Save your search and get notified when new inventory arrives.
Contact seller
Customize your budget
*Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.
**Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.
About your privacy: Cars.com is asking for your ZIP and credit rating because it helps us to make an educated guess at your sales tax and loan interest. These two factors can greatly change your monthly payment.
Used
Subaru Forester
for sale
near
Elma, NY
- Down Payment
- $0
- Net trade-in value
- $0
- Months
- 72
- APR
- 7.0%
- Sales tax
- 0.0%
*Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.
**Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.












Used
2024 Subaru Forester Limited






Used
2021 Subaru Forester Limited
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
A little slow on shop work, part looked at had a part
A little slow on shop work, part looked at had a part pushed in place had a park checked a second time and it still felt back out
Good cornering and visibility. Sportily boxy.
I like the solid feel of the car and the sturdy and high ride. Good acceleration. It would be a better SUV if the ground clearance was at least 10” or 12”, with the exhaust pipe properly tucked away!






Used
2020 Subaru Forester Base
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
They treat you like royalty.
They treat you like royalty...or that you're in the running for pope. I exaggerate...but it's a great experience...especially with Veronica Lorenz. They got me the SUV I wanted at the best price. KBB cash offer helped too. Thanks to all at WestHerr Toyota.
Happy Forester Owner
The Forester is the first SUV I ever owned. It has had a few issues, but the dealership, Kenny Ross in Irwin Pa, has always been top notch in customer service. First issue was the orignal tires went bald after only 10,000 miles. I called Kenny Ross and they said they would contact corporate. Got 4 new tires at no charge. Next issue I did not even know I had. Took it in for an oil change and they tell me I need a new CVT. Didn't know I had a problem. No charge again. Last issue was a radio that kept giving an error message and would not work. Took four visits to isolate the problem, but now have a new radio that brings in more stations. Again for free. Highly recommend the bumper to bumper warranty. Money well spent.






Used
2020 Subaru Forester Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Noah in service was so helpful and the work was done very
Noah in service was so helpful and the work was done very quickly! Everyone was very professional!
Happy and satisfied beyond my wildest dreams!
I have a 2020 Forester with 19000 miles. I love it, especially as a tall and aging man. It it easy to drive, easy to get in and get out. Miles per gallon is great, typically well over 30 mpg in day to day city driving. I have noticed a number of complaints about batteries. I think in 2019-2020 they had a bad supplier of batteries. My experience was total battery failure at about 10000 miles. I had to purchase a replacement from AAA. Such stories were common during that period. I was irritated but received reimbursement even though it is not typical for a dealer/car company to do so. Smart dealers want to keep your business. The only other expenses were created by potholes knocking the car out of allignment and nails in parking lots puncturing the same tire twice! Sweep your xxxx parking lots retailers and restaurants.






Used
2022 Subaru Forester Touring
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
The best place to buy a vehicle Mike de George, ken Kobe
The best place to buy a vehicle Mike de George, ken Kobe , Jim basil Jr the best in the business
Beyond Satisfied!
This is my third Subaru Forrester. I like the newer safety features and ease of handling. The size is perfect for me, not too small or too big! I would recommend if you’re looking for a midsize vehicle.






Used
2019 Subaru Forester Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Had a great experience at West Herr Toyota.
Had a great experience at West Herr Toyota. Staff is friendly, knowledgeable and worked hard to get my vehicle.
I had to make a 5 1/2 hour drive recently and loved how
I had to make a 5 1/2 hour drive recently and loved how smoothly my car drove, especially using cruise control with “eyesight” so it slowed when I was too close to the car in front of me. I couldn’t even feel it; I watched the speedometer. Love the safety features and extras like seat warmers and large sunroof.






