Used Toyota Corolla for Sale in Middle Island, NY

$11,495 42,377 mi.

2018 Toyota Corolla L

Ext. Color: White
Int. Color: Other
Transmission: CVT
Drivetrain: FWD

Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report

2018 Toyota Corolla L Review

Most reliable car I owned

by cas104 from Valley Stream, NY

May 14, 2019

Car is great met all needs, nicely equipped, has every option needed, great vehicle, safe, stylish and sporty. Great vehicle for the money, reliable and safe

See all 30 photos

$13,774 39,366 mi.

2017 Toyota Corolla LE

Ext. Color: Beige
Int. Color: Black
Transmission: CVT
Drivetrain: FWD

Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report

Baron Honda Review

Very pleasant & fantastic car buying experience!!!

by KPLIslander from Kings Park, NY

November 5, 2018

4.8 (951 reviews)

Our entire experience was great. Robert Noto was wonderful!! He was friendly and nice to speak with, and was straightforward, genuine and honest with everything, which allowed us to be very comfortable and stress-free throughout the entire process, which went very smoothly. He is easily one of the best salespersons that we have ever encountered and interacted with in over 30 years time of buying various vehicles. He handled the entire transaction very professionally and effortlessly. Very happy and pleased customer. We are glad to highly recommend Robert Noto for all of your needs at Baron Honda. Jenna and Jennifer were also very helpful with any questions we had and friendly with our interactions. Theresa was instrumental in assisting with and taking care of ensuring that some of the necessary documentation was in order. All around, very nice people at Baron Honda that made our shopping experience a positive one and we gladly anticipate returning there for future car purchases.

2017 Toyota Corolla LE Review

Wonderful car

by L.Gueva from Davenport

May 3, 2019

This car is what I expected and more. I feel very secure in it. Very reliable and has great gas efficiency. The design is very nice too.

See all 31 photos

$12,989 9,680 mi.

2016 Toyota Corolla S

Ext. Color: Silver
Int. Color: Black
Transmission: CVT
Drivetrain: FWD

Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report

Sayville Ford Review

Sayville Ford is the best!

by JB18 from DealerRater.com

December 3, 2018

4.9 (1771 reviews)

Marianna was so great to work with! I first met her about a month ago while I was waiting for an oil change (their service center is also great!) and wanted to ask questions regarding the upcoming end of my current lease. We talked about what I wanted in my next vehicle but I wasn???t ready to turn in my old Escape yet. I test drove an EchoSport but didn???t like it was well as the Escape. Since the 2019 Escape was coming out soon I decided to wait. As soon as the new Escapes arrived last week she contacted me to let me know. She already had one picked out for me that had everything I was looking for. Marianna did a great job of going over all the features with me and answering every question I had. I never felt intimidated or pushed to sign a lease I wasn???t comfortable with. It was truly a great experience and I love my new Escape!

2016 Toyota Corolla S Review

Good car if you use it just for work

by John Doe from Galveston, TX

May 6, 2019

It is a good car for people that go from house to work and hang out with friends but not for those who want to speed up and off-road

$10,995 47,594 mi.

2018 Toyota Corolla XLE

Ext. Color: White
Int. Color: Gray
Transmission: CVT
Drivetrain: FWD

Free CARFAX Report

Marathon Motors Review

HONEST CAR DEALER!

by Christine Reinhart from Mount Sinai

November 6, 2018

3.7 (25 reviews)

I received the most excellent assistance with financing with a FULL explanation regarding payments and 2 year warranty on my Chrysler 300. A few days later I had an issue with the vehicle. The HONEST CAR DEALER eased ALL my concerns with no cost from my pocket. The problem has been rectified and I am now driving a BRAND NEW vehicle.. I recommend that if you are tired of being manipulated by demonic car dealers then RUN to marathon motors in saint James..

