Skip to main content
Best match Lowest price Highest price Lowest mileage Highest mileage Nearest location Best deal Newest year Oldest year Newest listed Oldest listed
Skip to Listings
Best match Lowest price Highest price Lowest mileage Highest mileage Nearest location Best deal Newest year Oldest year Newest listed Oldest listed
Skip to Filters
  • Deep Blue Metallic 2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveDeep Blue Metallic 2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveDeep Blue Metallic 2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveDeep Blue Metallic 2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveDeep Blue Metallic 2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveDeep Blue Metallic 2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive

    $34,100

    43,475 mi.
    Est. $622/mo

    Fishers Imports NW

    4.7
    Indianapolis, IN (19 mi)
    Check Availability

  • Deep Blue Metallic 2021 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveDeep Blue Metallic 2021 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveDeep Blue Metallic 2021 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveDeep Blue Metallic 2021 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveDeep Blue Metallic 2021 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveDeep Blue Metallic 2021 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive

    $28,662

    61,354 mi.
    Est. $523/mo

    Northside Auto

    4.3
    Indianapolis, IN (26 mi)
    Check Availability
  • Red Multi-Coat 2022 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveRed Multi-Coat 2022 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveRed Multi-Coat 2022 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveRed Multi-Coat 2022 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveRed Multi-Coat 2022 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveRed Multi-Coat 2022 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive

    $27,671

    99,873 mi.
    Est. $505/mo

    Northside Auto

    4.3
    Indianapolis, IN (26 mi)
    Check Availability
  • Deep Blue Metallic 2021 Tesla Model Y Standard Range Rear-Wheel DriveDeep Blue Metallic 2021 Tesla Model Y Standard Range Rear-Wheel DriveDeep Blue Metallic 2021 Tesla Model Y Standard Range Rear-Wheel DriveDeep Blue Metallic 2021 Tesla Model Y Standard Range Rear-Wheel DriveDeep Blue Metallic 2021 Tesla Model Y Standard Range Rear-Wheel DriveDeep Blue Metallic 2021 Tesla Model Y Standard Range Rear-Wheel Drive

    $23,900

    81,983 mi.
    Est. $436/mo

    AutoGiant USA

    4.1
    Fishers, IN (29 mi)
    Check Availability
  • Pearl White Multi-Coat 2021 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DrivePearl White Multi-Coat 2021 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DrivePearl White Multi-Coat 2021 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DrivePearl White Multi-Coat 2021 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DrivePearl White Multi-Coat 2021 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DrivePearl White Multi-Coat 2021 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive

    $30,700

    37,602 mi.
    Est. $560/mo

    Carmel Auto Gallery

    4.5
    Carmel, IN (24 mi)
    Check Availability
  • Stealth Grey 2026 Tesla Model Y Premium All-Wheel DriveStealth Grey 2026 Tesla Model Y Premium All-Wheel DriveStealth Grey 2026 Tesla Model Y Premium All-Wheel DriveStealth Grey 2026 Tesla Model Y Premium All-Wheel DriveStealth Grey 2026 Tesla Model Y Premium All-Wheel DriveStealth Grey 2026 Tesla Model Y Premium All-Wheel Drive

    $49,800

    9,540 mi.
    Est. $908/mo

    Unlimited Motors

    4.4
    Westfield, IN (27 mi)
    Check Availability
  • Stealth Grey 2024 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveStealth Grey 2024 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive

    $35,900

    59,693 mi.
    Est. $655/mo

    AutoGiant USA

    4.1
    Fishers, IN (29 mi)
    Check Availability
  • White 2025 Tesla Model Y Long Range AWDWhite 2025 Tesla Model Y Long Range AWDWhite 2025 Tesla Model Y Long Range AWDWhite 2025 Tesla Model Y Long Range AWDWhite 2025 Tesla Model Y Long Range AWDWhite 2025 Tesla Model Y Long Range AWD

    $34,600

    24,106 mi.
    Est. $631/mo

    AutoSavvy Fishers

    4.2
    Fishers, IN (30 mi)
    Check Availability
  • Blue 2024 Tesla Model Y Long RangeBlue 2024 Tesla Model Y Long RangeBlue 2024 Tesla Model Y Long RangeBlue 2024 Tesla Model Y Long RangeBlue 2024 Tesla Model Y Long RangeBlue 2024 Tesla Model Y Long Range

    $31,700

    34,387 mi.
    Est. $578/mo

    AutoSavvy Fishers

    4.2
    Fishers, IN (30 mi)
    Check Availability
  • Stealth Grey 2026 Tesla Model Y Long RangeStealth Grey 2026 Tesla Model Y Long RangeStealth Grey 2026 Tesla Model Y Long RangeStealth Grey 2026 Tesla Model Y Long RangeStealth Grey 2026 Tesla Model Y Long RangeStealth Grey 2026 Tesla Model Y Long Range

    $51,431

    $400
    3,218 mi.
    Est. $938/mo

    Zeigler Honda of Racine

    4.6
    $224 delivery from Mt Pleasant, WI (225 mi)
    Check Availability
  • Gray 2026 Tesla Model Y PremiumGray 2026 Tesla Model Y PremiumGray 2026 Tesla Model Y PremiumGray 2026 Tesla Model Y PremiumGray 2026 Tesla Model Y PremiumGray 2026 Tesla Model Y Premium