Used
2023 Subaru Forester Limited
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
We came in to look at the new Palisade.
We came in to look at the new Palisade. Gentleman named Austin Kowalski. I have worked with the public for 45 years. He shines as a people person! He explained the different options available and could not have been more genuine in his efforts to help us. We came back to buy the vehicle, and he was great at explaining everything we were doing, and made us very welcome. You should be proud of him and your dealership, great job!
Safety first
This is our second Forester. Our first was a 2011 Premium we bought as a CPO in 2014 and unfortunately went through the headache of excessive oil consumption within months of buying it. Subaru did eventually replace the engine short block on their dime, but only after repeated oil consumption tests and being told by the dealer service department that it was within normal limits. Calling Subaru of America was the only way we got it resolved. I was impressed that they approved the service, and that's the reason we bought another Subaru. We also have a 2018 Outback Premium in our garage--no oil consumption, and no major issues except replacing the radio for failed lighting behind the volume knob and a minor leak in the oil pan (no dripping underneath the car though) at about 42k miles. We like our 2023 Forester Sport overall, and first and foremost we like its excellent safety ratings and features. I will say the ride is much firmer than our Outback which is only a couple hundred pounds heavier. Wish it had a little more storage in the center console and beneath the climate controls. We look forward to many years of driving with the Forester (and our Outback). Based on our experience, I do feel getting a Subaru-backed extended warranty is worth it for peace of mind (we bought them for our first Forester and now our Outback and both eventually paid for themselves). You DON'T have to buy the warranty when you purchase the vehicle. Call different dealers in your state and ask for their price on an extended warranty for your vehicle--we saved hundreds of dollars by doing this. You have until your manufacturer warranty expires to add an extended warranty.






Used
2021 Subaru Forester Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Spontaneous windshield explosion!
Spontaneous windshield cracked to 2 1/2 feet in just seconds! No stones seen, without warning, bang. The part cost $850.00 more for eye-sight calibration! Subaru dealer said total cost, around $2000!






Used
2019 Subaru Forester Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Everyone was pleasant, helpful, informative and friendly.
Everyone was pleasant, helpful, informative and friendly. It was a very nice experience and would definatly come back again
I recently had my car stolen and totaled.
I recently had my car stolen and totaled. I actually work for the dealership and enjoy the work I do with the company. Mr krohn has been helping me out for the past month and a half with a car. It has been difficult but with the patience and time he has given my mom and I, I could not be more grateful for him! He worked with my mom and I till the very end and has been nothing but helpful. I ended up getting a 2019 subaru forester. Lots of room and a perfect vehicle into the middle of my adult life. I hope this car lasts me through the next few years. Thank you Mr Steve Krohn for your hard work and the kindness you have shown us.






Used
2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
I highly recommend West Herr for new or used vehicles.
I highly recommend West Herr for new or used vehicles. My salesman, Emmanuel Conteh, is a true joy to work with. The minute you sit down in his cubicle, you know you are dealing with a man that is honest, knowledgeable and a joy to work with. He made my car leasing such a breeze! WNY is fortunate to have West Herr dealerships!
Great vehicle
I have owned my 2017 Forester since late 2016. Except for normal maintenance I've had no problems with thr vehicle. All of the warning systems work very well,they have saved me from accidents numerous times. The automatic seat repositioning when some one else has used my is really handy eliminates all the adjusting needed to get the position back to my needs. Traction and controll during winter and bad weather are excellent. My forrester get used like a truck at times. Great overall car.






Used
2023 Subaru Forester Wilderness
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
West Herr Jeep has a great selection of vehicles!
Jason, Aron, Liza and JP are an amazing group of people to work with when buying a car. They were so helpful and fostered a fun, relaxed atmosphere. I would highly recommend West Herr for your new Jeep!
Mostly happy
The radio and the heat settings leave a lot to be desired. If you’re looking for a heater setting, you won’t find it. Nothing annoys me more than unrequested updates on flood watch/warning. it just can’t be tailored to exactly where you live. But every 6 minutes is a bit of overkill. And our previous Forester had a tray in the middle storage (glove box). Even though we asked our salesman about that, we have heard nothing. Missing the change tray a lot.






Used
2015 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Paul was great he has great customer service skills would
Paul was great he has great customer service skills would highly recommend west herr Honda for vehicle service
Bought my 2015 Subaru 2.
Bought my 2015 Subaru 2.0XT Touring brand spanking new off the Subaru dealership's lot. Have owned it all this time about 9 years straight. Take care of your car with regular oil changes, servicing at recommended intervals, and your car will take care of you. Performed the required recalls during service periods. Not 1 single regret on owning this car, ever. It rides smooth and true. Had a clicking issue in the ball joints 2 years ago which Subaru fixed free of charge. Other than that, this car has been my dream machine.






Used
2014 Subaru Forester 2.5i Limited
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Nick and his brother Richard and the rest of the folks at
Nick and his brother Richard and the rest of the folks at SAS treat you like family. I thoroughly enjoyed the experience of purchasing my 2021 Ford Transit 150 Cargo Van from SAS. I traveled 75 miles to get the vehicle and it was absolutely worth it. I highly recommend SAS.
Great for family and pet owners
I was between a rock and a hard place after my Honda passed away-it drove itself to its demise due to the handbrake not on tight enough. So I had nothing to trade, no leverage. I know Subarus owned many Outbacks and they go forever. The problem is I'm 5' tall and this car is too big for me after the Honda and a Miata I have. I had 2 big dogs and felt the car would be great for a dog owner. Which it is. One dog rode on the back seat (covered) the other had the back to herself. Great for a dog owner. If you need a crate there's plenty of room. This would be a great vehicle for a children or pet family. I only have one 10 yr old dog left and this uses too much gas for me to consider a practical vehicle.