2018 Toyota Corolla XLE Review

Granny needs speed!!

by Gunning Granny from Los Angeles, California

May 12, 2019

In the past, I have owned a Dodge Durango with a hemi engine and BMW so I am used to great acceleration! This car is slow on take off. I am older now so maybe zooming around town is not a good idea 🙂 I am grateful for this car!

See all 30 photos

$6,926 97,220 mi.

2011 Toyota Corolla LE

Ext. Color: Black
Int. Color: Gray
Transmission: Automatic
Drivetrain: FWD

Atlantic Chevrolet Cadillac

CARFAX Report

Atlantic Chevrolet Cadillac Review

Great Service

by TonyTail from Bellmore, NY

November 5, 2018

4.3 (1455 reviews)

Came in for tire rotation, oil change and overall check up for 5,000 miles on new Traverse. I was told it would take about an hour and a half. It took just a little over that by minutes and all was complete. Waiting area was very comfortable with TV and WiFi, food and beverage were also available. I've owned a lot of vehicles and this was one of the best experiences for service.

2011 Toyota Corolla LE Review

Great, reliable and amazing gas mileage

by Grocerygetternohating from Monroe la

February 10, 2019

Great for running kids around town, getting to and from work. Gas mileage is great for college kids, working adults and people who love to run the roads.

See all 31 photos

$8,995 89,155 mi.

2014 Toyota Corolla S Plus

Ext. Color: Silver
Int. Color: Gray
Transmission: Automatic
Drivetrain: FWD

Atlantic Chrysler Jeep Dodge Ram

Free AutoCheck Report

Atlantic Chrysler Jeep Dodge Ram Review

A marvelous salesman!

by Ana from DealerRater.com

December 3, 2018

4 (553 reviews)

First lease at age 25 and it was an incredible experience leasing my first vehicle at this location. Craig among Anthony Mecca and Caleb went above and beyond helping me and answering questions to the perfect vehicle for myself. I came for a ???preowned vehicle??? left with a brand new 2018 Jeep Grand Cherokee! Craig has amazing interpersonal skills! Highly recommend requesting him to make your purchase from West Islip Atlantic Chrysler Jeep Dodge Ram!

2014 Toyota Corolla S Plus Review

Good performance, very cheap interior!

by BillT from Boston, MA

May 3, 2019

Excellent basic cheaper car with good gas mileage, good brakes, and good drivability. A little noisy, but like most in its class. Cruise control is terrible with any hills on your trip. No real cupholders, power outlets, or USB plugs in the back even though this is NOT the low end Corolla. The seat material stains way too easily and can't be cleaned, even by the dealer. The floor "carpet" is NOT carpet, but felt---which CANNOT be vacuumed or really cleaned well at all. It is the worst floor material I have ever had since my first car(of many) since 1962! Bought used with 7000 miles, I took it to my dealer every 500 miles for checkup and service. At 38K, I took off the wheel to check the brakes and found the inside of the rotors were heavily grooved while the outside was barely used. The calipers were BOTH frozen. Unfortunately, neither brakes or calipers are covered under any warranty, and the dealership (Acton Totoya) offered me nothing when I showed them the problem! How could they have missed such a big problem if they really checked my car over each time? I fixed it all myself and now, with 68K, have had NO more problems with the brakes. The plastic front overhang is too low and has broken off twice when hitting the curb stones in parking lots while parking at low speed. The left front two speakers have not worked since about 10K and I haven't taken the door apart to find out why, but heard there is a problem with the door wiring just above the lower speaker. Except for the brakes thing, it has been an economical and zippy commuter car, but I will definitely go back to the Camry next time!

See all 36 photos

$13,699 24,848 mi.

