Toyota

Toyota Highlander for Sale in Staten Island, NY

New Search Sort Filter
563 vehicles found
Get the latest listings by email

You have created an alert for this search

When a new relevant car is added to our site, we will email you!
Island Toyota
(4.6) 414 reviews
(888) 346-1892
(888) 346-1892
Dealer Website
Currently in stock: 541 New 28 CPO 67 Used
GREAT DEAL GOOD DEAL HOT CAR PRICE DROP JUST ADDED FAIR PRICE
2016 Toyota Highlander XLE
2016 Toyota Highlander XLE
$28,999 31,834 mi
GREAT DEAL GOOD DEAL HOT CAR PRICE DROP JUST ADDED FAIR PRICE
2015 Toyota Highlander XLE
2015 Toyota Highlander XLE
$29,999 28,890 mi
GREAT DEAL GOOD DEAL HOT CAR PRICE DROP JUST ADDED FAIR PRICE
2016 Toyota Highlander XLE
2016 Toyota Highlander XLE
$30,999 45,133 mi

View all 67 Used Toyota Highlanders in stock

See all 26 photos
    • 26 Photos 1 Video
    Toyota Certified
    $29,999 17,118 mi.

    2018 Toyota Highlander LE

    Good Deal
    Bay Ridge Toyota
    (888) 375-0921
    4.6 (523 reviews)
    3 mi. from 10301
    Authorized Toyota Dealer
    • Ext. Color: Black
    • Int. Color: Black
    • Transmission: Automatic
    • Drivetrain: AWD
    Save
    • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
    • Toyota Certified Warranty Details
    Check Availability
    (888) 375-0921
    Details
    See all 32 photos
    • 32 Photos 1 Video
    Toyota Certified
    $29,761 42,909 mi.

    2017 Toyota Highlander XLE

    Good Deal
    Hudson Toyota
    (888) 404-7161
    4.6 (79 reviews)
    5 mi. from 10301
    Authorized Toyota Dealer
    • Ext. Color: Silver
    • Int. Color: Black
    • Transmission: Automatic
    • Drivetrain: AWD
    Save
    • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
    • Toyota Certified Warranty Details
    Check Availability
    (888) 404-7161
    Details
    PRICE DROP
    See all 32 photos
    • 32 Photos 1 Video
    Used
    $35,500 $36,000 30,571 mi.

    2017 Toyota Highlander Limited

    Good Deal
    Hudson Toyota
    (888) 662-3059
    4.6 (79 reviews)
    5 mi. from 10301
    Authorized Toyota Dealer
    • Ext. Color: White
    • Int. Color: Orange
    • Transmission: Automatic
    • Drivetrain: AWD
    Save
    • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
    Check Availability
    (888) 662-3059
    Details
    See all 32 photos
    • 32 Photos 1 Video
    Toyota Certified
    $33,792 23,149 mi.

    2016 Toyota Highlander Limited

    Good Deal
    Hudson Toyota
    (888) 404-7161
    4.6 (79 reviews)
    5 mi. from 10301
    Authorized Toyota Dealer
    • Ext. Color: Beige
    • Int. Color: Beige
    • Transmission: Automatic
    • Drivetrain: AWD
    Save
    • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
    • Toyota Certified Warranty Details
    Check Availability
    (888) 404-7161
    Details
    See all 41 photos
    • 41 Photos 1 Video
    Used
    $16,559 96,438 mi.

    2013 Toyota Highlander

    Good Deal
    Koeppel Subaru
    (888) 844-8343
    4.5 (166 reviews)
    12 mi. from 10301
    • Ext. Color: Black
    • Int. Color: Other
    • Transmission: Automatic
    • Drivetrain: AWD
    Save
    • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
    Check Availability
    (888) 844-8343
    Details
    See all 30 photos
    • 30 Photos 1 Video
    Used
    $24,780 33,721 mi.

    2015 Toyota Highlander XLE

    Great Deal
    NYC Motorcars of Queens
    (888) 882-1468
    3.3 (123 reviews)
    13 mi. from 10301
    • Ext. Color: White
    • Int. Color: Black
    • Transmission: Automatic
    • Drivetrain: AWD
    Save
    • CARFAX Report
    Check Availability
    (888) 882-1468
    Details
    See all 41 photos
    • 41 Photos
    Used
    $19,980 57,238 mi.

    2015 Toyota Highlander LE Plus

    Great Deal
    Queens Auto Mall
    (888) 887-4707
    4.2 (470 reviews)
    14 mi. from 10301
    • Ext. Color: Black
    • Int. Color: Gray
    • Transmission: Automatic
    • Drivetrain: AWD
    Save
    • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
    Check Availability
    (888) 887-4707
    Details
    See all 46 photos
    • 46 Photos
    Used
    $23,980 60,103 mi.