Used
2019 Subaru Forester Limited
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Happy Demanding Customer
I’ve driven the Forester before and have been wanting one for two years. So now that it was time for me to give up my 2010 Legacy with 222,000 miles on it, I chose the Forester. The dealer is very customer friendly and very competitive in their pricing, even though I paid 25K plus for a four year old car…vestiges of the used car pandemic pricing. The car drives beautifully, smooth and quiet. I am very happy with my purchase.






Used
2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Above and Beyond
Husband and I drove an hour and a half to check out a certain vehicle they had for sale. We had searched and viewed several at other locations. Our salesman Bradley and the dealership, went above and beyond what you normally find while searching for a specific vehicle, to make sure my husband would be happy with his purchase. Added bonus information: Bradley is a man that everyone should meet. Thoroughly kind and fun- and not in a fake way. 🥇 I will shop here again if we ever need another used vehicle. 🏆
In love with this vehicle
I've never owned a Subaru before but after purchasing the Forester, I may never own anything but a Subaru again! I love the Eyesight Drivers Assistant that it came equipped with. I can see why this car has one of the best safety ratings out there. The interior is very open, spacious, & comfortable and the panoramic sunroof is amazing! It drives and handles like a dream. I would recommend this car to anyone. You won't be disappointed!






Used
2020 Subaru Forester Limited
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Rick and Scott were a pleasure to deal with.
Rick and Scott were a pleasure to deal with. They treated me like family throughout the whole process. I will definitely recommend them to my friends and family.
I love driving again!
This is my first Subaru and I’m so impressed! Just a great drive! I love the safety and convenience features…but I also just love to drive again!!!






Used
2011 Subaru Forester 2.5X Touring
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Great Prices and Friendly Staff
I purchased a 2014 Ford Transit from this dealership last week. Andrew, as well as the owner, were very professional and easy to work with. The Transit was sold at a very fair price and I was able to drive it off the lot sooner than expected. Overall, it was a very pleasant and stress-free purchase with a friendly staff.
Dependable and built to last.
I've owned a 2011 Subaru Forester for years and it has been supremely dependable through northern Michigan weather. Super cold to humid and muggy, it's been a comfortable, reliable ride throughout.






Used
2015 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Definitely win my approval !!!!!
The process was seamless. The Sales Manager was informative, patient, thorough and easy to work with. Negotiating was a little challenging but I am satisfied with my purchase !
Excellent choice!
Bought this car three years old with less than 50K miles on it. I’ve loved it since we got it. It has been very reliable, fun to drive, with pretty minor drawbacks. For example the maintenance has been very minimal. I haven’t noticed ANY oil burning or leaking (I have personally changed the oil every 3-4K miles). Sometimes on long trips it will burn some oil and need a top off, which the car alerts us to. Overall I’d buy this car over and over as long as it fit my needs at the time. Currently looking into an Ascent for future hockey trips and other trips.






Used
2018 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Excellent dealership and people.
Joe and Laurie are great people to deal with. No pressure, trouble free process. Everything was handled. I was given a complete run down of the vehicle. Would Definitely recommend this dealer.
Love my 2018 limited Forester , Great as you the very
Love my 2018 limited Forester , Great as you the very comfortable love how it drives good gas mileage so far.. highly recommend this car great for transporting kids also… Very quiet driving experience






Used
2021 Subaru Forester Limited
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Best Salesman.... Demani Barnes
When it's time for a new vehicle, Demani Barnes is very knowledgeable and has an excellent can-do attitude. I highly recommend dealing with Demani and manager Amy Sabers. Thank you Amy and Demani for finding my new ride!! We'll be back!!
The BEST.
One of the best cars I have ever owned. It drives like a dream, has more get-up-and-go then I ever thought a 4 cyl. could have. I make a 3000 miles trip from Texas to Utah in may and averaged 34 miles per gallon. I would recommend them to everyone.