2017 Toyota Corolla LE

LOCAL HOME DELIVERY

VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS

Ext. Color: Black
Int. Color: Beige
Transmission: CVT
Drivetrain: FWD

Free AutoCheck Report

Toyota of Huntington Review

Simply Amazing!!! Huntington Toyota the place to go!!

by Larry59 from DealerRater.com

December 3, 2018

4.6 (2399 reviews)

I don't normally write reviews, but I felt compelled to let others know of the absolute pleasant experience my wife and I had when visiting Toyota of Huntington on Sunday, October 7th, 2018. They are under new management and it was clear they are aiming to please! From the moment we walked in and were greeted by the lovely receptionist, Alanis, to the introduction of our salesperson, Ray Nazario and to the closing of our Tundra truck sale with Jay Cooper and Tommy Mcfall we felt it was all professional, courteous and like your saying on the window states "all about you". We definitely felt it was all about us when Ray very patiently answered all of our questions and clarified all of our concerns. We never felt rushed and appreciated the trust rendered when we were allowed to test drive the cars we wanted to be sure of our final purchase decision. Ray was magnificent! In addition, Jay was very friendly, funny and honest in giving us the best price for our trade in! Can't thank him enough!! We know that this professionalism and patience to listen to you is hard to come by. The staff of Huntington Toyota made our car shopping experience an enjoyable one for my wife and I. So thanks a million Jay, Ray, Tommy and Alanis for everything-you exceeded our expectations!!! We will definitely be recommending you guys to all our family and friends!! Thankfully, Larry

2017 Toyota Corolla LE Review

Corolla I have owned

by Toan Duc Cao from Starkville, MS

April 24, 2019

I bought my car from Carl Hogan Toyota in 2017 and each experience is better than the last. this car is very good for me .

$10,968 26,495 mi.

2013 Toyota Corolla S

Ext. Color: Gray
Int. Color: Gray
Transmission: Automatic
Drivetrain: FWD

Free CARFAX Report

Nissan of Huntington Review

Service

by Wislande jeansimon from Long island new York

November 5, 2018

2.5 (74 reviews)

I love going to Nissan of Huntington everyone there are great.

2013 Toyota Corolla S Review

Best car I’ve ever owned

by Kelly S from Highland iN

May 2, 2019

This car has met all my needs gets great gas mileage and have had no problems with the car other than regular wear and tear

$6,691 59,042 mi.

2008 Toyota Corolla LE

Ext. Color: Gray
Int. Color: Other
Transmission: Automatic
Drivetrain: FWD

Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report

M & A Motors Review

5 stars is not enough!

by TomJ14 from DealerRater.com

December 3, 2018

4.8 (96 reviews)

I want to thank again to all at M&A Motors for their time and patience in my purchase of a 2015 Jeep Grand Cherokee...everyone went above and beyond for me and even helped fix my moms car knowing the situation I was in. For a dealer to offer to fix a car that had nothing to do with the sale of the car I was buying and to help me out and wait for the funds to be available due to the situation I was in,is something that needs to be recognized! I can???t thank everyone enough for making me so happy to finally have the Jeep I???ve been wanting for the last few years! I hope everyone enjoyed the lunch I brought in and hopefully Keya made it back in time to enjoy as well!! Lol If I could give more than 5 stars...I would! Again thanks to everyone there for the help!

2008 Toyota Corolla LE Review

Great Car

by Father Buying Car for Son from Clarksville, IN

March 20, 2019

Great car for my Son. Wife used to have one, and he really wanted one of his own. He was excited to get it and we are thankful God blessed to buy it for him

See all 18 photos

$4,495 101,253 mi.

2008 Toyota Corolla LE

Ext. Color: Gray
Int. Color: Gray
Transmission: Manual
Drivetrain: FWD

CARFAX Report

2008 Toyota Corolla LE Review

Super reliable. After 60K miles no issues at all

by Devdog from Huntington beach

May 5, 2019

Meets all my needs and is very reliable. Great fun car to drive around and doesn’t look bad at all either. Great on gas average 28 mpg city and 38 on highway

See all 5 photos

$7,000 95,000 mi.

