. Color: Gray
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
West Herr Subaru
() -
(585) 687-4390
4.8 (606 reviews)
13 mi. from 14226
Authorized Subaru Dealer
Check Availability
() -
(585) 687-4390
Dealer Review
Subaru
by forester from Hamburg, NY
November 30, 2018
5 4.8 (606 reviews)
I've always wanted a subaru but wasn't sure exactly what I was looking for. I worked with Rob Moore to find the perfect fit in my price range. Happy I went to West Herr.
I love my Forester more than a Cadillac
by KeyLime from Shiloh, Illinois
January 13, 2019
5
I have a 2015 2.5i base. I fell in love with a Cadillac XT5 at a car show, and test drove one and a Lexus but could not bring myself to give up the Subie. While I would like more power, I like the MPG. Therefore when a more powerful engine is more important I will drive my Taurus SHO and get 20 MPG. I love the visibility in the Forester, one of the prime reasons my next vehicle will be another Forester. I very much like the visibility. For people who complain about the seats, I'm not sure what's wrong; I have a bad back and they're fine. If you test drive one and don't like the seats, don't buy it and then complain. Also for people who complain about the stiff ride, it's an SUV with AWD so not sure what they expect. Buy something with a suspension for a soft ride. I feel like the Forester is very sure footed, I'm comfortable on long trips and very happy with it. Mileage is great for AWD, I've gotten as much as 37MPG (albeit when stuck behind someone going a lot slower than I want). The sound system isn't the best, but it's upgradeable if that's important and you want to pay for it. Cons: uninspired styling (but then again exciting looks don't make it go faster), no guts (but I knew that going in), and underwhelming audio. Pros: good MPG, great safety features and outstanding visibility.
See all 41 photos
Subaru Certified
$24,422 22,520 mi.

2016 Subaru Forester 2.0XT Touring

Good Deal
  • Ext. Color: Silver
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
West Herr Subaru
() -
(585) 687-4028
4.8 (606 reviews)
13 mi. from 14226
Authorized Subaru Dealer
Check Availability
() -
(585) 687-4028
Dealer Review
Love my new Subaru!! Thank you Lindsay!!
by WTL from Buffalo, NY
November 26, 2018
5 4.8 (606 reviews)
Lindsay and her assistant, Dominic helped me pick out the perfect car that fit my needs and budget. Chuck, the ganeral manager, was also very helpful in figuring out how to get me into my new Subaru within my budget and with a great protection plan. I definately recommend calli g Lindsay and her team for your next car!
Great car; excellent visability
by LynO from Boone, NC
January 30, 2019
5
This car is great for mountain roads and highway driving. Eyesight was a selling point when I purchased and recommend buying Starlink every year. Having that connection when something has happened is worth every cent. What sold me along with Eyesight was the visibility of the Forester and the interior room. I tested a CRV and the Forester and the Sub won hands down.
See all 40 photos
Used
$17,951 51,952 mi.

2015 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

Good Deal
  • Ext. Color: Green
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
West Herr Subaru
() -
(585) 687-4390
4.8 (606 reviews)
13 mi. from 14226
Authorized Subaru Dealer
Check Availability
() -
(585) 687-4390
Dealer Review
Great customer service!
by MariaB from Buffalo NY
November 23, 2018
5 4.8 (606 reviews)
Everyone’s so nice and helpful- wonderful place to go for sales and service. Love my new Forester from Mike Decarlo! Recommend him to all family and friends.
Best handling and economic car we have owned
by Mountain Lovers from Jacksonville
January 9, 2019
5
This car has great gas mileage, and handles really well. We have taken it on camping trips up into the mountains, and had to problems with packing in all our camping gear. It has been a dream car for both in town, and on vacation trips.
See all 42 photos
Subaru Certified
$26,906 6,767 mi.

