Cars for Sale

Used Cars for Sale in Middle Island, NY

13282 vehicles found
Save Search
Filters
Save Search
13,282  matches
  • Location
    • Search within
  • New/Used
  • Year
  • Make
    Show all Makes in A-Z Show Popular Makes
  • Price
  • Mileage
  • Vehicle History
  • Deal Rating
  • Features
Show Less Filters Show More Filters
Get the latest listings by email

You have created an alert for this search

When a new relevant car is added to our site, we will email you!
PRICE DROP
31 Photos 1 Video

2011 Chevrolet Malibu LS

$3,000 $6,995 112,459 mi. Used
HOT CAR
Centereach Hyundai
~ 6 mi. away from 11953
(4.8) 957 reviews
  • Exterior Color: Imperial Blue Metallic
  • Interior Color: Titanium
  • Transmission: 6-SPEED A/T
  • Drivetrain: Front Wheel Drive
Save
Compare Added
Centereach Hyundai
(4.8) 957 reviews
6 mi. from 11953 (877) 241-9307
Check Availability
20 Photos 1 Video

2010 Ford Mustang GT Premium

$14,908 61,453 mi. Used
Great Deal
Est. $1709.23 in added features
Certified Headquarters
~ 9 mi. away from 11953
(5) 47 reviews
  • Exterior Color: Sterling Gray Metallic
  • Interior Color: Brick Red / Cashmere
  • Transmission: 5-Speed Automatic
  • Drivetrain: RWD
Save
Compare Added
Certified Headquarters
(5) 47 reviews
9 mi. from 11953 (631) 240-4783
Check Availability
30 Photos 1 Video

2014 Chevrolet Corvette Stingray Base

$40,450 22,913 mi. Certified
Good Deal
Est. $2065.81 in added features
Atlantic Chevrolet Cadillac
~ 18 mi. away from 11953
(4.5) 1191 reviews
  • Exterior Color: Velocity Yellow Tintcoat
  • Interior Color: Jet Black
  • Transmission: Manual
  • Drivetrain: Rear Wheel Drive
Save
Compare Added
Atlantic Chevrolet Cadillac
(4.5) 1191 reviews
18 mi. from 11953 (888) 783-3288
Check Availability
32 Photos 1 Video

2017 Mercedes-Benz AMG S 63 Base 4MATIC

$128,500 3,252 mi. Used
Great Deal
Mercedes-Benz of Fairfield
~ 23 mi. away from 11953
(4) 33 reviews
  • Exterior Color: Designo
  • Interior Color: Black
  • Transmission: 7-Speed Automatic
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
Compare Added
Mercedes-Benz of Fairfield
(4) 33 reviews
23 mi. from 11953 (888) 232-5815
Check Availability
32 Photos 1 Video

2016 Dodge Durango R/T

$32,799 28,143 mi. Used
Great Deal
Est. $3948.6 in added features
Curran Volkswagen
~ 23 mi. away from 11953
(5) 101 reviews
  • Exterior Color: Brilliant Black Crystal Pearlcoat
  • Interior Color: Black
  • Transmission: 8-Speed Automatic
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
Compare Added
Curran Volkswagen
(5) 101 reviews
23 mi. from 11953 (866) 976-4239
Check Availability
32 Photos 1 Video

2009 BMW M3 Base

$24,985 80,753 mi. Used
Great Deal
Est. $9635.44 in added features
NY Auto Find
~ 25 mi. away from 11953
  • Exterior Color: Alpine White
  • Interior Color: Fox Red
  • Transmission: 6-SPEED M/T
  • Drivetrain: Rear Wheel Drive
Save
Compare Added
NY Auto Find
25 mi. from 11953 (631) 412-4076
Check Availability
27 Photos 1 Video

2005 Toyota 4Runner SR5

$8,895 89,997 mi. Used
Great Deal
Est. $2004.62 in added features
Power Motor Group
~ 25 mi. away from 11953
(4.9) 79 reviews
  • Exterior Color: Gold
  • Interior Color: Dark Charcoal
  • Transmission: 5-Speed Automatic
  • Drivetrain: 4WD
Save
Compare Added
Power Motor Group
(4.9) 79 reviews
25 mi. from 11953 (631) 693-4918
Check Availability
32 Photos 1 Video

2018 McLaren 720S

$384,900 513 mi. Used
Motorcar Classics
~ 25 mi. away from 11953
(5) 4 reviews
  • Exterior Color: Cosmos
  • Interior Color: Carbon Black
  • Transmission: Automatic
  • Drivetrain: RWD
Save
Compare Added
Motorcar Classics
(5) 4 reviews
25 mi. from 11953 (631) 830-6815
Check Availability
32 Photos 1 Video

2013 Lexus GS 350

$16,499 106,360 mi. Used
Great Deal
Est. $5637.23 in added features
Lexus of Westport
~ 25 mi. away from 11953
(4.8) 842 reviews
  • Exterior Color: Obsidian Black
  • Interior Color: Black
  • Transmission: 6-Speed Automatic
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
Compare Added
Lexus of Westport
(4.8) 842 reviews
25 mi. from 11953 (203) 916-5565
Check Availability
31 Photos 1 Video

2013 Dodge Charger R/T

$11,975 87,375 mi. Used
Great Deal
Est. $931.53 in added features
Power Motor Group
~ 25 mi. away from 11953
(4.9) 79 reviews
  • Exterior Color: Gray
  • Interior Color: Black
  • Transmission: 5-Speed Automatic
  • Drivetrain: RWD
Save
Compare Added
Power Motor Group
(4.9) 79 reviews
25 mi. from 11953 (631) 693-4918
Check Availability
32 Photos 1 Video