2015 Toyota Corolla LE

Ext. Color: White
Int. Color: Black
Transmission: Automatic
Drivetrain: FWD

CARFAX Report

Saeed (Private Seller)

23 mi. from 11953

2015 Toyota Corolla LE Review

Really good cat overall and good on gas

by Gary from Sykesville

May 11, 2019

Very reliable good gas mileage good looking vehicle very easy to work on if you are handy man in want to get the job done by yourself

See all 23 photos

$7,789 78,171 mi.

2009 Toyota Corolla S

Ext. Color: White
Int. Color: Other
Transmission: Automatic
Drivetrain: FWD

CARFAX Report

Huntington Auto Mall Review

Excellent experience.

by John H from Hicksville

December 3, 2018

5 (62 reviews)

I Bought my 16 GMC from them. Had an excellent experience. I will recommend them for sure. Thanks to Jessica willie and the whole crew.

2009 Toyota Corolla S Review

Still working great!

by Lina from Plainview, Texas

May 11, 2019

I bought a Corolla through Gene Messer Toyota and I still have it. I now drive a 4Runner that I bought at another Toyota dealer in Plainview. The only reason I went back was to service my 4Runner since my old Toyota place closed.

See all 25 photos

$8,995 66,655 mi.

2014 Toyota Corolla S

Ext. Color: Gray
Int. Color: Black
Transmission: CVT
Drivetrain: FWD

CARFAX Report

2014 Toyota Corolla S Review

Quite satisfying car

by Executive from Jeddah, ksa

April 28, 2019

This car met my needs, am satisfied with its over all performance. Good car, reasonable length, readonable space and comfortable seating. Ultimate in its category

See all 21 photos

$6,963 126,382 mi.

2012 Toyota Corolla 2.0 LE

Ext. Color: Other
Int. Color: Other
Transmission: Automatic
Drivetrain: FWD

CARFAX Report

Napoli Kia Review

Flawless purchase

by Farley8335 from DealerRater.com

November 5, 2018

4.2 (100 reviews)

Customer service is exceptional, sales and financing painless, this is my third Kia, 1) Rondo 75,000 miles, 2) Optima Hybrid, 98,000 miles and now Sorento V6, AWD is my favorite to date , seamless power, solid construction, 3 rows of seating and best of all I am currently averaging 27 mpg, I have gotten it 31 mpg, I drive 23,000 miles in the average, cheers, John F Santa, Santa Fuel, Equipment Specialist

2012 Toyota Corolla 2.0 LE Review

Great Car so far

by Rebecca from Phoenix, AZ

May 4, 2019

great looking car meets our needs so far. We have not had the car for long. But, we enjoy driving it so far. We also hope to enjoy the car for years to come.

$16,475 41,458 mi.

2019 Toyota Corolla LE

Ext. Color: Silver
Int. Color: Gray
Transmission: CVT
Drivetrain: FWD

Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report

Atlantic Toyota Review

Pleasant experience!

by Biteme from DealerRater.com

December 3, 2018

4.7 (1479 reviews)

I went into Toyota to trade in my truck, I was offerered a great deal and walked out with a brand new Toyota Highlander. Joe mankuski was my salesman and he went above and beyond for me! He made everything so easy and enjoyable! All of the staff there was great there to me and working a great deal! I would highly recommend Atlantic Toyota and ask for joe mankuski! He is so easy to talk and make sure you find a car with your best interest in mind!! Great job👌🏻

2019 Toyota Corolla LE Review

really ike our new toyota

by debridge from eureka sd

May 16, 2019

this car is very well made. Its comfortable and a very nice ride , the body style is also very nice and it over all looks great

$12,575 65,545 mi.