    2016 Toyota Highlander XLE

    Good Deal
    Queens Auto Mall
    (888) 887-4707
    4.2 (470 reviews)
    14 mi. from 10301
    • Ext. Color: Gray
    • Int. Color: Beige
    • Transmission: Automatic
    • Drivetrain: AWD
    Save
    • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
    Check Availability
    (888) 887-4707
    Details
    See all 23 photos
    • 23 Photos 1 Video
    Used
    $27,933 54,614 mi.

    2014 Toyota Highlander XLE

    Good Deal
    Douglas Volkswagen
    (908) 325-5989
    4.9 (170 reviews)
    16 mi. from 10301
    • Ext. Color: Black
    • Int. Color: Black
    • Transmission: Automatic
    • Drivetrain: AWD
    Save
    • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
    Check Availability
    (908) 325-5989
    Details
    See all 33 photos
    • 33 Photos 1 Video
    Used
    $18,000 82,963 mi.

    2012 Toyota Highlander Limited

    Good Deal
    Madison Honda
    (877) 227-0678
    5 (16 reviews)
    18 mi. from 10301
    • Ext. Color: Gray
    • Int. Color: Black
    • Transmission: Automatic
    • Drivetrain: 4x4/4-wheel drive
    Save
    • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
    Check Availability
    (877) 227-0678
    Details
    See all 30 photos
    • 30 Photos 1 Video
    Used
    $25,590 30,749 mi.

    2016 Toyota Highlander LE

    Good Deal
    Star Chrysler Jeep Dodge Ram
    (888) 520-0935
    4.6 (290 reviews)
    18 mi. from 10301
    • Ext. Color: Black
    • Int. Color: Gray
    • Transmission: Automatic
    • Drivetrain: AWD
    Save
    • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
    Check Availability
    (888) 520-0935
    Details
    PRICE DROP
    See all 26 photos
    • 26 Photos 1 Video
    Used
    $28,495 $28,995 36,479 mi.

    2016 Toyota Highlander XLE

    Good Deal
    Route 46 Nissan
    (888) 815-7264
    4.3 (1455 reviews)
    19 mi. from 10301
    • Ext. Color: White
    • Int. Color: Black
    • Transmission: Automatic
    • Drivetrain: AWD
    Save
    • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
    Check Availability
    (888) 815-7264
    Details
    See all 21 photos
    • 21 Photos
    Used
    $12,940 77,771 mi.

    2010 Toyota Highlander SE

    Great Deal
    Prestige Collection
    (201) 625-1321
    3 (4 reviews)
    19 mi. from 10301
    • Ext. Color: White
    • Int. Color: Gray
    • Transmission: Automatic
    • Drivetrain: AWD
    Save
    • Free CARFAX Report
    Check Availability
    (201) 625-1321
    Details
    See all 32 photos
    • 32 Photos 1 Video
    Toyota Certified
    $26,495 25,727 mi.

    2017 Toyota Highlander LE

    Great Deal
    Advantage Toyota Valley Stream
    (888) 404-7160
    4.8 (1015 reviews)
    19 mi. from 10301
    Authorized Toyota Dealer
    • Ext. Color: Silver
    • Int. Color: Gray
    • Transmission: Automatic
    • Drivetrain: FWD
    Save
    • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
    • Toyota Certified Warranty Details
    Check Availability
    (888) 404-7160
    Details
    See all 31 photos
    • 31 Photos 1 Video
    Used
    $16,740 79,544 mi.

    2013 Toyota Highlander Base Plus

    Great Deal
    City World Toyota
    (866) 820-0341
    4.5 (875 reviews)
    20 mi. from 10301
    Authorized Toyota Dealer
    • Ext. Color: Blue
    • Int. Color: Gray
    • Transmission: Automatic
    • Drivetrain: AWD
    Save
    • Free CARFAX Report
    Check Availability
    (866) 820-0341
    Details
    PRICE DROP
    See all 26 photos
    • 26 Photos 1 Video
    Used
    $27,500 $28,000 29,806 mi.

    2015 Toyota Highlander Limited Platinum

    Great Deal
    Eastchester Chrysler Jeep Dodge RAM
    (845) 584-3188
    4.5 (2309 reviews)
    21 mi. from 10301
    • Ext. Color: Gray
    • Int. Color: Other
    • Transmission: Automatic
    • Drivetrain: AWD
    Save
    • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
    Check Availability
    (845) 584-3188
    Details
    See all 34 photos
    • 34 Photos 1 Video
    Used
    $25,995 26,552 mi.