    $59,998

    2,413 mi.
    Est. $1,095/mo

    CarMax Rivergate

    4.8
    $399 delivery to Indianapolis, IN (18 mi)
    Check Availability
  • Gray 2023 Tesla Model Y Long RangeGray 2023 Tesla Model Y Long RangeGray 2023 Tesla Model Y Long RangeGray 2023 Tesla Model Y Long RangeGray 2023 Tesla Model Y Long RangeGray 2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range

    $36,998

    37,018 mi.
    Est. $675/mo

    CarMax Bloomington

    4.5
    Bloomington, IL (147 mi)
    Check Availability
  • Gray 2023 Tesla Model Y Long RangeGray 2023 Tesla Model Y Long RangeGray 2023 Tesla Model Y Long RangeGray 2023 Tesla Model Y Long RangeGray 2023 Tesla Model Y Long RangeGray 2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range

    $37,998

    27,264 mi.
    Est. $693/mo

    CarMax Cincinnati

    4.4
    Cincinnati, OH (104 mi)
    Check Availability
  • Solid Black 2024 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveSolid Black 2024 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveSolid Black 2024 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveSolid Black 2024 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveSolid Black 2024 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveSolid Black 2024 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive

    $37,375

    56,526 mi.
    Est. $682/mo

    Glenn Chrysler Dodge Jeep Ram

    4.4
    Crestwood, KY (107 mi)
    Check Availability
  • Pearl White Multi-Coat 2022 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DrivePearl White Multi-Coat 2022 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DrivePearl White Multi-Coat 2022 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DrivePearl White Multi-Coat 2022 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DrivePearl White Multi-Coat 2022 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DrivePearl White Multi-Coat 2022 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive

    $33,407

    36,645 mi.
    Est. $609/mo

    BMW Of Bloomington

    4.8
    Bloomington, IL (147 mi)
    Check Availability
  • White 2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveWhite 2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveWhite 2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveWhite 2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveWhite 2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveWhite 2023 Tesla Model Y Long Range Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive

    $33,319

    50,879 mi.
    Est. $608/mo

    Sam Leman Ford

    4.6
    Bloomington, IL (147 mi)
    Check Availability
  • Pearl White Multi-Coat 2022 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DrivePearl White Multi-Coat 2022 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DrivePearl White Multi-Coat 2022 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DrivePearl White Multi-Coat 2022 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DrivePearl White Multi-Coat 2022 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DrivePearl White Multi-Coat 2022 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive

    $32,450

    81,073 mi.
    Est. $592/mo

    Auto Group of Louisville

    4.9
    Louisville, KY (111 mi)
    Check Availability
  • Stealth Grey 2025 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveStealth Grey 2025 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveStealth Grey 2025 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveStealth Grey 2025 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive

    $49,995

    24,820 mi.
    Est. $912/mo

    Unlimited Motors

    4.5
    Elwood, IN (49 mi)
    Check Availability
  • Gray 2024 Tesla Model Y Long RangeGray 2024 Tesla Model Y Long RangeGray 2024 Tesla Model Y Long RangeGray 2024 Tesla Model Y Long RangeGray 2024 Tesla Model Y Long RangeGray 2024 Tesla Model Y Long Range

    $44,998

    25,395 mi.
    Est. $821/mo

    CarMax Tinley Park

    4.7
    Tinley Park, IL (148 mi)
    Check Availability
  • Gray 2023 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveGray 2023 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveGray 2023 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveGray 2023 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveGray 2023 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveGray 2023 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive

    $37,907

    17,136 mi.
    Est. $692/mo

    Leman's Chevy City

    4.5
    Bloomington, IL (147 mi)
    Check Availability
  • Black 2022 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveBlack 2022 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveBlack 2022 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveBlack 2022 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveBlack 2022 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel DriveBlack 2022 Tesla Model Y Performance Dual Motor All-Wheel Drive

    $34,990

    $1K
    51,080 mi.
    Est. $638/mo

    HyperCars

    4.8
    New Albany, IN (102 mi)
    Check Availability
  • White 2025 Tesla Model Y Long RangeWhite 2025 Tesla Model Y Long RangeWhite 2025 Tesla Model Y Long RangeWhite 2025 Tesla Model Y Long RangeWhite 2025 Tesla Model Y Long RangeWhite 2025 Tesla Model Y Long Range

    $46,998

    8,348 mi.
    Est. $857/mo

    CarMax Fort Wayne

    3.7
    Fort Wayne, IN (119 mi)
    Check Availability
  • Silver 2025 Tesla Model Y PerformanceSilver 2025 Tesla Model Y PerformanceSilver 2025 Tesla Model Y PerformanceSilver 2025 Tesla Model Y PerformanceSilver 2025 Tesla Model Y PerformanceSilver 2025 Tesla Model Y Performance

    $44,998

    28,057 mi.
    Est. $821/mo

    CarMax Dayton

    4.2
    West Carrollton, OH (115 mi)
    Check Availability