2015 Toyota Corolla LE

Ext. Color: Black
Int. Color: Gray
Transmission: CVT
Drivetrain: FWD

Free CARFAX Report

Atlantic Toyota Review

Amazing

by joeyallmyfaith from DealerRater.com

December 3, 2018

4.7 (1479 reviews)

Upstanding Shamika Luciano was very helpful professional she help me through the process of choosing the vehicle of my choice. It was no pressure felt comfortable. I would recommend Atlantic Toyota At sunrise Hwy to anybody that???s looking for car. 👌🏽

2015 Toyota Corolla LE Review

Great Gas Mileage, Reliable, Not Very Comfortable

by Michael from Lawrenceburg, Kentucky

May 2, 2019

Averaging over 36 MPG in mixed driving. The "S" version handles well, and rides fairly well for the car's size, but that isn't saying much - you still feel pavement strips, bumps, etc. It's certainly no Camry or Avalon! The car is attractive, and as reasonably priced as other cars its size. There is enough power for anyone who drives sanely. If it doesn't have enough power for you, you probably drive too aggressively to start with. The CVT is not a problem. Driven sanely, you'll never notice it. Reliability is excellent for all years of the Corolla. That, and the excellent fuel economy are the car's best selling points. On the downside... If you are considering a Corolla, take a long test drive. Compared to a Camry or Avalon, the car is simply not very comfortable, especially if you are older.

See all 30 photos

$15,421 30,449 mi.

2016 Toyota Corolla S Plus

Ext. Color: Silver
Int. Color: Other
Transmission: CVT
Drivetrain: FWD

New Country Toyota Of Westport

Free CARFAX Report

New Country Toyota Of Westport Review

Long time customer for a reason!

by bmbrush413 from DealerRater.com

December 3, 2018

4.9 (458 reviews)

I've been going to New Country since before it was New Country - but I've stuck around because the experience has been second to none. I bought my first car there in 2004 (Highlander) and my second in 2005 (Camry). We've bought 3 more since then - 2014 RAV4, 2017 Highlander, and just today and 2015 RAV4. Our last two purchases have been through Nick Roberts - super easy to deal with! Very friendly, and explains everything thoroughly. He has also made himself available after the sales to help with any questions. I've serviced my cars exclusively with New Country and can vouch that their service department is excellent and won't overcharge you for unnecessary work. Dwayne Taylor is super helpful and makes sure that everything is right the first time. I highly recommend New Country - and I wouldn't go anywhere else!

2016 Toyota Corolla S Plus Review

Love this car!

by Toyota Fan from Midliand, MI

May 3, 2019

Just took a road trip and couldn't be more satisfied with my new Corolla - very reliable and great gas mileage. Am a big fan of the Toyota Corolla - great value for the price!

See all 31 photos

$13,584 39,033 mi.

2019 Toyota Corolla LE

LOCAL HOME DELIVERY

VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS

Ext. Color: Red
Int. Color: Other
Transmission: CVT
Drivetrain: FWD

CARFAX Report

South Shore Kia Review

Got the best deal.

by JoeCollaz0 from DealerRater.com

December 3, 2018

4.5 (98 reviews)

After visiting a few dealers and getting the run around, I was apprehensive about coming into South Shore Kia. Soon as I walked in I was greated by Billy from sales and my time with him wasn???t rushed or pressured, he completely understood my financial situation and worked with me to the best of his ability. After negotiating with him, I was able to get a great price for my trade-in (2006 Kia Sportage) and drive out with a 2018 Sorento that same day. I am very happy with the service I received and would highly recommend anyone to have a seat with him. Thanks again Bill! - Joe Collazo

2019 Toyota Corolla LE Review

Driving

by Lewis2 from Atlanta ga

May 14, 2019

Car basically drives itself. Car small I would love to stay in the middle of lane but the computer says different. Seems like I fight with the car more then anything. Other then that I love the car just wish I didn’t have to fight with the computer so much.

See all 22 photos

$9,998 97,247 mi.

2011 Toyota Corolla S

Ext. Color: Black
Int. Color: Black
Transmission: Manual
Drivetrain: FWD