    2015 Toyota Highlander XLE

    Great Deal
    Victory Mitsubishi
    (888) 203-9289
    4 (59 reviews)
    22 mi. from 10301
    • Ext. Color: Black
    • Int. Color: Black
    • Transmission: Automatic
    • Drivetrain: AWD
    Save
    • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
    Check Availability
    (888) 203-9289
    Details
    See all 17 photos
    • 17 Photos 1 Video
    Used
    $32,995 17,101 mi.

    2017 Toyota Highlander XLE

    Good Deal
    Galaxy Toyota
    (888) 862-6744
    4.6 (560 reviews)
    23 mi. from 10301
    Authorized Toyota Dealer
    • Ext. Color: Black
    • Int. Color: Black
    • Transmission: Automatic
    • Drivetrain: AWD
    Save
    • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
    Check Availability
    (888) 862-6744
    Details
    See all 24 photos
    • 24 Photos 1 Video
    Used
    $17,149 62,272 mi.

    2012 Toyota Highlander Base

    Fair Price
    Bridgewater Chevrolet
    (866) 898-8896
    4.9 (133 reviews)
    24 mi. from 10301
    • Ext. Color: Black
    • Int. Color: Beige
    • Transmission: Automatic
    • Drivetrain: 4x4/4-wheel drive
    Save
    • Free CARFAX Report
    Check Availability
    (866) 898-8896
    Details
    See all 30 photos
    • 30 Photos
    Used
    $23,500 32,402 mi.

    2015 Toyota Highlander LE Plus

    Great Deal
    World Volkswagen of Neptune
    (866) 688-4276
    4.8 (1424 reviews)
    28 mi. from 10301
    • Ext. Color: Gray
    • Int. Color: Gray
    • Transmission: Automatic
    • Drivetrain: AWD
    Save
    • Free CARFAX 1-Owner Report
    Check Availability
    (866) 688-4276
    Details
    The information on vehicles provided in this service is supplied by the seller or other third parties; Cars.com is not responsible for the accuracy of such information. Cars.com provides this service and materials without representations or warranties of any kind, either expressed or implied. See our terms of service for more details.
    Save Search
    563  matches

    Filtering by:

    • Back
      Location
        Search within
    • Back
      New/Used
    • Back
      Year
    • Back
      Model
    • Back
      Trim
    • Back
      Price
    • Back
      Mileage
    • Back
      Vehicle History
    • Back
      Deal Rating
    • Back
      Features
    Show Less Filters Show More Filters
    New Search

    Similar Cars

    Honda Pilot For Sale

    1,983 Great Deals out of 41,069 listings starting at $835

    Acura MDX For Sale

    1,151 Great Deals out of 15,232 listings starting at $1,495

    Nissan Pathfinder For Sale

    2,539 Great Deals out of 19,128 listings starting at $950

    Toyota Highlander Hybrid For Sale

    36 Great Deals out of 1,505 listings starting at $2,800

    Toyota 4Runner For Sale

    744 Great Deals out of 21,761 listings starting at $1,495

    Toyota Venza For Sale

    207 Great Deals out of 1,678 listings starting at $6,999

    Used Toyota Highlander By City

    Toyota Highlander in Bronx, NY

    9 Great Deals out of 18 listings starting at $6,495

    Toyota Highlander By Year

    VEHICLE GREAT DEALS GOOD DEALS PRICES FROM LISTINGS
    2019 Toyota Highlander

    0 Great Deals

    3 Good Deals

    $32,988

    18 Listings

    from
    2018 Toyota Highlander

    40 Great Deals

    528 Good Deals

    $24,990

    882 Listings

    from
    2017 Toyota Highlander

    86 Great Deals

    896 Good Deals

    $23,791

    1,323 Listings

    from
    2016 Toyota Highlander

    250 Great Deals

    2,530 Good Deals

    $18,490

    3,256 Listings

    from
    2015 Toyota Highlander

    561 Great Deals

    2,624 Good Deals

    $15,997

    3,539 Listings

    from
    2014 Toyota Highlander

    58 Great Deals

    303 Good Deals

    $15,995

    514 Listings

    from
    2013 Toyota Highlander

    147 Great Deals

    370 Good Deals

    $10,995

    665 Listings

    from
    2012 Toyota Highlander

    59 Great Deals

    263 Good Deals

    $10,490

    551 Listings

    from
    2011 Toyota Highlander

    28 Great Deals

    130 Good Deals

    $8,999

    295 Listings

    from
    2010 Toyota Highlander

    31 Great Deals

    98 Good Deals

    $8,814

    282 Listings

    from