Used
2019 Subaru Forester Limited
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Fantastic customer service from Nicole in the service
Fantastic customer service from Nicole in the service department. She was professional , engaging and knowledgeable. We are die hard Subaru and West Herr fans and Nicole only reinforced our faith in the dealership.
Amazing car for the price
Love my Forester only drawback is the tires are made of a soft compound and you only get 25k miles then they need to be replaced.
Subaru Forester prices by year
Model year | Prices from | Deals |
---|---|---|
2025 Subaru Forester | $32,125 | |
2023 Subaru Forester | $27,538 | 4 Good deals |
2022 Subaru Forester | $25,000 | 13 Good deals |
About the Subaru Forester
How much does the Subaru Forester cost?
The Subaru Forester price depends on several factors, including the trim level, optional features, mileage, vehicle history and location. The nationwide average price for the Forester is $21,756, with pricing starting at $1,900.
What is the MPG of the Subaru Forester?
The Subaru Forester with traditional internal combustion engine offers up to 26 MPG city and 33 MPG highway for a combined rating of 29 MPG.
These figures are based on EPA mileage ratings and are for comparison purposes only. The actual mileage will vary depending on the selected vehicle model year, trim, driving conditions, driving habits, vehicle maintenance, and other factors.
What are some similar vehicles and competitors of the Subaru Forester?
The Subaru Forester compares to and/or competes against the following vehicles:
What trim levels are available for the Subaru Forester?
The Subaru Forester is available in the following trim levels:
What model years are available for the Subaru Forester?
Available model years for Subaru Forester inventory range from 2010 to 2025.
*Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.
**Your Saved Vehicles list will be shared along with your contact information when you submit a vehicle request to a dealership. To opt out of this sharing, please view your options on Cars.com Privacy Notice.
Used Subaru Forester by price
- Subaru Forester for sale under $20,000 in Elma, NY
- Subaru Forester for sale under $25,000 in Elma, NY
- Subaru Forester for sale under $30,000 in Elma, NY
- Subaru Forester for sale under $40,000 in Elma, NY
- Subaru Forester for sale under $50,000 in Elma, NY
- Subaru Forester for sale under $100,000 in Elma, NY
Similar Cars
-
Honda CR-V for sale
4 Great Deals out of 144 listings starting at $8,987
-
Mazda CX-5 for sale
7 Great Deals out of 54 listings starting at $13,994
-
Subaru Crosstrek for sale
2 Great Deals out of 52 listings starting at $11,498
-
Subaru Outback for sale
2 Great Deals out of 47 listings starting at $8,995
-
Toyota RAV4 for sale
5 Great Deals out of 100 listings starting at $11,409
Compare the Subaru Forester
Used Subaru Forester by city
-
Subaru Forester in Elma Center, NY
2 Great Deals out of 77 listings starting at $5,650
-
Subaru Forester in Billington Heights, NY
2 Great Deals out of 77 listings starting at $5,650
-
Subaru Forester in East Aurora, NY
2 Great Deals out of 77 listings starting at $5,650
-
Subaru Forester in Marilla, NY
2 Great Deals out of 77 listings starting at $5,650
-
Subaru Forester in Town Line, NY
2 Great Deals out of 78 listings starting at $5,650
-
Subaru Forester in West Seneca, NY
2 Great Deals out of 77 listings starting at $5,650
-
Subaru Forester in Aurora, NY
2 Great Deals out of 76 listings starting at $5,650
-
Subaru Forester in Lancaster, NY
2 Great Deals out of 77 listings starting at $5,650
-
Subaru Forester in Depew, NY
2 Great Deals out of 77 listings starting at $5,650
-
Subaru Forester in Orchard Park, NY
2 Great Deals out of 71 listings starting at $5,650
-
Subaru Forester in Cheektowaga, NY
2 Great Deals out of 77 listings starting at $5,650
-
Subaru Forester in Wales, NY
2 Great Deals out of 76 listings starting at $5,650
Subaru Forester by trim
-
Subaru Forester Premium
25 listings starting at $17,599
Used Subaru Forester by body style
- ${price_badge()}
- ${ami_badge()}
- ${battery_badge()}${ev_report_link()}
- ${hot_car_badge()}
- ${award_badge()}
- ${cpo_badge()}
${price_badge_description}
${ami_badge_description}
The EV Battery Rating is based on this vehicle's current expected range relative to the vehicles expected range when new. ${battery_badge_text}
Certified cars are manufacturer warrantied and typically go through a rigorous multi-point inspection.
This car is likely to sell soon based on the price, features, and condition.
${award_blurb}
${award_two_blurb}