2019 Subaru Forester Premium

Good Deal
  • Ext. Color: Gray
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
West Herr Subaru
() -
(585) 687-4028
4.8 (606 reviews)
13 mi. from 14226
Authorized Subaru Dealer
Check Availability
() -
(585) 687-4028
Dealer Review
West Herr Subaru
by Matthew from Buffalo, NY
October 31, 2018
5 4.8 (606 reviews)
This afternoon I picked up my brand new Subaru Forester! I can't even put into words how exceptional my experience was! Amanda was my salesperson and she made the entire buying process effortless and FUN! If you're looking for a car dealership that FAR EXCEEDS expectations, West Herr Subaru is the dealership for you!
Couldn't be happier!!
by Stephanie32 from Wyoming, Mi
January 28, 2019
5
I recently began leasing a 2019 Subaru Forester and couldn't be happier! The AWD and safety features are so amazing! This vehicle practically drives itself!
See all 41 photos
Used
$20,520 20,481 mi.

2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

Good Deal
HOT CAR
  • Ext. Color: Silver
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
West Herr Subaru
() -
(585) 687-4390
4.8 (606 reviews)
13 mi. from 14226
Authorized Subaru Dealer
Check Availability
() -
(585) 687-4390
Dealer Review
Great Experience!
by Julie from Wyoming, NY
October 27, 2018
5 4.8 (606 reviews)
Hasan made our purchasing process for our new Subaru Crosstrek simple and actually fun! Our entire experience from the moment we walked in to the moment we drove out in our new car was stress free and enjoyable. Hasan was very helpful but not at all high-pressure. We will definitely be returning to West Herr for any future car purchases and will highly recommend them to our friends and family.
Love my Subaru
by Ivonne from Nashua, NH
January 20, 2019
4
Feel safe! Had a rollover in a 2012 Forester, the other driver fell sleep. Because I am alive, the insurance adjuster said he has never seen anyone survive such an accident, I bought myself another one, a 2016. The only complaint is the Yokahama Geolander tires. I only have 24,000 miles on them but they are worn. Never seen such a thing. Will be replacing them in a few days before inspection. Other reviews say the same, they are the low quality eventhough they are expensive. In my family we own several Subaru's.
See all 39 photos
Used
$19,520 20,682 mi.

2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i

Good Deal
HOT CAR
  • Ext. Color: Silver
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
West Herr Subaru
() -
(585) 687-4390
4.8 (606 reviews)
13 mi. from 14226
Authorized Subaru Dealer
Check Availability
() -
(585) 687-4390
Dealer Review
Kelan
by Kel from Buffalo NY
October 18, 2018
5 4.8 (606 reviews)
Amazing experience. This is my 3rd Outback and i am cannot say enough about the car and the service. Chuck, Amanda and Jason were the personification of customer service. Nothing but West Herr Subaru for me and my family!
Superior for low back & mobility issues.
by MartiJP from Dayton, Ohio
November 22, 2018
5
This car met our family needs. Gas mileage is very good for commuting and very supportive for passenger comfort. Wide doors for easy entry for physically impaired passengers, and loads of leg room. Although better than most, the thickness of the descending support for the right arm rest puts uncomfortable pressure on lateral knee bone. Must adjust seat to partially avoid.
See all 40 photos
Used
$20,923 23,909 mi.

2015 Subaru Forester 2.5i Limited

Good Deal
HOT CAR
  • Ext. Color: White
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
West Herr Subaru
() -
(585) 687-4390
4.8 (606 reviews)
13 mi. from 14226
Authorized Subaru Dealer
Check Availability
() -
(585) 687-4390
Dealer Review
Subaru Outback
by Joe from Buffalo, NY
October 5, 2018
5 4.8 (606 reviews)
Excellent customer service from Sal Sorrento once again. Highly recommended! He took his time to find us the perfect vehicle we were looking for to meet our budget.
Most Reliable Car I Have Owned
by SUVLover from Manassas, VA
January 7, 2019
5
Durable , reliable, a joy to drive, excellent gas mileage, panoramic sunroof, excellent in mud and snow. This vehicle is a true value , It has a premium stereo system
See all 39 photos
Used
$17,945 45,557 mi.