2011 BMW M3 Base

$25,985 74,259 mi. Used
Great Deal
Est. $8270.88 in added features
NY Auto Find
~ 25 mi. away from 11953
  • Exterior Color: Jerez Black Metallic
  • Interior Color: Beige
  • Transmission: 6-SPEED M/T
  • Drivetrain: Rear Wheel Drive
Save
Compare Added
NY Auto Find
25 mi. from 11953 (631) 412-4076
Check Availability
30 Photos 1 Video

2004 Lexus LS 430

$12,499 59,390 mi. Used
Good Deal
Est. $1469.2 in added features
Lexus of Westport
~ 25 mi. away from 11953
(4.8) 842 reviews
  • Exterior Color: Black Onyx
  • Interior Color: Black
  • Transmission: 6-Speed Automatic
  • Drivetrain: RWD
Save
Compare Added
Lexus of Westport
(4.8) 842 reviews
25 mi. from 11953 (203) 916-5565
Check Availability
30 Photos 1 Video

2010 Lexus GS 450h

$17,699 46,807 mi. Used
Great Deal
Est. $1252.66 in added features
Lexus of Westport
~ 25 mi. away from 11953
(4.8) 842 reviews
  • Exterior Color: Starfire Pearl
  • Interior Color: Parchment
  • Transmission: Automatic CVT
  • Drivetrain: RWD
Save
Compare Added
Lexus of Westport
(4.8) 842 reviews
25 mi. from 11953 (203) 916-5565
Check Availability
32 Photos 1 Video

2015 Dodge Challenger SRT 392

$34,000 29,109 mi. Used
Great Deal
Est. $675.56 in added features
Novak Motors
~ 26 mi. away from 11953
(5) 93 reviews
  • Exterior Color: Torred Clearcoat
  • Interior Color: Black
  • Transmission: 8-Speed Automatic
  • Drivetrain: RWD
Save
Compare Added
Novak Motors
(5) 93 reviews
26 mi. from 11953 (631) 881-4304
Check Availability
32 Photos 1 Video

2015 Dodge Challenger R/T Scat Pack

$34,750 3,026 mi. Used
Good Deal
Est. $8730.12 in added features
Novak Motors
~ 26 mi. away from 11953
(5) 93 reviews
  • Exterior Color: Pitch Black Clearcoat
  • Interior Color: Black
  • Transmission: 6-Speed Manual
  • Drivetrain: RWD
Save
Compare Added
Novak Motors
(5) 93 reviews
26 mi. from 11953 (631) 881-4304
Check Availability
32 Photos 1 Video

2013 Ford Fiesta S

$3,995 71,021 mi. Used
Great Deal
Est. $684.42 in added features
NY Off Lease
~ 26 mi. away from 11953
(4.4) 7 reviews
  • Exterior Color: Silver
  • Interior Color: Gray
  • Transmission: 5-SPEED M/T
  • Drivetrain: Front Wheel Drive
Save
Compare Added
NY Off Lease
(4.4) 7 reviews
26 mi. from 11953 (631) 693-4654
Check Availability
19 Photos 1 Video

2005 BMW 325 Ci

$14,995 18,983 mi. Used
SZ Motorcars
~ 28 mi. away from 11953
(5) 2 reviews
  • Exterior Color: Gray Metallic
  • Interior Color: Gray
  • Transmission: 5-Speed Automatic
  • Drivetrain: RWD
Save
Compare Added
SZ Motorcars
(5) 2 reviews
28 mi. from 11953 (888) 431-4669
Check Availability
32 Photos 1 Video

2017 Cadillac CTS-V Base

$79,995 5,031 mi. Certified
Good Deal
Buzz Chew Chevrolet Cadillac
~ 28 mi. away from 11953
(4.9) 333 reviews
  • Exterior Color: Black Raven
  • Interior Color: Jet Black
  • Transmission: 8-Speed Automatic
  • Drivetrain: RWD
Save
Compare Added
Buzz Chew Chevrolet Cadillac
(4.9) 333 reviews
28 mi. from 11953 (631) 593-2083
Check Availability
31 Photos 1 Video

2015 Audi A3 2.0 TDI Premium

$15,999 45,353 mi. Used
Great Deal
Est. $2371.76 in added features
Legend Auto Group
~ 28 mi. away from 11953
(4.6) 36 reviews
  • Exterior Color: Mythos Black Metallic
  • Interior Color: Black
  • Transmission: 6-Speed Auto-Shift Manual w/OD
  • Drivetrain: FWD
Save
Compare Added
Legend Auto Group
(4.6) 36 reviews
28 mi. from 11953 (631) 609-4432
Check Availability
22 Photos 1 Video

2015 Toyota Sienna Limited Premium

$29,999 27,681 mi. Used
Great Deal
Est. $14715 in added features
Amico Leasing & Sales
~ 30 mi. away from 11953
(5) 7 reviews
  • Exterior Color: Gray
  • Interior Color: Gray
  • Transmission: 6-Speed Automatic
  • Drivetrain: AWD
Save
Compare Added
Amico Leasing & Sales
(5) 7 reviews
30 mi. from 11953 (516) 308-2042
Check Availability
The information on vehicles provided in this service is supplied by the seller or other third parties; Cars.com is not responsible for the accuracy of such information. Cars.com provides this service and materials without representations or warranties of any kind, either expressed or implied. Click here for more details.

by Popular City

Cars for sale in Atlanta, GA
Cars for sale in Chicago, IL
Cars for sale in Columbus, OH
Cars for sale in Dallas, TX
Cars for sale in Denver, CO
Cars for sale in Houston, TX
Cars for sale in Los Angeles, CA
Cars for sale in New York, NY
Cars for sale in Philadelphia, PA
Cars for sale in Phoenix, AZ
Cars for sale in San Diego, CA
Cars for sale in Seattle, WA