2015 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

Good Deal
HOT CAR
  • Ext. Color: Silver
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
West Herr Subaru
() -
(585) 687-4390
4.8 (606 reviews)
13 mi. from 14226
Authorized Subaru Dealer
Check Availability
() -
(585) 687-4390
Dealer Review
Hasan is the man!!
by Tom Porter from Oakfield
September 25, 2018
5 4.8 (606 reviews)
Hasan was unbelievable to deal with. Anyone that can deal with my wife calling and texting for over a week to get the deal she wanted is a god! Very professional and quick witted. We or should I say, my wife got what she wanted and was pleased with the deal Hasan got for her Can't wait for her lease to be up so we can do business there again and "deal" with him again, lol.
Twas almost the night before Christmas.....
by Grateful to be alive! from Daniel Island, SC
December 21, 2018
5
Our Subaru saved our lives tonight! Those airbags deployed beautifully when that idiot tried to beat the red light, speeding straight toward us and totaled our car, head on! We walked away after we were cut out of all the protective airbags! Oh my God, thank you EMTs and Subaru! I opened my eyes, hands shaking to feel like I was in a cocoon! Truth!
See all 39 photos
Used
$15,951 51,644 mi.

2015 Subaru Forester 2.5i

Good Deal
  • Ext. Color: Black
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX Report
West Herr Subaru
() -
(585) 687-4390
4.8 (606 reviews)
13 mi. from 14226
Authorized Subaru Dealer
Check Availability
() -
(585) 687-4390
Dealer Review
New Impreza
by New Impreza from Hamburg, NY
September 21, 2018
5 4.8 (606 reviews)
Everything was great! Andrew and Chuck went above and beyond to get everything done! I'll refer anyone I see to Andrew and Chuck! Excellent time
easiest experience ever- buying a car
by cheapchick56 from tulsa, ok
December 18, 2018
5
I love this car! I've wanted a Subaru for a while now. It's comfortable, really nice to drive- great experience with Jim Norton Toyota!! Brad Minser, BEST SALESMAN EVER!! Financing people... it was great!
See all 42 photos
Used
$21,912 12,530 mi.

2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

Good Deal
HOT CAR
  • Ext. Color: Gray
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
West Herr Subaru
() -
(585) 687-4390
4.8 (606 reviews)
13 mi. from 14226
Authorized Subaru Dealer
Check Availability
() -
(585) 687-4390
70,000 mile review from the Pioneer Mtns
by Buddy from Apex, MT
November 1, 2018
4
No mechanical or electrical problems so far. Fuel economy 22-28 mpg at highway speeds, 300 miles for sure on a tank of gas. Wet road and snow traction is excellent with General Altimax Arctic or Hankook Ipike tires. Switched to Subaru 16? steel wheels, 16x6.5, these are spare tire wheels for year 2012 or older. Good low speed acceleration, acceptable highway passing power. Steering wheel adjusts up/down and in/out which is helpful. Good brakes. Good visibility from inside to outside. Nice heavy duty floor mats, much better than aftermarket. For first 11,000 miles, switched to 5w-30 conventional oil with oil changes every 3k miles. I saved the oil and filter and reinstalled in the car after 11,000 miles. At this point switched back to 0w-20 full synthetic oil. Current oil consumption is less than 1 quart between 6000+ mile oil changes. Fine print in manual said 5w-30 was ok. Interior heater / defroster when below freezing best to let the car warm up for at least 10 minutes so windshield can defrost. Seat covers stain easy, clean-up water stains them too. Delay of vehicle movement shifting from forward to reverse or back, have to plan for this lag time.
See all 40 photos
Used
$20,919 19,987 mi.

2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

Good Deal
HOT CAR
  • Ext. Color: Silver
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
West Herr Subaru
() -
(585) 687-4390
4.8 (606 reviews)
13 mi. from 14226
Authorized Subaru Dealer
Check Availability
() -
(585) 687-4390
Fun to drive, does what it is supposed to do!
by thinuwang from New York, NY
October 25, 2018
5
So far, I am very happy with my Forester. Plenty of power, enough space, fun to drive. It's not the most sportiest looking compact SUV, but still it is very decent looking.
See all 39 photos
Used
$20,820 20,561 mi.

2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

Good Deal
HOT CAR
  • Ext. Color: Silver
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
West Herr Subaru
() -
(585) 687-4390
4.8 (606 reviews)
13 mi. from 14226
Authorized Subaru Dealer
Check Availability
() -
(585) 687-4390
I love Subarus!
by Jmr from Paxton
October 8, 2018
5
I traded an older Forester for a newer Touring. This was the 3 rd subaru I’ve owned and I will never buy another brand. The quality, safety options, visibility, turning radius far succeeds any other cars I have owned
See all 41 photos
Used
$20,721 21,977 mi.

2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

Good Deal
HOT CAR
  • Ext. Color: Black
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
West Herr Subaru
() -
(585) 687-4390
4.8 (606 reviews)
13 mi. from 14226
Authorized Subaru Dealer
Check Availability
() -
(585) 687-4390
We love this car in all kinds of weather
by Cobbmaster from Sweetwater OK
October 2, 2018
5
This car is most likely the best car I have ever had. It is roomy and easy for us to get in and out of the back up camera works great and it has all the power it needs from the boxer motor there is room for a lot of hauling with the fold down rear seats we love it
See all 44 photos
Used
$23,525 25,491 mi.

2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium

Good Deal
  • Ext. Color: Blue
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
West Herr Subaru
() -
(585) 687-4390
4.8 (606 reviews)
13 mi. from 14226
Authorized Subaru Dealer
Check Availability
() -
(585) 687-4390
Good All-Purpose Car
by Alex from Brooklyn, NY
January 29, 2019
4
Full disclosure: My girlfriend owns it, but I drive it a lot. I find the 2017 Forester to be a pretty decent small SUV. I find it comfortable and fairly well-designed. I'm not a huge fan of CVTs but find it has enough pep when I need it. The dash is fairly well-organized and all critical controls are knobs and buttons rather than buried in the touch screen like some cars. A few things could be slightly better organized but these are minor details. The Subaru infotainment system is pretty lacking and the touch screen is buggy sometimes. They're behind the curve on this. But overall it's a decent car even if I'd like it more with a 6 speed manual.
See all 41 photos
Used
$20,930 30,280 mi.

2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i Limited

Good Deal
  • Ext. Color: Gray
  • Int. Color: Gray
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
West Herr Subaru
() -
(585) 687-4390
4.8 (606 reviews)
13 mi. from 14226
Authorized Subaru Dealer
Check Availability
() -
(585) 687-4390
Extremely pleased. Meets our list of desires.
by Forester Fan from Gresham, OR
September 26, 2018
5
We are extremely satisfied with this car. It is a used vehicle but has a Suburu Certification of quality. Drives like a dream, great power, tight turn radius, beautiful. Has all the bells and whistles I wanted.
See all 41 photos
Subaru Certified
$26,905 5,066 mi.

2019 Subaru Forester Premium

Good Deal
HOT CAR
  • Ext. Color: Gray
  • Int. Color: Black
  • Transmission: CVT
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
  • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
West Herr Subaru
() -
(585) 687-4028
4.8 (606 reviews)
13 mi. from 14226
Authorized Subaru Dealer
Check Availability
() -
(585) 687-4028
So happy to be back in a Subaru!
by Jules from Vancouver WA
January 28, 2019
5
I previously owned a Subaru outback, which was the best car I had ever had. I was determined that I was going to get another Subaru some day and I’m not disappointed at all In my new Forrester. This car handles very well, has plenty of zip for this lead foot, and is a very comfortable ride. It’s too soon for me to Comment on the reliability because I’ve only had it for three weeks. However, past experience with Subaru makes me feel very comfortable that I have a reliable safe and economic vehicle.
* Title, other fees, and incentives are not included in this calculation, which is an estimate only. Monthly payment estimates are for illustrative purposes only and do not represent a financing offer from the seller. Other taxes may apply.
The information on vehicles provided in this service is supplied by the seller or other third parties; Cars.com is not responsible for the accuracy of such information. Cars.com provides this service and materials without representations or warranties of any kind, either expressed or implied. See our terms of service for more details.
69  matches
  • Back
    Location
      Search within
    • Include vehicles outside of my search radius that can be delivered to my home.
  • Back
    New/Used
  • Back
    Year
    to
  • Back
    Model
  • Back
    Trim
  • Back
    Price
  • Back
    Mileage
  • Back
    Deal Rating
  • Back
    Features
  • Back
    Body Style
  • Back
    Exterior Color
  • Back
    Interior Color
  • Back
    Drivetrain
  • Back
    Transmission
  • Back
    Cylinders
  • Back
    Photos
  • Back
    Fuel
  • Back
    Door Count
  • Back
    Dealer Ratings
  • Back
    Listing Date
  • Back
    Seller Type
  • Back
    Keywords
New Search